Delightful, prompt, fresh and delicious. These cash-only fabulous duster have lunch dialed in. Fresh sammiches made with love (that's a quote)! $14 for any sammich on the menu with a bag of chips for lunch as of 27 SEPT 2023. Come out and help us support local women owner small businesses! We got the Twisted Sister and Brigid Beachin'. Both were outstanding! read more

Three Sisters - Truly cannot make a bad selection. All prepared fresh on the daily! - Sandwiches Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

Enjoyed a Sunday evening dinner from the raw Crudo and Grill menu. Gourmet presentation. They advertise BYOB but the the corking fees were extremely excessive. $32 for wine and $25 for beer. They really need to rethink this. read more

Three Sisters - Dinner menu - Sandwiches Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

They're doing God's work. My friend and I have traveled land and sea just for their perfectly crafted sandwiches. When the food arrives at the table we go completely silent to allow no distraction from savoring every particle of flavor. If I was on death row I would ask for a twisted sister, drink and cookie and I could die happy. read more

Great casual environment, very quiet. Sandwich was excellent, I would definitely come back again for it. Very fresh and tasty. Only downside for this restaurant is that they have very short hours so it becomes packed quickly. Make sure to come early so you can be at the front of the line. read more

Three Sisters - Brigid's Beachin - Sandwiches Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

Had the Hippie Sister and it was very good. Quick service and a nice ambiance in the picnic area behind the building. Might like to check out the outside cooking area sometime. Looked very interesting! Highly recommend 3 sisters for lunch on the island. It's a bit out of the way so you may need to plan to be there during their limited hours or you could easily miss it! read more

AMAZING! Best sandwiches i've had in a LONG time! They have the cutest outdoor seating and an awesome vibe. The sandwiches were delicious (especially the twisted)... but nothing beats those chocolate chip cookies!! Super pleasant out front taking our order and we didn't wait long for sandwiches at all read more

Three Sisters - picnic tables under a yellow shade - Sandwiches Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

See all

It's been several years since I've been to Block Island, but I wanted to make a point of it to go to Three Sisters for lunch which I always enjoyed in the past. It is just a shame what they have done to the place. Instead of creative meals, they serve primarily sandwiches. My selection was an uninspired tuna sandwich which I had as a wrap. Once you realize that you've made a mistake, you can't go back. I should have gone elsewhere. It just was not very good. All of their selections were for $15. The person who took our order seemed disinterested in taking our order, but it may have just been shyness. With so many good places to eat on Block Island, this is now a place I won't return to. read more

Three Sisters is a reliable and delicious local spot that's been around for 25 years! The best place for lunch on the island, and reasonably priced too. I love to support small family businesses like Three Sisters, and enjoy a quick lunch in their yard or takeout to enjoy on the beach. Great cookies too!! read more

Delicious sandwiches Impolite service Pseudo-bohemian atmosphere Minuscule. Busy, with slow service. Tasty food. Outdoor seating to service a quick pass-through of a kitchen/service-counter. The dining room is essentially a back lawn and picnic area behind the tiny structure that houses the operation. I was one of more than a handful of people who wandered out of the ordering line muttering under their breath "what's wrong with THEM?" after getting treated curtly for no apparent reason. I have no need for a return visit after the first impression. Delicious is fine, but with all else in the equation, whatever to this place. read more

Three Sisters - An example of your lunch. - Sandwiches Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

See all

This place is a quaint sandwich shop. The menu is fairly large since subs are easy to make. There is outdoor seating, and a bike rack. It tends to get very crowded from tourists (like me) and will quickly run out of seating. The menu did not have prices on it, despite all the subs costing the same. Our group ordered our food and payed afterwards. Not the way to go, it forces you to have to wait in a long line. I really wanted to give it a 4 but the high price for such a small sub and the slow service made me drop to a 3. read more

Small nice shack with plenty of food options that are all good. Lots of outside seating but no inside seating and they also only take cash. Hours are a bit iffy but overall a good place to eat lunch. Line takes forever and is not efficient at all especially with short hours. read more

We ate outside on a Sat evening while enjoying live music from Lucas Neil, a local musician. The food, ambiance and entertainment were terrific. The serving staff was friendly and helpful. No liquor license but you can BYOB- they helpfully provided a wine opener and glasses. We had the open face kale / beets / some kind of creamy spread sandwich (so yummy!) and another with crab. Go here- you won't be disappointed! read more

Good grief! Half an hour to get a sandwich! The warning was 20 people waiting for food, 2 people eating when I arrived. I have been here before, and the food is great! seems ridiculous that it takes so long. It does not help that their friends keep sticking their heads in the back door to socialize.... read more

Nice little wraps and sandwich shop , good food, nice friendly staff , total recommend for people at block island for vacation trip .

Cash only. There is NO indication of this until you go to pay and suddenly they won't let you have your food. Rude. No sympathy for a diabetic potential customer visiting the island. I am on a set schedule and wasting my time could lead to a hypoglycemic emergency. Signs need to be placed in clearly visible areas before a potential customer even picks up a menu. They seemed willing to make an exception to let me pay later (I have no idea what that was about....) until they found out I was touring and would only be around for a short time. Sadly they were one of few establishments open due to off season. I cannot and will never be able to review the quality of the food because I will never step foot in here again. If I were to base my experience on Block Island off this place I'd never come back. But you can guarantee if my family comes back at any point in time, we'd rather go hungry than give our money to rude people, cash or not. Consider updating your archaic methods to accommodate all customers as many vacationers do not carry cash and do not know your local policy. read more

The owner threw change into my moms face. How pathetic is your life that you make mediocre sandwiches like your life depends on it, and you can't even do that right? The food was ok, but bland. Orders were incorrect, but the customer couldn't possibly be right. The seating is just crappy picnic tables. The ordering system is atrocious. If I was an old lady on an island making boring sandwiches, I'd probably hate my life too. However, I don't think I could ever throw money into someone's face .. especially change from something they just purchased from me. Embarrassing. If they didn't have the luxury of an island location with unknowing tourists, they'd never make it. Don't waste your money here. OH and when they brought out our corrected sandwich the owner threw it on the table THREW IT.. and said "don't come back here" or something stupid. I'm still living with the second hand embarrassment. read more

As a native New Yorker, I take my corned beef sandwiches seriously; don't change it and please don't try to reinvent it. When I started commuting to Philadelphia, before I was informed about 4th Street Deli, I was in desperate need of a corned beef sandwich. My co-workers suggested a few sandwich places that served Reubens. It was served with russian dressing and coleslaw. I am used to sauerkraut on my reubens but hell...I decided to give it a shot. It was one of the worse decisions I ever made. I was hanging with the family July 3 on Block Island. I read about Three Sisters on Yelp and decided to give it a try. A nice10-15 minute walk from the beach, we arrived at Three Sisters. It's a small cottage with picnic tables in the back. With so many options on the menu I decided to go out on a limb and order the McSister. It is a lean corned beef sandwich with Swiss cheese, Russian dressing and coleslaw on a sub roll. Swiss cheese is one of my lease favorites, and like I said earlier, I am very particular with my corned beef sandwiches. I am not sure what they are doing in the city of brotherly love, but they need to have a chat with the ladies of Three Sisters. There was nothing over the top about it, but that was pretty good sandwich. My wife's sandwich, the Twisted Sister, was pretty and the other members ordered the Big Sister, which looked pretty appetizing as well. All sandwiches are served with a bag of potato chips. If you are on Block Island during the summer and in search of a light lunch that is going to satisfy your hunger, then Three Sisters is your place. read more

Three Sisters - Sandwiches Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

See all

One of my favorite places for a tasty beach lunch on-the-go! I put my order in and then grab my other beach essentials so the timing is always perfect. Most of all... I like the sassy owner - she adds some fun character to the day. Can you imagine what it must be like running a small business (and I mean physically small too... there's not a lot of room in that cottage) with a bunch of entitled tourists hooting and hollering at you? I've seen people wander in (from walking in the MIDDLE of the street mind you) and stand inside while they stare, mouth agape, at the simple (but delicious!) menu. It's not hieroglyphics folks, keep it moving! Garner some fortitude, place your order, wait your turn, and get to the ocean before you melt snowflakes! read more

Although the sandwich was good- the customer service was terrible. The owner was so rude. I guess making $50 for 10 minutes of work makes her cranky. If you can't handle treating patrons with respect for 2.5 hours a day, I think you're in the wrong industry. We won't be back and will be sure to let others know about our unpleasant experience. read more

We had lunch today after coming off the ferry. Thankfully I had brought some cash as they don't accept credit cards . All sandwiches were $12.50. The Hippie Sister (all veggie) sandwich was delicious! The Sailor Sister (tuna fish) could have been better. More capers and some salt would have helped. This is clearly a hot lunch spot as it took almost 25 minutes for the sandwiches given how many people were there. They also throw in potato chips. The tables and chairs out back in the shade were appreciated on this hot sunny day. read more

Very quiet, amazing food, great seating environment, pet friendly. Unfortunately they have short hours and there order/paying counter is not very efficient but once you order the food it comes out pretty quickly read more

Stumbled upon Three Sisters while meandering about on the island. They had an interesting set up. The kitchen was outside in a partitioned off area and a cloth cover. There's a little house that keeps the raw foods/prep. On the other side of the lawn are a few picnic tables. I went for breakfast, but there are hanging lights set up for a romantic feel in the evening. Food is yummy local and delicious. Try try try! read more

Three Sisters - Sandwiches Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

Great place to pick up sammies before heading to the beach. There's a bit of a wait but it's worth it! read more

Three Sisters - Italian Sub - Sandwiches Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

Wow where do I begin! I don't usually write reviews, but I had to hop on here and say something for this awesome BI lunch spot!! My personal favorite is their tuna sandwich, the "Sailor Sister", with added avocado...fresh tuna salad; fresh, soft bread; fresh lettuce and tomatoes! What more could you ask for a hot summer day?? The "Brigid's Beachin" is another great choice...the only place I can get a great Italian sub outside of New Jersey!!!! It's the real deal! To top it all off, it is situated in an adorable spot! A sweet little cottage down Old Town Rd. with beautiful flowers lining the property. Quintessentially Block Island! This is sure to be a must-stop on my future trips to Block Island. read more

Delicious sandwiches with quality ingredients. Typically our first stop after the ferry (even before the house!) Seating is limited (and entirely outdoors), but if you can't snag a picnic table it's nice just to wander the yard while waiting for your food. The prices are steep because it's the island, but it's an upgraded lunch option! read more

Wow, amazing sandwiches. Quick and easy bite. Picked up and took it home. The twisted sister was great. Their cookies are so good as well! Great easy quick bite. read more

Three Sisters - Twisted sister - Sandwiches Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

Absolutely DELICIOUS sandwiches! We are traveling with 4 children and 5 adults and not one of us left unhappy! I had the Hippie Sister (veg, avocado, hummus)which was scrumptious. My 15 month old devoured the Little Sister (sunflower butter and jelly). My niece is gluten intolerant and was able to make a salad out of her sammie. Will return every BI trip! Spray available to sanitize your table before eating. read more

I have never left a Yelp review before but I honestly am so unbelievable dissatisfied with this place I feel obligated to. Everyone was extremely unfriendly and our order, which consisted of 6 sandwiches (all of them the same) came out wrong. It was legitimately as if they listened to nothing we said. Nothing was right. I wish it was wrong and good but it wasn't. I could have made a better sandwich. Oh, we also waited for 30 minutes. read more

I had an amazing sandwich at this place. Great for if you're looking to grab sandwiches for the beach or sit in there backyard and hangout. It came out quick so I didn't have to wait long and they gave me a chocolate chip cookie on the house.. Having Gatorade in the can was also a nice touch. Highly recommend read more

Great sandwiches and cutest outdoor dining atmosphere. I love to grab a Hippie Sister and take it to the beach!

Unfortunately I have to agree with some of the reviews with how they're rude. The sandwiches aren't anything special and you're better of going to the deli to grab a sandwich. The bread isn't anything special and you'd think it would be delicious since they specialize in sandwiches. read more

Ordered one simple sandwich and took 45 minutes. Everyone else was sitting and waiting and frustrated. By the time got food was just mad.

45+ minute wait for two scoops of tuna fish. Really? we watched a dozen orders go by us before ours. Too bad - we wanted to love this spot. This is just not OK! read more

Great sandwiches. Personal favorites are the twisted sister and the celeb sister. The mustard on the celeb sister is just out if this world. Sandwiches are always yummy and made to order with fresh ingredients. Also their fresh baked chocolate chip cookies are just to die for. However, we have had bad service here . The employees can seem rude and do not easily apologize for any mistakes. The wait for sandwiches at time is ridiculous. We have now taken to ordering over the phone and picking up to avoid the cramped house just to order and then wait. Great lunch place for a sunny day. No indoor seating so keep that in mind when wanting to check out island dining. read more

Been here a bunch of times and not impressed. The food isn't that good the service is worse and I didn't ask for a side of shitty attitude. Block Island Grocery make better sandwiches without the attitude! read more

BEST SANDWICHES I'VE EVER HAD. HANDS DOWN. every bite is delicious. the yard is a peaceful oasis and the staff is both beautiful and charming. Your Block Island trip is just not complete without going to three sisters. Things that are awesome- twisted sister- a sandwich containing bacon, cheddar, avocado, tomato, lettuce and turkey. the most popular sandwich by far. Any of the sandwiches and wraps can be made into a salad and the salads the best on the island. Incredible chocolate chip cookies...get there early before they stop baking them for the day. They also have dinner outside in the yard called MR. SISTER, they grill fresh seafood and always have live music in the yard under candlelight. Very Romantic. Very good price. BYOB. Gotta check it out. read more

Pretty subpar service. One of the "sisters" was rude and they got the order wrong. Perhaps the sandwich competition is not terribly stiff so they can act the way they do. All of us were pretty hungry so although we received the wrong order we ate the sandwiches anyway. I guess the silver lining is the sandwich I happened to eat was pretty good (hence the 2 stars). read more

One of the best lunch spots on the island! I could eat here every day. It's a small place and might take a bit of time since they are so busy, but worth the wait. Grab your lunch and sit outside and enjoy on their picnic benches. I would recommend sandwich options, but honestly all of them that I had were greatly enjoyed! read more

Three Sisters - Outside seating- how adorable! - Sandwiches Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

Second trip this year to Block Island and wanted to try something different that was refreshing. Found this little gem and tried out the "Big Sister" Enjoyed the freshly made roast beef sandwich with a bag of Cap Cod chips. Also make sure to grab some home made cookies on top of the counter. The picnic area outside is nice place to relax after some shopping in town. read more

Perfect beach sandwich spot! So many delicious options that it was tough to decide. Definitely worth a stop in.