Wheeler's is a pretty solid sports bar and restaurant! Some friends and I came here to watch Knicks Finals Game 3 and it got packed! So of course service was going to be a bit slow but we didn't understood. The drinks and food are decently priced. But my favorites were the buffalo wings and brownie cake with ice cream. The pizza bread was very interesting, I was expecting more like the cheesy breadsticks from domino's. read more

Wheeler's Restaurant - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Unassuming bar with modestly priced drinks. The service is prompt but bartenders are in their 50s or 60s and unnecessarily rude/crotchety. Asking for a lemon wedge after receiving a drinking is committing a cardinal sin of forcing unnecessary movement and will be met with snide comments regardless of how well someone was tipped or how politely asked. Bring a tube of Bengay and some treats to possibly have a different experience. I won't be returning. read more

I went here with my friend for dinner on Saturday. We ordered the appetizer sampler & wings. For drinks we had Mojito, Hugo Spritz, Guinness, and Paloma. The staff were ok, the ambiance was nice. It looked like a regular classic bar in the front but surprisingly there was a lot of space in the back which extended into a restaurant. The food was good, but the drinks kind of looked light in color for a Spritz & Paloma read more

See all

Guinness, Wings and Steak tidbits, what's not to like? Enjoyed my food. Appreciated the atmosphere. Service on point. read more

See all

5 stars amazing! Such good food and service the servings are humongous! Love the vibe very clean and quality place

Sheepshead bay institution that serves good bar food plus phenomenal entrees too. Great bar vibe with a fun mix of older and young people drinking and eating in a great environment. If you need a spot to meet up with friends or a spot to make new acquaintances this is it. read more

Food is delicious and can put a lot of big name spots under the rug and the portions are big with a great price point. Drinks are equally as good. Service is great, I love when bartenders have eyes behind their heads and can communicate with sign language when they down thw other side of the bar. Ambiance? Well it isn't the Meatpacking District but it's one of the best looking pubs I have been to in NYC. Special shout out to John, Jimmy, Geo my A1 bartenders. read more

Wheeler's Restaurant - Steamed Mussels - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Wheeler's is a Sheepshead Bay staple. There are always a lot of people by the bar, but i am not a drinker and head to the dining area. The food is tasty and reasonably priced. Their onion soup is very good and so are their burgers and salads This is not an establishment for fancy dining, but a nice local eating spot. read more

I'm so at home AF here. Amazing drinks and atmosphere. John is a top-tier bartender. No bullshit involved. Just pure skill and customer service out the ass. . Always look forward to coming here. If you are all about the GenX era of partying/relaxing, this is your spot and John is your bartender. read more

Awesome vintage vibe with great food and even better service. The staff were super friendly and made the night feel easy. Food was way better than your usual bar fare. Plus, they're open till 2am--which is a huge win. Definitely coming back! read more

Wheeler's Restaurant - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Wheelers is one of the BEST! Sport bar, Restaurant the food is excellent service is fantastic Jack is the manager and I have to compliment him he is very organized and pleasant, a great manager, one of the Best . I will keep coming back, The appetizers are fantastic ,steaks , burgers and many of the dishes like I said their food is amazing! everyone must go and enjoy ! The services is Excellent . Thank you Wheelers Veronica read more

F00d is outstanding, delivered hot and correct every time. Burgers, quesadillas, to turkey dinners Excellent. Never disappointed

SEVERE FOOD POISONING ...AVOID THIS RESTAURANT! DO NOT EAT HERE. We visited this restaurant as a group of four on Saturday at 9 PM and ordered wings, nachos, quesadillas, and french fries. We believe the chicken poisoned us. All four of us spent the entire night violently vomiting. My fever spiked to 39°C forcing me to go to the hospital for emergency IV serum treatment. Over 24 hours later, we are still suffering. I have severe body aches, extreme weakness, and am still nauseous . This is not a simple stomach bug; this is severe food poisoning caused by their negligence. This restaurant plays with people's health. Their blatant disregard for basic food safety in the pursuit of profit is absolutely unacceptable. I am taking legal action. Do not make our mistake. Avoid this restaurant at all costs for your own well being. read more

I went to this restaurant on Saturday with a group of friends, and we all ended up with severe food poisoning afterward. Within hours, we started feeling sick -- nausea, stomach pain, fever, and weakness. My condition got so bad that I had to go to the emergency room to get an IV for dehydration and fatigue. This is absolutely unacceptable and shows a serious lack of hygiene and food safety standards. We went there expecting a pleasant meal and ended up dealing with days of sickness and medical bills. Clearly, something is very wrong with how their food is being handled or stored. It's shocking that a restaurant can operate under such unsafe conditions. Avoid this place at all costs. No meal is worth risking your health. I'm posting this to warn others before they go through the same terrible experience. read more

I have to say, I was pleasantly surprised by how good this local bar is. While the bar itself is typical with cozy vibes, it's the food that you need to try here. Plus, the bartenders are friendly and attentive. Aside from the drinks, we got some food. We ordered the Buffalo Wings ($13.95 for 10pcs) and Pizza Bread ($7.50). The pizza bread is good, but you need to eat this hot or else it gets a bit soggy. But the buffalo wings are so large and juicy here slathered in sauce. Definitely some of the best wings I have had. read more

Wheeler's Restaurant - Buffalo Wings. - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Great !! Had an amazing near thr bartender was super friendly!! Will definitely be comimg back!!

It's hard to find something to eat even when there's so many options around, but for whatever reason, I landed on Wheeler's this night and thanks to other Yelpers, I decided to try the steak tid bits with fries which were delicious! The steak slices might have looked dry, but they were so tender and juicy. The garlic bread and cheese made it extra yummy and the fries were also really good! I also got the fried zucchini sticks which were good and had a decent sauce, but I was enjoying my tid bits so much that they kinda went to waste. Tried to eat them the next date toasting them up in the toaster oven, but it wasn't the same. The tid bits on the other hand heated up quite nicely for a yummy late night snack. I'd definitely get these again! read more

Wheeler's Restaurant - Steak tid bits with fries and fried zucchini - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This place can do no wrong. The food is consistently delicious and well- prepared. Wings and buffalo calamari are a must have. The service is friendly. It has an all- around comfortable atmosphere. Great local place ! read more

Completely excellent without fault. This place understands food quality, drink quality and ambient quality. The dishes here excel in both flavor and freshness. This restaurant reveals impressive skill. This spot offers apparent skill. read more

Wow talk about disappointment. Wheelers used to be the go to spot for fajitas. Well obviously they left the recipe back in the 1990's. What an unmitigated disaster this order was!! It was a non flavored soupy mess. I kid you not. I wouldn't eat this even if it was free. I paid nearly $40 for the absolute worst fajitas I've ever had. When I say no flavor, I mean it. The vegetables looked and tasted like they were sitting around for a few days. Barely any meat and I'm still looking for the chicken lol. Shame on them to send that slop out. read more

My husband took me to Wheelers when we had just met. It became our go to place. He proposed to me there. We had my son's birthday there. We went back when that son turned 21. It was very nostalgic for us. The food was ok. I miss the old wheelers. Glad the walls can't talk. It was a fun place to hang out. read more

Love this place . Drinks are cheap waiters are always great and funny . BUT THE WINGS are wow . Extra crispy lite on the sauce can't go wrong . 10 out 10 read more

Wheeler's Restaurant - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Food and drinks are great.service is excellent . Watch all the game action on the TV'S

Food not fresh. Wraps. And buns very hard. Had a hamburger. The meat tasted rotten. Changed for chicken wrap. Wrap ver hard and had hardly any filling. That too was tasting very funny. Needless to say we went home and three of us were in the bathroom most of the night. Please don't dine there if you want to stay well. read more

In Brooklyn visiting. Typically order from the same proven restaurants every time I'm here. This time decided to try wheelers. First thing I must say either they haven't realized there is inflation or that is all just a sham. Look at the prices on their menu. Nothing is cheap obviously but the prices are drastically more reasonable than at other places! Their portions are great. Ordered 2 types of wings, calamari, fried zucchini and the mixed seafood pasta dish. Considering we got this delivered the quality of food was on point. If we are at the restaurant it would have been even better. Seamless does seem to take quite a few fees for this place so that part isn't good but otherwise this is awesome to order from. I almost feel bad for the chef for the amount of seafood he had to stuff into their aluminum bowl and then close. That thing was ready to burst! But also packed pretty well. Do yourself a favor, check this place out! read more

This has been a place that was on my radar but just never went and I thought to myself, what was I waiting for? This is truly a gem in Sheepshead bay. It has a the air of a local pub but with a nice restaurant feel as you walk deeper in the back. It's definitely a great place to take the family. Now to the service. We were seated promptly and the staff was super attentive without being overbearing. They were kind and professional. Let us take a few extra minutes to order. They never made us feel rushed and the food came out in a good time. The menu is a bit large but there are options for everyone and I appreciated the variety, personally. With a good mix of cocktails, beers both draft and bottles it'll make a great spot for a night out with some friends or just dinner. The poulet au champignon was delicious. Everything was cooked just right, the meat was juicy and not dry, the side of creamed spinach and mashed potatoes was a nice rich accompaniment. Needless to say they along with the side salad which was very fresh and the wonderfully cooked apps of wings, fried zucchini and mozzarella sticks I was totally satisfied. I look forward to coming back and trying the 16 oz Sirloin next and of course the measure of any good American fare, a good juicy burger. Only reason I could say it's a 4 is due to the portions. While it was fine for me there were some in my party that had to take a to go bag and it was just too much for them. Unfortunately sitting in the back we did have some flies around us at some point during our dinner which was not pleasant but I never felt unsafe eating my food. All in all this was a good experience and I've got a new place to take friends to around the area. read more

Wheeler's Restaurant - a plate of chicken with mushrooms, mashed potatoes, and broccoli - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Roast beef all the way with melted mozzarella on a toasted garlic hero is now my go to. Really outstanding and chill vibe here as always. read more

Wheeler's Restaurant - Roast beef all the way! - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I've been coming here for years and their food has always been top notch. Everything is fresh, hot and delicious. Not only a great local bar and business but the atmosphere here is great! read more

So - after many more visits here, I can only say that I love Wheeler's even more, & they are now tied with New Belacan Malaysian restaurant (which may or may not be located next to Soccer Tavern) as my favorite restaurant in Brooklyn. They are not fancy - for that, we go to Michael's. But the food at Wheeler's REALLY rocks. In addition to their Buffalo wings (best of NYC), their burgers, sandwiches (tuna melt ), pastas, & salads are all awesome. The staff is super friendly & attentive, & clearly want people to feel at home, be happy, & have a good time. Their drinks pack a punch, & are reasonably priced. They also have a diverse jukebox w/ some great music. And to the craft beer snob that complained about their selection: considering that their crowd does not seem to care about craft beer, I can always find something interesting (traditional German beer) that I'm very happy with -! Viva Wheeler's ! read more

Wheeler's Restaurant - a glass of beer on a bar - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Awesome Place!!!!!!!! I got the Chirizo Nachao and it was phenomenal! Fast delivery.., according to specifications..., and food was hot! Excellent professional service. Great Location for a Date! A plethora of menu options! Spacious Location for large groups.., and birthday parties read more

Wheeler's Restaurant - Love the French Fries - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Old school type of bar vibes! The buffalo chicken strips are great so is the pecan pie!

Great food. Try the steak tidbits, you will love it. I go there a lot of times. The place is clean and they have great service. read more

Great food...Great service...friendly atmosphere...had the chicken sandwich, really good....just as equal to the rest of the menu

Food and service was excellent manager is superb definitely would recommend ambience was beautiful. I am a new customer frequently visit once a week. read more

Service and burgers are great - is a bar not fine dining next times I will try the wings. Cesar salad for 2 feeds 4

We found this spot and was actually excited that it was open for sit down dinning. My wife and I haven't done so in so long. This is a very nice establishment staff is friendly and polite. Location seems to be a neighborhood hot spot. I've definitely decided to come to sheepshead bay to do some more fine dining and shooting as well. read more

Wheeler's Restaurant - Ordered the Mojito very good very smooth - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I always go here with my family and close friends and I always have a great time. The service is good and no one makes me feel like they are rushing me out. Comfortable place, service is great. Atmosphere is laid back. read more

Great Neighborhood spot although I have went out of my way to get their food !! I love comfortable chill spots to have a beer and some awesome pub food !! I lost the pics I took but trust the steak is flavorful and the portions are shareable !! The loaded nachos are a meal for 3 !!!! read more

Love this spot it's like home to me waiters are also great and food is great too the wings ... are amazing not sure if they still do the Tuesday discount but it's worth looking into read more

So you have a wing night, which draws a crowd, which turns a profit. Then you get a little greedy and you enforce a 20 wing per table rule at a time. I get it, it takes 35 minutes for new wings to come out of the kitchen. A bored sad customer will order another drink. "Hooray, profit!". If only the wings were something worth waiting for. Can you imagine the embarrassment of arriving with a full table of hungry friends and nibbling on three wings each? You're averaging 5.7 wings an hour. Unless you're into meth, I'd skip the trip, get a 4 piece from McDonald's, and brown bag a beer. It'll probably taste better and certainly be classier, plus you'll save a few dollars which is probably why you clicked on a placed called "wheelers" in sheepshead bay, Brooklyn anyway. read more

Wheeler's Restaurant - Yeah, they actually look that old and greasy in person too... - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York