Order Unregular Pizza Takeout or Delivery
Unregular Pizza Photos
Business Info
Unregular Pizza Popular Dishes
UNREGULAR PIZZA ATMOSPHERE
You might also consider
More like Unregular Pizza
Recommended Reviews - Unregular Pizza
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
Pizza. OKAY. The fresh toppings on the MARGHERITA Square made the Pizza taste much better than the CACIO E PEPPE Square i ordered last time. WALK DON'T RUN.
Pepperoni and burrata is visually fun. It tastes ok. The pepperonis are too crispy. Not soft. Was lukewarm too. The vodka was perfectly heated. Quite warm. Tasty sauce. Overall, this place is visually striking and the food looks so good but it doesn't quite hit.
This is a hole in the wall kind of pizza joint located in Union Square. The staff is very friendly and some of the pizza flavors seem interesting and different. One that I ordered was the zucchini with lemon zest white pizza. I also ordered the pepperoni and burrata but I was less than a fan of this one because the pepperoni proved to be very greasy. The slices are also a little more on the costly side as they are around $7.50 each.
This review is strictly for their vegan slice - there are two options, one that was a margherita and a "veggie fiesta" which was essentially a vegetable pizza. While most vegans do enjoy vegetables, not all vegan options have to be so vegetable forward. It would be nice to have a slice that mimics what most people who eat pizza enjoy - a vegan pepperoni slice (maybe with "hot honey" agave) or even a bbq chick'n. Service was quick and friendly, had a short wait for my slice but I was grateful to have it fresh. I opted for the veggie fiesta which was advertised as having a cherry tomato confit - it wasn't really a confit, it was whole cherry tomatoes that hadn't been cooked down very much. The vegan cheese they used wasn't particularly good, I was attempting to scrape it off while salvaging the rest of the toppings. It was also a bit steep for a slice but I'll give them a break because I assume rent is steep around Union Square. Was it filling? Sure. But the standard for vegan pizza has to be higher than this, their non-vegan slices looked incredible so I wish this matched.
Not your regular slice, as the name suggests and even though I'm usually not a fan of the square-style pizza, this one didn't disappoint. I really like the variety on the menu, and they're generous with the toppings, which is always a win. The prosciutto burrata pizza was my favorite! If I had one minor complaint, it's the sauce felt a little overpowering. Some bites felt like a full-on tomato explosion in my mouth. Still, overall, a solid spot for a great slice with quality ingredients and flavor.
Friendly guy behind the counter. The place itself is super small and cramped but the pizza wasn't bad I was starving so I gulfed down the food super fast when I got home. Dough was okay a bit different from your average pizza but def worth the try
Great casual pizza spot with bigger than most square slices. Unregular pizza has the type of toppings you want in a casual setting. There is limited seating inside. The slices are deceptively filling, especially if you get the Barada so warning that two might get you to being full more than you think as someone who's accidentally ordered three slices for a lunch day Service is pretty standard for a pizza joint in the city. Recommend trying the spot at least once their unique flavors and the heftier square slices are worth a try.
Different but good. Pizza is all the same until this place best selection of slices ever. I have eaten a few all good. I never actually been here it's a lunch spot for work someone picks up but none the less it amazing pizza for a good price.
Unregular Pizza, located in Union Square, excellent location, small shop, nice selection of pizza - meat/ veggie/ vegan/burata / pepperoni Staff is so friendly and accommodating. Top notch. I chose the prosciutto and burrata slice. The crust was a nice and crispy but the flavors were a bit off. The sauce was too saucy. I would maybe try a different flavor next time but I'm not in any rush.
A spot for really unique pizzas! I tried the Burrazuchini slice -- the crust was great, but it had a bit too much burrata and not enough seasoning for my taste. It's a very small place with no seating, fitting only about 4-5 people inside.
Stopped in for some pizza. I tried the zucchini pizza with burrata. The slice was huge and filling. However if zucchini is not seasoned properly there's not much of a taste but overall the pizza was not bad. There is a counter where you can stand and enjoy your pizza. They have a lot of pizza options and other goodies as well. The worker was super friendly and her vibe was perfect. I would definitely go back to try a different slice. The mushroom one seemed popular.
I've been here twice now and enjoy the colorful, cheerful atmosphere. It's standing room only with a counter for those who would like to eat in the establishment. The place has many unique pizza flavors, as well as stromboli, fried pasta, and sandwiches. They even have a delightful looking Nutella pizza. The first time, I had the Pepperoni Stromboli ($5), which was wonderfully cheesy, full of well seasoned pepperoni, while the bread was soft and doughy. I also got to try the Special pizza flavor of the month, which is Ossobucco Milanese ($8). This consisted of beef ossobucco, gremolata, saffron sauce, along with Mozzarella. I enjoyed the beef, which was tender, full of bold flavor. The saffron sauce added a nice element to the slice, but would have liked more melty cheese. The crust was light and crisp. Service was warm and friendly. Prices were a little high, but ultimately worth it. I would come back to try the Meat Dream, Burrapizza Cafonata and Chicken Out pizza slices, as well as the Cacio E Pepe Fried Pasta.
I stopped by after work bc the pizza looked delicious. Picked one of the most expensive ones bc it looked delicious. It was good but not sure if it was worth the price. Not much of service stood there ate it. Not sure if I would come back again
Took myself on a solo date the other day to see Jurassic World: Rebirth I was looking for a sandwich spot to have a snack at the theatre and I came across Unregular Pizza. This place has been on my list! I order the vodka parm on a croissant. This sandwich was EVERYTHING! Buttery, cheesy, the perfect amount of sauce. The chicken was juicy and flavorful. I'll definitely be back for the sandwich and the pizza. Service was amazing as well. The person that helped me was kind and welcoming. read more
1st time at a Unregular. Stopped by on a rainy Sunday afternoon at their 4th Ave close to Union Sq and various NYU dorms area. Bright well decorated space. Friendly staffer. Window sign says clearly this is Roman style pizza. Got a plain slice $4.5 plus tax. Ovalish pie/slice. Cheesy. Not much of an undercarriage but slice did not slop. OK tasting but just not my style. They are definitely not your neighborhood everyday pizzeria but also not your fancy pants special toppings place so somewhere In between. Same standing area to eat inside. Closes 10p every night except 1130P on Fri and Sat. Worth a try but not in rotation for me. read more
Cafonata and Burraproscuitto are worth a try but would not recommend the veggie ones. The meat slices were super saucy, with good seasoning, and a nice crispy bottom. The veggie pizzas were lacking some salt / spice. The inside is big enough for maybe 5 groups of 2 so a little small but cute space with local art. The workers are friendly and quick to take your order and bring the food out. read more
4 months ago
4 days ago
Pizza. OKAY. The fresh toppings on the MARGHERITA Square made the Pizza taste much better than the CACIO E PEPPE Square i ordered last time. WALK DON'T RUN. read more
Pepperoni and burrata is visually fun. It tastes ok. The pepperonis are too crispy. Not soft. Was lukewarm too. The vodka was perfectly heated. Quite warm. Tasty sauce. Overall, this place is visually striking and the food looks so good but it doesn't quite hit. read more
3 months ago
This is a hole in the wall kind of pizza joint located in Union Square. The staff is very friendly and some of the pizza flavors seem interesting and different. One that I ordered was the zucchini with lemon zest white pizza. I also ordered the pepperoni and burrata but I was less than a fan of this one because the pepperoni proved to be very greasy. The slices are also a little more on the costly side as they are around $7.50 each. read more
This review is strictly for their vegan slice - there are two options, one that was a margherita and a "veggie fiesta" which was essentially a vegetable pizza. While most vegans do enjoy vegetables, not all vegan options have to be so vegetable forward. It would be nice to have a slice that mimics what most people who eat pizza enjoy - a vegan pepperoni slice (maybe with "hot honey" agave) or even a bbq chick'n. Service was quick and friendly, had a short wait for my slice but I was grateful to have it fresh. I opted for the veggie fiesta which was advertised as having a cherry tomato confit - it wasn't really a confit, it was whole cherry tomatoes that hadn't been cooked down very much. The vegan cheese they used wasn't particularly good, I was attempting to scrape it off while salvaging the rest of the toppings. It was also a bit steep for a slice but I'll give them a break because I assume rent is steep around Union Square. Was it filling? Sure. But the standard for vegan pizza has to be higher than this, their non-vegan slices looked incredible so I wish this matched. read more
1 year ago
Not your regular slice, as the name suggests and even though I'm usually not a fan of the square-style pizza, this one didn't disappoint. I really like the variety on the menu, and they're generous with the toppings, which is always a win. The prosciutto burrata pizza was my favorite! If I had one minor complaint, it's the sauce felt a little overpowering. Some bites felt like a full-on tomato explosion in my mouth. Still, overall, a solid spot for a great slice with quality ingredients and flavor. read more
Friendly guy behind the counter. The place itself is super small and cramped but the pizza wasn't bad I was starving so I gulfed down the food super fast when I got home. Dough was okay a bit different from your average pizza but def worth the try read more
1 year ago
Great casual pizza spot with bigger than most square slices. Unregular pizza has the type of toppings you want in a casual setting. There is limited seating inside. The slices are deceptively filling, especially if you get the Barada so warning that two might get you to being full more than you think as someone who's accidentally ordered three slices for a lunch day Service is pretty standard for a pizza joint in the city. Recommend trying the spot at least once their unique flavors and the heftier square slices are worth a try. read more
4 months ago
Different but good. Pizza is all the same until this place best selection of slices ever. I have eaten a few all good. I never actually been here it's a lunch spot for work someone picks up but none the less it amazing pizza for a good price. read more
2 years ago
Unregular Pizza, located in Union Square, excellent location, small shop, nice selection of pizza - meat/ veggie/ vegan/burata / pepperoni Staff is so friendly and accommodating. Top notch. I chose the prosciutto and burrata slice. The crust was a nice and crispy but the flavors were a bit off. The sauce was too saucy. I would maybe try a different flavor next time but I'm not in any rush. read more
A spot for really unique pizzas! I tried the Burrazuchini slice -- the crust was great, but it had a bit too much burrata and not enough seasoning for my taste. It's a very small place with no seating, fitting only about 4-5 people inside. read more
Stopped in for some pizza. I tried the zucchini pizza with burrata. The slice was huge and filling. However if zucchini is not seasoned properly there's not much of a taste but overall the pizza was not bad. There is a counter where you can stand and enjoy your pizza. They have a lot of pizza options and other goodies as well. The worker was super friendly and her vibe was perfect. I would definitely go back to try a different slice. The mushroom one seemed popular. read more
I've been here twice now and enjoy the colorful, cheerful atmosphere. It's standing room only with a counter for those who would like to eat in the establishment. The place has many unique pizza flavors, as well as stromboli, fried pasta, and sandwiches. They even have a delightful looking Nutella pizza. The first time, I had the Pepperoni Stromboli ($5), which was wonderfully cheesy, full of well seasoned pepperoni, while the bread was soft and doughy. I also got to try the Special pizza flavor of the month, which is Ossobucco Milanese ($8). This consisted of beef ossobucco, gremolata, saffron sauce, along with Mozzarella. I enjoyed the beef, which was tender, full of bold flavor. The saffron sauce added a nice element to the slice, but would have liked more melty cheese. The crust was light and crisp. Service was warm and friendly. Prices were a little high, but ultimately worth it. I would come back to try the Meat Dream, Burrapizza Cafonata and Chicken Out pizza slices, as well as the Cacio E Pepe Fried Pasta. read more
1 year ago
I stopped by after work bc the pizza looked delicious. Picked one of the most expensive ones bc it looked delicious. It was good but not sure if it was worth the price. Not much of service stood there ate it. Not sure if I would come back again read more
1 year ago
After experiencing a date night out at the Chelsea Film Festival at the nearby Regal Theatre, we conveniently came across this place and asked for Vegetarian options. Guys working that night were helpful! She tried the Zucchini Stromboli and I gave in and couldn't keep my eyes off the Pepperoni Stromboli, amongst the other pizza selections. So tasty! Right choice! There were benches out front to sit but we didn't mind standing at a counter. Worth a try if you're on the Go. read more
After seeing this pop up on TikTok and instagram for years, decided to give it a shot. The garlic bites were made from amazing bread and packed with flavor, but the fried penne vodka was clearly the star of the show. So rich and creamy - and considering I'm not usually a fan of smoked cheese flavors, the smoked mozzarella hit all the right notes! Absolutely delicious bites and something i certainly will be back to try again! read more
Fast casual Sicilian pizza storefront in Union Square of NYC offering variety of square pizza by the slice. The service was attentive and the pizza was tasty. The crust was crispy thick yet light and the sauce was tangy and flavorful. Thanks for satisfying the pizza craving! Now onto the next slice! read more
LITERALLY WAS ON CLOUD 9 AFTER THIS SLICE. The Cafonata had all the best elements in one slice--burrata, the lil cup pepperonis, and hot honey. I loved the little sweetness from the honey and how fresh the burrata was. BEWARE this is MESSYYY but totally worth it. We also tried the Chicken Out just to have one crazy slice and one demure slice. I love anything pesto so this was also good and honestly still impressed us even being in "competition" with our Cafonta slice. This space is very small. There is a standing bar that could fit maybe 4-5 people. There's a pretty constant flow of traffic in and out of the place so be aware that other people will be walking by/bumping into you. read more
4 months ago
Feb 19,2026, went to try their pizza since I was in the area prior to attending the Winter Film Festival and to my surprise was not impressed at all. I had like a veg Roman pizza and the sauce was tasteless. Will not be back. The garlic square bread was not properly seasoned . There is no sitting and very narrow. I travel a lot and go to many restaurants, pizza restaurants etc. I always give me reviews for others to know. read more
11 months ago
6 months ago
The pizza is delicious. I can totally it is made with quality fresh ingredients. I got the grandma slice and a cheese slice . I love the brightly light and colorful design of the store. The service is quick and fast. There isn't room to eat in but there are lovely benches outside. I will come soon to try a sandwich. read more
1 year ago
The service was efficient and super friendly! I got the Stromboli and the garlic knots which were super flavorful! My friends got the vodka and the cacio Pepe slices. The vodka was the sauciest and was basically eating pasta! read more
5/5 Loved unregular pizza it's such a cute pizza place their pizza was very tasty. Pizza was also hot and fresh I loved the crust and the thickness of the pizza I would definitely recommend and come back again when I'm in NYC read more
6 months ago
2 years ago
Great lunch special deal - 2 slices and a drink for $10.99. Their pizza is innovative and Instagram worthy where you add a full burrata to any slice. Standing room only and is very limited, better to take out. Their pizza is pricey for their small slice but it is very flavorful and delicious. After toasting up, it was crunchy. Quick fast service to order and tap for blackbird points ! read more
We came here specifically to try the deep fried pastas. 3 of us split one of each, the cacio & pepe, and the bolognese. They ARE made/fried to order, but sadly ours were a little cold in the middle, which was a bummer. Of the 2, I preferred the cacio & pepe. For reference they are about these size of a stick of butter, a little fatter, but shorter. I will say all the pizza slices on display looked divine and I would not count this place out because of this experience. read more
Food (4/5): Solid slice that was quite good and flavorful. The amount of cheese and meat was good Service (4/5): We came here right before the Yelp Elite immersive game box event. The event said that we get 20% off pizza but both the immersive gamebox and unregular pizza staff didn't know about the discount. We had to spend a lot of time waiting as they talked to managers to figure it out. Eventually the unregular pizza person applied a discount and it worked out. The pizza came out fast and besides the issue with the promo, the service was good. Ambiance (4/5): A quick pick up pizza shop with some available stool seating. read more
I tried the pepperoni pizza with burrata and I'm sorry to say it was just not good. Something about the sauce gave it a weird too sweet taste and the crust was below average. The burrata itself was decent and the person at the counter was nice. The shop is tiny. Entry is wheelchair accessible but it is tough to make a turn because there is a standing bar for people to eat. There is no wheelchair friendly place to eat inside or outside unless you sit next to a bench and eat the pizza on your lap. You only get a bag of you order one slice but a box of you get two. I wish I had asked for a box to make it easier to eat outside. Union Square is very close. read more
Pretty solid pizza with a good variety to choose from. I can't remember exactly how this came on my "to go to list," but I knew I'd stop by when I was around Union square. More of a to go/takeout place as there's minimal room to eat inside, maybe standing room for 5-6 people. I ordered the grandma peppina and one slice is pretty filling actually. I also got the Fried Pasta Cacio e Pepe which reminded me of a large mozzarella stick with some spaghetti inside. It is very cheesy and filling, and I kinda wish I got the penne vodka one as that one was likely less cheesy and more saucy! Or maybe I would've gotten another pizza instead. The burrapizzas looked a bit intimidating to try, but maybe it's good, is on the pricier side as there's a whole burrata cheese on it. read more
1 year ago
Page 1 of 11
More info about Unregular Pizza
135 4th Ave
New York, NY 10003
Union Square, Greenwich Village, East Village
Directions
(646) 609-4699
Call Now
Order Takeout or Delivery
Start Order
Visit Website
http://www.unregularpizza.com
Full menu
Hours
Payment methods
Food & Alcohol
Indoor Amenities
Outdoor Amenities
Other Amenities
More Info
Health Score
Unregular Pizza Reviews in Other Languages
Ask the Community - Unregular Pizza
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
159 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
1 year ago
5 years ago
1 year ago
1 year ago
5 years ago
2 years ago
2 years ago
2 years ago
2 years ago
5 years ago
1 year ago
1 year ago
1 year ago
1 year ago
1 year ago
1 year ago
1 year ago
1 year ago
1 year ago
1 year ago
