This is a special of theirs the All' Amatriciana. Delicious! That's all I will give you. But I will also share that the staff and bartenders are amazing, chill, and welcoming. The focaccia bread is worth the trip alone (sorry I didn't photo it) . The vibe in here is upscale but not pretentious. You can eat upscale food and fancy bev but also feel chill at home vibes. Mama mia focaccia pizza heaven read more

Wayfarer Tavern - This is a special of theirs the All' Amatriciana. - Pizza Near Me - Dayton, Kentucky

Love this bar. It's in an old building with the ambiance of exposed brick, and wooden floors. Beautiful. The food is amazing - we had the Caesar salad and meatball appetizers and the Tavern Classic pizza. All delicious. Although I would say that while the Caesar salad is rightfully delicious, it's not a classic Caesar flavor profile. I want to go back and explore other intriguing menu items! Our server, Ann, was attentive and helpful and made the evening very pleasant for us. Thank you! read more

The hubs and I have been on the hunt for the best pizza, and this was a recommendation. Very interesting pizza combinations! They were unfortunately out of foccacia bread when we got there, but the manager told us about the secret garlic Flatbread option and we were sold. We also got the meatballs. We were surprised by the size, but with all the food we had it seemed smart that the meatballs were on the smaller side. Cool little place, we'll definitely come back. read more

Love everything about this place! It's so great to see quality food coming in to Dayton, ky! The interior is fun and cozy, we loved the bar area and the food was delicious! The carpaccio was some of the best we've had in cincy! We also loved the crispy pizza crust! We tried the staff pick of the month and it had pepperoni and hot honey. read more

See all

we went here after seeing it on Chowdown Cincinnati, and we're so excited to try it out There was a 45 minute wait to sit inside, but outside was available, so we decide to sit outside and were completely fine with that because it felt great out. our server was amazing, and he was great and super friendly while the girl that delivered drinks seemed to be very annoyed with our presence. I really loved the focaccia bread and the Caesar salad. I thought they were absolutely delicious. And would 100% go back. Just to eat that. As for the pizza, I was not impressed, and it had a hot honey sauce on it. That was good, but it seems to be completely covered in it, in a negative way. I had two small pieces, and then decided to just leave the rest due to not enjoying. I would come back to give this place, another chance or just for the Caesar salad. read more

See all

Very over priced for what you get. Charging extra for every little thing, like the olive oil. Really? Pizza had very little sauce and dried out. Wine is out of the question$$$$ read more

Best tavern style pizza in the Cincinnati area. Crunchy, cheesy crust around the edges is incredible! read more

Wayfarer Tavern - Da Bears pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dayton, Kentucky

holy SMOKES! this place is sooooo yummy, I went twice in one week. the pizza alla matriciana is mouth watering, and the cocktails were a dream. the espresso martini was good, but the disco queen might now be my favorite cocktail of all time. great vibe when you walk in as well, with a verrrry cool bar. also our server, tristan, was absolutely wonderful! highly highly recommend read more

Wayfarer Tavern - espresso martini - Pizza Near Me - Dayton, Kentucky

See all

My absolute favorite pizza place! The best crust, the most creative pies while still providing classics. I wish I could come here everyday because it's so much more than your average pizza joint! read more

See all

This place is soooo good! The Caesar salad was phenomenal and full of flavor. The toasted breadcrumbs and Caesar dressing that came with it had us begging for more. We had the classic tavern pizza and fully planned on taking some home, but my husband and I CRUSHED it because it was that good. We are already planning another trip back so we can try a different pizza! read more

Wayfarer Tavern - Caesar salad - Pizza Near Me - Dayton, Kentucky

See all

Went to Wayfarer for Valentine's dinner and had an excellent time! It's so great to see new spots popping up in Dayton. My favorite part of the meal was genuinely the cocktails. They were perfect. The meatballs and pizza were delicious. I like how the pizza is cut into smaller squares. Overall it was very delicious, but it was a bit pricey for pizza. Service was good and the ambiance is an elevated bar. Has a very cozy vibe that I really liked. We will be back! read more

See all

We love this place. Think of an upscale pizza place. Great little date night. Highly recommend sitting at the bar. We loved the vegetarian buffalo chicken pizza. Great service. Everyone is very friendly. read more

Good tavern style pizza. Fun combos. We got the Korean corn cheese and potato rosemary truffle pizza. My friend also got the Thai tea cocktail. Service was good. Nice staff. read more

Wayfarer Tavern - The Korean corn cheese and potato rosemary truffle - Pizza Near Me - Dayton, Kentucky

some of the best pizza i've had in the greater cincinnati area! we were a walk-in and promptly seated in the bar area (which was GORGEOUS) and service was prompt and friendly :) everything we ordered was so delicious & i willllll be thinking about that focaccia for the foreseeable future MMM read more

See all

It's everything you want it to be!!! The ambiance is fantastic! The good amazing! The service well it could of been better Over all we are going back soon!! read more

Finally tried out the much anticipated pickle pizza at wayfarer. While the food and drinks were tasty it's definitely overpriced. Also our pizza orders were accidentally served to the table next to us so while we watched them eat our 2 pizzas and their 2 pizzas we waited over 45 mins for ours. The staff comped focaccia, another round of drinks and our $8 peppadew appetizer which was nice of them. Kinda wish they took care of at least one of our pizzas. We unfortunately didn't have the best first experience :( read more

Wayfarer Tavern - Cheese pizza and pickle power - Pizza Near Me - Dayton, Kentucky

We had a great meal here. Service was quick. Pizza was like was a boujie version of Donatos. Our bartender Andrew was super kind and knowledgeable about the menu. read more

See all

Our server was great, giving us many recommendations that we appreciated. We were seated near the open kitchen but it was a casual vibe for a girls night. The food was good, with the Korean cheese pizza being our favorite, but our other orders were not as memorable. read more

Wayfarer Tavern - Pickle power pizza and Korean corn cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dayton, Kentucky

My family and I were here celebrating my uncle's retirement and everything was incredible! Not pictured but equally delicious were the meatball appetizer, pepperoni pizza, korean corn cheese pizza (the bbq on this one is kind of spicy, which I liked but some would've preferred it on the side), trusty chords pizza, and veggie deluxe. Our server Riley was great as well. read more

Wayfarer Tavern - Burrata Peppadew pepper stuffed with herbed garlic cream cheese Gigante beans with red onions, garlic, and breadcrumbs - Pizza Near Me - Dayton, Kentucky

See all

From the food to the drinks to the atmosphere and service, Wayfarer is just killing it. We have been there a few times and have thoroughly enjoyed it each time. Friendly staff, tasty food, and good drinks. Can't ask for much more! Highlights so far include the pickle pizza and Korean corn bbq pizza, but the caesar salad and stuffed peppadew peppers are a must have as well. The cocktail menu is well thought out and has options for everyone. The strawberry puree cocktail (I forget the name but we subbed out vodka for the gin) is just the perfect summer drink. Also, they have a very generous rewards program, which makes it a great place to throw into the regular rotation. Can't wait to go back! read more

See all

Tavern Style pizza in Ohio is hard to come by ever since I moved from Chicago and this one is the best I've found. For just being open a few months their pizzas hit the spot everytime. The pepperoni on this pizza is filled with cup-char pepperoni! The only thing I noticed was the service was quite slow and hope this will improve the longer they are open. I'm glad I found this spot because now any time I am craving tavern style I will be sure to pick up a pie from here. read more

Wayfarer Tavern - Pizza Near Me - Dayton, Kentucky

Cool little tavern in a remodeled old house. Went there for lunch and had a great time. Great friendly service! We shared marinated olives, chips and horseradish onion dip, and the Devil's Backbone Pizza with red sauce. The olives were amazing! Good marinated olives, but topped with chopped almonds, garlic, and cheese (just a little of each) and came with hummus and focaccia. The horseradish onion dip was nice and came with an assortment of colorful vegetables! The pizza was good as well - tavern cut with dollops of spicy sauce on top. Finished it off with a root beer float with vanilla gelato. Not far from Newport - worth a visit if you're in the area! read more

See all

Service and drinks still amazing . I can be back for the pizza . It wasn't terrible next time I'll ask for more sauce . I love the then crust . I will say the apps made more of a lasting impression. But there is great food to be had in dayton KY! read more

Wayfarer Tavern - Poizza - Pizza Near Me - Dayton, Kentucky

This place serves interesting pizzas like Korean corn and Dill Pickle, along with craft cocktails and small bites. I think it's something fun and different, but all of the pizzas are 12 inches and around $20 a piece. They are a touch overpriced for the value so I'm not sure I would go back, but I do see this as worth a visit if you haven't been! The Korean corn was our favorite, and the Caesar and tavern salads were good too read more

Great pizza and salads. Mixologist is awesome. Service is attentive. Prefer the room with the bar.

Made it in tonight for their soft opening and was not disappointed. Super cute spot in Dayton. Bartender Scott was amazing and they were packed! Always got to work out the kinks but the food was amazing!!! Had a little bit of everything: oysters, meatballs, beans, mortadella, and stuffed peppers to start. Highlights were the beans and peppers by far. I would have preferred the oysters to come with everything on the side but still good. Always prefer west coast oysters too. Got a wedge and literally almost licked the plate. Deluxe pepperoni pizza and dill pickle. Both the best! It's donato's style, could have been a bit crisper. Pepperoni won in my onion but the group was a mix. Either way solid place! read more

See all

Really good food, but slow, vibe-y service. Like we weren't cool enough to be there. But once we started asking about the food the server became nicer. read more

We went in on Sunday at 2:00 in the afternoon. There was one table already there and we were the second. We ordered 4 pizzas and drinks. It took right at an hour to get the pizzas, and one of them was the wrong pizza. They did remake it, and it only took half an hour. If you want an interesting twist on pizza they have it and they are pretty good. Just be ready to wait and they are pricy. If you are expecting a Chicago tavern style pizza, this is not the place for it. read more

The pizza is outstanding. Very nice selection of toppings. The coffee martini outstanding. Service excellent. While it is a bar, it is family oriented. Went there twice. Had two stellar experiences. Highly recommend it. read more

Wayfarer Tavern is making some of the best pizza you'll find in any city, anywhere. The restaurant its self is classic and welcoming. Great vibe. The service is always top notch. We've tried a few of the specialty pizzas and loved them all. For me, it's usually cheese pizza, but with tavern style pies it's fun to get more than one and share. Try the Korean Corn if you're looking for something non traditional. 5 stars across the board. read more

Wayfarer Tavern - Korean corn pizza / cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dayton, Kentucky

Honestly great and inventive pizzas are coming out of Wayfarer Tavern, which also offers a fine selection of tempting cocktails. For a family dinner, we ordered three different 12" pizzas -- the Korean Corn Cheese (Confit Garlic Cream White Sauce, 3 Cheese Blend Corn, Sweet & Spicy Pickled Jalapeño, Gochujang BBQ Sauce, Green Onion After Bake), the Pickle Power (Confit Garlic Cream, White Sauce, Pickles, Onion, 3 Cheese Blend Fresh Dill, Chive, House-Made Ranch, & Ridged Potato Chips After Bake) and the May Staff Choice (Crispy Cup-and-Char Pepperoni, Bacon, Sweet & Spicy Pickled Jalapeño, House-Made Hot Honey, Red Sauce, 5 Cheese Blend). All were really good but the Korean Corn Cheese was my favorite with all the ingredients blending to create something really special and different. I was going to have the El Capitan Margarita when our great server let me know about an off the menu special margarita made with ginger. It was wonderful. The only reason I am not giving Wayfarer a top rating is the level of noise in the restaurant. Between the wood floors and high ceilings, there is nothing to soften the sound of happy conversations. I truly only caught about 20% of our table talk, which is a shame given how rarely we are all together. read more

Wayfarer Tavern - Off menu ginger margarita - yummy! - Pizza Near Me - Dayton, Kentucky

See all

Love the tavern style pizza! Perfect crisp and good undercarriage so it's not too floppy. Sat at the bar ! read more

Wayfarer Tavern - Pep pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dayton, Kentucky

Wayfarer is a great addition to the Greater Cincy Pizza scene serving up tavern style pizzas. The outdoor seating is super great on a nice day and the service was friendly and attentive. The star of the show was the caesar salad. The crisp lettuce, toasted breadcrumbs, anchovy pieces and flavorful dressing went perfectly together. The tavern style veggie pizza was very unique with the lemon and ricotta with a great cook on the pie. The cheese was cooked well and was solid, but the flavor was nothing special. I am excited to come back and try the pickle and Korean corn pizza! read more

This is my 3rd time eating here, can't wait to go back. The food and service are excellent! I've sat at a table and at the bar and both have great vibes. Had the Pappadew Peppers to start with and then The Heatwave pizza. Andrew the bartender is very knowledgeable and provides awesome service! Wow is all I can say! read more

See all

Amazing. Delicious. So full. Pepperoni pizza and pickle pizza were both so freaking good. Leftovers are lunch for tomorrow. I love it. read more

Wayfarer Tavern - Pepperoni pizza, pickle power pizza, martini - Pizza Near Me - Dayton, Kentucky

Love this place! Have been twice and both times we had excellent food and service. The Burrata and wedge salad are a must!

WOW! I can't wait to go back and I was just there last night. This is such a cool old building, I'll have to ask what it originally was next time. We split the horseradish dip, the peppers, the family style salad for four and the pickle pizza. We devoured it ALL. Everything was so good. The wine and beer list is extensive and even includes multiple NA options. Our server was fantastic, too, and clued us into their loyalty program. When I paid last night, I'd already earned $17 off my next visit. I wish I lived closer, I'd be here weekly. Already planning my next trip back. read more

Pizza is unreal, thin and crispy. Be sure to get a reservation if on a weekend or be prepared to wait.

This place absolutely delivers on every level. The tavern crust is the perfect balance of crispy and delicious, the toppings are always on point and unique, and the flavors are spot-on every time. You can tell they put real care into their ingredients and craft. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, the staff is friendly and attentive, and the service is quick. Whether you're grabbing a pizza to go or sitting down for a full meal, you always feel taken care of. I've tried basically everything on the menu, and everything has been fantastic. The standout is definitely the tavern style pizza, but don't sleep on the salads and apps, including the shrimp cocktail, spinach artichoke dip, marinated beans, wedge salad, and focaccia, all of which are Highly recommended! If you love pizza, this is a must-visit. read more

Walked by this place a few weeks ago and noted that we needed to try it because it smelled so insanely good. Went back with a med sized group on a Sunday evening and they were able to seat us immediately. Very kind staff and lovely interior as well as very clean bathrooms. Super unique pizza - loved each one we tried. 4 pizzas fed 5 people nicely - had a small box of leftovers after. The only thing that would make this place just a *tad* nicer is if they changed out their tablecloths for something more neutral read more

Wayfarer Tavern - Pizza Near Me - Dayton, Kentucky

See all