We had other plans in the plaza on March 11th where The Exchange is located, but my husband saw…read morethem and our plans quickly changed. My hubby was in heaven looking around and told me I am officially in charge of making yelp use a 6 star system so I can give them 6 stars. They have wall to wall and several aisles stocked full of product. They even have a buy 2 items under $3 get the 3rd item under $3 free. They have loads of dvds/blurays, cds, some books/manga, old and new games and systems, and some awesome collectibles. The employees definitely were the cherry on top. He was telling us about the setup of the store, deals the have and about their trade in policies (which are the states policy and super intense to stop stolen items from being sold. They even do fingerprints). My husband is officially obsessed with this store and if he could live here he would. We had to go back to the hotel to grab a game to trade in and on the way back he said "I love this place. I know we aren't there but I'm going to talk like we are because my soul is there". I have no doubts we will be back. We ended up getting a few different things and we were pleased with everything.

The Exchange is located in a small strip mall and has a fair amount of parking. I primarily went in…read moreto check out their CD section, which was a pretty good selection. What was even better was their variety of vinyl, and I ended up purchasing two LPs and one CD. Prices for either medium were either reasonable for used or overpriced, not really in the middle. A lot of their collection, including the CDs, is behind glass, which makes it not as easy for a shopper to quickly check out the inventory before buying.

This is a kid and/or adult's dream--regardless of what you're looking for. They have a bit of…read moreeverything for the kid who wants to play or find some unusual toys for their ever-expanding collection, or an adult who wants to revel in some nostalgia. In addition, the staff are kind, helpful, and knowledgeable about their various products. Finally, if you are looking to sell or trade some items, they are fair and considerate when reviewing your items. Every city needs a "Toy Pit."

I purchased four vinyl records from The Toy Pit on September 6, and unfortunately, the experience…read morehas been extremely disappointing. After the purchase, I discovered that the records I received appear to be counterfeit rather than legitimate releases. I contacted the store to try to resolve the issue, but they refused to provide any type of refund or stand behind the products they sold me. Considering how highly priced many of the items in this store are, I find it unacceptable that a customer can spend their money there, discover there is a serious issue with the authenticity of the merchandise, and then be left with no resolution. At this point, I will be disputing the charge with my bank. The entire situation has been handled very unprofessionally, and based on my experience, I would strongly recommend verifying the authenticity of anything you purchase here before spending your money.

Why would a woman who has never played Warhammer review a store that's all about Warhammer? Because…read morethe kind person at Games Workshop took the time to explain the store and its purpose to me, as well as a little bit of the game. And now I want to bring my kids to see if Warhammer is something they might be interested in! I popped into Games Workshop because I happened to be visiting a restaurant in the same shopping center. It had the word "games" in the name, so I had to check it out. Turns out, the store is all about one particular game: Warhammer. I had heard of Warhammer, but I didn't know an entire store could be dedicated to it. Indeed, an entire store can be dedicated to Warhammer! There are kits and mini figures, and paints to paint your figures, and tables at which to play the game, if you want. They have a lot of product in the store, but they can also order things for you, from what I remember. There are also some cool displays set up. I like mini things, so to see such intricate scenes set up is really fun, even if I have no idea what the context is in terms of game play. If you're into Warhammer, this is the place to be. And if you don't know about Warhammer but think it might be something you want to try, this is also the place to be because they will help you out here, and are very welcoming to newbies.

Went by to pick up some paints and other GW goods, and the store was closed, sign said they are…read moreopen from 12 to 6, so I went and burned an hour at another errand and headed back. Arrived at 12:50 on a Thursday and the store is still not open. Thanks for the waste of time. If you're going to post hours online, they should be correct. FFS get it together

If a teenage boy declares that this is his "favorite shop in Indianapolis," that means a lot. If he…read morealso says that he could spend all day in your shop and not get bored, you probably have something good going. It's hard to impress teenage boys. I'm not a teenage boy (as far as you know), but I also think Disc Replay is quite neat. It has an amazing collection of used video games for a variety of platforms, like Xbox, Playstation, Nintendo Switch, Nintendo DS, Gameboy, Wii, and even games for systems that old heads like me were brought up on, like the original Nintendo, Super Nintendo and Sega Genesis. The prices for these used games are suuuuuper good. Like, I was seeing price tags with $1.99 and $3.99 on them. We picked up a Plants vs. Zombies Nintendo DS game for $14.99, which according to my kid was a good price for a game he really wanted. They sell everything from refurbished Meta Quest VR headsets to Tamagotchi, which I didn't even know kids played still! Wow! A blast from the past. That's another thing: If you're a person of a certain age and you want to wax nostalgic about your middle school/high school years to the teenager you brought with you, visit Disc Replay. In the back of the store are aisles and aisles of used DVDs and Blu-Ray movies. My teenager asked me if this is what Blockbuster used to look like. Bless his heart. I said no and patiently described the wonder that was Blockbuster. Kids today just won't ever know; it's a dang shame. But thankfully, physical media is still a thing, and if you want to pick up a DVD copy of You Don't Mess with the Zohan, you can do that here. The people who work at Disc Replay are friendly and know their stuff. They answered our questions, and you can tell they don't only sell video games and movies, but they partake in this culture, too.

This place sucks! I would never go back. Went to trade in some old controllers told me wait time…read morewould be 3 hrs so I left them. When they call me saying my items are ready tell me that if I can't make it there before close, I forfeit the items. This should've been made clear before I dropped the items off. Once I arrive, they tell me we can't take these controllers because of XYZ. Something that very easily could've been communicated over the phone and would've held no issue picking up at a later time. Very poor managed with very poor communication. I've also had friends experience similar issues at the store would not recommend to anyone.

I brought in my original gameboy color from 2001 to be cleaned and have the speaker repaired…read morebecause it didn't work anymore. I also brought three gameboy color games that I love to have the batteries replaced and to get repaired for another issue. Brought them in on a Sunday and had them back home by the following Thursday. It was only $80 to have the batteries replaced in three games, have them cleaned and one of them repaired, and to have my gameboy color fully taken apart and cleaned, AND have a new speaker and screen protector put in. It was a very reasonable price for all the work! My gameboy looked brand new! Highly recommend bringing your older games or consoles here if they are in need of repair. Also has a great selection of hard to find games and gave me a fair trade in rate for the gameboy color games I don't play anymore.

This is honestly where you want to go if you are a *collector* and want that pristine game or…read moreconsole, in-box or otherwise. Prices on games not in-box and are just loose are reasonable at about what market rates are. Decent variety of handheld consoles, most of which are in a rotating case. They will clean the game once they sell it to you, and will even instruct it on how to clean it yourself for the future. They also do repairs for consoles. As the name suggests, this is really anything, and it is clear the people behind the counter are passionate and know a lot about the stuff they are selling. It is a little bit haphazard and there are some sections where stuff is kind of thrown together, but that is the flea market vibe. It is a bit of a trek but if you are looking for a serious video game purchase and want to avoid the Ebay nonsense, you should stop by Booth 31 for a visit.

The store is well organized and clean. Staff are super friendly and helpful. We didn't find…read moreanything this trip but they have plenty of items. From movies to music and novelty items. The cases are locked up so you have to ask for items out.

They recently opened up this location and I havent been disappointed. Everything is very well…read moreorganized and for the most part the staff are nice and attentive. The last time I went in to sell, it did take a few minutes to get an employees attention to check my items in, but it wasn't a super big deal. I'm sure as time goes on and they're able to get more staff on, they'll be just as awesome as the location in Castleton. I'll definitely be back soon. I've been a regular at their other location for a few years and I'm glad to see them expanding (and opening up a place closer to where I live).

Very reasonably priced games for Xbox, ps4, switch, and more!…read more They also have retro game systems, movies, toys, and other collectibles. If you're a 90s kid, you'll love this store!

This place has great games at great prices. I just wish I had more time to look around at all the…read moregreat retro game he had.

Any time I stop in Brownsburg I stop by here. Small store but good finds and good prices. The…read moreservice is always nice and polite. The selection is small but worth a look.

Have been loyal customers for here for years and I'm not sure why. 99% of the time we leave with a…read morebad taste in our mouths. Kindness community and growing their business is clearly not a priority by what is being put forth by staff and the owner.

The Service Is Great The Selection Is Cool And Wide…read moreEverything Else Is Good And The Value Can Be A Little Pricey At Times... But I Like This Place

Terrible, stay away! Purchased used game console that comes standard with 30 day warranty…read more Purchased extended warranty for coverage out to 6 months. Unit returned in 13 days as it would not read disc. Did not have another so got a refund. Refused to refund extended warranty purchase price. We never got to the time frame! Sent emails to this store via website, no response. They don't care about the customer.

We frequent here often and it's our opinion that it is the better of the Indy stores. The selection…read moreis usually decent and the prices, for the most part, are fair. The staff is friendly as well. The store could use some updating. It seems kinda blah, especially compared to their competition. We've never sold anything here so can't speak to that side of the business.

I've been to all kinds of used cd/dvd/game places before. This place is the best by far. They…read morehave pretty much anything you can imagine, media wise. They have a lot of old games for NES, SNES, Genesis, etc. All kinds of systems too, I think I saw an Atari Lynx in there one day! WTF! The place is loaded with DVDs. The east washington store has the best selection from what I've seen. I stumbled upon the Antoine Doinel Criterion Collection box set there a while back for sixty bucks and it was in perfect condition. All of the DVDs and CDs that I've bought there have been in pristine condition. The only bad thing to say about the place is that it's PURE EVIL. Your wallet WILL leave lighter than when it came in.