Dead Eye Dicks is another place on BI that can take big groups. Likely only inside, but when you've got 10 plus people - we will sit anywhere! Service was attentive and friendly. We loved all the food. The Parker house rolls are hot and yummy but only 4, so order extra! We love the honey soy edamame! The hot lobster roll was filled with a toasted butter roll! The tuna was fresh and delicious - we got a side of the honey soy for dipping the tuna! Sooo good! I also love the pitcher of strawberry lemonade! Statler chicken is moist and tender! The fries aren't anything to write home about but plenty of other good things to bring us back! read more

See all

Been to Block Island many times but had never been to Dead eye Dick's. Interesting place. Chill vibe. Got two ice cold Mich ultras. The menu just didn't grab me. Mixed drinks look d interesting -we were at the bar and watched the bartender making a variety of adult beverages. read more

See all

The atmosphere here is great. Near Paynes marina and right on the water. Great views. All staff we encountered were very friendly and helpful! Food was excellent and we enjoyed everything we ordered! The crab Rangoon flatbread was tasty, the lobster fettuccine was great, crab cakes were excellent- it was all fantastic and all worth a little bit of a wait to sit. I'd love to come back! read more

See all

Came for the views and it did not disappoint! We arrived around 2 and were able to get a seat on the deck overlooking the water easily. The warm lobster roll had a good amount of lobster and tasted fresh. Fries were hot and crispy. Calamari was also a good portion - the batter was nice and light and perfectly flash fried. We liked the wasabi aioli drizzled lightly on top for a nice twist. Service was quick, relaxed and friendly. Server forgot one of our beers but brought it out shortly after we reminded him. Would definitely return next time we're on the island! read more

See all

Breathtaking ocean views sitting on the deck watching the harbor. Food was amazing, I highly recommend the Cajun swordfish bites! so juicy and tender! The lobster roll had some of the biggest portions of claw and tail meat I've ever seen! Server was friendly, however service was a little slow. That being said, there were 3 servers to wait on the whole establishment, outside being the most packed read more

See all

great location and spectacular views of the harbor make this a must visit on any trip to Block. We enjoyed lunch on a sunny afternoon with delicious blackened swordfish bites and a lobster roll. I would recommend any of the casual fish dishes...crab cakes, swordfish Ruben, shrimp & grits, etc. my friend had pasta with clam sauce and thought it was delicious. It's casual, there's a covered deck, it's laid back and a good place for some day drinking with a cold beer. You get the picture. read more

Great views from the covered outdoor porch. The staff was attentive, friendly and professional. I had the best lobster roll I've ever had (and that's saying something, because I've had my share throughout New England). The portion was substantial and the lobster was tender, perfectly cooked and delicious. I took a photo, but now I can't find it :-( DED's is my new go-to for hot lobster rolls! Oh, yeah, the group I went with also loved everything they ordered. read more

The fish and chips were fresh and delicious. Plus you have a great view of the boats on the water. Everything came out quickly and the servers were very warm. read more

Dead Eye Dick's - New American Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

You know when you're asked "if you were on death row, what would you your last meal be?"... well, my answer used to be steak, potatoes, and green beans. Now, after eating what I consider one of my all time best meals ever, my answer will be "Dead Eye Dick's ribeye with their fingerling potatoes and mixed greens". That ribeye was full of flavor- an explosion of heaven in every bite. Due to my extensive list of allergies including shellfish, they baked it to avoid cross contamination. It had a charred taste on the outside followed by a deep savory mix of perfectly prepared meat. It wasn't dry at all, and at the risk of sounding cliche "it melted in my mouth" (if meat can even do that!). The fingerling potatoes and mixed greens complemented the ribeye perfectly. It was a large portion so I shared with my friends, and surprisingly I still I had some left over. Our server, Alex Jackson, went above and beyond in accommodating my dietary needs while meeting my friends' requests for shellfish as well (do they want me to get sick ??? lol) Their food was brought out separately. He also made sure we had enough drinks and asked us if we needed anything a few times. This seaside restaurant overlooking New Harbor in Block Island boasts spectacular views, exceptional service, and outstanding food. The interior is tastefully decorated. It is a bit pricier than some other restaurants on the island, but it is worth every penny. P.S. The modern styled bathrooms are very clean which is much appreciated after visiting several establishments on the island which desperately need updating. read more

Dead Eye Dick's - View of the beautiful exterior from the water - New American Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

See all

I honestly don't even know where to begin. Everything I tasted at Dead Eye Dicks's was incredible. For me, the stars of the show were the cocktails and this unbelievable lobster truffle Fettucini. I ate every last bite. The flavor is rich and comforting - and the lobster - wow. It's not all claws so you get the meat of the tail and it's just ‍ . The island fog was delightful. So delightful I had two. Strong like a cocktail should be, but we'll-crafted with other flavors. I highly recommend if you go to block island! read more

Dead Eye Dick's - Island Fog and Lobster Truffle Fettucini - New American Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

We came here because some locals say that DED's is the best restaurant in town. THERE IS NO FRIED FOOD MENU, to the dismay of my dining partner. She wanted fried shrimp, so our server asked the chef to make that as a special request. It came out hot and crispy, and my friend enjoyed it a lot. I ordered the hot lobster roll, which came with a side of sriracha butter sauce. I dipped my lobster in it and put some on my roll. It was so good. TIP: Squeeze some lemon on both the sauce and lobster for a fantastic flavor boost. Both orders came with fries, made from fresh-cut potatoes. They were hot, crunchy and tasty, and a dip in ketchup made them taste even better. This restaurant is only a five minute taxi ride from the ferry. There were shops nearby the restaurant, but they were closed because it is early season. The season kicks off in June when fishermen start catching striped bass, which is the island's signature fish. Tourists from all over the world come to Block Island, just to have some. My dining partner and I plan to return to DED's later on this summer to see how they prepare striped bass. read more

Dead Eye Dick's - Lobster Roll - New American Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

Good place with good food with nice views. There are three seating options here: inside, outside on the deck, or on the grass. On the deck it was. We found it to be a little cooler and breezier then the grass. Starting out with the cocktail, the Sailor's Painkiller. Mount gay rum, coconut, pineapple, topped with nutmeg. Absolutely refreshing and outstanding! We tried two of the lunch sandwiches. The first was the swordfish ruben. It comes on marble bread and is very lightly toasted. The flavor was OK. The sandwich was decent. Beside the swordfish you get coleslaw and Russian dressing. More dressing and better toasted would have made this sandwich much better. The second sandwich was the tuna melt. Likewise, it comes on a toasted marble bread. That too comes with coleslaw on the sandwich. If it's not coleslaw, it's some sort of green. Either way, it has for a nice flavor. Again, if the bread was better toasted it would make the experience a bit better. The sandwiches come with fries. We asked if there are other options we were offered a side salad. It was a good call, the vegetables were fresh and the dressing was outstanding. By the way, this is a $2 charge for a salad substitute. Overall pleased with the experience. read more

See all

Dead eye Dick's is a treasure tucked away! We had an assortment- the Spoon Tuna was unbelievable! I was skeptical about the Fried Prawn Chips, but this was amazing. We had been excited for the lobster roll, it was ok. The fish Rueben however was fabulous. This is a spot to go to and enjoy sitting on the lawn for drinks or food and enjoying the boats passing by. read more

See all

We stopped in for lunch on our recent Block Island trip. I did enjoy my lobster roll, I opted for warm with butter and the roll came toasted which was a standout for sure! Seems like a great spot being right on the water, with an enclosed deck for water views and the servers were attentive. read more

See all

Heard about Dead Eye Dicks while reading a blog post on Block Island and I'm very glad they recommended it! They had really unique dishes that were also incredibly tasty. I ordered the vegetarian Bánh mì and it was delicious! I also tasted the lobster roll which, though it was equally appetizing, was a bit overpriced and not worth the high cost. Would still highly recommend this restaurant to anyone visiting Block Island! The service was quite fast and the waitress was very kind and attentive! read more

Dead Eye Dick's - Vegetarian Bahn mi - New American Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

See all

I've been dining in Block Island at least once or twice each summer for the better part of the last two decades. For years, my go to was the National Hotel porch. While food at the National is fine, the addition of the view made the "package" my default choice for lunch. I was introduced to Dead Eye Dicks a summers ago after a bad experience at my usual. Wow. I've found Dick's to be consistently excellent and a reasonable value for the experience. I often choose one of their lobster rolls, which are generous and delicious. We've had a few of the other summertime fish lunch dishes, and have never been anything but pleased. Sitting out on the deck overlooking the docks is just lovely. read more

We always go to Dead Eye Dicks for lunch when on Block Island. Great view and great vibe from the staff. A must is Swordfish Rueben. The view of the New Harbor is always great. read more

See all

Food was okay, fries were great! We came on Thursday of Labor Day weekend. Lydia was our server, and she was not very attentive. The place was not crazy busy... Lydia didn't even introduce herself, the only way we knew her name was from our bill. I asked for a refill of water and after waiting ten minutes when I asked a bus boy, it was finally refilled. Good spot to go for lunch, but don't have high expectations for service. read more

Have eaten here in person and take out. Food is great but if visiting during high season make reservations. When dining in person we were seated outdoors and the BI scenery was relaxing. Food and service were excellent despite it being very busy. Great takeout service and food when we have decided to stay home. read more

Great views on the patio and the food was so delicious. We had a hard time deciding what to get and boy did we make the right choices. Service was nice. read more

Dead Eye Dick's - Lobster BLT - New American Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

See all

This is a must stop! Honestly perfect spot after we did a bike tour of Block island. The menu is so fresh and they have some great drinks too! Our number one pick was the crab ragoon flatbread! It was so delicious and great flavor palette. The crab cakes were a perfect size and the lobster on the roll was HUGE pieces. There was a wait when we came but we were able to sit in the bar area right away. Tons of bike parking right outside. read more

See all

Great experience on BIRI. All around fresh and delicious food: lobster roll hit it out of the park. Best of our Block Island eating venues! Fun, pretty view. read more

Amazing, fresh lobster! Best steamed lobster dinners and lobster rolls on the island. We tried two different places, plus Dead Eye Dick's for a total of 3 places, and DED's Lob roll was hands down THE BEST! Service was pretty good. Nothing to complain about. Ambience outside on the water is a nice touch! Something about the waves crashing, boats sailing, and lobster steamin'!!! Went for my bday lunch and was not disappointed. Prices are great for a couple of Californians visiting the East Coast! read more

Great service, great cocktail, delicious appetizer-shrimp and grits were good, but a tad too sweet for my taste. Pimiento cheese didn't really come through, due to level of sweetness. Our server was wonderful, and I'm sorry I don't remember her name-but she was great. Service was very fast!! read more

See all

The service was friendly and relaxed. I always ask for recommendations, and the waiter was SO helpful. We had fish and chips, fish tacos, calamari, and the sunshine lemonade pitcher. The calamari, lemonade, tacos, and fish were perfect. I can't say enough how well the calamari was fried. It was light. The fish tacos were not as great. There's not a lot of food there, and you primarily taste the slaw/greens on the taco. The restaurant overall was great and would highly recommend . read more

Dead Eye Dick's - Fish and chips - New American Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

See all

Absolutely. Wide range of choices. Excellent food very well prepared & attentive service.

Every thing was great from the servers to the food And as far as the location perfect Will be back read more

Delicious!! We were walking and came across Dead's Eye Dicks.. we had one of our friends in a wheelchair and needed a restaurant that had a ramp. We looked at the menu and it had great choices! A lot of seafood of course. So we checked it out. The inside of the restaurant was very roomy and opened space with a nice bar. There was also outdoor dining but there was a wait for outside. When we looked at the menu, prices were reasonable for what they had on menu and well.. it was Block Island. 3 of us chose the same dish ( Lobster Avocado BLT) then the rest of the group also Ordered a burger, calamari, grilled chicken sandwich and PO'Boy . It was well worth for what I paid for my lobster BLT. Fries were nice and crispy and perfect in taste!! Everyone ate everything and we were very satisfied. Tge portion was a great size and very filling. Our sandwiches were stuffed with lots of lobster. It was amazing!! Service was wonderful and they took allergies very serious. They don't have a separate fryer but GF but they had GF buns. We lived this place that unexpectedly happen to check Out. The one thing I must say is that the bathrooms weren't very roomie for those handicapped or in a wheelchair. Besides that, I recommend for you all to try this place. Came in happy, left happy! read more

See all

This place is right across the street from an inn we frequent, The Narragansett Inn. We've sat outside on the back lawn both times we've been here. There are several tables and fire pits as well as Adirondack chairs. There's a beautiful view of the water where lots of boats are docked. You can also watch the sunset (see picture below) This place serves delicious espresso martinis. Ask for them with Baileys if you like them 'creamy'. The only food we've gotten here was the crab Rangoon flatbread. Delicious. However, next time we will ask for this flatbread 'well done' and perhaps less sauce. 5/5 would recommend read more

Dead Eye Dick's - Delicious espresso martinis are served here. - New American Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

See all

The restaurant: has good service and a nice server. A local driver recommended it to us. However, our fellow captains advised against us going. It was a bit loud and the decor was very basic. It was an ideal location being that it was near our mooring and also close to a ice cream shop. The line gets very long so be prepared for that. Edamame: Huuuge portion and was very tasty. The fish and chips: looked like they could be hit or miss from online. I ordered them and they were fine. Nothing fancy, just the basic cod with breading. It had more of a crumby feel compared to the normal deep fry texture. Buckeyes Burger: "Excellent, some could say magnificent, so good, I would shiver" ~Buddy of mine. read more

See all

Had to wait for our table so started with a drink @ the bar. Bartender wasn't very friendly but it was just a way to pass time until our table was ready. Sat outside under the awning with a fantastic view. My Lobster BLT on marbled rye was phenomenal! Would definitely add that to your must have list if you're on BI! read more

My husband and I rented mopeds and toured the island one day. We stopped at Dead Eye Dick's for lunch as I had seen it written up on Yelp. It was the best lunch we had during our three night stay on Block Island. We were so pleased with our soup choices ... my husband finally got his a Rhode Island Clam Chowder which is more of a broth than the creamy New England-style that I favor. They were both delicious and clearly homemade. Their New England Clam Chowder was creamy without being overly thick. Perfect consistency. Mark's (hot) Lobster Roll was also superb, probably the best we experienced during our trip. My Fried Oysters (an appetizer) were small but sweet. Unfortunately, we dove into our food without taking more photos. CeeCee was an attentive server and timed our meal well. We liked the food and reasonable prices enough that we seriously considered returning for dinner, despite the $12 cab ride in each direction. Alas, we were very tired when we got back to our hotel after a full day of moped touring that we ordered pizza at our hotel and chilled watching Bing Crosby movies. Make sure you have a meal here. You won't be disappointed. read more

See all

WARNING: EXTREMELY HARD FOR SHELLFISH ALLERGIES Took over an hour to seat 10 people, make sure to come not during rush hour so you don't have to wait. Environment was a little loud and packed, LOTS OF GLASS BREAKING. I personally had a tough time eating here due to a shellfish allergy. My steak was baked which lead to it being medium well/well done instead of medium rare, my rice was changed to a baked potato, I couldn't have the mushroom sauce but they still put it on my plate, and they completely forgot my asparagus. I'm very pleased and thankful with how the staff was accommodating but it's very hard to get an actual meal when everything is contaminated. The rest of my parties food was hit or miss, some people who ordered things such as burgers or fish and chips loved it, but others who ordered things such as clam chowder or swordfish didn't like it one bit. I personally wouldn't come back again due to my experience. But it's worth a try if you love raw seafood. read more

Dead Eye Dick's - Steak frites - New American Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

Cheesy fries are the best ones I have had! Fish and chips were so crunchy, fish portion is a little small. Waitstaff has been super friendly and accommodating. We walked in pretty close to closing, like ran down the street...and they seated us with a smile and treated us like the first customer of the day. Great place! read more

Scallop tostado and Lobster BLT. That's it. These are the only two things you need to get at DED's. The scallops were cooked better than most Michelin rated restaurants. Huge diver scallops and just cooked to perfection. Lobster BLT was great. Wished they filled up the gaps of the sandwich with more meat but the amount was good, the flavors worked in lobster harmony and just a satisfying sandwich. read more

See all

Service was 5*. Could not have been better. I had the swordfish. Very fresh, thick large portion. Potato and veg also perfect. They don't take reservations, and the line starts early. We ate outside overlooking the harbor which was a pleasant experience. You can bring dogs if you eat outside. My wife had soba tuna. A generous portion which she described as delightful. read more

Has a great sunset view and the food was decent. They were very accommodating for a large party and the servers were friendly and attentive. The food was nothing to rave about but had something for everyone. read more

Where. To. Start. I was freakin hungry when I got to my seat and unfortunately I may or may not of under ordered. I got the shrimp and grits and it tasted fantasticly in my mouth. Unfortunately I did not nearly have enough to eat and had to order an extra $5 potato. It was a potato. The best meal of the table was by far the The buckye burger the person next to me who ate the burger said: "excellent, some could say magnificent" It seemed like 15 minutes or so a glass broke, I'm not sure if it was an accident or if the bartender was getting his angry out but it most definitely added to the experience. I had to witness the person across from me order the grits but thought it was mash potatoes(very sad) In closing: - shrimp and Grits read more

Dead Eye Dick's - Post food enjoyment. - New American Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

We finished our bike ride around the island with a delicious lunch! There's outdoor seating with waterfront dining. Everything was really fresh and our bellies were very happy! Quick and friendly service and great vibes all around. read more

See all

We tried Dead Eye Dick's for the first time, and it's now our favorite Block Island seafood restaurant. Excellent food! Great water views! Great service! read more