Clean, charming, and honestly way friendlier than any "Times Square" I know of. The regular pizza was solid and flavorful... but the stuffed pizza? My GOD. That thing came out looking like it had its own gravitational pull. Heavy, cheesy, buttery crust, and an outrageous amount of cheese (yes, I asked for extra -- no regrets). I've never had a stuffed pizza before and now I feel like I've been lied to my whole life. It stole the show, the spotlight, and probably my calorie budget for the week. Totally worth it. Would absolutely come back just for that cheese monster. read more

Times Square Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Melbourne, Florida

See all

Just like Texan-Style Mexican (TexMex) food, there is no shortage of pizza available here along the Space Coast. Now to be fair, Florida pizza will generally not stack up to the "Big Three" (New York, Detroit, Chicago), but the indie restaurants having that "mom and pop" vibe come damn near close. Fortunately for my friend Chops and I, Times Square Pizza does a very good job as we enjoyed both a classic and unique flavor pizza. Chops and I came into Times Square Pizza after making the call to eat lunch over waiting in a slow-moving line at the new Mochinut Melbourne located north, across the street. We'd figure that after eating pizza, the line would have both progressed and been shorter. Spoiler alert: they were neither. Still, we enjoyed the pizzas we ordered. I asked the waitress, a sweet older lady in her mid-age, what were the signature foods or most popular foods among locals. She suggested the stromboli, calzone, and pepperoni pizza. Since the restaurant is called "Times Square," I assume it is a callback to Times Square in New York City. Ergo, I expected the pepperoni pizza to be as close as it could be to a general New York Style pie. Times Square Pizza did a great job and though not exactly like a New York style pizza, it is probably more what is available locally as well as climate. I am sure the humidity and not using New York water affected the pizza pie from truly being a New York style pizza. Still, very good. I could see what it is one of their more popular dishes. Chops ordered the gyro pizza (In which he actually said "J-EYE-row" and not "Year-row"). Since this pizza wasn't truly traditional (nor is most pizzas here in the United States), I rate it differently compared to eating crostata or torta from Italy, the traditional Italian food that pizza possibly originates from. If you ever eaten a gyro, all the basic flavors are in this pizza and they are delicious. It blends well on a pizza dough in a way that a Greek pita is replaced. If their nontraditional flavor is this good, I wonder how the others stack up. Actually, I wonder if they actually correctly use pineapple on pizza too. As for other details about Times Square Pizza, it has a trattoria kind of feel mostly with indoor seating but some outdoor seating as well. They serve a selection of alcoholic beverages specialized from Italy especially an Italian beer (sorry, could not remember the brand). Finally, staff was friendly and helpful and the restroom (at least the men's restroom) was clean. Overall, a great initial visit to the pizza place that suddenly caught my eye when I was out and about during the opening day for The Sweet Heartists, Times Square Pizza's neighboring business in the same plaza. If I come back and Times Square Pizza remains consistent with the excellent service and delicious food they provided, they will earn their fifth star. SIDENOTE: Times Square Pizza is the third location in Brevard County's Geocaching Tour, TMNT Series, by the Leffert's Family. read more

Times Square Pizza - The waitress suggested the pepperoni pizza. It was good but maybe I should have asked what kind of crust would best pair with it too. - Pizza Near Me - Melbourne, Florida

See all

Quaint spot that serves up great pizza and Italian dishes. The food was delicious and my appetizer paired with garlic knots was a meal in itself. read more

Times Square Pizza - Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Melbourne, Florida

See all

Pizza was okay, service was exceptional and ambiance was acceptable. Prices were reasonable.

The food here is always fresh, hot, and delicious. We have never left disappointed. The family who runs Times Square Pizza, and its sister restaurant Times Square Diner take great pride in their service and the food they prepare with loving hands. We always get a warm greeting and checked on often. The restaurant is roomy, clean, comfortable, and usually not too loud. This is one of our usual haunts. read more

Times Square Pizza - Jalapeño Poppers - Pizza Near Me - Melbourne, Florida

See all

Love the margherita pizza! Casual comfortable atmosphere. Super clean. Friendly staff. Good menu. Reasonable prices. Consistently great food. This is our go-to restaurant for a relaxing dinner. read more

Ambience, trying to be upscale in a strip shopping mall. Music was odd choice, 70s rock, & it was loud. A 10" pizza was pricey. It was disappointing. Dry, no sauce, & crust is chewy. Service was slow. Server seemed scatter-brained. Tried it, won't be back. read more

Times Square Pizza - Server station near front door. - Pizza Near Me - Melbourne, Florida

See all

Time Square Pizza, 7777 N. Wickham Rd., Ste. #22, Suntree, FL 32940 5 Stars ***New BBDO #1 Pizza in Brevard*** In my 50-plus years of gracing the surface of this planet, I have been accused of being a lot of things: a jerk, a crook, a curmudgeon, and a witling, to name a few of the least offensive. However, one thing I have never been accused of is sugarcoating things. This is the unique perspective that separates BBDO from the crowd. I don't pull punches, and I most certainly do not write "fluff" pieces. To that end, when I say a place is horrid, you can believe it. Therefore, the opposite is also true. If I say Time Square Pizza in Suntree is the new #1 pizza joint in the county, you can "take dat to da bank." Kim is our service professional today. She is the one you encounter who has been working the job for 40 years and lets you know it. She would appear to hate her work and comes off as plain miserable. This is just another example of why I won't rate the service. The service has nothing to do with what kind of food emanates from the kitchen. Sure, it can affect one's dining experience, but certainly not one's taste buds. I put in an order for the Mac & Cheese pizza and an order of Buffalo-style wings. From the ground up, this is an amazing slice o' pie. The crust is made from soft, flavorful fresh dough, and the macaroni & cheese is wonderfully put together to rival even the most authentic homemade mac and cheese anyone's grandma made back in the day. This stuff is like manna from on high (or wherever manna comes from). The pasta is cooked to perfection, the cheese is ooey and gooey with a bit of crunch on top as it should be. It took all my willpower to put it down and move on to the next dish. If you take a gander at the photos, you can see that the wings were cooked to perfection. What you can't see is that they had just the right amount of "oomph" to make sure your taste buds were awake. The accompanying blue cheese was your standard fare, nothing special there. But the magnificent flavoring of the wings more than made up for it. If you don't want pizza or wings but are seeking other Italian-inspired food, this is not the place you are looking for. Steve, the chef who opened this place, also personally designed the menu. This tells you that he really cares about the product that comes out of his kitchen. This is real talent in the trenches of fast/casual dining. The Big Boy says, "The pizza and wings are outstanding and 5-star all the way. The service, however, was down a few notches to land around 2.5 stars. In other words, prepare for Kim, but anticipate sublime sustenance slung from Steve's scullery." read more

See all

Beauty is in the eye of the pizza holder, and I felt this one was lovely. Crust was crispy, not burnt crispy, the nice crispy bread should be. Good amount of toppings. Good stuff read more

Consistently the best pizza in Suntree! Just wish they were opened a bit later during the week.

Caution! The food was good, but they charged more than prices on their website. I called and the lady responded "we are updating the website". A simple "sorry", that was it. I'm ok with their new prices, be transparent though. With so many options, go to a business that cares! Thankful I used a $5.00 coupon (they list as a manager comp), perhaps that is why the higher prices? Don't know, won't be back. I need to trust a business. read more

Times Square Pizza - Difference in prices as compared to the website. - Pizza Near Me - Melbourne, Florida

Great service and our dinner was amazing. We there on New Year's Eve. If we couldn't be Times Square in New York, this is the place to be!!! The owner met us and made us feel like we're at home. We will be back again!!! read more

Perfect place for the best wings and pizza ever. We had a large party and they took such good care of everyone. Drinks were quick, food was well prepared and was delicious. The very best wings. We particularly loved the garlic parm wings and the vegetarians enjoyed the vegetarian cauliflower crust pizza. The servers were absolutely wonderful and made us feel like we were so special. If we could give more than 5 Stars we would, read more

We enjoyed this pizza. We came on a Tuesday for pickup though and didn't realize until later that we didn't get the Tues special price. Do you have to mention the special when ordering? read more

Always a great experience. We eat at Time Square Pizza weekly! It's our go to spot for pizza & subs!

The greasiest pizza I have ever had. The crust was thick and shiny and greasy to the touch. The crust had a weird air like crispiness like some ingredient made it that way. The cheese and sauce were unremarkable. It may have been an off night, but I'm not taking any chances so sadly we won't return. I am so disappointed. I like food shopping in that mall and would have made it a go to place. We took out, so I can't comment about the service. read more

Our favorite pizza place in town. Their takeout works perfectly and tastes great. That said, their dine in experience is also excellent. Love their salads. Highly recommended read more

Went TSP @ 8:30 pm last night with four friends only to find out the place was cleaned up for the day and was told they were closed. A full 1/2 hour before posted 9:00 pm closing time. None of us were happy! read more

Everything there is awesome. The food is amazing. The service is very friendly and personable. Highly recommended

I just have to make a shout out to Time Square Pizza. I finally got the chance to go and get a pizza (Alfredo Chicken) and the famous garlic knots. Without any exaggeration It is the BEST pizza I have tasted on this side of the pond!!! And the knots were superb. The servers were delightful and the price was great! The interior is amazingly put together! Bravo! We will be back for more! read more

Times Square Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Melbourne, Florida

See all

Apparently owned by the same people who run the nice diner next door. Great pizza and appetizers. Everything is seasoned so deliciously. Had some pizza, garlic knots, and even had a sampling of wings. Definitely a place to try if you're tired of the usual corporate mass produced pizza joints, or you're in the mood for an "upscale" pizza date. If you're a beer person, you'll love their Italian beer list! I was told they deliver within a 5 mile radius. read more

Six months ago it was the greatest pizza and wing place in the area but they must've got a new cook because now the pizza and the wings are the worst in the area read more

Time square pizza! Thank you for your great customer service. There was a snafoo with our delivery order and when we called Mariana(?) was so quick to correct the mistake and promptly had a new pizza delivered. The pizza was great! Again, thank you. My husband and I will be back (I'm sure sooner than later! ) read more

Two hours and three phone calls later, and we didn't even receive the correct order. Very disappointed with our experience. If you're going to offer delivery, you need to do better. read more

Best pizza ever. We love the Times Square diner next door and go at least every two weeks. This pizza...omg. The crust is so good. The toppings? Amazing. Quick delivery, still piping hot. Nothing about that restaurant or it's sister is bad. Never have a bad experience at either. I'm sitting here stuffed and warm and happy. Thank you Time Square for all of your amazing food and service always number one! read more

Just a couple months into business. Wonderful New York pizza by the slice. I had salad with a homemade vinaigrette dressing that was amazing and a slice of pepperoni pizza for $8.99. Great new place that will soon be one of the goto places. Lunch was less than $20.00 including drinks and tax. Wife had a white basil pesto pizza that she was infatuated with. Going to come back without a doubt. read more

Best pizza in Brevard. Especially love the BBQ chicken, but all are great. Wish they had a better beer selection, but I'd rather have a great pizza so they still get 5 stars. read more