Had a Margarita Pizza that had absolutely no flavour and the crust could've been cooked a little more

Rip off restaurant!! This is NOT the original Toni's. Every single item is made different. They have the NERVE to charge the same price for their cheap, crappy, cafeteria style pizza. Wait, cafeteria pizza is better than this. I have even had high school cafeteria pizza better than this! Just one big giant disappointment all the way around. There was more crust than cheese. Used to be an amazing place with the best pizza I have ever had in my life! Whoever bought it did Toni's a disservice because now this place sucks donkey balls big time!! read more

Well the ownership must have changed family's yet-again. Today's Sicilian pie with extra cheese and pepperoni had virtually no sauce and one paper-thin slice of pepperoni per slice. Even the dough was flavorless. Cannot recommend for anyone at this time ... read more

Toni's Pizza - Yuck... - Pizza Near Me - Virginia Beach, Virginia

Toni's Pizza is located in the Holland Plaza Shopping Center, which is near the corner of Holland Rd. and S. Plaza Trail. You won't necessarily see the place from Holland Rd., but you should see the shopping center from both roads. It took me a little time to find it as the GPS in the car wasn't as helpful as it normally has been. My visit here was on January 4, 2025. From the outside, it looks like a quaint little place. Apparently there are new owners for the place now, as I saw a notice about that on the door as my mom and I came in. I like to try several new to me places around the beginning of the year, and this is one of those places. I also had a coupon from the back of a Kroger receipt. When we came in, we were the only patrons there. The two owners were there though when we came in, and we were able to choose where we wanted to sit. They came over with the menu for us to look over. I generally stick to water with lemon as the drink since I try to keep my blood sugar in check, as I have been in diabetic remission for over a year and counting. My mom decided to go with Pepsi since they are one of the places that does Pepsi instead of Coke. After looking over the menu for some time, we decided to go with the large white pizza, while also adding green peppers and pepperoni. We decided against appetizers since we knew the pizza would be big and will have enough carbs by itself. About ten to fifteen minutes after ordering, the pizza came out and boy did it look and smell good. They asked if we needed anything else other than the plates and such, and we were good to go at that time. Normally, I'd just go for one slice of pizza, but it was so good that I ended up having three slices that day. In the end, there were a few slices left to bring home to have the following day. Overall, this was an excellent experience. They served us well when we were there. They were on top of it, and the food was phenomenal. I even mis-read the coupon, but they honored it anyways. Even with having the three slices of pizza, my blood sugar levels did not spike either. I am definitely looking forward to coming back soon. It's always great to support local businesses. If you are in the area and looking for some great pizza or Italian food, you definitely need to put this place on the list of ones to try out. read more

See all

My first time here, I'll give it 4 stars. The young man at the front was cordial and professional. I ordered the Philly Marinara cheesesteak. The sandwich was hot and fresh, and the flavor was good. It was easy to chew, which I prefer. The restaurant was pretty clean, but could use a little more attention probably. Overall it was a good experience. I will definitely stop back and try the pizza another time... read more

We moved close to this restaurant and tried it yesterday for the first time. I found the pizza to be quality, the crust was a nice texture. They don't offer a military rate, but we will be ordering from them again. read more

Toni's Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Virginia Beach, Virginia

That place is full of crap the 12-in submarine meat Philly crap was full of grease and salt the tiramisu was old and stale the meatballs were bland and old also I don't care how long they've been here I don't care if they're Italian or not that place is totally trashed read more

A childhood memory of coming here as a kid. Great service great food 10/10 ! Greek salad and pizza so good! read more

The flavor is kind of bland and I had to cut my own pizza , Not really a good pizza place! Very dissatisfied

I was craving NY style pizza and gave Tonis place a chance, being from NY I can be very picky. The pizza was delicious and the cannoli was delicious as well! If you're craving something very close to NY style this is a great place to go. read more

Toni's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Virginia Beach, Virginia

I'm glad I chanced this place! Just another day craving pizza. My barber is in this complex, so I decided to try it after my haircut. I was hoping for pizza by the slice. They don't do thst so I got a small. I love onion pizza, so that's what I went with. I was greeted when I walked in. The guys behind the counter we're very polite. I used the restroom while I waited for my pizza. And that's when I really started to notice how clean this place is. Everything is very clean. Not what you expect from the average pizza joint. A short wait later and my pizza came out. We all know the crust makes or breaks the pizza. And ooh! what a crust. This pizza was delicious. The crust had a great crunch to it. There was plenty of cheese. The sauce was good. I am very happy I ordered here. I will probably get a small pizza whenever I get my haircut now. read more

Toni's Pizza - Small onion pizza - Pizza Near Me - Virginia Beach, Virginia

Great pizza!! We did have a little trouble finding it but it's next to the old Animal Jungle(now a gym). The food was very good and the owner was very friendly. We can't wait to go back! read more

really good pizza a 7 out of my 10 for sure. Authentic NY Style cheese and tomatoes. Place is clean and staff is great, family owned since 1976. Very traditional pie! read more

See all

Food was Excellent service top notch, we ordered a foot long meatball sub the sauce was fresh not caned, meatballs were tender tasty and full of flavor Highly recommend recommendation of this place, go there get filled up and leave happy read more

This is the best pizza and Italian food in Hampton Roads. Normally I just get pizza but today I got manicotti. Just freaking delicious. The place is very clean and they have a couple of outdoor tables. The people are just the nicest, kindest people. I just love everything about Toni' Pizza. read more

Toni's Pizza - Manicotti to go. It tasted just like I was craving. - Pizza Near Me - Virginia Beach, Virginia

Great food and service in a nice casual atmosphere! I ordered the small mushroom pizza. It was just as delicious as it was in the '80s!!! The mushroom pizza has a deep-dish crust and has a hearty savory flavor that will satisfy any big appetite!! It's topped with loads of fresh cheese and mushrooms!!! The staff is very friendly and accommodating! read more

Toni's Pizza - Small mushroom pizza - Pizza Near Me - Virginia Beach, Virginia

After going to FunVille with two little kids, we were all starving! The two workers were so incredibly sweet to my kids! They kept talking to my nephews and getting them to laugh the entire time we were there. As soon as we came in, one of the workers gave both of my boys juice and he kept bringing more as they finished their juice. When the bill came, they didn't even charge us for either juices. When we went to say thank you, one of the employees gave us a free piece of cake to go. If you want something reasonably priced and extremely family friendly, this is your go-to place!! read more

I would love to give Toni's a great review, and to be fair, they had just changed owners again and we're in the process of making adjustments. So all I can share is how the pizza was when I was there and on a scale of one to five I would give it a three. The sauce is good, however I don't like the crust at all. I will give it another chance as the new owner has had time to settle in. I will update my review in the future when I try it again. read more

A friend of ours told us this was the best pizza he's had in Virginia Beach so we decided to try it today. We ordered the Toni's famous pizza in size Large, which has so many items on it, onions--thinly sliced(omg-so good), green peppers, mushrooms, sausage, pepperoni, salami and ham no black olives. We came on a Monday so our pizza was $15.50, $4 off on Monday's which makes it less than the medium. The crust was perfectly cooked and held up to all the toppings on the pizza! This reminded me of the days when i traveled with my grandparents on summer vacations. Draft beer In small mugs!!!! Their menu has a lot of Italian dishes so we must come back and give them a try. You will surely enjoy their pies, so make a trip, yum! read more

See all

excellent food ! Authentic Italian ... friendly service ... friendly atmosphere... we had Pizza, cannolis and ravioli ... will return

this is a great spot plenty of easy parking tables and booths. the owners is very funny and a great guy. I had the steak and cheese sandwich and it was the best one I've had in years. toasted bread and came out very fast. please try this spot. it's also kid friendl. read more

Really good! A quiet little pizza place in a strip mall. Looks like not much on the outside. Pizza was great! Deep dish crust that was savory and crunchy on the tall edge. The mozzarella was generous and so flavorful. We had both Hawaiian and the special. Both really good. Coming back again! read more

Very Friendly service from the young lady at the register. Leo made sure the pizza was ready in a timely fashion and it is consistently tasty!! read more

Toni's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Virginia Beach, Virginia

Been going to Toni's for probably 20 years - considered it my favorite pizza place. When ever my birthday, or father's day cam around - where does dad want to go to eat - Toni's. A couple months ago, we went. New storefront images - interesting. Ordered as usual. Pizza didn't seem right - didn't taste right - didn't have the right consistency. Hmmmm, has something changed? Someone new in the kitchen? Bad day maybe? Then this weekend we went back, I had to see if it was a fluke or if something had changed. The pizza "looked" okay, but I could immediately tell it wasn't. Crust is too think. I am no fan of "NY style" pizza with its ultra thin and floppy crust, and loved Toni's because it wasn't just right - not too thin, not thick. The new pizza was thicker. My favorite thing about Toni's pizza was the thick, chewy, gooey cheese. That is gone. Now the cheese is blah and lacks any substance at all. And the sauce is just not good compared to the past. In the end, I (and my wife) thought the pizza was no longer good at all. I have since learned they are under new management. Well, when you buy a historic place, it is a real no-no to screw with the recipes. If you are going to do that, CHANGE THE NAME. This is NO LONGER Toni's, and I have lost my favorite style of pizza. We won't be going back sadly. So many great family memories of the past at least. read more

Wow! More people NEED to know about this place! It's a hidden gem of yester-year! Awesome pizza! Highly recommend! read more

Toni's Pizza - Half Hawaiian half pepperoni with mushrooms. The pic doesn't do it justice! - Pizza Near Me - Virginia Beach, Virginia

See all

Tried a new pizza place called "Tony's" the sauce is some of the best pizza sauce I've ever had and toppings and cheese were good . How ever they only have " Pan" crust . The crust was just thick for me . For people that like pan ,you would probably love this . I wish they had had other crust options as then this would've been a total win and they would have won a new regular, as we eat pizza almost weekly. Clean and friendly environment. I even bumped into a friend who happen to be eating there. She is definitely a "pan"lover as she loves their pizza and told me I need to try their lasagna because it's the best. So I guess I'll be back for that. read more

Toni's Pizza - Meat, lovers pizza extra cheese, and onions added - Pizza Near Me - Virginia Beach, Virginia

The pizza is so cheesy and delicious. To me the star of this place is the Greek salad. It's incredible.

Had heard good things about Toni's and decided to grab a carryout pizza... wish I had gone here sooner !! Pizza was truly fantastic and unlike traditional NY style.. something about it reminded me of pizza I used to eat growing up, was hard to explain, but very enjoyable and reasonably priced.. staff were friendly both on the phone and in person... pizza was ready in quoted time. Will order again 100% read more

We are pizza snobs and we love Toni's! especially the Sicilian Pizza. Jaime, the owner, hand makes the dough and twists up the garlic knots and I watched him lovingly stir the tomato sauce...yum! read more

Don't be fooled by Toni's carpet in his hone because the pizza was truly a pleasant surprise. I moved into the neighborhood a few months ago and was given a gift certificate to check this place out by my realtor. Walking in I wasn't sure what to expect. It had a shab look to it mainly by the carpet and well after being in a Classic Chuck E Cheese party room I had no idea what I was getting myself into. The decor not on the full modern side and the signage could be a wee bit better. The taste of the pizza for me was a strong contender of large chain restaurants. The pizza had great flavor and was a healthy size for the price. I would return for another slice. So swing through for a quick bite to eat! read more

See all

Called in my order and it was ready for pick up right on time. Hot and delicious. One pepperoni and one supreme.

This place was great. Pizza can be easily amazing but also easily destroyed. This place was one of the best pizzas I've had in years. They didn't try to go full food network on the pizza and didn't over complicate it. I will be back, and I live 8 hours away. read more

Toni's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Virginia Beach, Virginia

So happy the new owners went back to the old recipe, their pizza is so delicious We are ordering it tonight read more

Finally the old Toni's pizza is back! New owner but they brought back the original recipes. read more

See all

Good place with good food! Lasagna is wonderful! New management, home made Pies and dishes and extremely delicious!

This is not an Italian place anymore. It's African and most of their food is African. and that's great if you are looking for an African menu. I just want a pizza read more

Used to love this place. Went a couple weeks ago, and it seems like they couldn't care less if you're there. The pizza was off, maybe the cheese not sure. So I tried again today, same service and the pizza was burnt. Ate 2 pieces and left the rest on the table when I left. Come back Toni. They are doing disservice to all the years of your great pie! Won't try again. read more

Small hole in the wall place. Their phones were ringing off the hook the whole time. Only on other family was there and they had their food before we sat down. The reason I said that, it took 45 mins to get our food. The only people that was in there for that whole time. Nicest people working the shop but very slow in the delivery to table. Food? We got 1/2 of a meatball sub and a large pizza for $29. Like someone else said, a large pizza there is about the size of a medium pizza at Pizza Hut. They did have the pizza pie plates that showed sizes on the wall next to the menu, but unless you were looking you didn't know the size difference. My husband saw it after this smaller pizza had been delivered. The sausages weren't Italian like we asked, just kinda dull sausage. I actually dotted the pizza with a napkin because of the amount of grease and had to cut it with a knife and a fork because it wouldn't stay on the dough. I am NOT someone who eats pizza with a fork and knife. My husband liked the taste, me and my mother didn't. The meatball sandwich on the other hand was great. The meatballs weren't balls, they were liked sliced so they didn't fall off the bread. The bread was real Italian bread, not just some cheep rolls. I ended up eating the whole meatball sandwich and ditching the other 1/2 of the pizza slice I had grabbed. Sweet people but unless it's carry out I wouldn't visit again. I put a dollar bill next to the pizza for size read more

Toni's Pizza - The size I was trying to show. The slices were about the size of a dollar bill - Pizza Near Me - Virginia Beach, Virginia

Didn't know it was under new management until we opened our pick up order. We thought the pizza did not look as expected when we opened the box when we got home. The cheese was all over the place. When we picked up a slice! It slid right over and all that was left on our hand looked liked a cutout cardboard slice of a triangle pizza slice. Just giving everyone a heads up, SAVE YOUR MONEY ELSEWHERE!!!!!!!!!!!! They should have a big warning say "UNDER NEW MANAGEMENT " YOU ALL HAVE BEEN WARNED. read more

They are recently under new ownership again, and the new owners are doing an outstanding job of bringing Toni's back to the community! The pizza is fabulous, the sausage is exactly as it used to be, and the newly added garlic knots are excellent. If you grew up on Toni's and were devastated by the change after it was originally sold, give the new people a chance! They are making EVERY effort to restore its greatness! read more

Toni's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Virginia Beach, Virginia