I was looking for something between work and the hotel awhile I was here in the area. Tiffany's looked like a nice local restaurant that did field to Fork. I was greeted as soon as I entered and seated. The lighting in the booth was at a comfortable brightness and all was clean. The staff is friendly and had lots of info on the menu. I love a French Onion soup so that was what I ordered for my appetizer. For me the French Onion delivered in flavor. The Bourbon and the Gruyère cheese were delicious. For my main course I decided on Tiffany's style Clams with a loaf of peasant bread. The rich garlic source on the clams were delish for me and I love a fresh baked loaf of bread. Great stop for dinner! read more

Tiffany's Tap & Grill - Tiffany's Clams with a loaf of peasant Bread. - New American Near Me - Eynon, Pennsylvania

The owner (Mrs) is obnoxious and treated us terribly. When we told our waitress our food was cold the owner came over to our table and scolded us for "scaring " the waitress. Two women who complained about cold food? How is that scary? We didn't threaten her we just told her. The owner told us that she wouldn't put her waitress through any more terror and claimed our table. She then went on to ignore us for the rest of the night. We have never been back and prior to that we were frequent customers. read more

All the elements are in place here. Social distancing, masks must be worn upon entering etc. It's been a while since I've been here and Alex, our server, was assigned to our table. Drinks, starters and entrees and even conversation are your typical fare. A portobello mushroom and Sesami Ahi Tuna with a passion fruit cocktail hit the spot. Even the owner came over and bid my friend a "welcome back" hello. Not rushed, and a quiet atmosphere with background music made it an enjoyable evening. read more

Tiffany's Tap & Grill - a margarita in a glass - New American Near Me - Eynon, Pennsylvania

See all

Great service, our waiter was good, Food is ok, nothing blew me away. I didn't walk out thinking wow that was excellent. It was just ok. I had the veal Sinatra, if you look at the photo, between the sauce and the water from the veggies it was a wet soggy plate. Veggies zero flavor ( no salt what so ever. If your not going to put salt and pepper on the tables you better make sure you season everything. My son had the crab cakes, just ok. I had a wasabi shrimp appetizer very good, however you get like 8 tiny shrimps . My son had the boneless buffalo bits, they were excellent. Like I said it's just an ok place, I can take it or leave it. read more

Tiffany's Tap & Grill - Crab cakes and veal Sinatra. - New American Near Me - Eynon, Pennsylvania

See all

Always a fun night out at Tiffany's! You can't go wrong with any of the appetizers. I recommend the Wasabi Shrimp. Bourbon Street Chicken is one of my favorite dishes, but sometimes can't pass up on their creative nightly specials. Save room for dessert, or at least share one. Soooo good. Service is always great, and the staff and owners are so friendly and welcoming. They also have a separate room in the back for private gatherings and plenty of parking. read more

Excellent food and service will be coming back again and again. Nice environment and plenty of parking.

4 for service, but some of the dishes I used to order back in the day have changed. I used to love the penne rústica, until they changed the noodle to the spiral ones. It definitely doesn't compare. I thought the Alfredo dish lacked flavor and was watery. I had too as A LOT of salt, but the blacken chicken I added to it was on point. The shrimp wasabi last 2 starts for me. I think the shrimp are not quite cooked enough and could use additional sauce so I'll probably order extra next time... because no matter what, I always seem to order this appetizer. The apple nut salad was also on point. I couldn't eat it all with all the items that were about to hit the table on this Mother's Day. Oh, speaking of... My mom got the special... which was an eggplant park and she LOVED it. I'm looking forward to stepping outside the box next time and finally trying some new things. Oh... I can't believe I forgot... they have the best French Onion soup I ever had. Wish I could find the pics but they've disappeared on my phone. read more

Always great place to eat. The food is very good nice portions. The staff and owners are friendly and serve your needs as well. Try it you won't be disappointed. read more

The person who ordered the salad loved their meal. Another ordered fish stuffed with crabmeat it came with a creamy salty white sauce and matching mashed potatoes. It was not appealing to look at and too salty. Another person ordered lightly breaded chicken that was very breaded and fried. The portions were large. Expensive evening when you are not ordered booze. They tax on 20% tip automatically if they split the check for you but didn't tell us until we paid. It would be nice to know upfront. read more

Good & service is always on point. Our servers Maria & Kay were so nice and very accommodating! Love the bourbon selection and I ALWAYS get the specials the New gnocchi dish is stellar! Thank you for all that you do Celebrating 25 years in business says it all!! read more

Why on earth would anyone eat at this restaurant? The food was disgusting. I got French onion soup NOT in a crock and spilled all over the cup it was in. The blackberry ribs tasted like Heinz BBQ sauce. Mgt recognized the faults and comped the bill. All in all the experience was POOR read more

Had a wonderful dinner. The miso vegetable soup was perfect. Veal Sinatra and veal chiiprata (?) were wonderfully prepared- juicy, flavorful and nicely presented. Staff and service were warm and welcoming. Highly recommend Tiffany's! read more

Don't understand the great food reviews. Staff friendly and attentive. Nice people. But food was fair at best. Special appetizer was fried stuffed zucchini blossoms, breading was thick and greasy, when you picked it up and squeezed, oil dripped out. Flavor of cheese stuffing and marinara dip was good. Caesar salad was fresh romaine, croutons were ok, dressing good flavor. But they top with a bacon that they smoke themselves, looks like crumbled hamburger meat, no real flavor. Grilled shrimp on my salad were tasteless, small, probably frozen. Husband's had special short ribs, they were tough, short ribs should fall apart. The veggies with it were undercooked large chunks of carrot and brussels sprouts. This meal with 2 beers, was $70. Was really hoping this would become a go to place with all the good reviews. Maybe it was an off night, but not gonna risk spending that much for another poor meal. Sorry Tiffany"s. read more

Ok so we used to go here all the time. Now that I moved back. Our friends told us it's gone down hill. So we went anyway they had a pork chop special all I can say is Holly SALT!!! Everything had way too much salt!!!!! Even the pistachio cake had too much salt in the pistachio. The next table said the same thing too much salt seems like the chef has gone salt crazy. The atmosphere and service are still good. However cut down all that salt in everything.!!!! We will go again but if the food is salty as it was this time we will not go there anymore!!! Just for the record if people want salt it's on the table!!! This review hurts to have to do. This place used to be one of my favorite places to go. I hope it can be again!!! read more

Ate dinner here tonight with my wife and kids, based on the strong reviews. The food was really excellent. I had the bbq chicken special. One of the best chicken dishes Ive had in years. (Note it's a half chicken and takes a while to make.) Soup was great, mashed potatoes great. Everyone ate literally everything we ordered, even the two picky kids traded their kids meals back and forth. Would definitely eat here any time I'm in town. read more

Such a nice place. The service is very good and our waitress really took care of us. I had dinner with some colleagues; they had a black angus beef, I tried it and it was very good. I had one of their speciality that was mac and cheese and it was tasty and very well made. I am going to be back and I surely recommend it. read more

Tiffany's Tap & Grill - Black angus - New American Near Me - Eynon, Pennsylvania

See all

The best old fashioned cocktail I've ever had. The food so good, so unique and delish. Love the atmosphere and our server was so sweet. Highly recommend read more

So excited to go back to Tiffany's. We haven't been here in 3-4 years (life, kids and work gets in the way). So we book Valentine's dinner on Sunday 2/14 @ 6pm. Their hours were 4-8pm for Valentine's Day. They hyped that it was a lobster extravaganza. Lobster martini, chicken and lobster, lobster shrimp risotto. Again, we had 6pm reservations. We get here and we have menus. No mention of lobster I asked THEY FREAKING RAN OUT OF LOBSTER! Who does that? When she was telling us the specials, she said lobster and shrimp risotto. We order it and guess what she says I'm sorry we just sold the last one...so dissatisfied and disappointed. I was afraid to order anything. I tried to order chicken with asparagus with you guessed lobster. Nope. I just think if you are advertising a special you should deliver. Poor waitress has to deliver the news. We were prepared to get up and walk out. But where to go at 6pm on. . So disappointed if we were to put Tiffany's back on our go to list we will wait esp. how the cook/slash/ owner treated us. He comes over and asked how things were. I said you should not advertise for something and not have it . He told us Governor Wolf didn't shut them down. Some excuse about a press conference...blah blah blah. He did have lobster tails. Then proceeded to say he made his money. So it worked out for him. Glad the manager made all his money on his shelf life of lobster. You lost a potential good customer. Place is still the same. Dark decor. Covid precautions in order. Shields and masks used. Sanitizer available. Certainly will call ahead next time. I suggest that if they only have two lobster meals book early. Not recommend read more

Second time we have eaten here with my family when we come to town to visit and the food was amazing. Had one of the best French onion soups I have ever had and then the Beet and Blue salad was huge and awesome. NY Strip special was cooked perfect and tender and then had a slice of cake that was bigger than my head and awesome. We will be coming back next time for sure. read more

The aesthetics of Tiffany's Tap and Grill are very pleasing both inside out out. The outside and interior decorations immediately capture the eye. The owners are classically trained professionals whose purpose is to give their customers a pleasant dining experience. Staff members reflect the owners professionalism and dedication. I would heartily recommend Tiffany's for a memorable dining event. read more

Come here a few times a year. It's a nice local restaurant. With good food. Menu is small but has a little bit of everything. Chef always comes out to check on how everyone is doing. Prices aren't to bad. Staff is always very nice. They are consistently busy but never a wait. read more

Tiffany's Tap & Grill - New American Near Me - Eynon, Pennsylvania

See all

Apps are great. Love that they offer chickpea pasta for a healthier gluten free option. If you aren't gluten free I would advise you to also get the cookie! read more

First time I ever had a bad meal there was today. Steak was completely unseasoned and over done. Butternut squash ravioli was in a thin green runny sauce. Bread was not fresh. It was too dense. Salad had too much dressing. It had one slice of cucumber and one tomato. We stopped eating and took our leftovers home reluctantly and will try to salvage it tomorrow. Dessert menu hasn't changed in a long time. We used to call this old reliable but we're disappointed today. read more

Our favorite place to go on a cold night! The food is fantastic, and the wine collection is extensive. What really is wonderful is that the specials are unique and quite varied. The staff is polite and attentive. The owners are hands on and very accommodating. read more

Tiffany's Tap & Grill - New American Near Me - Eynon, Pennsylvania

We were at Tiffany's Friday night for a small retirement party and it was EXCEPTIONAL. Everyone raved about the food. We had about 10 kids for the party and the staff was so incredibly patient with us. Even the waitresses who didn't work our tables, were incredibly patient with all the kids running between tables. They let us order off the menu and everything came out incredibly fast (less than an hour for 30 people) and the food was hot and delicious. I can't say enough how incredibly impressed I was with the exceptional level of service. And the food and drinks were incredible. Excellent all around. If I could give 7 stars, I would. read more

Food was excellent great atmosphere the owners are awesome Tom and Cheryl make you feel like family beer selection was amazing so many to choose from can't wait to go back !!! read more

With all the fervor around farm to table, this is one of the only restaurants in the area that does it right. Amazingly fresh food in creative recipes. Love this place. read more

This restaurant is one of my favorite. Owners and staff are wonderful and friendly. Food is always delicious and hot out of the kitchen. Very nice wine selection. I would HIGHLY recommend for families and couples. read more

Their specials are always so good. They always seem to have a good theme going on. Great seafood and wonderfully drinks and wine. They like farm-to-table stuff - so expect the veggie to be fresh and from a local farm (of course in PA season terms). read more

This is the best food I have ever had! I recommend the French onion soup!! and the chicken with crab meat on top, yum!! Very polite staff and the setting/decor has a home like feel. Anyone traveling to PA needs to make the trip here! Traveled from MO for work, so glad I found your restaurant. read more

My parents retired from the Philly suburbs to Waymart late last year and one of the things I really thought they would miss is good food! They've tried a bunch of places in the area and often have been disappointed. I was up for a visit last weekend and my dad suggested Tiffany's. He had been once before and loved it -- and he's a picky dude! Since it was July 4 weekend we made a reservation. Boy did I feel silly when we arrived and there was no one there lol. Upon walking in I wasn't very impressed. To me, it looked just like any other bar/pub in Philly that has decent beer specials and an ok menu. I thought this would be one of those places that HAS a dining room, but no one goes just for dinner. Much to my surprise, the food was absolutely delicious!! We started out with the southwest eggrolls which were very good. The portion was somewhat small -- two eggrolls cut in halves, so four pieces for the three of us. My dad had a steak smothered in onions, some kind of sauce, and mushrooms (well he did order mushrooms but they were not included). From what I could tell it was cooked a perfect medium. He said it was delicious regardless of the missing mushrooms. His only complaint was that it was small. I'd have to agree. It looked to be around 6.5oz and the price was ~$27. My mom and I both ordered the crabcakes which were truly tasty. They were sauteed perfectly with very little filler. Every single bite had chunks of crab. The onion mashed potatoes were also very good and the vegetable medley (while somewhat small) was so fresh and perfectly cooked. The tartar sauce was homemade and you could tell. For dessert, my parents split a brownie sundae and I had the Lemon Coconut White Cake. O. M. G. It was an incredible dessert. Homemade. Airy and fresh with vibrant flavors. I was still thinking about that cake the next day. I mean wow. I had a beer and my mom had two sangrias. I believe the total was $97. For a delicious meal WITH drinks, that's really a bargain. In the city that meal would probably exceed $130. My brother is visiting from Houston this week. I told him he HAS to make mom and dad take him to Tiffany's and I plan on going back myself!! read more

Our go to place for a great meal. The food is always 10/10, their menu contains basic items mixed with some very unique.

I have been here many times and have never been disappointed but the AMAZING food that was presented to me last night is forcing me to write a review. To get right to the point, I ordered ghost pepper mango salmon off their weekly special menu. I know, ghost pepper .... I was scared too at first but it was perfectly blended in with a delicious butter mango sauce on top of a bed of rice pilaf and mixed vegetables. The salmon was crusted with a teriyaki/ginger combination and it was AWESOME. I ordered their beef satay as my appetizer and it was one of the most delicious things I have ever eaten. This is a great place to go for a laid back meal. It will be my go-to restaurant in the area when I am in need of a dependable great, meal. My only knock is the craft beer selection is somewhat limited but that is something I can easily get over. I highly recommend trying Tiffany's if you haven't yet! (No complaint about service but I have never been there during a typical rush). Enjoy! read more

We order from Tiffany's weekly! Never dissatisfied! The food is always fresh and delicious! The desserts are homemade and to die for!!

I have been to this place about 4-5 times. The first two times everything was great and i couldn't wait to go back. Unfortunately i cannot say that anymore because the last three times i went there the food was mediocre. I ordered a NY Strip steak and i got something that looked more like a roast beef. I had asked the waitress for med/well but got med/rare instead and top it all the steak was cold. VERY DISAPPOINTED. we asked for extra veg instead of fries or mashed and we got veg that looked more like a garnish. We were wondering what if we didn't ask for extra veg we would have gotten A string bean and two slices of carrot. We drove 45 mins to eat at this place...what a waste of time and money. Don't think i will go back there. The owner or the chef comes around to ask how was the food i wish i could be honest with him but my partner said not to say anything. He also looked like he was in his pajamas. read more

Tonights Happy Hour "Build Your Own Burger" was delicious. I had the mushroom Swiss and am very happy I did. We arrived at 5 pm and it got busy as we ate. read more

My fiancé and I along with 14 close friends celebrated her 28th Birthday at Tiffany's. I'm glad we made the choice to celebrate there!! Everything was PERFECT! Food was perfect! Service was perfect! The entire staff was professional and extremely friendly!! I would highly recommend this restaurant to everyone! We will defiantly return! read more

I went here tonight with my boyfriend, dad, and step-mom. My step-mom suggested Tiffany's when I offered to take her out for her birthday. I had never been here before and she said it had been about 10 years since her last visit. I had the Ruby Red Mule, Whipped Ricotta appetizer, and Ahi Tacos. I can't remember the last time I've had a meal this fresh and wonderful! Everything was delicious and none of it felt over-processed or heavy. The others in my party had the Caesar salad with chicken, 14oz. Porterhouse Steak special, and the pasta special (can't remember the name but it had pistachio pesto and smelled amazing!). Everyone left with clean plates, a smile on their face, and plans to come back soon! read more

Horrible service to start out. I went with my fiancw and two children. He ordered steak medium rare and it was completely rare to start off, everything the waitress put on the table was aggressively as if slamming it. Even my 4 year old asked why she "made a loud noise with the plate". Next we were given dry carrots and zucchini as a side with our steak and it was as if it came from a frozen steamed bag. Next off there was a business party next to us in which once they came out waitress immediately ignored us and we weren't a priority anymore. We had finished our meals for a full 15 minutes before she decided to acknowledge us even after looking my fiancé in the eyes multiple times clearly seeing we were finished. In total it's a pretty pricy place which we wouldn't of minded if the service and food were up to par with the price! Better off going to Texas Roadhouse and pretty upset we opted not to. Again not worth the money , and they need to not judge and assume a person can't afford to eat somewhere because we have tattoos and piercings you ma'am missed out on a great tip being that we usually give Texas Roadhouse 30-40$ tips because they're just that great! read more

I've always loved Tiffany's. The food is great! However the last couple of times I have gone, the portion sizes have shrunk and the prices have risen. I don't like paying $20 for a dinner and then still leaving hungry! I do recommend the brussel sprout appetizer, it's amazing! They're shaved and drizzled in balsamic. SO GOOD! read more