Very very good. Like a true New York style pizza. 2 slices plus a fountain drink less than $10. Had 2 cheese. My brother opted for pepperoni. Righteous amount of cheese with a whisper of drip. Great understructure and easy fold. Slight burn at crust. To make it perfect, our server was super polite and smiley. Going back. read more

Tomato Pie Pizza Joint - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Silver Lake, California

See all

My son and I were looking for some place close by after enjoying the morning at Griffith Observatory. My son said he wanted pizza so we drove over to Tomato Pizza Pie. We ordered a few slices and drinks. We weren't really sure where to go to get the drink so I had to ask and they said we could walk to the right, it felt like we were walking into the kitchen area. After a few minutes our slices were done. My son who normally loves a NY style or thin crust loved the Sicilian style and ended up wanting one more slice to-go. The slices were a nice size and heated well. They offer coke products which makes me happy. The employees were friendly. I do think the prices are a tad high, but we enjoyed our pizza and wouldn't hesitate to come back if we were in the area. read more

See all

This spot has some delicious deep dish vegan pizza! The saucy has a nice bite and they use some wonderful plant based cheese that melts on perfectly. It is a pretty penny but it's a treat so worth it. I added black olives, roasted garlic and red onion which is always my go to. It is perfect! Plus it is massive! You end up with a rectangle pizza with about 8 slices. The thing must have weighed 15 lbs too! My partner ordered and picked up so I can't say what it's like inside and what the service was like, but I bet it's worth it all! read more

Tomato Pie Pizza Joint - Vegan deep dish - Pizza Near Me - Silver Lake, California

See all

350 pm, Wednesday, August 20, 2025 I just snuck in to order the daily special (slice, salad, drink) for $10.99. First time here so might as well try the combo. I asked for the most popular slice (Grandma), a house salad with balsamic. The self serve fountain is around the back, lol. I've always wondered about this place. I'm unsure if they have a full size dining room! Seems like a place that is mainly for take out but has 4 petite booths. I asked the head honcho for more info and he said there's an outdoor patio too. Ooh baby! That slice hit the spot! It was warmed up. I believe and still had a bit of crispiness on the crust. The house salad was great too with the balsamic dressing tossed together. Shoot, next time I'm here for a somewhat quick service at Electric Ave I am returning to Tomato Pie for the daily deal! It hit extra good cause I've been avoiding fast food for a long minute. read more

See all

Solid pizza joint with a nice diner aesthetic. Fast service. Check out the art store nearby too :) read more

Tomato Pie Pizza Joint - Pizza Near Me - Silver Lake, California

We've been on a mission to find good pizza in LA and this one has been added to that list! I'd actually give it a 4.5. Love the old school diner feel inside. Not much seating but they have an outdoor area with a bunch of bunches as well. The staff were really nice and gave us suggestions on what to try and the drink specials. We are the Traditional Cheese , Grandma , Really Really Funghi , Syracuse, Utica slices. They were all good but the Syracuse, Grandma, and Utica were the best and I highly recommend. We'll definitely be back. read more

See all

Even though I passed it very often, I only tried Tomato Pie for the first time within the past year. I was in the mood for a slice of pizza, and I appreciated the friendly customer service while I thought the pizza was fine but not overly impressive. I revisited recently and decided to try the garlic knots along with a slice of pepperoni. Given the stream of customers coming in to pick up to go orders, I got the sense that the restaurant is definitely popular! The garlic knots were mixed, with some of them being overly charred while others had a tender texture. They also lacked a strong garlic flavor. However, I would come back if I'm in the mood for a solid pizza slice and happen to be in the area. read more

My sister was raving about this place, I actually had no intention of coming here today but saw it while driving and was like ooohhhhh Snappppp it's right there! And turned in. The place is small and cozy, parking lot is perfect size for the shop. When I went inside I was greeted right away. I ordered the Utica deep dish square and the fungi fungi slice. They heated it up perfectly and the Utica was super yummmmmy! Buttery and crispy crust and super flavorful. The fungi one was loaded with mushrooms and veggies and pesto that was super yummy too. Can't go wrong with anything you order everything looked bombbbbb! Make sure you give this place a try it's definitely worth it! read more

Tomato Pie Pizza Joint - Utica and fungi - Pizza Near Me - Silver Lake, California

This is probably my favorite pizza joint in the city if I'm being honest. I come here with my partner at least once a month to split a whole pizza to share. I usually get the Miss Green and he gets The Primo and boy let me tell you it always hits. They're very consistent here when we come to eat so I appreciate that very much. The crust is always crunchy and thin ( makes me think I'm not eating too much carbs, but I highly doubt it). When you order, you order in front where the cash register is and they will provide you a number so they know where to place your order if you're eating in. The place is a casual spot to eat, nothing formal, but you get to have one of the best pizza's in the city. It may be hard to find because it's in the corner or a bending street. The parking lot is small too, so if you can find street parking that's the way to go! read more

Tomato Pie Pizza Joint - Half Primo (left) half Miss Green (right) - Pizza Near Me - Silver Lake, California

Some people call me a space cowboy, some people call me a fat kid who loves pizza more than he loves cake. Tomato pie slings affordable, filling slices with unique, extremely vegetarian friendly flavors. My favs include: * Mr white - it's like Michael Jackson but you want it. If you love cheese and garlic, but want to go past the mozzarella, this one is for you. * blanco veggie - it's like the the mr white, but I want to pretend I care about fiber and my health. you're probably the person that considers the cilantro on a katsu sando as ruffage * miss green - you love pesto pasta, but wished it was a pizza * really really funghi - this guy is invited to every single rager I'm every throwing. hands down the best pizza they throw here. it's easier to catch a mew on the first try with a regular poke ball than find this behind the slice cage. I'm glad I make those big bucks now so that I can just buy an 18 inch instead of meal prepping for the week. p.s. did you know you can freeze pizza slices individually in foil and then air fry to crispy perfection at 400F for 6 mins in your air fryer. don't thank me, buy someone that needs it a slice and pay it forward. read more

Tomato Pie Pizza Joint - Pizza Near Me - Silver Lake, California

Garlic Knots: 1/5 Tomato Pie: 2/5 Bbq Chicken: 5/5 Employees: 5/5 Clean: 5/5 Parking: 5/5 16th of August 2025 Took so long for the garlic knots to come out and they were tasteless. The sauce was watery. The tomato pie pizza had cold sauce on it yet the crust was warm and delicious. The bbq chicken pizza was my favorite and very tasty. read more

See all

First time customer, best customer experience!! I wish I remembered the name of the staff members who helped us out. The nice blonde woman working as a Cashier helped us out with deciding what Pie to chose. She gave us a PIece of pie to try. It was delicious! The entire staff was friendly, warm and informative. We ordered the meatball, sooo good! And the Detroit style great grandmother. Delicious!! 100% will be back. read more

Fantastic slices of pizza! Reminded of a local shop in New York and gives a nice solid flavor with their sauce. Here in silver lake they sell by the slice and also whole pies. I prefer by the slice so I can try different styles . I got the pepperoni, Utica, and bbq chicken. Service was very friendly and gave some good suggestions so I decided to try all 3 slices. The ambiance also was very chill and laidback. They call your name once you order your pizza then go to the patio or back home to eat it. read more

See all

Tomato Pie is the best and today they infinitely upped the game. I have some wacky allergies. When I arrived, Caesar shared that he had been working on a Sicilian Style pizza that I could safely enjoy. It is delicious and I'm even more delighted it turns out that others are enjoying the new pizza as well. I feel incredibly grateful to have such a caring and delicious spot in my neighborhood. Thank you Tomato Pie! read more

Tomato Pie is in my neighborhood and amongst all the numerous pizza places nearby it's quite good but not truly great. Good selection of veggie pizzas and I like the Ms. Green and the Florentine. They also have a variety of pasta dishes and salads that are sharable and pretty good too. My kid loves the Grandma slice. The pizzas (uh, pies) are 30 bucks for a Large plain cheese and then more for any of the other pies. Ouch. The service is generally good and there's just a counter to order from and two registers. There are also a few tables/booths for indoor dining. It's decent but just a little bit expensive IMO. They have a seating area in the back that's good to sit outside when it's nice and enjoy your pizza etc. Stop in for a slice and decide for yourself. read more

Been a loyal Tomato Pie fan since 2019. I used to recommend it to everyone, now I am going to actively divert people elsewhere. I've never had such a terrible time trying to order a pizza or such a lackluster response to an obviously egregious mistake on the restaurant's part. I ordered around 7:00 for delivery on the website. For 45 minutes my order was frozen, pending "approval by manager". I call around 7:45, and they say "oh, it got stuck. Just a bug in our new system. It should be to you in about 25-30 minutes. Another 45 minutes later, the order tracker finally changes to "delivered." I look around -- no pizza.... I call, and they say "oh, yeah, you are 1.5 miles outside of our delivery zone" (meaning I am 4.5 miles away from the shop) "and we're not allowed to deliver to you". I waited for an hour and a half. Now it's too late to pick up, too late to order another pizza. I'm so angry. I *loved* Tomato Pie but I will never order another pizza from there just because of how terrible their protocol is. Guy on the phone was nice. You could tell it wasn't a 'him' problem, but a company one. read more

Generally, LA is not known for great pizza until now. Tomato Pie Pizza Joint (est 2006) is corner pizza joint that makes the perfect NY-Style pizza in Silverlake. They have two other locations: So.Pasadena and Woodland hills. As far as I can remember I have driven past by this place going to work for years. But today is the day I checked it out. I arrived as a first time customer. I was warmly greeted by Cesar, staff, at the counter. I told him that it was my first time at this joint and he explained to me the pizza slices they have. I perused their menu (pizza, pastas, subs, appetizers, salads) and decided to get a slice of Mr. White (Garlic olive oil, oregano, romano, ricotta, parmesan & mozzarella cheese), reg Cheese pizza and bottled water. He was kind enough to give a complimentary pizza The Grandma (crushed tomato, garlic, basil, light mozzarella & our original pecorino romano crust) pizza, as a first time customer. I was grateful! Pizza was flavorful and its crust was great. It's exactly the kind of NY style pizza taste that I'm accustomed growing up in NYC. Service was great. Staff were friendly. Atmosphere was relaxing. Their sleek interior 60's design definitely stands out compared to other pizza joint in LA. Prices seem fair. Overall, I loved every pizza moment. I highly recommend them. read more

See all

Best Pizza in LA!! The food is amazing, the prices are really fair and the service is great. So lucky to have this spot close to my home. My favorite slices are the Utica, the tomato pie and the pepperoni. Their cheese slice is great as well, if you're feeling like Dave Portnoy. read more

I ordered to-go and the wait time was pretty quick. I ordered a half & half (grandma and florentine). The grandma was a great basic plain pizza, but the florentine surprised me in a good way. I loved the flavor of all the vegetables together and would definitely order entire pizza of this next time! And don't miss out on the garlic knots- they're great with the gooey melted cheese and pesto! There's a small parking lot otherwise it's street parking. read more

Tomato Pie Pizza Joint - Garlic Knots with Pesto - Pizza Near Me - Silver Lake, California

See all

So me and my friend were walking around the area and we spotted this place while walking to her apartment. The ambience seemed nice so we spontaneously decided to stop by and I'm happy to say we made a great decision. I ordered the Utica and my friend got the Blanco Veggie, and they gave us the Grandma slice on the house which was awesome. I think my favorite was the Grandma, the tomato flavor was just so good. I'll get that one the next time we go there. The other two slices were also very very good but overall it was such a nice experience that I will be coming back again! read more

Tomato Pie Pizza Joint - From bottom to top: Utica, Grandma, Blanco Veggie - Pizza Near Me - Silver Lake, California

This seems to be the unofficial caterer of most kids' birthday parties in this area. Classic and affordable pizza when you need to feed 20-40 hungry humans. read more

Tomato Pie is a welcome fixture for the neighborhood I'm a big fan of their ever-changing slice selections and covered patio out back. They have a nice selection of bottled sodas, Italian desserts and salads are definitely worth a try (if you're wanting the greens). The staff is always friendly, and it's good to see the ever-present manager at the helm. Bring the family and sit outside (good space for them to explore and play a bit, or grab a pie to go. Tomato Pie is my go to. read more

Affordable good daily deals wait time was short quality of food was spectacular was looking for somewhere to eat on my break found this local place came in and was outstandingly satisfied service very welcoming and friendly would definitely recommend if your looking for top notch pizza read more

Amazing food and customer service from Garret. Attentive to the order and great recommendations for toppings. Do not miss out on their Ranch! read more

Tomato Pie Pizza Joint - Half Butcher/Half Primo 18" - Pizza Near Me - Silver Lake, California

One of my favorite pizza spots! The prices are great, the pizza is delicious, and the customer service is always amazing. Plus, their interior is absolutely adorable. read more

went in this evening to pick up some pizza and salad after a long family Christmas and Michael was super helpful. great food, nice folks. will be back. read more

This place is pretty good my boo liked the chicken Riggies which lol cute name for some pasta? I had the pizza and it was not bad. I got the Mrs green one. Yum read more

Parking: they have their own parking which is always killer anywhere you go! It's tricky going out due to the light signals is right on the corner as you exit. Pizza: freakin so good and I'm super happy that they offer pizza by the slice! My favorite is Mr.White! read more

See all

I came in for my first time and was greeted in such a friendly way. And then I ordered and explained that this was my first time and he gave me a free piece of pizza! As I was leaving, I look around for something to cover the pizza with and he brought me a box! This is the kind of service and kindness that will keep me coming back! Also, the pizza was delicious read more

I am lactose intolerant and had their vegan cheese pizza tonight. I've tried many vegan pizzas and I can attest, this one was phenomenal. I'm not sure I can share this, but I heard they use "follow your heart"vegan cheese (no nuts), one of my favorite brands for vegan mayo. The cheese on this pizza was super melty and gooey and the flavor was outstanding. I would highly recommend this vegan cheese pizza. Yum. Yum! Thank you! read more

A small pizza joint hidden away in Los Feliz. Pizza was nice and hot. Everyone was very friendly and polite. The place was nice and cozy. Would definitely return to try more of the pizzas! read more

Tomato Pie Pizza Joint - Half Grandma and Mr White. - Pizza Near Me - Silver Lake, California

Love their pizza. It's all in the dough !!! I'm never disappointed! Great service. Good people answering the phone. We order once a week ! Recommended read more

Got the Sicilian and was very disappointed. There was very little sauce and the pizza was dried out and stale. The unpleasant feeling of rock hard bread cutting up the inside of my mouth still haunts me. read more

I thought my favorite was the Syracuse. HOWEVER; today my coworker gave me a slice of his BBQ chicken pizza. OMG, so GOOD.!! I just love this place.!!! read more

I pass this place every time I take my wife to work and have wondered what the pizza was like. I Had a slice of the Sicilian Utica-style after a post run with silverlake track club. I am a big fan of pizza with bread. Sicilian pizza is probably my favorite type of pizza. Bread was hot, soft, and chewy along with the right amount of toppings to not overwhelm myself. *I only had one slice but I am going to be coming back to try the others to give a more in depth review* read more

Pizza has been always on point here, the sauce actually has flavor and the crust is crunchy. The guy behind the counter was the opposite of welcoming but luckily it didn't mix with the pizza. Everyone has a bad day, at least he was professionalish. read more

Giving four stars even though I actually mean TWO, just don't wanna bring down your score... hot and cold in the same bag = melted... cheesecake was upside down, next to a hot meatball sub, therefore I had a melty, mushy, warm cheesecake... also that's a lil baby meatball sub eh... nothing on it but sauce and some cheese... definitely was unwise to order it for delivery; by the time it got here it was like eating raw bread... Los Feliz - Glendale... * Shouldn't judge a place by a basic delivery...and everything about that delivery was basic mind you... so I'll have to try it in person some day. Might order a pizza delivery but I dunno... * Just bumped up my stars to five, cos the OWNER freaking messaged in a jiffy, which is some crazy fast customer interaction... hope my tone didn't come across as dickish, but yes, it was all in one bag... and the raw feeling/soggy bread is more on me and the driver... he went missed an exit and took an extra five to ten minutes getting here, and I shouldn't order a hot sub to go... just meatball sounded good. read more

Tomato Pie Pizza Joint - Upside down cheesecake was nice and warm next to the hot meatball sub... - Pizza Near Me - Silver Lake, California

See all

Sold Pizza joint. First time walking in and getting a look at their pies I can tell I was in for a treat. Garret and his team at the original location know what they are doing and I will be coming back again and again. Thanks for the chat Garret! -Coffee Guy. read more

Tomato Pie Pizza Joint - UTICA and Tomato Pie. I ate like 2 squares and 3 NY Style slices. lol - Pizza Near Me - Silver Lake, California

Was next door getting new tools at Baller. I constantly need tools. Decided to get a slice before dinner because, Hey. I'm 45. Pepperoni slice as a quick, pre dinner snack? You bet. I'm an adult. Let me tell you - it was just what I needed. I'm tired of eating 3 course meals without Pizza being one of the courses. My ideal 3 course meal woul be a slice of pep pizza, a chicken sandwich, and then a gouda macaroni with mashed potatoes and gravy. And for desert? Another slice of pizza. Any place that sells pizza by the slice is worth supporting. Plus, it was pretty tasty. Crispy outside crust with a warm soft dough interior - it's like I'm eating mini tunnels of emotions. The pepperoni is great. Some places don't have good pepperoni, am I right? This place - they got it. I think the only bad part of the experience is since my wife didn't get a slice - I forgot to offer her a bite until I only had crust left. She still liked it - but that's not what Pizza is, am I right? Ps - I was holding tools the whole time I ate - so just so you know - I'm pretty good at eating pizza read more

Tomato Pie Pizza Joint - Flavor Dimension - Pizza Near Me - Silver Lake, California

Tomato Pie owners and manager reached out and made everything right. Frankly, I didn't return to the Silverlake location; only Pasadena. However, the manager and owners of Tomato Pie are passionate about customer service and their products. If they mess up your order, speak up and they aim to please! Thank you Tomato Pie Pizza management team. Your pizzas Rock! read more

See all