*CASH ONLY* This 40 year old, family-owned, deli is a true gem! I went here because of a Yelp elite review and it was the best decision I've made today. TGIF! Service was quick and friendly! The lady at the counter knew both of the other customers by name. Regulars are always a good thing in any establishment. The sandwich was excellent, and I miss my Long Island, Deli's! I didn't know it was cash only and came up short $.50. She told me not to worry about it. That won me over and every time I'm on Long Island I will attend this deli as well as tip her. I highly recommend you check this place out. read more

See all

Good food, good service. An excellent example of small, local business that beats the corporate alternatives. It's cash only, so no credit cards, debit cards or cash phony cryptoFake money. But that's understandable. The originators of this business have passed but their daughter (I am told) carries on in their footsteps. I hope she knows they'd be proud. It's a great deli. read more

Didn't realize it was cash only until after I ordered. Didn't have cash on me, or my ATM card. They were so nice, gave me my order and said I could stop in and pay if I'm ever in the neighborhood. And on top of that, it was a really good egg sandwich and coffee read more

This place is fantastic. The breakfast and lunch sandwich options are vast; plus the breakfast sandwiches are affordable. The selection of chips is impressive, too. I don't mind that it is cash only. The first time I visited I had to use the ATM. $2.50 charge, which my bank took care of. If "cash only" is your breaking point, that sucks for you. And maybe have a bank that takes care of ATM fees. read more

That was a BANGIN' B.E.C. I had this morning! Just before Thanksgiving I posted on social media teasing everyone who moved to Florida to get in line for their B.E.C (Bacon-Egg-Cheese on a hard roll, very NY) well, my buddy Lou said the best he ever had was on Maple Ave in Smithtown. I walked in this morning to a typical Long Island Deli. I see a gentleman behind the counter wearing a Hawaiian shirt taking orders. He said to the customer in front of me, morning Fred. The usual? Yessir. He asks for my name and I ordered my go to: A soft scrambled B.E.C with S.P.K. The gentleman pours me a coffee and we start talking about the military (both Navy) he was also an amphibious guy so he's a solid dude. My egg sandwich? Perfectly cooked soft eggs, freshly melted cheese and just the right amount of bacon. Bacon is the key because if it was some weak, limp bacon I wouldn't be rushing to write a review. Not over cooked bacon but mamma pulled bacon out of the pan, crispy bacon. That is my 5 Star Yelp review. Yelpers, for 2022 I found for you the best B.E.C. being served on Long Island. Bill S approved! read more

Weinisch's Deli - That was a BANGIN' B.E.C! - Delis Near Me - Smithtown, New York

Food is great. Not a fan that it's cash only . Service is fast and friendly . Place is clean

Their lettuce wraps are so good I went back for more! Very attentive to each customer and fast service. It looks like a typical Long Island Deli, but they definitely go above and beyond. I will definitely be back when I visit Long Island. read more

Cash only. No sign or inconspicuous sign. Food was good but heavily overpriced. This is one and done for me Thumbs down.

I called up before hand and ordered a 2 bacon egg and cheese's on a roll to be picked up. When I walk in there and pick up my order there's only 1 sandwich in the bag. but I wasnt gonna say anything only because i only ended up paying for the 1. I paid for 1 anyway and went back home only to find that my sandwich HAD NO EGGS in it and it was just a bacon and cheese on a roll. When I went back in and I explained to them. no apology, no discount. All they said was "Well he didn't hear you on the phone". That will be the last time I walk in that place. read more

I have yet to have a bad meal here. Everything is always cooked perfectly and they don't skimp on portions. The staff couldn't be any friendlier. There's a reason they seem to know their customers on a first name basis. If you haven't eaten here yet, you're missing out. read more

Consistently good fresh and affordable breakfast, lunch and picnic choices. Fresh hot soups, authentic German salads, boars head meat and delightfully LARGE sandwiches. Friendly clerks, Ample parking, accessible. All prices have gone up everywhere so the change they increased to my selections was well worth it and i support the local places as much as i can. Note: Potato, Macaroni and Cole slaw were made with real mayonnaise, not salty and delicious. BTW they have an assortment of desserts on the counter and fresh rice, tapioca and bread pudding as well read more

Very clean, everyone is always friendly, pricing is fair, food is delicious!! Cash only.

A great place Friendly staff that know you. Best salads in the area. If you want the NY LI Deli experience and great egg sandwiches, this is the Busness to go to you will not be disappointed. business read more

Upon entry its like cheers.... everyone knows your name, how your tea/coffee is prepared, and the type of breakfast sandwich you prefer. I was moved by the " old school feel here" it took me back to when people talked to people w/o texting. Exceptional quality, great tasting choices and A+ freshly made mini muffins... They are a small treat to temp the taste buds. Sections vary; Cappuccino chip, banana nut, chocolate chip, corn, bran& blueberry. Easily accessible to Rte 347/454, Rte 111, Northern State and the LIE. Ample parking. They get crowded do come early for breakfast, lunch. You'll be glad you did so will your belly. Enjoy read more

See all

Absolutely amazing! I've been hunting for a good deli in Suffolk for a minute, and I was extremely impressed. Service was better than great, and the sandwiches were DELICIOUS. I live in Commack, but 100% will be trekking the extra few miles whenever I'm craving another sammy. read more

where is the beef? It's right here conveniently located along Smithtown's main thoroughfare... Let me level with you... the best bacon I have ever had in Suffolk county... Having having swine three times a week for the last 30 years, I should be ready to squeal... It's not the case, though these folks are worth the travel . read more

the best around! fold is great staff is awesome. Best egg sandwich on long island hands down . highly recommend

Service was fast & friendly! I got a sausage, egg & cheese on a roll, all very fresh! Will definitely come back :) read more

Weinisch's Deli - Sausage, egg & cheese on a roll - Delis Near Me - Smithtown, New York

The cost is a little Expensive. The food is very good overall. The Service is also very good.

I stopped in during my lunch break, the food is a little expensive yes, but it was a tasty sandwich. The people working were very friendly and welcoming. read more

Every time I come to Long Island I hit up Weinisch's Deli for the BEST bacon egg and cheese sandwich!Macaroni salad is dope too.

I walked in just in time. Here it is, 2 pm on a Saturday afternoon and there's a line ten deep as I was leaving. made me feel good about stopping here. I decided to have a #3,roast beef (I had regular instead of Cajun), bacon, mozzarella, on a garlic roll. No use pushing my luck, it's a long ride back to MA. It's been 2 years since I've been in a real NY deli, bu I thought nine bucks for a sandwich (non hero) was on the pricey side. I will say that it was one fine sandwich. It was hot, it didn't make a mess and it tasted great. Much better then anything I can get in MA, I would definitely stop back again, now that I am over my sticker shock. read more

Weinisch's Deli - Delis Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

First time I visit this deli I never thought a chicken sandwich w mayo, lettuce and tomatoes on a roll will cost $12.45 I will definitely not going back to this place ever again, stay away from this place it's a reap off read more

Can not tell you enough good things about this deli. It's old school. Knows peoples names and orders Food is great. read more

This deli has mastered making lettuce wraps!! Delicious low carb or gluten free option. read more

Weinisch's Deli - Delis Near Me - Smithtown, New York

Food is fresh. Great service. The only issue is cash only. But there is a atm inside.

Incredible! Very very clean, friendly staff, fast & efficient and absolutely delicious. Great egg sandwiches, delicious bagels, and coffee was also awesome. It is cash only but that's to be expected for a mom and pop shop like this. I was amazed that every single person that walked in while I was there at least about 6 people they knew every single persons name. So glad that we tried this spot especially being that it's 3 minutes from home for us! Definitely a hidden gem! read more

I have been coming to this family run deli for over 20 years and go out of my way and pass 3 other delis to come to Weinisch's. The place is spotless and aways nicely stocked. Great place to visit and the staff is first class. read more

Weinisch's Deli - Great family deli you won't be disappointed.. - Delis Near Me - Smithtown, New York

I do not get in often but when i do i am never disappointed by their kindness or good food. Great old school breakfast sandwiches read more

Thought I would give it a shot went there ordered a basic turkey hero sandwich lettuce tomato mayo. Went to the ocean opened it up and not impressive at all in fact the worst sandwich I've probably have eaten in my life. We definitely not recommend this place to anyone and will not be going back. read more

I feel like I need to update this as a week has gone by and the sting has worn off. As I mentioned I've been going here for years and it's always been good so I don't feel a knee-jerk 2 stars is fair based on one bad experience considering the overall history. read more

Sorry, when you are listed as a German deli there should be German food. There were premade Italian and American dishes that were in the cold cases. I purchased four deli salads. German potato salad, Dutch potato salad, regular potato salad and macaroni salad. All 4 had too much sugar added to them. That was not German potato salad. The German potato salad was an insult to my heritage. The other salads were okay. The Dutch potato salad was very watery. Not a fan and won't go back. 09/21/17 Apparently somebody did not like my review and left a nasty note. I stand by my original review. To the nasty person that left a nasty note(comment without a profile) I do make my own salads and I make better salads than this Deli. read more

Sandwich was fair with nothing extra. And we are talking tuna fish. And with extras paid $13. Gave the young girl $15 and needed to remind them I got change as in,$2. She was leaving the room as if it was her tip ??? Odd place. read more

I eat there a few times a week. The breakfast specials are outstanding. Free coffee or OJ with your Sammy. They also have these homemade muffins for 50 cents each or 3 for$1.50 They are the best. The staff if friendly and the place is spotless. Go there, you won't be disappointed. read more

I've been going to this deli for years and the food is always great sandwiches are big and food is fresh and the Coffee is the best!!! Tammy is always nice and friendly. read more

A little pricey is an understatement!!! They do not accept credit cards and so happy to take your cash and lots of it!!! I just don't understand why a simple chicken cutlet on a roll, quarter pound of mac and a small bag of chips with no drink would come to 13.00 Ouch!!!! read more

Best coffee in town! Great service and people. Tammy, Annie, and rest of the staff are the best in the biz...

Great place. Home town feel. Grew up in the neighbor and always a pleasure to come back and grab a sandwich. Good helpings and good value for you money. Way better than Jersey Mike's or Brendels which are both in the area. Owner is awesome and all family employees! read more

I had a sandwich here yesterday and it was loaded with lettuce, cucumbers, onion, dressing, pepper jack cheese and more. It was simply incredible. Their egg sandwiches are also yummy so I definitely recommend it. read more

Best service and food at a deli that I've had in my life. Would recommend it to anyone in the area this small family business does it right!