Had a friend recommend this place. I decided to try this on our anniversary. From start to finish this place didn't disappoint. Notified them of certain food allergies and they were very attentive and polite to accommodate. Service was fast and very friendly. Food came out one after another, apps, soups, salads then main course. Sorry it took this long to find this place but will definitely be going back. If you haven't already tried this place WHAT ARE YOU WAITING FOR?? Give it a try. read more

TIMELESS TAVERN - Blackberry roasted duck - Seafood Near Me - Northville, New York

See all

Very friendly staff, good food! The menu offered smaller or regular size portions which was great!

Decent food.. varied menu..nice ambiance.. good vibe ~drawbacks... lighting is so dark you have trouble seeing what you are eating. Asked that they turn the lights up a bit and was ignored. I have a tough time being "nickeled and dimed" to death also.. $5 for a side salad .. $2 extra for soup.."this is an up charge .... and no substitutes .. what if I'm on a special diet or allergic ‍ All in all a good place.. not inexpensive.. just be aware. read more

This is my new favorite place. If my wife is to be believed, I'm a bit of a food snob. Incredibly good-looking and flawless otherwise (that's her talking, not me), but she thinks I can be a little judgmental when it comes to food. And I suppose she's right about that (and how I'm essentially perfect otherwise). Let me be clear though: I don't need fancy fare, although I've eaten a lot of it. We just all have to eat every day, and I'd rather have tasty things to eat than the alternative. And if I'm being honest, my expectations were not super high for Timeless Tavern, not because of anything they've done, but because in my experience, restaurants can be hit or miss in Hamilton County. Timeless Tavern is a hit. This joint is everything I wanted. We spent the day tearing up floors, and we were tired and hungry and just looking for a good, hearty meal. That's what you can get here. A really good portion of delicious food, at a good price, from good people. Our server Becky was outstanding. She was welcoming and warm, and she led us to the right things on the menu: steaks. It seems like what they do best here, and we went for the garlic sirloin, the Delmonico, and for me, the chocolate, balsamic, and bleu cheese covered NY strip. Yeah, it sounds a little weird, but I felt like you don't put something like that on the menu unless you know it's good, and it was. The steaks were cooked properly, seasoned properly, and honestly a pretty massive portion as well. The menu said 16 oz, I wouldn't be surprised if it was more. I can't remember the last time I didn't finish a meal, but I took a little bit of it home for a snack later on. That's probably because they also come with soup and salad, which leads me to another reason Timeless Tavern is my new favorite place: The Chicken Riggy. It's a tomato-based, creamy, hearty chicken soup with rigatoni in there, and I was legitimately blown away by how tasty it was. As soon as I had a bite, I knew we'd be coming back here whenever we're in town. It was rich, and flavorful, and unexpected. Also, I absolutely love that almost all the salad dressings are homemade. Parmesan peppercorn? I'll always get that. I've written a lot here, but the moral of the story is that I love this place. The food is great, the people are great, and it seems like a fun and lively spot to just come for a drink if you aren't hungry. Best of all, the prices are super reasonable. Looking forward to when we're back in town, and I'm bringing the whole family. read more

See all

Good overall menu but their pork osso buco served over pasta is unbelievable! I get it every time!

Our waitress was so nice and helpful, oysters were delicious This is my second time here always consistent service and food delicious '! I will be back soon! read more

Multiple Errors on bill, owner made a huge scene after we complained so we just paid and left , will not go back

We unsuspectedly wandered into one of the best dinners we've had in 20 years. Why you ask. All of it - from the minute we walked in we were greeted and seated in a polite, professional and uplifting manner. The host was an older man and cracked a funny joke that made us all laugh. The waiter, also a man, made suggestions, checked in and overall did a perfect job. The food was EXCELLENT. I think the owner popped over to check on us too. It was simply a great night. THANK YOU! read more

TIMELESS TAVERN - Enjoying dinner. - Seafood Near Me - Northville, New York

Been coming here for 4 years or more and on point every time. Amazing service and food. Well tonight was such a disappointment...started with their special crab cakes. They came out like hockey pucks. Returned them which I never do. I suck it up and eat them. These were inedible. Second batch came out. A little better but ate the interior and left the less slightly burnt crust. Next was salad. Always fresh and amazing but what we received was wilted lettuce. Blue cheese was best part of the plate. I do have to say my chocolate balsamic blue cheese strip steak was very good paired with 2 little bland fingerling potatoes and crunchy green beans. Bread was over toasted but butter was good. Their prime rib is not the same!! All I will say. No pics sorry as I wasn't going to write a review but feel I had to. read more

To be honest, the food is almost always good, especially steaks. . The ownership is on the rude side. If you call to make reservations anytime in the Summer, they kinda make fun of you for not knowing that they are always busy and have a " I can't believe you even called us" attitude. read more

The homemade cucumber dill dressing was delicious! The service was prompt and very friendly. The ambiance is rustic and Adirondack without being overly woodsy. I loved it! The seafood bisque was delicious. However I was not a big fan of the chocolate balsamic strip steak. The steak is great and the added flavors were too much. I can't wait to return and order something else! read more

TIMELESS TAVERN - Salad with Cucumber Dill dressing - Seafood Near Me - Northville, New York

See all

Charming restaurant with really good food. Menu is typical American done well. Nice drive too!

Great food very consistent friendly staff quick service comfortable atmosphere. Great prices amd a lot of food for the money

Food was great as was the service we received. We will definitely be regulars! We will bring our friends when they come from out of town

Great food and service in a nice setting. Everyone enjoyed their food! The menu was well-rounded and all was delicious.

Always a welcoming place! Excellent service! The meatloaf sandwich was fabulous!! Strip steak cooked perfectly!! Chicken parmigiana delicious & brought the extra home ! Blue crumb pie with ice cream the best!! Carrie a great server!! read more

A "feels just right" place. Food, ambiance, service all really fine. This place is such a comfortable fit. Well worth seeking out.

The Timeless Tavern is a short trip from Sacandaga lake in a small town called Northville. Unless you are a local or vacationer it is highly unlikely you would know the spot or be anywhere near this restaurant. There is very poor cell service so it is possible you won't read this review without Wifi! Despite what I mentioned above this restaurant is decent and must be a huge hit with the locals. They had some decent beer on tap and an impressive list of dishes. Duck, pasta, and a monster cut of prime rib. A real meal can be had. I dined with a large party and people were generally impressed. I ordered an Adirondacker which was a roast beef panini with bacon and horseradish sauce. Nice bread. The beef was slightly dry so I asked for a side of au jus which helped. I ordered a side salad with parm peppercorn dressing which was kind of odd. This would be a cool place to order some apps and have a beer. I ordered the stuffed jalapenos which were tasty (more than 4 seemed appropriate for the price). I have also had the wings which are excellent and they offer a very unique flavor, honey jalapeno. Definitely check these out. A nice place in an area of NY that is definitely timeless. When I visit friends on the lake this is a spot that will continue to get our business. read more

See all

Great food and service! On a Wednesday night in the middle of February, the place was jumping! Wife had the ravioli and I had a burger.

Disappointed in the treatment we received while attempting to have a nice dinner. The drink I asked for was sent back 2 times as was made incorrectly . The managements decision to not comp my incorrect drink the first time I asked them to, made me suspicious of their practices in the kitchen and wary of eating the food. It was a very uncomfortable experience fed the $100 dinner to my pigs . The waitress was lovely. Management not so. read more

What a great place. Service is perfect. Get the delmonico- the flavor is unreal. The dessert selection is extensive, but gotta start with the tollhouse pie ! read more

Consistent excellent food & service. Definitely restaurant to go to when in Northville or surrounding area.

Great drinks great food .... Entrees come with both soup and salad and their soups are amazing. We highly recommend timeless tavern !!

Thank you Tom &Lisa for an amazing dinner on Saturday night. The staff was very attentive and the food was perfect. The veal francais was cooked perfectly and came out at the perfect temperature again thank you for what you do. The steak from the bar menu was flavorful and cooked to perfection thank you again. read more

I waited a year to check this place out so we made a birthday reservation and I was so excited! Normally I order a prime rib when I go out but everyone told me get there steak best ever so I ordered a steak and it was gorgeous this huge hunk of meat but it was so over cooked I was not impressed esp when I said medium on my steak and the vegetables where barley cooked green beans shouldn't be crunchy. I feel we were rushed by our waitress with the food and she kept asking if we were done and needed boxes like can we just eat please maybe she was new? We did order these fried mozzarella balls with there raspberry sauce they were delicious but when she went to bag them up she tossed the raspberry sauce and I kept asking for more to go and she had attitude and also said the cook won't allow anymore they need it so that was another disappointment I mean who does that it was maybe a tbsp? Anyways once we got home that night and for a few days after we both were very sick with stomach issues and come to find out they closed the restaurant from being sick. Was it the food idk maybe it's just a place for small town people but my experience sucked we won't be going there again read more

We held a private event at Timeless Tavern. Food - exceptional. Service - outstanding. Chicken Francais, Prime Rib and Penne Ala Vodka can rival any NYC midtown restaurant. If in the area make sure to stop here. read more

We had been wanting to visit after other family and friends had raved about this place. It did not disappoint. Such a quaint rustic tavern. Very comfy and inviting. The host was a perfect gentleman that brought us to our seat. We were quickly introduced to our very attentive, sweet waitress. We started with grilled clams as our app that were so buttery and garlicky!!! Next we were each brought a cup of seafood chowder. So chunky, tons of seafood, slightly peppery but so creamy and homemade exuded from this soup. Next was a fresh side salad. Then onto our main entrees. I had the chocolate balsamic strip and my husband the Delmonico. There was enough beef between the two meals to literally feed a table of ten!!! Cooked to perfection!!!! The sides of potatoe, fries, green beans and carrots were a perfect pairing!!! We will be eating leftovers for a few days, but cannot wait to go back!!! Highly recommend the trip to Northville for this amazing experience! A shared dessert and a much needed walk in the lakefront park out back was a wonderful ending to our 33 year Anniversary dinner outing!!! read more

Always have had a good meal and excellent service here. Best to call for reservations!

What a great place. Friendly staff and great food, the kids didn't even complain and that's a tough sell. The prime rib was a bit on the spendy side but for the portion you receive it's more than fair. Would've liked some spicier horseradish but the place was great. Clam chowder had great consistency and our party of 6 had zero complaints. Call for reservations read more

Their food is always great! From sit down strip steak dinner to pick up steak or chicken Caesar salad to chicken wings and a Ganesh of football on the big screen,it's always a nice experience,and friendly staff. read more

Being a local, I can honestly say Timeless ranks at the top of places to dine in the area. They are the trifecta - excellent food, service, & value. You will not be disappointed. read more

Food was delicious and staff were very welcoming and friendly on a cold snowy night! Would definitely go back again.

We needed a place to spend a 2 nights stay.. the room was perfect for us, very very clean and the owner helped us with our luggage to our room..the price was very reasonable for us..I would definately stay here again.. thank you timeless tavern the shepherds read more

fast service great food always coming back to see if you need anything have no complaints

Excellent dinner tonight. Prime rib is a very large portion of at least 20 oz boneless. Blackened chicken salad and a salmon dinner..all delicious. We finished with a chocolate chip cookie and ice cream..yummy!!! I would recommend dinner here for a nice experience and super friendly staff. read more

It was surprising to get quality food in a small town. The service and preparation of the food and drink is second to no one in the Northville region. I would recommend this restaurant to friends, however I recommend that reservations are made in advance. read more

Located right on Main street, totally unassuming place! Man and i thought it was just a little tavern! But inside it was a eclectically well decorated restaurant! I loved the cozy clean and up to date ambience! Food was perfect, farm fresh green beans and carrot slices done to perfection ! I ate them all, home made mashed potatoes and salad dressings were the best I've had in a long time!! They also offer homemade desserts!! My Jack Daniel's glazed pork chops were scrumptious!!!! Hubby had sliced garlic sirloin served on homemade garlic bread! He ate it all!! He also enjoyed his seafood chowder! Which had lots of seafood in one cup of soup!! Very affordable and the service was spot on! Very friendly staff!!!! Great ride from our Mayfield camp!! We found another hidden gem in Northville!!!! read more

TIMELESS TAVERN - a group of people sitting at a table - Seafood Near Me - Northville, New York

Fantastic experience! Great service and the food was top quality. Delmonico steak was the best steak I have had in years, and I travel the world for work. Mediterranean chicken was excellent, as was the veal with spinach and three cheeses. Great find in the town of Northville. read more

The best place to eat in all of Sacandaga. Fresh homemade food with daily specials. Friendly wait staff and bartender make this the summer place to be. If I could give them 10 stars I would! read more

We both ordered salads. Great homemade dressing! Generous portions for the price. Location is also pretty, right by the water. Service was a little lacking but otherwise great! read more