Wow ! I always drove by Valentinos but it never caught my attention to come in and eat. And what a mistake ! I recently order through Ubereats and everything was absolutely delicious. I ordered chicken Marsala (came with pasta and garlic bread) this is the best chicken Marsala I've had in a very long time. They give you a huge portion , you'll definitely have leftovers or you can even share one plate for two . I also ordered the stuffed mushrooms parm, also to die for, that tomato sauce was everything! . The only thing I have to say is they could have added a little bit of pasta when boiling it bc it was a little simple , but the tomato sauce on top of the pasta makes up for it . ( I just added the Marsala sauce to the pasta , soooooo good !) Overall I can't wait to try what else is on their menu read more

See all

I only gave one star because I had to. I placed an order online for a simple ham sub. No cheese, no tomatoes, no lettuce, no onions, no oil, no vinegar! They sent me a sub loaded with all of those condiments/veggies! The bread is soaked to the point of being mushy; I cannot even save it for another day because the bread begins absorbing the excessive amount of oils/vinegars they use. I have tried this place before, and hoped it would be better but it seems as if the quality continues to decline. Never, ever eat here. Subpar food, subpar ingredients, take your hard-earned money elsewhere! There are so many amazing restaurants here that are worth your money and will take the time to prepare your food to your liking. Also, fix your menu. Include everything that is in the item/meal on your various menus because people have allergies, preferences, etc. Disgraceful to charge so much while serving food so carelessly. read more

I'm extremely disappointed in this restaurant for allowing itself to be part of a dishonest business practice. When booking a party at Pump It Up, I was told I had to order food through their "partnered" restaurant which turned out to be this one. What they didn't tell me is that the prices were marked up significantly compared to the restaurant's regular menu. The worst part is that when I questioned it, no one took accountability . . . not Pump It Up, and not this restaurant either. If your food is good, great but standing by while another business lies to customers using your name is not a good look. You're complicit in misleading families who are trying to plan special events for their kids. People deserve transparency, especially when it involves money and trust. I can't recommend a business that allows this kind of shady practice to continue. read more

Just received my pizza pure shit not cut properly cheese all over opened it threw it away without even taking a bite read more

Valentinos - Shit pizza - Pizza Near Me - Roselle Park, New Jersey

Came here to pick up a late night pizza... drunk pizza! For drunk pizza standards this is okay. I probably wouldn't go out of my way to get this on a normal day, but it wasn't bad. A bit expensive for regular style pizza. read more

See all

Food and Service was REALLY GOOD. If want NY style pizza this is the place to go to. Keep up the GREAT WORK. read more

Valentinos - 1 slice of cheese and 1 slice of ssg & pepperoni. - Pizza Near Me - Roselle Park, New Jersey

Love Valentinos! Food is always good and the service is always great! Highly recommend their mussels in red sauce, antipasto salad, penne vodka, pizza, jalapeño poppers, fries, peppers & eggs sub, meatball parm sub, and eggplant parm. read more

Pizza Was Delicious! Restroom and Dinning Area Clean and Welcoming. Love how Family orientated they are. Friendly and Courteous. Im Picky With My Pizza's and I have no complaints! Thank You Valentinos! read more

Valentinos - Pizza Near Me - Roselle Park, New Jersey

While browsing the net for neighborhood pizza I came across Valentinos and decided to give it a try. My son was treating (finally) so we ordered a regular pie and one with bacon and pepperoni. They did not disappoint. The staff was friendly and the food was great. I enjoyed it so much that I went back the next day to buy a sicilian for my lady. Good job. I'll be a regular customer from now on. read more

Food is mediocre at best. You could definitely find something better at a cheaper price. The restaurant is a nuisance to those who live in the area. Delivery trucks take up space and block the street making it hard for actual residents to park their cars and go home. The customer service and treatment overall is unfortunate. Would not recommend unless you prefer overpriced average food. read more

Ordered pizza. It was ok. Just like every other bland pie around here lately. Only thing impressive was the $6.90 delivery fee.

We love Valentinos! My kids loved it since the first time we went to Pump it up for a bday party, but we lived very far from the area so it wasn't often we got to eat there. We have recently moved to Union and called one day to order and found out they DELIVER to us!! Now it's a weekly dinner night for us! Pizza is always fresh. Pastas and appetizers are great. People on the phone very helpful and friendly. Definitely worth it! read more

Valentinos - 13. Margarita Pizza and 16. Chicken Bacon Topping with Ranch Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Roselle Park, New Jersey

First.... The delivery boy is a little cutie! I'm no couger (yet) however he's probably good for my daughter. IJS! Second... The pizza... I have ordered the same thing twice. A Stromboli w the Works. Super filling and they are NOT cheap w the ingredients. Delicious. Also ordered a 4 cheese pizza and it's really really cheesy. I like that the pizza is semi-thin and not a whole Lotta crust. Just a good experience overall. I'm new to the area (just about a year) so I think this place will be my go-to pizza spot. read more

Always great food, friendly service. A true gem in Roselle Park! Pizza, sandwiches and salads, everything is wonderful.

Taste good but looks slapped together. I asked for a half cheese half pepperoni pie. I couldn't tell which half is which. I had high expectation for this pizzeria based off of the reviews. read more

Valentinos - "Half cheese, half pepperoni" - Pizza Near Me - Roselle Park, New Jersey

No matter what l ordered here from pizza to hot subs to cold has been absolutely delicious.

If you like surprises in your food, this place is for you! Who? WHO puts pork in their eggplant rollatini without noting it on the menu? What a terrible faux pas!! I'm vegetarian & haven't eaten pork in over 2 decades. I paid over $25 for an eggplant rollatini platter & it showed up with pork diced in it! I would've gotten so sick had i not inspected my food. What a total disappointment! To add insult to injury, when I called to inquire, I was told "oh that's how we do it". No attempt to make the situation better. Not remorseful, nothing. IF that's how you make it, then STATE that on your menus on GrubHub, Uber Eats, etc. so your customers can make the right decision. After calling, I googled top 5 eggplant rollatini recipes and NONE of them contain pork. I wonder if this is their way of covering up a not-so-flavorful dish. I'll never order from them again because I have no idea what I'm getting. read more

I ordered a eggplant rollanti instead I was given a eggplant rollanti with ham. I'm a vegetarian, I do not eat ham, I'm very disappointed. I suggest the restaurant paying closer attention to orders because this is unacceptable. The salad also was nothing special and a little wilted. read more

Valentinos - Eggplant Rolatini - Pizza Near Me - Roselle Park, New Jersey

These guys are such gracious tolerant hosts for a beloved fan group of 12 children who love to go there after pump it up! Our children, although awesome, are loud and rowdy following an hour plus of jumping and the crew always tolerates them ! And to boot, the food is always consistent- The garlic knots are our favorite and the veggie pie! Thanks for giving us a great place and lots of memories read more

See all

Best pizza . I always order mine well done and it is delicious ! The pasta and sandwiches are good as well. My favorite pasta is the Vodka sauce and favorite sandwich would be chicken parm. read more

This is my office's go to spot for lunch! They're really affordable and treat us well since we've been ordering lunch from them for years ! Can't ever go wrong with their fresh subs and their buffalo chicken wrap is to die for! Highly recommend!! read more

They have the best pizza Of all time doesn't matter what type of pizza you get It's always gonna taste like heaven it's super good The only thing that would be good for them in stuffed crust other than that they're the best pizza That you can buy read more

Folks, I am basing the review on 2 things: Pizza/Slice quality and Service I have been in and out of Valentinos for the last year or so. We like the pizza, always good I have to mention that in an age where most retail/food and beverage places act like they are doing you a favor by selling you food, Valentinos is different. The last few times I have been at Valentinos, my daughter and i have been treated special. We usually stop in on a sunday for a quick lunch. my daughter sits down and watches the flat screen Tv they have set up and also looks at all the cartoon memorabilia hanging on the walls (scooby doo lunch box) There is a young man that works there who actually brings the pizza to our table, the slice with a fork and pre cut into pieces fro my daughter. Winning over customers can be that simple. Great job Valentinos! read more

Great pizza friendly staff!... It took less than 20 mins for my pizza to arrive and it was fresh and tasty... My boys said they never tastes a pizza so delicious.. And the guy that answer the phone was so pleasant and patient! kudos to Valentinos! read more

Valentinos is a small restaraunt that has mostly Italian foods at reasonable prices. The service is fast and friendly. I used to eat at Valentinos all of the time until recently. I don't know what changed but whatever it was, it was for the worse. The last few times that I was there and ordered the pasta, it was very watery and didn't have much of a taste. However, I have had other dishes here (chicken fingers/fries, chicken parm sandwich, etc.) and they were OK. Steer clear of the pasta and you should be fine. read more

Great food and plenty of seating. Good for groups and BYOB!!!!!! While your there stop across the street to pump it up and have a great time with your family. read more

Valentinos - Even skeletons like the pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Roselle Park, New Jersey

i have place an order with them 3 times the first time i ordered the food was exceptional then when i ordered from them a second time their chicken francaise was horrible when does a place not add noodles in the francaise sauce and add there pizza sauce so today i decided to give them one more chance and ordered a veal parm they ended giving me a chicken and peppers sandwich that the bread was so soaked threw and soggy it tasted disgusting i wanted to vomit and their pizza tasted as if they use imitation cheese that every bite was oily as of today i will never order from them again. read more

I just had lunch at Valentinos earlier today. This is the third time I've eaten there and I wanted to make a point to write a review for this restaurant. The food is absolutely excellent. Today, I ordered the chicken parmigiana and they gave me a massive plate of food with a basket of fresh hot bread. It was delicious! The entire meal cost me $8.50 with a large coke! The owner, Manny, is a really nice guy as well. It's not the type of place you would go to have a formal sit down dinner, but for a casual night, you can't beat it. The food is great, the service is friendly and the prices are unbeatable! read more

They have some pretty solid pizza and the muscles I got tonight were excellent! Will Be ordering again

I've had their pizza, pastas, salad and appetizers and I really enjoyed it all. I definitely order from here at least twice a month. I'm glad I found a good pizzeria since I moved to NJ!! read more

This place has the best serving of mussels I have ever had. When. traveling back to the east coast we always try to make it back to Valentino's. read more

The Valentino specialty wrap is my favorite! Manny goes above and beyond when it comes to customer service. My family and I enjoy the food and company. read more

See all

Food is good, we order once a week and pick up, but the owner doesn't even know that we come here a lot. My pet pea about this place, they get my order wrong even though I order the same thing week after week. Good food service, Soso read more

First time ordered from Valentinos. Today I called to place a to go order. I was surprised by the great service I received over the phone. Restaurant is very clean and staff very friendly. I ordered the chicken parm dinner and a meatball parm sub. Food was amazing. Will definitely come back. read more

We love it and order from them at least once a week. Excellent service and friendly employees. They give you an ample portion of everything and their prices are fair. read more

This is now our local go to pizzeria/restaurant. It's a no nonsense neighborhood place, take out/eat in, family place. There's some cute kitschy decor, but that's not why you come eat here, it's the food. Fresh, good quality, nice portions, reasonably priced. Pizza is always a good option, but so are their sandwiches and dinners. Actually, the best thing I ever had there was a calzone! Highly recommended for those who want an enjoyable, home style italian meal. read more

The chicken alfredo with garlic bread is usually what I get. I also tried the turkey wrap which is very good as well. Every time I place an order it is done in a decent amount of time. The way the place is decorated is very interesting, I always seem to find myself reading everything on the walls. I definitely recommend this place! read more

Decided to order from here yesterday night and boy am I happy I did!! Ordered a large pie some chicken fingers with French fries a chicken parmigiana platter and baked ziti. Not one complaint. It came in a timely matter it was hot and delicious. Everything was so good. This place does not disappoint. read more

I remember loving this pizza but the last two times I've ate here the pizza was sooooo greasy and the cheese literally slid off the bread ( even after it cooled down). Maybe it's a change in ingredients or vendor? read more

The food is good though the service is awful. Every time I order food for delivery they always forget to include something that comes with the order. They are also taking much longer than they say they would for delivery. I am better off spending my money elsewhere. read more