NY-style pizza that rivals NYC! Pizza, Service, and Ambiance!! NY Style Pizza tastes just as good, if not better, than most of the Pizza places in NY! Fresh ingredients, savory, and packed with flavor!! Haven't been to a Cali based- NY style Pizza place that matches NY Pizza in awhile and this one definitely takes the slice (pun intended) Garlic knots were a tad dry but the free marinara sauce made up for it. The service alone was welcoming! High foot traffic, near a school, so Pizza is definitely fresh read more

Times Square Pizza & Bagels - NY-style pizza that rivals NYC! Fresh, savory, flavor-packed, and this Cali spot definitely takes the slice! - Pizza Near Me - Temecula, California

If you're hosting a game night or just staying in and don't want to cook, Times Square Pizza & Bagels is your place to order from. Their Margherita pizza, Pepperoni & Jalapeño pizza, garlic knots, cheesy bread and bagels are just a few to name, that we've tried and loved! The two pizzas mentioned above are our usuals ordered every time. The fresh basil and slices of tomato on their Margherita pizza really make the difference than other Margherita pizzas I have tried. You can order whole pizzas or by the slice. Each time we walk inside the restaurant, we're greeted and provided a status on our order. The restaurant itself has a family feel to it. If you haven't tried Times Square Pizza & Bagels, visit today and try it! Grab a pizza for tonight and bagel for the next morning! read more

This pizza place is consistently delicious. We always order the Margherita pizza, and it never disappoints--fresh ingredients, perfectly balanced flavors, and a great crust every time. What really keeps us coming back, though, is the friendly and welcoming staff. The team is always attentive, helpful, and genuinely appreciative of their customers, which makes the experience even better. If you're looking for great pizza and excellent service, this spot is definitely worth a visit. We'll absolutely be back for another Margherita soon! read more

Stopped in for a quick bite while running errands. They have s special 2 slices and a drink for less than 12$ the slices are warmed up in the oven and were very good. They carry Pepsi products and have an additional drink fridge as well as beers on tap. Clean inside and friedly staff read more

See all

Warm welcome, delicious pizza, and ice-cold beer, what more could you ask for? Times Square Pizza is a great little spot tucked inside an unassuming Temecula shopping center. The restaurant isn't large, but it is clean, comfortable, and inviting. From the moment we walked in, every single person working greeted us, welcomed us, and asked whether we were there to try the pizza or the bagels. The staff was busy, one person was rolling out dough, another was adding toppings, and we watched a gentleman slide an extra-large pizza into the oven, but everyone still had a smile on their face and made us feel at home. We ordered the two-slice-and-a-drink special and upgraded the soda to a cold Coors Light from the tap. The beer was refreshing, and the pizza was flavorful without being overly greasy. The crust had a wonderfully crisp undercarriage, and everything tasted fresh. Our table was clean and comfortable, and there was a steady flow of customers throughout our visit. We can't wait to return and next time, we're trying the bagels! read more

Times Square Pizza & Bagels - 2 Slices and Coors Light each - Pizza Near Me - Temecula, California

Oh my word I wish we lived near here! This for sure will be our go to when in the area. This and the Peruvian place in the same plaza. The pizza really is like the pizza i enjoyed for years in time square. Much respect!!!! And the ranch. Delish!!!!! Clean place too. read more

Times Square Pizza & Bagels - Trust!!! It tastes DELICIOUS!!!!!!!!! May not look great but it is the best!!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Temecula, California

First time here. Saw the great reviews and awards so had to come check it out. Ordered their special ~ 2 slices and a drink for $11.95. What a great deal and filled us up! Love the NY style thin, crisp pizza. So good and hot...fresh out of the oven! Enjoyed each slice. Hard to pick a favorite! Fun, casual vibe inside and friendly, knowledgeable service. Will definitely come back! read more

See all

I ordered the special that includes two pizza slices and a drink. All of the pizza looked delicious but since I was with my daughter, we decided to keep it simple and go with cheese and pepperoni pizza. My daughter loved the cheese pizza. As soon as we walked in, we were greeted right away. The restaurant was very clean and they got our slices out quickly. Before leaving, I also ordered two bagels to go, and I'm really glad I did. The bagels were delicious. We will definitely be back again! read more

Times Square Pizza & Bagels - Pepperoni Pizza slice - Pizza Near Me - Temecula, California

See all

I've never really been a fan of NY style pizza, but that all changed this weekend when we stopped in for this pizza. I was blown away on how flavorful the sauce was, how fresh the ingredients were, and the crust... Dammmm!!!!! That crust was so good. It was light, and when you got to the end it was crispy. Each slice was such a great size and the toppings come perfectly distributed. We ordered a pepperoni, a supreme, and 1 slice of Margarita (which was my favorite.). When we come back to Temecula, this will be our go to now. The staff are also so amazing. They're all so friendly and had some good tunes playing. You can see the reaction of other customers who are eating there. They love this pizza, and the love the atmosphere there. It's what imagine a local NY pizza parlor would be like. Thanks for a great dinner and making us feel welcomed! read more

See all

Great selection of delicious pizza choices, bagels, calzones, salads and even 5" chocolate chip cookies! Yummmmm! Their two slice pizza & drink is what has us coming on the regular! read more

Times Square Pizza & Bagels - Great selection of delicious pizza choices, bagels, calzones, salads and even 5" chocolate chip cookies! Yummmmm! - Pizza Near Me - Temecula, California

See all

People hyping as the closest to an authentic NY pizza place and I guess I have to agree! They do have one,if not the tastiest pizza in town. My son who loves pizza loved it more than his usual pizza spots. Highly recommended! read more

Times Square Pizza & Bagels - Doing a double slice pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Temecula, California

See all

The staff was patient with me my first time here, as I tried to figure out exactly what I wanted to order. They offer pizza by the slice, and you can see which are available as soon as you walk in. I tried the Margherita and Spicy Pig slices, along with a 3 piece garlic knots. Both slices were delicious and still nice and warm when I got them back to my hotel. The location is a little small. It is a good vibe though, and seemed to be a little busy when I walked in. Good slices, friendly staff, good vibes. read more

Times Square Pizza & Bagels - Spicy Pig, Margherita, Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - Temecula, California

Delicious every time. They also have excellent customer service. The pizza is large and crispy, ranch is amazing, and we also love the wings! Easy going spot that is reliable. Our go too! read more

The good.. pizza arrived on time. The not so good. Pizza was not hot at all. Not many toppings. Crust was limp. I prefer a little crunch to mine. There was too much tomato sauce... It was very thick which I've never seen pizza like that before. Antipasto salad was just blah. No peppercinis, not much meat. I didn't like the cheese they used, it was bland. The artichoke hearts were very hard so I couldn't eat them. I've had much better. For what we paid, I feel it was a very lackluster meal. Sorry, wish I had a better review. read more

What an amazing pizza place! The pizza was absolutely delicious, the ingredients tasted so fresh, and every employee was incredibly sweet and welcoming. The owner was right there singing while making pizzas, which was so fun and refreshing to see...it gave the restaurant such a warm, authentic atmosphere! If you're in Temecula, you NEED to try Times Square Pizza & Bagel. The food, service, and entire experience were wonderful. We will definitely be back! read more

The service was great, the ladies offered good recommendations even though I'm sure they all taste good. They bake everything from scratch everyday! Great service, food is amazing with fresh ingredients, the place is clean and has a great home town relaxing vibe! Oh, and they have a yummy chocolate chip cookie, they warm it up for you. read more

I ordered today using the app on the website and the experience I just had was very bad. First, the delivery took a very long time through the 3rd party service that is used to deliver food. Had to call the driver and the company for them to update me on where the food was. When the food came in I was not sure why the large pizza had thin crust. I ordered a large pizza. I also ordered a medium pizza and that one looked how it should with the crust. I called the store and the associate told me that this happens a lot with the ordering app where they don't have a medium pizza in regular dough it's only gluten free dough. I asked if I could return to get an extra large regular pizza and the associate was pretty rude and told me yes as long as I pay for it. I will not go here again. I like to support good small businesses around here but only if they are a good small business. read more

Why is it I never knew Times Square existed until just a few days ago? I was tasked to pick up bagels for a small group of us. Times Square came up as being the closest place to me and with high ratings. I walked in, picked from their display case and my task of bagel picker upper was completed. Very good freshly baked bagels! The next morning we enjoyed our bagels topped cream cheese and paired with a cup of coffee. Tip: if you need more than a few bagels, call ahead and preorder to make sure they have enough for you. read more

Wings so good (if you like them crispy ask ahead of time)! Pizza crunchy and soft all at once don't know how else to explain (sausage on the meats lovers is so tasty)! Bagels delish! The garlic knots are a must have! All very delicious! Staff is friendly, such a nice atmosphere. read more

Times Square Pizza & Bagels - Pizza Near Me - Temecula, California

Great food and service a hidden gem Temecula worth stopping by... I love a pumpkin bagels with cream cheese and oh my God the garlic knots are absolutely delicious read more

Very good quality food. Perfect ratio On the pizza. I love the classic little seasoned croutons on the ceasar salad. Salad dressing very tasty. Cheesecake very good as well. Probably ordered from NY which is the move to make. Very friendly staff and great atmosphere counter service pizza place. read more

Times Square Pizza & Bagels - Cheesecake - Pizza Near Me - Temecula, California

See all

A friend recommended this place, so maybe we just caught an off night. Unfortunately, the pizza we picked up was the greasiest and coldest I've ever had. It was scheduled to be ready at 5:26, we arrived at 5:32, and got home 12 minutes later -- yet it was colder than room temperature and greasier than a cheap Costco slice. It also made both my wife and me sick, and it was the only thing we had eaten in common that day. On the positive side, the staff were friendly, and the ambiance inside was warm, though the space is small and the signage could be clearer. Overall, I wish the food matched the kindness of the people working there. read more

Thin pizza,crispy bbq wings. Such a good combination. Love this place. The Caesar salad is also good read more

See all

Wow, NYC got transformed to a Pacific City. Walk in and see the fresh pie, thin crust of course. Never mind the ambiance it doesn't matter when it comes to taste. I can't tell you which one to get. But I will guarantee one thing. You will buy another slice. They do the XL diameter and serve it by the slice. It crust is re- toasted at high temp for a minute. I'm going to guess the guy is from NYC. This due to the sauce. Tangy, slightly sweet, thick, smooth, evenly placed but all the way to the edge! Go! Do it! Can you tell I'm hyped about this place in a little strip mall? read more

Ordered 18" Margherita pizza before with no issues. Fresh, hot, tasty. This last time I ordered it for pick up and the crust was hard and you could tell it was reheated and had been sitting for quite some time. it was sitting on top of the oven when I arrived, but I didn't think to open the box to look at it. When I opened the box I could tell right away it was a reheated pizza. Not cool to pay $40 for a pizza that was not fresh! Boo! read more

I have only been here once for a bagel lox; it was okay. Wayyyy too much cream cheese and the salmon was not as fresh as I'm accustomed to on the east coast; especially NEW YORK! Came today to try the pizza. The "big girl" (I'm fluffy too so I can say this) had several opportunities to tell me that they had a 2 slice special with drink for $10.99. She NEVER ONCE offered. Then she made sure when she delivered the semi-warm slices to my table that I phad to PAY before I could take a bite. Good thing as when I bit into the cold, chewy dough and the tasteless toppings I was saddened. :( Sadder still was hearing the folk that walked in to order and was told about the 2-slice/drink special. Here I am eating 2 miserable slices, no drink for $12.94!! Remember Bongioirno's (sp?j of Temecula? They are now UPPER EAST SLICE. Now that's GENUINE, AUTHENTJC NY pizza‼. The owners are originally from Catskills, New York. read more

Times Square Pizza & Bagels - NY BAGEL LOX - Pizza Near Me - Temecula, California

This was my first time here. The staff was really friendly. We ordered the lunch special which included to large pizza slices of your choice and a drink for $10.99. Inside they had table seating for small groups. read more

Uptown Pizza & Bagel is hands down the BEST in town!!! From the moment you walk in, Vanessa makes you feel so welcome--she's the sweetest and truly sets the tone for such a great experience. The jalapeño bagel is my absolute favorite (perfect little kick ), and the white pie is SO good... but honestly, you can't go wrong with anything on the menu. And don't even get me started on the cheesecake--OMG it's a must!! If you haven't been yet, you're seriously missing out! read more

I've been to so many differ pizza places and this place does it RIGHT! They have a deal with two slices and a drink for only 12 bucks and their slice selection is amazing so many different pies to choose from and they all look delicious. The service was fast and friendly too, I only visited for a break during work hours but I'll definitely be coming back any time I'm in the area ! read more

Super authentic nyc shop pizza is good and bagels are great as well . Just a little flop but good undercarriage. 7.8/10 one bite score

First time here from LA and I will be stopping by every time I come visit my family in Temecula. Glad to discover Times Square pizza & Bagels. Pizza and wings are very good! One of the best I've ever had ( and I l've eaten a lot pizza and wings with beer while watching sports). Great and fast service. Cashier (forgot her name) was very helpful and nice. We will definitely try out the bagels as well next time. read more

See all

Been here many times, pizza and bagels are fine. Added a cookie to my bagels cause why not, but checked what one was in bag in aluminum foil because I had thought there were two types while still at the register, but turns out it was burnt or regular. I asked her if I could switch it out and she said no cause I touched it (aluminum foil) but is right since you can't take food in. Solution if I wanted a non-burnt cookie was to purchase another one which I did. Picture attached. You can tell what a burnt cookie is. I thought it was double chocolate or something. Basic food service and customer service if someone spends over $25 don't pass something burnt off and then say basically, "you touched no take backs". Won't be back, not big deal, just principle of it all. read more

Times Square Pizza & Bagels - Both regular choco chip cookie.... One obviously burnt. - Pizza Near Me - Temecula, California

First time and it was I went in for lunch I wanted a pizza and saw this place sold by the slice. I will be coming back. Staff was super nice and place sure nice as well. read more

Times Square Pizza & Bagels - Lunch special! - Pizza Near Me - Temecula, California

Food great, fresh and lots of toppings per selection. Great price and the staff is friendly. Ordered the 18 pizza with 3 toppings and was not disappointed. read more

No flavor whatsoever. Wouldn't be returning to this location. After two slices, I still felt extremely hungry. All stars deducted. read more

Times Square Pizza & Bagels - Pizza Near Me - Temecula, California

See all

Do they boil their bagels before baking or do they just bake them into its case you have round bread?

EVERYTHING! You're instantly greeted when entering by everyone working! I love that I can pick from a variety of different slices! And honestly can't wait to come back for a bagel and salad and the turkey club! read more

Times Square Pizza & Bagels - Pizza Near Me - Temecula, California

Is the flavor in the building with us?? NY style my arse. Do they own a salt shaker?? This was the most bland flavorless pizza ever. Just nasty.. no way this is how pizza tastes in NY. As a Chicagoan, I give this a thumbs down! Never again! Eeeyuck! read more

$12 dollars for two slices or $8 a Alice this place use to be two slices for $8 such a joke don't waste your money lol

We went yesterday to try Temeculas Best Pizza.... Absolutely terrible is an understatement. Nothing wrong with the employees, the pizza itself had to be the most tasteless thing I've eaten in years. I had to look up if this was the only pizza place that entered this competition because that's what it seems like. If this recieved first place I can't imagine the other places in the area. Again nothing wrong with the cleanliness or employees that was all fine, the pizza itself is just definitely worth not even looking in this direction when you're hungry. Try little Cesar's instead you'll save money plus better tasting by miles. 1 star only because employees were nice. 0 stars otherwise read more