Had family visiting and considering the bitterly cold weather, I was feeling in the mood for some Italian comfort food. I happen to live close by, and it has been on my list for a while. Extremely glad I made the short trip. Tortello has a casual feel: you order up front before you are seated. I ordered the cacio e pepe, plus foccacia with honey and ricotta as an appetizer. The latter was an excellent combination of flavors and textures, the savory and crunchiness of the bread with the soft creaminess and (not overwhelming) sweetness of the cheese and honey. The cacio e pepe had a high bar to clear as a result, but did so handsomely. The pasta had a pleasant bite, and the pepper and cheese were excellent. In short, a great experience. I look forward to coming here when it isn't 5 degrees outside! read more

Tortello - Cacio e Pepe - Pasta Shops Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Warm familial atmosphere, fresh pasta, deep flavors, and an adorable storefront where people take parta making classes. There's a light casual feel because you order at the counter, but table service is still on point and prices match the white table clothes. I've walked past many times wanting to stop for dinner but they're often packed. It's first come first serve. So we lucked out with an impromptu dinner on a cold rainy evening. The heaters were on in their outdoor patio so we sat outside which can be quite romantic if you don't mind the squeeze. I most enjoyed the seasonal duck pasta (Pappardelle all'Anatra) and the focaccia with ricotta and honey; although their classic Tagliattelle Tina (popular dish denoted with a heart on the menu) was hearty and rich. Truth be told, we selected our dishes based on what we could not so easily recreate at home. And we were not disappointed! read more

See all

Tortello is another spot that's been on my list for way too long. This casual spot offers freshly made pasta in house. They don't take reservations so it can get quite busy inside. You order at the counter and then find a table. This place is a great choice for a date or just a casual lunch or dinner. Inside of the restaurant is very cute. They offer pasta making sessions in the front of the restaurant. They have their products for sale as well as the fresh pasta on display. I wanted to get something I haven't tried before so I ordered the Chiusoni alla Gallurese. The saffron is what really makes this dish. Very very delicious! And the pasta was the perfect al dente. read more

See all

I came here on a Friday around 12:30pm. We could not make a reservation and it was an order at the counter service. I went with my partner, overall good pasta, al dente of course. We started with the focaccia and ricotta with honey. It was sweet but a delicious combination. I also got a glass of wine but it wasn't given to me so I had to ask for it from the person passing the food / expediting. I got the Aglio, olio e peperoncino, it had chilis and cheese with olive oil. It was good, simple but good. My partner got the Cacio e Pepe which he says was tasty and better than most food on Division. He also got a macchiato which he also had to ask for because it was not delivered. It's pretty good pasta. read more

See all

Fast service but unfortunately was disappointed in my pasta. I got the pomodoro and while the pasta was fresh and a great texture, the sauce was incredibly thick and sweet. Definitely needed to be thinned out and needed way more spices. read more

Tortello - Pomodoro pasta - Pasta Shops Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Tortello is a great local and chef driven restaurant in Wicker Park. They have great Italian ingredients and you can watch authentic pasta being made. All various different kinds and shapes of pasta. Offering daily pastas as well. A great patio setup for those great weather days in Chicago. Whether day or night you will be amazed by the quality of pasta that is served here. read more

Tortello - Pasta - Pasta Shops Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Hands down some of the best pasta in Chicago. I always get some extra to go and am waaay full after the meal. Bring friends who are out of town here or heck just come out with your locals. Worth the $$ for sure. Try the special! read more

Tortello - Tagliattelle Tina - Pasta Shops Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

What a wonderful idea that reminds me of great restauran in Rome Al42. The idea of fresh made pasta and few perfectly made choices of sauce is awesome. We take classic Bolognese and Papardelle baked with duck, both were absolutely delicious. Myself I would add a little bit more saltiness to the Bolognese pasta but other than that pasta was made al dente and the sauce was classic. They also serve variety of anti pastas and the olives were great. I like the idea of having a carafe of house wine with affordable prices as opposed to some places charging fortune for a wine. When leaving you can get some Italian specialties from the restaurant . We cannot wait to come back and try more! read more

See all

Dare I say, some of the most delicious handmade pasta in Chicago? The line looks intimidating but it goes quickly, but the wait at your table takes a bit too. In total we waits about an hour for our food to arrive on a Friday early dinner (20 min in line and 40 min at the table). The system is you wait in line to order at the counter and then a staff member will get you to an open table (indoor or outdoor). The outdoor patio space they created is quite nice too - a smidge cramped but it works. It's more casual, but the quality is upscale and the price is very reasonable. The staff were pretty friendly and efficient too! We started with the espresso martinis which are more sweet and creamy than spirit-forward, but was tasty. For the pastas - all were cooked perfectly, that exact soft/al dente middle spot. My rankings include: 1. Signature Tortelli di Burrata 2. Squid ink bucatini with prawns 3. Paccheri all' Amatriciana 4. Cavatelli al Pesto I think the menu changes seasonally, so looking forward to coming back! read more

See all

AMAZING! Came for a late lunch and it was delectable. The owner was friendly and greeted us as soon as we walked in. We even struck up a conversation. The food was some of the best I've ever had and the pasta was cooked perfectly al dente. The interior was bright and cheery. And the gelato was also amazing. Overall an amazing place and I will be coming back. read more

Tortello - Motorcycle on the ceiling - Pasta Shops Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Was the food good? Yes, yes it was. This place makes their pasta from scratch and that's always a great thing. However, the fact that it was an order at the register spot but still cost what it did, not to mention the slightly curt behavior of the cashier when I was, admittedly, asking for suggestions for my order, made this place lose it's shine for me. Cool neighborhood and the food was really good also, but it's a one and done for me. read more

See all

I've wanted to try more Italian restaurants around Chicago, but so many are open for dinner only, and I'm usually around the city in the early afternoon. Tortello is open by noon on most days, so this makes them a more amenable option. Their more casual dining approach where you order at the counter keeps this a more simple experience. The prices are not as cheap as you would expect for this type of dining and somewhat small portion sizes, but the flavor was top notch. Our first time dining there, we were asked to move over to a smaller table to leave room for any potentially larger parties. Not a problem, but the tables are all small and able to be configured into a 2- or 4-seater easily, so they could've just scooted the table over and made space. That larger party never came, and we were moved to a seat where the radiator dripped on me. Unideal. read more

See all

Don't let the portion of the food and length of the menu fool you! Loved every bite of the tortelli and the caccio e Pepe.. you can taste the difference with their handmade pasta. So light and fresh. The Focaccia was soft and so fragrant, not at all greasy with ricotta and honey as a dip. To end it the meal, nothing could beat a limoncello and a fresh tiramisu. Absolutely heavenly. I will dream about this meal just so i could relive my experience in their cute cafe-style restaurant! Since they don't take reservations, i recommend you arrive for a brunch/early lunch to beat the rush over the weekend. read more

See all

Updating my review since I made it back here. I like the casual atmosphere, I did have to wait in line this time though on a Friday night around 7:45, but was seated outside shortly after. The line moves fast! My take on the food: it's good quality, but it's nothing to write home about, especially being on the pricier side. I can tell the noodles are handmade which I really enjoy! I just haven't been wowed by any of the sauces. Great spot to come to for the casual but also elevated vibes. read more

Tortello - Tagliattelle Tina - Pasta Shops Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Sadly disappointed by this place. I first ordered the tiramisu (4/5) for takeout and it was very good. Great texture, just enough of a coffee flavor, sweet. It was actually so good that I came back a second time for dine in. The cacio e pepe (4/5) was good but nothing special. Then I got the pesto out of curiosity (1/5) and it was terrible. There was a weird after taste, not seasoned at all, and it was a big disappointment. I could barely tell this was pesto. The pasta was cooked well and that's the only redeeming quality of the dish. It was so bad I couldn't even force myself to finish it. Then I got the tiramisu once again and for some reason it wasn't as good as the takeout. It was more wet and just didn't taste as good. Only thing I'd recommend here is the tiramisu for takeout and that's it. read more

See all

Amazing place for lunch and dinner! The best place to gather your closest friends for the tastiest pasta rich in flavor! Sauce taste fresh from hand picked tomatoes read more

See all

What a cute place in Wicker Park. Order at the counter and then they deliver to your table. Went on a Sunday at 1 pm and got seated right away. Started with the focaccia bread with ricotta and honey. Delicious. Have to get this! I ordered the tortelli- burrata, butter, sage and hazelnut. The pasta was amazing. I loved this dish! My husband got the tagliatelle Tina- he thoroughly enjoyed his as well. My brother got the special with sausage and green peppers. Ordered the tiramisu - kinda perfect. Highly recommend. Fun to watch the people make the pasta. I wish I would have bought some to bring home. This place is amazing. Spent $120 for lunch for 3 people (just drank water). It's not cheap and you won't have leftovers but so worth going. Service was friendly and helpful. read more

See all

The food is delicious here. We stopped in before a show at the Den. The service is fast and they have outdoor seating. I would prefer table service but otherwise it's a nice casual spot with good food. read more

See all

Tortello has a "meal of the month" club (not sure if thats what they call it) that we are big fans of. Each month we get a box filled with ingredients and instructions on how to prepare and every month the meal(s) are absolutely wonderful (it's really at least a meal and a half). We highly recommend Tortello, whether you eat in, carry out, do the monthly subscription or take one of their pasta making classes! read more

See all

Decided to go early this past Friday night (5:30) and got in immediately for seats inside. We started out with the Fagioli alla Veneta as a starter. I really liked the mix with onions, it had good taste, but maybe not my favorite beans in town. Next time I'll try a salad probably... Now the pastas, the pastas I will dream about til my next trip! Cacio e Pepe is my favorite pasta ever. This was excellent, my only complaint was the pasta was a little more al dente than I prefer. My husband's Tagliattelle Tina was simply amazing. I'd get it again every day til I die. Can't wait to come back and try more! read more

See all

*Walk ins only We shared: 1. Signature Tortelli di Burrata - egg and '00 flour based dough, filled with imported burrata from Puglia, cooked in a butter and sage sauce with toasted hazelnuts, balsamic & parmigiano 2. Squid Ink Bucatini - prawns, homemade roasted tomato butter, shallots, cherry tomatoes, lemon, basil 3. Tagliattelle Tina - all natural grass-fed beef ragu, aged parmigiano reggiano 4. Focaccia & Honey Ricotta 5. Tiramisu Excellent fresh pasta cooked al dente. I loved that the namesake tortelli was properly packed, creamy inside, and balanced flavor overall. I'm wary of butter sauces but this was pleasantly mild. Squid Ink Bucatini was my favorite dish with its perfect pasta chewiness and great rich, acidific pasta flavor. Freshly baked focaccia smeared with honey ricotta was fantastic. Tagliattelle and Tiramisu were textbook and I'd also recommend. Service was good. Interior is very small with limited seating and you have to order at a counter, meaning very limited time to decide, before seating yourself. Pasta prices are high and don't match the smaller portions. Parking is very hard to find in this busy area. Although the food is excellent, I would recommend going outside peak dining hours and/or special occasions. read more

See all

The pasta is out of the world, as fresh as can be. When I dined here I was fortunate enough to enjoy some prawns on special; they were divine, milky and creamy. Desserts are also noteworthy. Beware that the house wine is a full liter, so revel in the bonus 250 mL surprise! read more

Incredible hand made pasta - maybe the best pasta I have ever had. The cacio e Pepe is unreal. The passion they have for their food is self evident. My favorite spot in Chicago. read more

Tortello - Cacio e Pepe - Pasta Shops Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Attended my daughters friends bday pasta making party . The private space upstairs is incredible. Mads was the hostess and utterly sweet ... the adults got their own table and beverages . The old fashioned was excellent and the only glitch being we had to go down to order our food . All the pastas are freshly made from scratch and i was surprised that there was no protein on most except the squid ink and beef ragu . Certainly a vegetarian haven for all the no meat folks this is a must visit . The lines are long but move fast . I was a tad surprised when we split the bill for 2 adults 3 drinks shared appetizers and 2 pastas it was a tab of $175 . Kind of expensive. But worth the visit read more

See all

The pasta here was delicious! We had to wait in line for a bit around dinner time for our group of 7 but it went pretty quick. You order up front and they bring your food to your table later. It's pretty small inside and a bit cramped but it can accommodate bigger groups. Was a very cozy familial vibe inside. All the pasta we tried was really good and the bread was amazing. Service was also great. read more

See all

So a couple years ago my sister was exploring Chicago and was told by some locals that should had to try Tortello!!! Fast forward and here I am in Chicago for a weekend and I had to go! This cute little restaurant has people making pasta in the store front so as you walk by or wait you get to enjoy the creation of the some of the best pasta I have tried! High praise but deserved! When you come in you order at the front which happened to be with the owner when I was there. I was told to try his Nonna's gnocchi and how could I refuse! I also ordered the focaccia with ricotta, honey, and olive oil! Melt in your mouth delicious carbohydrates!!! The bolognese gnocchi was a beef based sauce with the gnocchi! The gnocchi, was so light and airy and pared well with the savory sauce! 10/10 will return! read more

See all

Before going to Chicago me being the foodie that I am I searched must visit restaurants and this one came up and I def know why Small ?yes... cute? Definitely Started off with a aperol spritz yum!! The Fabiola app was so heart for it being beans. Had the perfect warming taste Another must is the TORTELLI DI BURRATA They are little clouds of homemade past filled with cheese and cooked in a brown buttery sage sauce. Yummy richness You just can't go wrong with the place. They have salads that start your rap off perfect and all homemade pastas that give you the warm being at home mama cooked for you feeling read more

I thought the food was ok. Nothing special. I wouldn't go back. I would expect a place that just does pasta to be more flavorful.

I am one of those Diners Drive inns and Dives followers and a mega business traveler. I was blessed with an opportunity to try Tortello's today. It's a GEM of GEMs super cool brightly lit sleek open and a bit whimsical dining area has more of a pasta shop vibe than a restaurant. I met a lovely lady making hand mixed pasta dough with Triple Zero and Semolina flour. The other lady was rolling and folding sheet pasta dough in the window so you get dinner and a show. The gentleman behind the counter was awesome! Thank you sir for politely changing with me in Italiano. They have a limited but mighty menu but I got the special which was the most awe inspiring Carbonara I have ever had. The fresh spaghetti was a perfect al dente and the guaiacoli was crispy crunchy and almost a bit nutty which was heavenly blissful. Every now and then you got a little tix bit of fresh cracked pepper. If you aren't aware Carbonara is an egg yolk sauce that is cooked from the steam of the cooked pasta and hot starchy pasta water. It ain't easy to get right but Tortello's blew my mind how fabulous it was!!!! This was a true and authentic Italian experience and it's a must visit in Chicago. They have take out pasta and meal kits along with other Italian items. There outdoor seating on the sidewalk. Parking is street only so prepare to find a lot or uber there. Do not miss an opportunity to eat here! read more

See all

I think that it is an interesting concept where you order at a counter and have a server bring out your food. We got the tagliatelle tina, the burrata pomodoro, cacio e pepe, and the tiramisu. I thought the tagliatelle pasta was good well but I would say the pasta to sauce ratio was 4:1. There was not enough sauce. The burrata pomodoro didn't have ripe enough tomatoes but had good sauce but again not enough if the balsalmic. The cacio e pepe was a bit too salty and the pasta was a touch under al dente and was a bit hard. The tiramisu was good and probably would get that. It is a cute date spot but probably would be interested in trying other places before coming back. read more

See all

Unfortunately, Tortello has lost its touch from the first two times I had dined with them a few years back. This past week, revisiting the restaurant, I was disappointed in both my meal and the customer service. To begin, the espresso martini was disappointing as it fell short on flavor, and you are paying $15 for a small glass that is 3/4th foam. I ordered the Tagliatelle Tina, which had a good taste, but the pasta was slightly overcooked and not al dente. Another member of my party ordered the special, which was similar to my dish but with a white sauce and mushrooms. The owner pushed us to order it, saying it had pork, which it did, but only a small amount of crumble on top, and not the amount we expected, and it just got lost in the dish.  Not sure if it was just because the staff was having an extra busy night since we did dine on a Saturday, but I thought the interaction with us was not the most personable. One of the wait staff had told a member of my party to scoot in his chair even closer to the table to clear room for those walking past. Normally, I would pay devil's advocate to see the other side of this, but he wasn't even taking up much space in the walkway compared to a group that was standing two people deep in the same area. Lastly, there was a spill near my party, and the man who was acting as host grabbed napkins for him, the customer, to clean up, instead of the employee taking the initiative to clean it up for the dining guest. To sum it up, I was disappointed to return and not have as good of a meal and experience as I had in the past. Theres other Italian restaurants around the city I would try before returning here. read more

Tortello - Espresso Martini - Pasta Shops Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

This cute little pasta shop was the perfect spot for lunch while it was snowing out. It's casual and the store front is narrow. You order up front and they bring the food over to your table. The staff were friendly and were able to help me with vegetarian options and what could be modified without meat. We got the bread with ricotta and honey spread, tasty puttanesca pasta (without the fish sauce) and tortelli pasta filled with burrata. The front window displayed fresh pasta being made. It was a little pricy but the pasta was homemade and the sauces were really unique and flavorful! Can't wait to come back and try something new! read more

See all

Even better the second time around. Wow. We hung out there for 3 hours eating, drinking, and enjoying life. Totally Italian atmosphere even on a busy Chicago street. This is the best meal of Italian food I've had in the states. Period. read more

Tortello - Pasta Shops Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Oh wow! Excellent food. I'm not a fan of Italian food tbh. The way it's made being greasy & salty catering to a certain set of taste buds but this place was amazing. Ordered the 'Tina' AND the tortelli de burata (signature dish!) . Both were wonderful to taste and didn't leave you feeling bloated. It was a quick lunch so no dessert or drinks Service: was polite and efficient Ambience : not.a romantic first date place but more like a 4th or 5th date. It's close seating. Would I return ? Oh yes ! Absolutely! read more

Tortello - Tagliattelle Tina - Pasta Shops Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

I was unfortunately disappointed by this restaurant. I heard such great things about it, but here are the reasons why. - It was freezing!!! I get it, it is a very casual restaurant, but why did I had to leave my jacket on? I even overheard one of the waiters saying that it is cold. Didn't help with them ambiance and wanted for us to leave quite quickly. - The food was ok. Nothing exceptionally crazy. And compared with the high price. I unfortunately can't recommend it. - We got something classic Tagliatelle Tina. It was good and I liked it. - We also wanted something special so we got the seasonal Ravioli with ricotta filling and sage. Could not at all taste sage. The sauce was very disappointing, I was trying to find any taste in it. So overall: was so excited to dine here, but would not recommend it. read more

See all

What a great family style meal for my holiday party! We were treated to 4 different homemade pastas, so much good wine, tasty espresso martinis, some excellent breads and salads, and two desserts. I could go back just for the tiramisu and espresso martini, but that's only if I was already stuffed. Otherwise I'd want more of the tortellini-type pasta. YUM! The staff here is warm and kind. You'll be in great hands for dinner! read more

Tortello - Espresso martini - Pasta Shops Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

I don't know... I had a good experience here at first but we've been 4-5 times now because we live in the neighborhood and I just have been disappointed in my dishes the last few times. Not bad by any means but just nothing I would return for. I love the ambiance, the fact the owner is inside taking orders and interacting is great, and the focaccia with ricotta is every time BUT again last night just found our pasta to be meh. I got the baked duck paperdelle. It was good but nothing to write home about. My husband thought the noodle texture was a bit mealy. He got the special which was a Gorgonzola and olive pasta. Basically just tasted like a watered down creamy pasta with a few olives, no real flavor. Other recent thumbs up: - mortadella crostini - octopus starter - seasonal zucchini flower pasta 7/10 Meh: - aglio olio pasta - squid ink pasta (husband liked, I thought meh) I like that they value ingredients and Italian authenticity, it's just fallen a bit flat for me lately. read more

See all

Edited review: 3.5 stars. original review was 2 stars but changing it. Cute restaurant. You order at the front and then sit down. I was pretty sure I got food poisoning from the saffron dish which is why I gave the review 2 stars. But now I believe it's from a different dish from somewhere else. I also didn't love the taste of the pasta dish. I would try a different pasta but would NOT recommend the saffron dish unless u love the taste of saffron. I got a note from the restaurant owner privately that also told me about their temperature controls and that they didn't hear of any other complaints which made me reevaluate my food from that day. I thought the focaccia was a bit too doughy but I know people rly like it. I would recommend to other people to try but to me, I wasnt in love with the taste of the dishes I got but I would maybeeeee try again. read more

See all

I love Tortello! Their pasta is seriously the best and I love the ambiance of the space. It's cozy and quaint, and very warm and inviting. I've pretty much tried all their pastas and you just can't go wrong with any of them. My favorite is the aglio olio. Simple but so flavorful and the pasta is so perfectly al dente. Oh and don't forget to get the focaccia with ricotta and honey! It's absolutely divine! I think the only problem I have with Tortello is I wish they had more protein in their dishes. Most have no protein at all. Meatballs would be a great addition to their menu in my opinion. Other than that, I love this place! read more

Tortello - Pasta Shops Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Bib Gourmand designation well deserved. Was on a girls trip to Chicago and this place was a magical experience. The food was incredibly fresh and delicious. Price was on point. Service- amazing. The owner was working and made the experience so special and was lovely and patient with 4 girls trying to make up their mind... just all around wonderful. I wish I would have taken more pictures of the outside but it was so cool to see ladies making all the noodles through the window. We sat at the outside tent area and it was such a cozy ambiance! An absolute must if you are in Chicago. read more

See all