Update! Customer service is great, they called us after seeing this review, and wanted to refund us, replace the dish, and were sincere and very nice in their call. have had very good experiences with their food in the past, guess this was just a one off. want to keep being able to support local businesses and the small gestures like that mean a lot. they care about their customers and their customers' happiness. will continue ordering from troni brothers and greatly appreciate the time and effort to do that. thank you again for reaching out! original review this was very disapointing. got alfredo with mushrooms added, the sauce was very weird. also got a side of the alfredo sauce. tastes very, very similar to bertolli alfredo in a jar, or whatever other kind u can get. same texture, kind of oddly metallic, ect. not worth $18. would like to ask for refund just on that one dish but cant get through on their phone. have gotten calzones before and we really enjoyed them. this time was a bust. read more

Not a lot of seating options, I think it's mostly a take out place. Pizza and the calzone we tried were fantastic! read more

Service was crap, employee told me that I was just shit out of luck when what we ordered wasn't in stock and then said they can't refund me. Pizza is subpar and employees are immature and clueless without the owners help. Definitely try a different place read more

Amazing food and amazing people! This spot is gem, the food from this location is packed with so much more flavor and love! Calzones are monsters, and delicious! read more

Similar to the other Toni's but not owned by same people. I got the pasta trio which came with garlic knots and salad. I waited to use the knots to stop up the pasta sauce. Had left overs. Very good. read more

Troni Brothers Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kettering, Ohio

See all

I don't know how they have this high a rating without paying for fake reviews. Walked in on a football Sunday and the place is completely empty. Girl behind the counter tells us to grab menus and she'll be over. Twenty minutes later we walked out as no one ever came over. They didn't even look up from their phones when we left. read more

I could eat their hot honey pepperoni pizza forever. Absolutely love this pizza. We use it as an excuse to go to kings point. Probably the only pizza I enjoy cold. Highly recommended. read more

Atmosphere inside is cozy yet electric. Service is nothing notable (not a bad thing). You order at the counter, sit down, and they bring the food to your table. The pizza is one of the best pizzas I've ever had, and is my favorite in Dayton. My girlfriend and I go out to pizza almost every Friday night for the past few months and this place has topped the charts! Even went here for my birthday because it's just that good! The only problem is that I live too far away to get it more often. Definitely don't sleep on jt if you're driving through or living in Dayton read more

Really great NY style pizza and meatballs. Looking forward to trying other menu items

Wow, Troni Brothers needs a lot of help. I don't even know where to start. Take out order took about an hour and food somehow was still cold. read more

I was craving for some calzones and found Troni Brothers Pizza were the closest place to me that carried them. I ordered their deluxe calzone, meat lover calzone, tiramisu, and cannoli. Everything tasted delicious. The meat lover had a great balance of cheese and meat. The deluxe was very tasty, and adding the garlic parmesan sauce gave it an unexpectedly small spicy kick to the meal. The cannoli was sweet, crunchy, and very filling. The tiramisu was also a nice sweet treat. I think other than the food being amazing, the staff were amazing as well. The lady, most likely owner, was very sweet over the phone and in person. The atmosphere of the restaurant felt very welcoming and family oriented. Definitely plan on coming back here to try more of their menu, especially the pizza. Highly recommend Troni Brothers Pizza! read more

Troni Brothers Pizza - Top Left - Tiramisu Top Right - Cannoli Bottom Left - Meat Lover Calzone Bottom Right - Deluxe Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Kettering, Ohio

See all

Troni Brothers Pizza. 16" Nona pizza, (traditionally known as Gramma's Pizza, for those who like that style of pizza), pepper jack cubes, and trio pasta, (manicotti, stuffed shells, ravioli, side salad, and garlic rolls). Holy yum!! Everything was so freaking good! My only small criticism, is that I should have gone with the 12-in pizza instead of the 16-in. The 16-in was just a little too big, and not quite done in the center. But other than that, everything was absolutely amazing! read more

Troni Brothers Pizza - Trio pasta, (manicotti, stuffed shells, ravioli, side salad, and garlic rolls). - Pizza Near Me - Kettering, Ohio

See all

Troni Brothers is my fav pizza and calzones in all of the Dayton area. But the last night chef sent out three of my orders burnt. I think there needs to be some retraining. Not good for buisness! read more

Pizza is delicious, only reason I did not give it 5 stars was because when I opened the pizza box I had flop-jelopps.

Fantastic: we had heard about Troni brothers in Kettering, but then I noticed this one in Xenia when getting an oil change at Valvoline in front of the restaurant. The pizza is fantastic. We got a 16" deluxe, sauce and dough are top notch. I wanted to try their fettuccine sauce,so they brought us a bowl for $2, it's amazing too. Calamari was delicious. Garlic rolls are 1$ each, you don't have to buy 6 or 12. Nice sit down atmosphere wait staff is friendly, and up beat. It will be busy so get there early. We got two cannoli's to eat at home, yum. So glad they are in Xenia now. read more

When I saw that they have pizza by the slice, we had to go. It's a good size slice, and with a drink and chips, it's a good deal. The plain cheese is very good. My husband got additional toppings, we were happy that they have anchovies. I know anchovy is a little controversial, but we like it. I am happy that the pizza quality is still there. We also ordered a pie to go for the family at home. It was very good too. If you're a NY/NJ pizza snob like me, this is the place for you. My daughter ordered alfredo, it was a little bland, but she enjoyed it. The Alfredo came with garlic knots, which were very good. The side salad was tasty, and their house dressing is really good. The tiramisu was just not quite the best. It was good, but not great. Next time I'm going to try the limoncello instead. I wish I could give a half star, because the only reason it's not 5 is the tiramisu. read more

See all

This placed has changed hands since my first review and we don't go there anymore due to the quality of the dishes going downhill. My once amazing eggplant parm came out tough and the slices were way too thick. We've taken this restaurant off our list. read more

My spinach roll which I waited 45minutes for was raw dough inside. The waiter said they would take it off my bill and she did not. My spinach roll a side salad and a small kid pizza cost 48 dollars . This did include a tip that came up on the register when I put in the order - which obviously not based on service. Worst experience eating pizza out ever. read more

Staff is always very friendly any time i go in! food is always delicious and fresh. i've had a variety of food from here. the mozzarella sticks are the best i've had, fettuccine is delicious and pizza is some of the best. the environment is very nice and store is always clean and welcoming! will always return here. read more

Troni Brothers Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kettering, Ohio

Amazing, I had called earlier to see if I could hold a banquet for my Varsity Bowlers and family. The owner said they could assist. This is definitely one of the best if not the best pizza in the area. The young lady at the counter Alivia, she did an awesome job taking care of us inside and all the other take out orders. I think this is one of those that you have to try for yourselves, you'll like read more

i called for pickup and the phone rung and rung and rung. They claim it's open online but not answering the phone?

I've become a regular at the Wilmington location. Very informal atmosphere which I prefer to the more formal and unaffiliated Tronis on Dorothy Lane. Pleasant service and good food. We don't get it often but M-F they have a single large slice for eat in or takeout. About $ 4.50 and a nice meal in itself for most people. Never disappointed. Highly recommend. read more

Troni Brothers Pizza - Sydney Australia Oprah House - Pizza Near Me - Kettering, Ohio

Great people and fantastic pizza They're just trying to open up after COVID and doing a super job. I can't wait til they open up to indoor seating. The inside looks really nice. read more

Troni Brothers Pizza - troni bros pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kettering, Ohio

Outstanding pies! Love the crispy crust, and the red sauce is perfect. This will definitely be my go to pizza whenever I'm in the Dayton area! read more

I've been going since last year . This is on Wilmington pike in Kettering . The owners are very friendly and welcoming . I go in and have lunch with a huge slice of pepperoni and a side salad with their homemade Italian dressing ( which I can almost drink it ...it's so great ) with a pop... Note ...I walk out stuffed .... read more

Great for dine in or very efficient carry w. Have had many great pizzas and a very good eggplant Parmesan. Need better salad variety read more

Great food great service . I have nothing bad to say about this place . The food is amazing !

I went in after the new owners took over to pick up carry out and wanted a ice tea to drink while I waited and was told they no longer served freshly brewed ice tea and no fountain drinks as "it's to much work and messy " all beverages were in bottle and only had sweet tea . Yea this place is gonna last .... I don't know where the lady got her business sense & analogy of too much work , fountain drinks and in-house made tea are staples and were you make your money as I think they're total idiots I'll never be back. The food was acceptable but not as good as the original owners in my opinion read more

Wow! This is great Italian style pizza. Absolutely the best crust in Dayton. We get the regular but friends love the sauce on the old fashioned pizza. Buy local-eat better. read more

We found Troni Brothers by accident and what a discovery it is! I am an east coast pizza snob and our choices for real NY Style pizza in Dayton Ohio are limited to say the least. (sorry locals, no offense, but I just can't eat the stuff around here that you call pizza.) We returned to Troni brothers a few times, and the food is authentic. It's fresh and it is so good. If you're looking for some good Italian cooking that even rivals the New York style pizza on the north side of Dayton; Troni Brothers is the place! I would say that the guys up north might want to worry a little bit if Troni Brothers decided to open a location on the north side. (Please!!!) read more

Troni Brothers Pizza - a half eaten pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kettering, Ohio

One bite everyone knows the rules. 8.2 which is pretty great for a one bite review. Very chill spot with great pizza. The girls working the counter were patient and really kind. read more

Amazing. If you have not tried their Nonnas pie, you must. The closest pie on their menu to NY Pies. No need to ask them to cut triangles, either. That is automatically done here. Troni's comes close to our native NY, food. We have been looking for food to mirror NY since our transfer here. What a great find. Thanks Troni's, we will be back. read more

I ordered takeout yesterday. My bf and I ordered the meatball sub. It was finished quickly and when we got it home it was huge! It must have been a good 14 inches. It had tons of meatballs and cheese. We could only eat half. The price couldn't be beat at $13. We definitely need to go back and get the pizza. The subs were awesome. read more

I ate at this place for first time today! The restaurant was nice and clean! The waiter was excellent! We got our drinks real quick! We placed the order quick as well! I had meat lasagna and my husband had pizza! Both were excellent! The food was so delicious! We will be coming back soon! Prices are reasonable for what you get! Great place to go if you like pizza or Italian! read more

See all

said our order would be ready from 6:57-7:07. Picked up at 6:58 and waited in line. live 5 mins from the building. opened my pizza and calamari and the pizza was cold. not even luke warm, just cold. calamari was hard kike it had been in a warmer for awhile. overall, pretty disappointed that our food was cold and picked up on time/ consumed not much later than that. read more

My family and I ate dinner with you tonight and we all loved the food and the friendly service! We will definitely be back. Thank you!

Although Pizza is in the name, they are a full menu Italian Restaurant. Sick of eating my own cooking during these Covid times, I'm out anyway and on a lark order dinner here. I just rattled off standard items. I really should have checked the menu out...they had Lobster Ravoli! Oh well, next time. Got Bob a meatball appetizer, which was huge...he could only eat half so he can still look forward to enjoying those today. I had Cheese Stuffed Shells. Including two garlic knots swimming in butter. It was just that good. Will have to do again...sooner rather than later. read more

Placed a online order tonight for a pizza and garlic bread . Website said 40 mins. It is a Saturday after thanksgiving so that was expected. When my boyfriend arrived he overheard the staff say they have been trying to call him. Giving the impression the pizza had been sitting awhile. When he arrived home sure enough the cheese was almost hard. It actually was hard on the garlic bread. Disappointed to say the least and really hope they update the timing on their website to reflect accurately,or create a text notification when the order is ready. read more

Had an issue and the owner contacted me immediately. Found out my issue was with the previous owner. Looking forward to trying this out in the near future!! New owner really cares which is not so common any longer. read more

First time eating here. Service was very good and very attentive. The whole staff was extremely friendly. Spaghetti and lasagna were 10/10. The chicken parm was also a 10. Plan on making it back. You won't be disappointed. Thanks for a great experience. read more