The folks working there are great, easy to work with, but the food is terrible. Ordered the chicken cutlet sandwich with roasted red peppers, lettuce and vinegar. It's a large sandwich but there's no flavor, there's absolutely nothing to write home about, and for what they charged for it, it's shameful. The Chicken Parmesan dinner was ALSO SHAMEFUL. The sauce is so watered down, there's no crisp or crunch, sauce has no flavor, I had to dump out all the water because the breaded chicken was soggy the second I opened the container. Complete waste of money. read more

Pizza was okay. Pepperoni pizza was a bit greasy. Festive decorations! Beautiful flowers outside the pizzeria. Street metered parking until 6pm. read more

See all

We've been eating at Tony's for years now but just recently booked it for a lunch after my daughter's communion. I gotta say, the whole experience was exceptional. From the planning, to the picking out of the menu, everything was great. We opted for the family style service and the food was incredible and portions were huge. Plenty left over to take home. I also have to mention the waitress, who is possibly the nicest most attentive person ever. Overall my family and I couldn't have asked for a better day. read more

My favorite go-to spot for meatball and chicken Parmesan sandwiches. Their enchiladas are amazing! They definitely stuff them! Staff is friendly which is always appreciated. I love that you can get the best of both worlds with Italian menu and Mexican menu in one location. read more

Tony's is located in a cute historic looking area. When you enter, you can tell it's an older family owned establishment. The server was very attentive and sweet. We ordered pizza slices for the kids. It's thin crust, but not crispy. Not super greasy. Our picky eater who usually only picks the cheese off pizza actually ate the whole slices. I ordered one of the pastas and was shocked when it came out. It comes out in a bowl that's twice the size of an adult males head! Lol it took me 3 attempts to finish it! Great portion for the pricing. I would say it could've been more flavorful tho. I asked if it could be made spicy and was shocked that instead of red pepper they added pickled jalapeños. read more

Still the best pizza around especially dining there but take out is good too. Friendly staff, nice ambience BYOB enjoy read more

Tony's Pizza - This place has never failed on a great pizza The service was great also. - Pizza Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

Tony's is so so good. Love the diverse menu and the pizza is heavenly. Wish the would open up a chain in York County PA. Whenever we visit Pompton we always eat at Tony's. Lovely sweet people work hard to make sure you are 100% happy! read more

Excellent Pizza love the crust and the taste. Nice large slice reasonable price great place to eat. Going there for years. Friendly atmosphere and great service. read more

Ordered a philly cheesesteak and a frank Sinatra sub. Both were terrible. The bread is too bulky given the sparse ingredients. Therefore the ratio of bread to fillings in bad. I could get a better sub at Wawa or Subway and half the cost. Why there is so little meat and cheese/ greed maybe. Stick to their pizza and stay awy from the rest of the menu items. nice people. read more

Fun place with a huge menu so it is easy for a family with differing tastes. The tacos pleased our guest and the clams over linguine satisfied the picky granddaughter. The fried calamari was very well made. The ravioli dish left much to be desired and ended up being discarded once we got home and decided it just was not what we expected. Pizza for the little guy was a hit. Will go back but will stay away from ravioli entrees. read more

Stopped in at Tony's Pizza in Pompton Lakes with my sisters for some lunch. Apparently, it's a Mexican restaurant, as well. I wasn't in the mood for pizza, so I had a Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich (minus the peppers). The sandwich came out hot and there was so much meat on the sandwich that I had to take some off! My sisters got 2 slices of pizza each and said it was very good. One of us got dessert, a piece of Oreo Mousse Cake that quickly disappeared. The menu is HUGE!! Every kind of Italian or Mexican food you can imagine. Something for everyone. The service was excellent. Bathroom was clean. Recommended. read more

Everything was absolutely delicious and the portions were HUGE! The staff were so nice and the service was incredible! Highly recommend. read more

Tony's Pizza - Restaurant outside - Pizza Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

See all

Good food & service ordered some wings and chicken parm dinner Good size portions and tasted great Picked up my dinner service was good and friendly It was ready by the time I got their read more

Nearly 4 decades later still my FAV Tell'em what ya want & they make it happen !! Always pleased w dine in , take out & delivery. Strongly recommend. All cold subs great , pizza always fantastic. Enjoy. read more

I love a real pizzeria. Tony's is just that. I'm looking forward to trying their Mexican food. It looks like "restaurant Mexican." That is, not like like a Cali taco/burrito shop. The back section was full with a dinner crowd and everybody seemed to be enjoying their food. I was content to sit up front with a couple of slices of solid pizza. Recommended slice spot. Thanks Tony's. read more

Have eaten here many times both inside, take out, and delivery. Pizza is the best in the area and priced right. Dinner entrees are good as is their Mexican fare. Been a staple of Pompton Lakes dining for many years. You won't be disappointed. read more

If I could give Tony's pizza 100 stars I would I love love love this place so so so so much they have the best best best best pizza ever the Mexican pizza is the most amazing best pizza I ever had in my life for anyone who never been here I highly recommend trying they have the best best best pizza pasta nachos ever read more

Don't order the Flan.. it's frozen clearly kept frozen and was still frozen when arrived at my home with VERY watered down sauce.. disappointing. Shouldn't even be sold here if this is how it's served. Sandwiches aren't to bad. read more

I grew up in Pompton Lakes and don't get back that often. When I do I always stop at Tony's Pizza. We used to go there between snowball fights and shoveling to warm up when I was a kid. The pizza is so much better than I remember, and my memories are fond ones. You really need to go here. I know they have been in business at least 40 years. Hoping they go another 100 read more

I love their cheesesteak. Also thief stuff shells the young lady who Deloris so respectfully. Great job

Holy helpings, Batman!! Excellent service, terrific food, pasta served in giant bowls that will feed you for at 24 hours after. Yum I must come back to nosh on nachos. :) read more

Huge portions. Good food. Good price. BYOB. What more can you ask for ? Seafood pasta enormous. Tons of seafood. Awesome Caesar salad and garlic bread. Each dinner is enough for 2 meals. Easily. read more

Usually a $10 sandwich can't be bad but it was. Ordered tomato & fresh mozzarella w basil & balsamic. What a think pathetic excuse for a sandwich and the Basil they couldn't even take it off the stalk and maybe 3 drops of dressing. The bread was horrible, definitely stale and they tried to revive it in the oven or something. Don't waste your time or money here, go anywhere else. read more

Tony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

Use to enjoy their pizza, but lately the prices have gotten very expensive that 2 of our neighbors even mentioned it to us too get just a couple of pies that we now all go someplace else. Maybe they will start to take notice of their client dropping off :(( read more

Combination Mexican and Italian joint which is usually a bad sign, pick one and run with it. Grabbed a few slices and some mozzarella sticks and both were just bad. Tasted like cheap cheese, pizza was a big, bready, greasy, floppy slice. Just not very good. read more

We've been coming here for more than 15 years. It's one of 25 places to get pizza within 5 miles. Tony's is the go-to place for pizza and traditional American style Italian. Roberto, the current owner, was the sous chef for more than a decade when Tony sold the restaurant to him. Roberto and his wife had started a Mexican restaurant down the block; when the deal for Tony's came they folded the Mexican menu into the Italian one. Roberto has taught his sons to have the same light touch with the pizza dough, one of the more delicate in the area with just enough chew without being tough. As a traditional American style pizza it has a bit too much cheese in my opinion, but everyone loves it. Entrees encompass the classic and traditional as well as some newer combinations of ingredients. The Mexican menu is only a small part of restaurant's offerings but this is all home made; burrito, shredded beef chimichangas and flautas. Shrimp Vera Cruz is a delight. They have toned down the spice to appeal to the local community but feel free to ask for more heat for any reason. While prices are edging up there are only a couple dishes that near $20 and most are $9-18. A 18" pie is still under $15. Tony's is BYOB, there's no corkage fee and it's not uncommon to see a table sit down with a couple different wines. read more

Tony's Pizza - Veal ala Tony's - Pizza Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

See all

Best Pizza in Town, they also do Mexican food that's on the money. Very friendly Establishment

I have been going here for about 5 years. We always take a full pie to my kids in sleep away camp , parent visiting day. We love the pizza. I decided to Get a baked ziti and it was cold, put in a big random bowl. Cheese wasn't melted and pizza came first so I didn't get to eat them together. We ordered garlic knots. Delicious. Only one lady working the tables. I wanted to return the huge bowl of ziti read more

You can't beat Tony's for fresh food. Italian specialties excellent. Sandwich's - hot, cold, wraps - excellent. Pizza - huge variety all excellent. Mexican specialities - excellent. Truly something for everyone. We order from here frequently. Take out service is quick, efficient and the delivery persons are always friendly. I am so fortunate to have them close by! Try the Liza Minnelli sandwich for something truly special. read more

This review is based solely on the one time i ordered delivery from there. We got the chicken parm sandwich and it was soooooooo delicious. So cheesy!!! The sauce was delish! And it was huge- 10 inches and the price was reasonable. They came right on time, the food was still hot, and their prices are good! I would definitely order from here again! read more

Tony's Pizza was YUMMY! The interior is cute and I love the mix of Mexican and Italian cuisine. You can hear the chef/staff music from the kitchen and it gives the place a great vibe. The customer service is great! We had a classic pie and I thought it was flavorful, crust was perfect and the sauce too. I'll be back to try more of their entrees and update soon! read more

Came here with a group of 13 and they were welcoming. Service was efficient and the pizza pies were HUGE. Very reasonably priced. Pizzas tasted awesome, every variety. read more

*veggie pizza (yummy!!!! There was broccoli, zucchini and carrots on it, so interesting to have carrots but they were so good!! Haha. I loved the crust and the cheese. It was so surprisingly good and would definitely order this again) *buffalo chicken pizza (not bad, they were generous with the chicken but I've had better slices of this) This place is cute and they have good service, their slices are big and def worth $3.00; I would come back here and eat again. We got take out so I think next time I would eat dine in. read more

Tony's Pizza - from top to bottom: sausage & peppers, buffalo chicken, veggie - Pizza Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

Unfortunately I wasn't very impressed with Tony's when I went, I felt that it was a bit overpriced for what I ordered & it came out wrong too, (chicken cutlet sandwich plain is what I ordered with lettuce and tomato on the side so it didn't get hot and mushy) I got a chicken parm, which although wasn't what I ordered was very good. They were very busy so after I made sure I wasn't taking someone else's food by accident I decided to just eat it so they didn't need to remake it. read more

We've been ordering from Tony's ever since I can remember. Once the pandemic hit, Tony's was our go to place every Friday night, sometimes even 2,3 times a week. Every time their customer service has been spectacular, the food phenomenal and always so welcoming! Thank you Tony's for countless meals that were absolutely amazing!! read more

I am a foodie but a picky eater. Go figure. So when i say something is good it is GOOD. The chicken fajitas are so amazing. I have even called after having food delivered to tell them to tell the chef how great they are. It is a must have. read more

The food is great but you have to know that the portions are HUGE. I can tell you that the next time I go I may split a meal with my son or both of them, it's that big of a plate. The service is very quick and the food was well done. read more

Update: Tony's is still the absolute best. However, I've switched to the grandma pie and my life has never been so complete

Not only do they have the best pizza and Italian dinners in the area, their authentic Mexican cuisine is a nice added touch to the menu. The owners are kind and friendly and make delicious food. Delivery service is always fast and the drivers are nice and helpful people. Look no further if you want high quality Italian and Mexican food in the Pompton area. read more

Best mussels in hot sauce around! Thank you for making this very crazy Easter a little better with excellent food! Found you guys by mistake a while back, but never left a review. The pizza is excellent, as is the Stromboli! So far everything I've tried has been excellent! Friendly service when you dine in, timely completion of your order for pick up, and today I learned they will deliver to me (I'm a little far from the store)! Thank you for making my day! read more