Reading Vermillion's Yelp Reviews helped me to brace for the worst experience. But if their service and food truly does wildly swing from awful to extremely good as noted on this site, then I feel fortunate.
Let's get right to the food highlights, as we tasted a number of different items.
==Spanish olive boquerones (white anchovies), jicama citrus roll:
This was a great way to start the meal as fresh anchovies makes u wanna ban that crap some pizza places top their pies with. Hints of tangerine worked well with the almost juicy, green pear-like, crisp jicama. It's a very nice combo.
==Kabob dog with chicken, feta cheese.:
We truly enjoyed the kabob dog as the meat had a great texture and beautiful, pinkish color with dark spices speckling. It was smokey and had a little heat that pleasurably crept up on you--like the wonderful finish of a fine red wine--about 4 seconds after you bit down. I could definitely see Hot Doug's offering these as complimentary rewards for those who brave his ridiculously-long lines.
==Blue corn crusted scallops:
Our server and your Yelp reviews rated this highly. We received two fat ass scallops with a kali mirch Latin calabasa and goat cheese puree. These scallops were obese! I seriously didn't expect them to be so insanely tender and chunky. There are a lot of curry flavors going on here and they work quite well together. My only complaint is I wish that the dish was a little warmer... but not if that means over-cooking the scallops in this setting. The crushed blue corn chips drove the mouth feel over the top, in a good way.
==Coconut Chili Mussels:
Indian coconut milk soup infused with curry leaves, mustard seeds
It was like these fresh and tender mussels were drenched in a great Thai Thom Ka soup... and this really worked well together. There were both sliced Serrano peppers and dried red chiles in the dish. We should have ordered our side of Naan earlier just to dip this broth!
==Chocolate coffee doughnut frittata, chocolate mole.
==Avocado beignet, wild berry reduction.
Not sure if this was a different pasty/dessert chef, but this is where things got very interesting again as these treats were truly exceptional. The beignet is true ambrosia as it's so light and delicate. I'd use less berry reduction as it's a bit sweet for my own tastes, but probably fine for most people. Using avocado in a dessert here is quite bold and THIS kind of culinary mastery is what i expected from all of the menu items. The frittata is nice and the white creamy mousse-like topping was out of this world.
Here's a quick rundown of the rest... the crab-topped watermelon was interesting but the sweetness overtook the tender, tasty crab. The potato 3 ways was just plain bland, boring and should never be served again. It was like an impotent Pierogi that fell apart and didn't give a damn.
The roasted three pepper lentil soup was pretty nice with the papadum but would have been stellar if it was thicker like a bisque. We even topped the special rice dishes with it and brought them to life. The tilapia was fresh but we never should have picked the Indian spice rub. Try it with the cilantro and mint instead, me thinks. And NEVER serve a hot beverage in a stainless steel cup without rim protection! Looks pretty, but burnt lips. Though I found them just OK, my friend loved the Naan tandoori sandwich with chicken and mint cucumber. And he liked the fish papadum tacos, spiced yogurt sauce.
We were pleasantly and promptly greeted upon entering and quickly shown to a table by our friendly, patient and attentive server. Not that there's anything wrong with it... but because I've eaten a fair bit of traditional Indo/Paki food elsewhere, it was cute to see an African-American lady serving us in this setting.
My colleague purchased a Groupon $60 tasting menu and I chose a few plates from the tapas menu. You pick two meats, two spices and two sides. We really felt that the Chef should have chosen the spices and added more sauce and toppings to the special rice items, as they were lacking.
Even though I've eaten at a plethora of fine dining spots and divy, comfort food spots also, it's still challenging to write this review of Vermillion. It's hard for me to rate them 4 stars because though they offered up forward-looking dishes, it feels as if it will take them a while longer to really hit their stride with this culinary style and I truly hope that they get there.
We ordered a decent bottle of Pinot Gris and along with the Groupon dscount, we paid about $70 each.
And really, this is the River North area with expensive rent and where the well-heeled crowd hangs out so don't expect upscale places to be cheaply-priced like your neighborhood greasy spoon diner.
------UPDATE:
Confession. A few days after eating here, we went back to nearby lunch buffet at India House. I think their crew was on a cloud because it was the best I've tasted there. $17 is a great bargain, sorry Vermilion. read more