One of my.most fondest memories of Rahway was Tony's meatball pizza slices and believe it or not they had the best fountain soda (it may have been the ice that made it really good). I miss Tony's! I lived right down the street from them for years. Hope to get up to visit so I could have their pizza again. Thank you Tony's for still being around. read more

Tony's is my favorite local pizzeria. Not just for the pizza; their subs, sandwiches and pasta are delicious as well! Always fresh. In regards to the pizza- the spinach Florentine will change your life, and their vodka slice is amazing as well. Great mozzarella sticks. You can't go wrong! read more

See all

Tony's chose to provide poor service. Humans make mistakes but we are able to correct those mistakes. I ordered two pies of pizza but the driver lost the tickets with the address and phone number and did not deliver the pies in a timely manner . After waiting over an hour for the food, I called to find out where the status of our order, I was meeting with unprofessionalism. I asked that order be remade instead they reheated the pies and sent them back out. Tony's chose the easy route, not the correct route. Do better Tony's. You have my number. read more

Be very careful when ordering from their website. Although it says "Tony's Pizza & Cafe", they claim it's a 3rd party website. I ordered three items, paid a delivery fee and left a tip through the website. Once the food came, the receipt didn't show the tip so my very generous husband also tipped in cash. I don't care that he received a total of $10.63 in tip. My issue is that the website is misleading and when I called the restaurant the owner couldn't care less. He is a poor business man. The chicken marsala was so tough you couldn't cut it with a fork. My husband loved the eggplant. There's a new pizzeria that opened up the block. Love the owners and you never get a bad meal. I'll stick to them in the future. (R&J) read more

I have been ordering from Tonys for years but I think last night will be my last. I called to order a medium pizza. the man who answered the phone said we have a special on Monday, a large for less than a medium. I old him it was Tuesday and then he said the special was Monday through Wednesday. I said ok and we received an obviously frozen pizza. There was no crust like a hand tossed pie has and it was very light. we couldn't even fold the slice without it breaking like a cracker. Chicken fingers were hard and dried out. I will be searching for a new pizzeria now. I could have used a frozen pizza from the supermarket for way less if that is what I wanted. read more

Lunch specials are gone from the menu like wtf and prices went up. Broccoli isn't always green which is interesting bc I think it's frozen. But seriously if the main course includes broccoli, it should be green and not have brown spots on it. Lasagna is okay. Pizzas good. Used to order once to twice a month here but not any more. Hate when you have to change pizzerias after many years - over 10. Having to find a new go-to is annoying. Here's something that bothers me a lot. When I read the Yelp reviews, it seems the owner or whomever is answering the Yelp reviews isn't very nice to people and puts them down when they complain and I think that's poor customer service. And when I called and asked about the lunch specials, they said they still have them just not in the SLICE app/menu and what did I want. Well I don't have a lunch menu to look at so idk. lol. I'm sorry but this is a major turn off. read more

Probably preaching to the choir here. Anyway - I have lived in a lot of places and I have had a lot of pizza. And having lived many years in New York City, you'd think I've been spoiled for good pizza. I can't explain it - Tony's might be better than any place in the Big Apple. Might be the best pizza on earth. The pan pizza is all I ever dreamed pizza could be. Couple that with quick service, and consistent excellence across the menu - the wings! My lord, the wings! - Tony's has become a weekly mainstay at our household. read more

Overall nasty pizza. Way too many olives on the pie I ordered, ended up throwing the pie away after a couple of slices.

Saw this spot riding through the area and thought I'd give it a shot. Order: margherita pan pizza with pepperoni, sausage, garlic and peppers and an order of Buffalo wings. The wings were good. Would have preferred a little crispier (which I'm sure they can do upon request) bur still good. The pizza is definitely worth the price. Crispy crust, good amount of sauce and toppings. Service was quick and staff were pleasant. read more

Tony's Pizza & Cafe - Pan Margherita with pepperoni, sausage, garlic and peppers - Pizza Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

See all

I order at least 2 times a week the portions are nice the sausage and peppers sandwich is delicious The chicken noodle soup is as close to grabdma josaphines as I've ever had over all Tony's 5 stars read more

Met the new owner! Very nice man! Pizza, minestrone, and meatball parm sub were all delicious! Fast and courteous service.

In the past Tony's was one of the better pizzas in the area. Not now. It must be under new ownership. Cheap cheese,low quality sauce and no crust. Never again. read more

I have been ordering from Tony's Pizza Café on 1085 Broadway, City of Rahway for the last 8 years usually the same Lunch special that's from 11am till 4pm. I usually order Penne Vodka with grilled chicken. Today unfortunately I had the most horrific telephone call with one of the owners. I was charged $33.28 when it's usually $10 with some change the lunch special. I ask for it to be left on front porch as my 16 yr old teen is not allowed to open the door to strangers it's rule we enforce. First a young lady answered and politely apologize as she stated there is always a new girl working there and knows who I am. I requested a refund back on my card for the overcharge. The owner got on the phone and said I called after 4pm when I called at 2:58pm then he said it was a simple mistake the new girl made but wouldn't refund me back as things happen and according to them I was given a regular meal not the special. I explained that I am in need of my refund as he knows I always order from there and it wasn't my responsibity the young girl wasn't proberly trained. He started yelling that no refund would be given back and it was a mistake and I was lying about the time I called. He said what was I going to do call the president and complain mocking me. He says no driver ever wants to come to my house as I never tip which is untrue there are times I can't but most always due. He said I was a cheap and properly trash. He knows me personally. I remained shocked with my mouth opened without words as I expected a simple refund back on my card. He said he will never deliver to my address and could fuc* off laughing. Just sharing my personal experience from this place as I never expected this quality of service from him. This really has shocked me that a business owner whom I know can speak to me with such demeanor and laughing at me. I won't be ordering from them never again as i was left in tears on how aggressively he spoke to me when they made the mistake not me. read more

Tony's Pizza & Cafe - a receipt for $ 20 - Pizza Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

Came here today on a whim. Had a slice of white and a slice of chicken parm. The white had a crispy thin crust and I added some garlic powder and chili flakes. Chicken parm slice had a thick crust with a nice and crispy bottom. Surprised me with how good the pizza was. Parking lot is a challenge. Would come back Update: come here like almost every week. I think it's my favorite pizza spot in the area. The grandmas pie is fire! read more

Tony's Pizza & Cafe - Really good pies! - Pizza Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

Really pissed off I have been a loyal customer for over 14 years. I grabbed a $20.00 special wings knots pie , now it's $ 25.00 ... last time I ordered it was $23.00 now you charge $1.00 on credit card also... $$$$26.00$$$$$$$$$$ Sorry only when I am craving will I come back I'm sure you have positive feedback from me stating how delicious your food is and yes it is. Is it worth $25.00 NO IS IT WORTH $22.00 In cash and a $3.00 tip yep read more

Go to pizza in my new neighborhood!! Quick to make and Knots to die for! Old school vibes as well

Absolutely terrible no one was adhering to the mask requirements nor did they enforce them to the other customers. the young man who took my order didnt have a mask on nor did the person who seemed to be the manager. it felt very insanitary and just not a very clean place Edit: stop deflecting, focus on the facts safety is first, not once was race mentioned and there was nothing rude about the girls response she very politely told him about the law and he was offended and was the first to get loud stating "mind your business worry bout your pamper" and other such obscenities. You're response to this only makes you out to be a very petty person and unwilling to admit when you're in the wrong same with the older gentleman. Do not patronize me under the guise of trying to defend yourself or your business. I don't have a daughter, I didn't want to correct you but that seems to be the base of your argument and the word Bigoted was used not racist as well as ignorant I wasn't taking pictures otherwise I'd post them. Wrong review. read more

Not sure how I haven't reviewed this place yet! This is my go to spot for pizza! They have the best pizza around, the marina is just sweet enough and they are always generous with the toppings. The dough is not too thick, it's thin without being too thin to be classified thin crust. Their pizza is always cooked to perfection and I've never had a wrong order or burnt order which is surprising given the amount of times I've ordered from them over the years. Staff is always pleasant here, accurate wait times for pick up, delivery is prompt, I really have nothing to complain about here! You can order through GrubHub as well, which I often find myself doing. No extra delivery fee and so easy to see wait times without calling. We pretty much just order pizza here but an occasional chicken parmesan sandwich for lunch always hits the spot. A large split by two people for lunch is perfect here. Same great marinara as the pizza. There isn't much seating inside, it's mostly a spot to grab take out or order delivery, but I have stopped by to do pizza by the slice here. They have a pick up special during the week,I believe it's Tuesday and Wednesday (call them to verify), for two pies for about $20. Great deal during the week when you just need some Tony's pizza! If you haven't ordered pizza here yet, do it. You'll probably never order elsewhere. It's such a challenge for me because I want to try new places but I know the consistency and deliciousness that comes with ordering from here. Check it out for yourself. read more

See all

For Mother's Day, I ordered dinner for 5 people from Tony's and it was delicious! The servings were large enough to feed 10 people, and everyone enjoyed the meal. For the entrees, we had Veal and Chicken Marsala, Chicken Francese, and Chicken Sorrentino. Everything was cooked perfectly, and they included extra sauce like I requested. I also ordered Sauteed Spinach and a House Salad to have vegetables, which was great because the entrees also came with a house salad. Lastly, I ordered the Garlic Knots and found out quickly why they are a restaurant favorite! We really enjoyed the meal, and look forward to eating there again soon! read more

I got a large mushroom and cheese pizza and it was absolutely perfect. I'm new to the area, and if this is any indication of the quality of pizza around here, I think I'll have a good stay LOL! Oh! My delivery was early, too! read more

I love Tony's! Great pizza and friendly service. Fast delivery. Good prices.

This is a good place for pizza and other types of Italian food. The Fried Calamari is also good. There is parking on the side and on the side street. I ordered a large plain pizza, a large vegetable pizza and an order of fried calamari: $39. The pizza was a little well done on the crust read more

See all

Love this place! Specialty slices are delicious spicy buffalo and spinach florentine.

My husband and I live in Rahway and were searching for pizza on Friday night. Given the recent positive review of Tony's Pizza Cafe we decided to give it a shot. We ordered the veggie pan pizza online and was told that it would be ready in 15-20 minutes. When we got to the cafe the place was packed with people picking up pizzas and a few dining in (I think the majority of their business is pickup or delivery). Definitely a good sign that the place was busy! We specified online that we wanted the pizza slightly more cooked so we had a wait a few extra minutes, but no big deal the pizza was perfectly cooked to our liking and the staff were super nice. Now to the pizza, which was absolutely amazing. The crust was very crisp and buttery, almost tasting like a beer crust and the sauce had great flavor and herbs. The veggie toppings (spinach, eggplant, mushrooms, broccoli) were super fresh and flavorful. Everything combined this made a perfect combination. Typically veggie pizzas are soggy since the veggies release water as they cook, but not Tony's. This pizza crust could hold its toppings and you could easily eat the pizza with one hand. Please check this place out! read more

Tony's Pizza & Cafe - Veggie Pan Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

My family and I have been going to Tony's since I was kid , The pizza has always been good and consistent throughout the years never had a problem ! I just recently moved back to Rahway after living in NYC for the past 8yrs! On Monday I decided to order a pizza and the nightmare began !!! First , I used the app Slice and I got a notification 3 minutes after ordering and it was letting me my food was on its way ! How is this possible , it has only been 5 min ?? When the pizza was delivered , I ate the first slice and immediately I got a really strong smell/taste of freezer burn from the pizza and the crust was super hard !!! I called Tony's and told them and they said they would pick up the pizza and replace it with a fresh pizza ! This time , the pizza was delivered in about 30min , so I thought for sure I would be getting a fresh pixza straight from the oven, wrong !!!!!! The second pizza had an even stronger taste and smell of frezzzer burn and it was disgusting ! This time I contacted the Slice app customer service to contact Tony's !!! When I got the return call , customer service said they spoke to the owner and that the owner refused to refund me anything for the disgusting pizza !!! What's even more crazy is the pizza box has the word FRESH on the cover !!!! I am serious do not order from Tony's it was the worst pizza I have ever had in my life !!!! read more

pizza was clearly made at earlier tim and reheated. the crust was hard and dry . the minestrone soup was not edible it was a bowl of garlicky grease. the potato and egg sandwich was also overcooked and dry and tasteless. I would never eat from there again truly disgusting!! read more

I was just reminiscing with my bf about how amazing this pizza is. When I lived in NJ, I ordered from here weekly. Excellent pizza, especially the grandma pie. Twice when we were back in NJ for a quick visit, we made sure to order a grandma pie from this awesome place. I'm so glad to see that this place is still open for business, and I truly hope the pandemic hasn't affected the owners and staff too much. read more

Ordered here for dinner tonight, and we ordered a grandma pie with minced garlic. It was amazing. Every bite had fresh mozzarella cheese. There was no inch spared. The sauce was perfect, dough was just right. I have ordered from other places with grandma pies and this is my favorite one by far!! I've ordered here in the past but just a plain pie. Thanks for an amazing dinner!! read more

See all

We order from here whenever we crave pizza at home bc let's face it, the Grandma's pie is where it's at. I love Tony's! read more

I am second generation italian on both sides. I grew up with very authentic italian cuisine. I recently moved here to Rahway from Westfield, a power house of great italian restaurants. I've been to popular NYC Italian restaurants and others all over New Jersey. Tony's is the best italian restaurant I've been to. Whenever I have friends or family visit, they better expect to be introduced to Tony's. Amazing sauces and pastas, perfect deep dish pizza, they're all I ever want to order from now. I dont know how they do it, but I hope they keep doing it. Tony's, thank you for brining a slice of home to this new town. read more

Ordered delivery. Arrived well packaged but tasted like cardboard. Not a fan of the crust or the sauce. Will not be ordering again.

Ordered a grandma pie for delivery on a Saturday. I knew if would take a while and was pleasantly surprised by how quickly it came. Too bad the bottom on pizza was mostly burnt. read more

Tony's Pizza & Cafe - Crust to burnt to eat - Pizza Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

Best pizza in town by far! Tony's is a staple for everyone in the area and the staff is great

Awesome pizza. Small pie with sausage is incredible and the staff are always very nice to us

I don't just give out 5 stars so believe me when I tell you Tony's is my GO TO food place. From the girls that work the front to the flavor of ALL of their food, everything is perfection. The sauce is SO good. Their menu is full of options. Their rice ball parm, margarita, chicken sorrento, penne vodka & garlic knots are some of my favorite items. The pizza is great, weather it's pan or regular. I live a town over where we have plenty of pizzerias but as long as Tony's Cafe stays serving their food the way they have, I won't go anywhere else! read more

Terrible calamari , go to tuckys pizza instead . It's much tastier and has a cool seating area.

I really liked the pizza from here as well as the garlic knots and wings. I have to remember for the next time I order take out. They offer a few special priced packages like one large pie 12 knots 12 wings a salad and a soda for $23 or whatever. Pretty good deal. read more

Their pan pies are a must. The best margarita and cheese steak pan pies. Their pastas are actually pretty fresh and they have a lot of good discounts and coupons. The workers are always really nice and when I get it delivered their always on time. read more

Ordered 2 pizzas for pickup and asked how much it would be. The girl said she would check. She came back in about 30 seconds she said $31.00. When I got there I was told $33.00. I said I was told 31.00 over the phone and the person who gave me the pizzas said she was new and if I wanted the pizzas $33.00. If the girl checked and came back and told me 31.00 they should have honored this price. read more

My family and I are originally from New York and I was convinced there's no place in New Jersey that can match New York Pizza. I was very wrong. I've been coming here for years and they never disappoint. Cheap prices, delicious food, and a GREAT staff. Head over here for a slice or sandwich and they will NOT disappoint. read more