Omg I'm soooo happy this place is so close to my home! Pizza was ready in 15 mins on a busy Sunday! And it was so so yummy!! A++

Great pizza, wings and salad. Can't go wrong with Three Fellas. Best pizza in CT hands down!!!! Five Stars

FIVE STARS AN EXCELLENT PIZZA JOINT, walking in you are greeted by a stunning clean interior. There is no family seating however there is an excellent lunch counter. The pizza is a well developed thin crust, I personally ate two slices one bacon chicken ranch, and buffalo chicken I was absolutely blow away, the crust is crunchy and flavorful and their takes on these popular flavor combinations are top notch. 10/10 recommend this place. read more

5 stars, you hicks have it good. jk obviously, i have roots, i am not antiboro or anything. so this was a good pizza, mer was smart enough to spring for the caprasie without tomatoes. nice strings of basil on a well balanced fresh mozzarella and not too chunky sauce. i really liked it a lot. it was a tad cold as it had to make it back to east stabyou, but i housed it, it was great, way too good to give to my kids, we were glad to have to share this incredible pie. 17 bucks for the privilege, worth it. read more

We have been ordering pizza from here since they have opened. Just recently tried two of the pasta dishes they offer. We loved the house special of cheese tortillini in a blush sauce. This is the best dish ever. We also tried the beef raviolis. Again another winner. I was happy with great pizza, now we can add pasta to the list of great food they have. read more

I have no idea where I was, but I came across the Three Fellas and took a chance on their pizza. It was a bit past lunch time and the slice selection was on the low side, so i got one cheese and one with fresh tomatoes and some other typical things. I got the slices to go, they reheated it in about 20 seconds and it was warm but not hot which was OK because I was hungry. The oil started seeping through the bag before i got to my car (which is a good sign maybe if you are a fan of oil) .. The slightly crispy thing slices weren't really all that oily, as i ate them the oil wasn't running down my arm or dripping on me. Overall they were decent reheated slices - makes me want to go back and order a whole fresh pie one day maybe. The one thing that I thought was weird was the "& Market" part of Three Fellas .. so it's a few shelves with Italian groceries like peppers and olives. The fridge had some decent looking cake (i wonder if they bake it themselves?) I have no idea what other pizza around here is like, but this one was worthwhile. read more

Three Fellas Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Marlborough, Connecticut

See all

DELICIOUS pizza!! Came here on a Thursday night and enjoyed a nice slice of cheese pizza. I love that they will heat your pizza up for you in a wood fired oven so you get a crispy pizza on the spot! Probably the best pizza you will get in town, don't even bother going anywhere else. I was greeted by a very lovely girl named Maura, who worked at the front counter. read more

Best Thin Crust Pizza around! I love the extra large single slices I get to go too! Always friendly service at the counter!

Three Fellas filled a niche in a really genius way. Not only do they provide the best Italian thin-crust style (and only New York style) in the area, but they are one of the [if not only] only place in the Hebron, East Hampton and Marlborough that will actually deliver. These are small towns and do not generally deliver. For that service alone, they can get away with having their food be a bit more expensive- but it is SO worth it. My rule is if a pizzeria can't deliver a good slice of just traditional cheese, it's not worth it. Well, Three Fellas makes an amazing cheese pie, as well as a plethora of delicious specialties. My absolute favorite pizzeria is Antonios in Amherst, MA, and Three Fellas might have come to be my second favorite. The buffalo chicken pizza is really incredible. My family tells me they make a good grinder, and their pasta is quite good- the special with the tortellini, mushrooms and peas is great. They have an extensive catering menu that looks delicious...makes me wish I can an event so I could inquire their services. Service is usually pretty quick, everyone is always nice. The inside of that place is so hot (I feel bad for the workers!) but it's not meant to have a lot of people come sit. I never would have expected for Marlborough to have a place where I could go inside, order one slice of an usual specialty pizza, and eat it at a little bar. Very modern for our town- but awesome! Overall: Three Fellas is the most expensive pizza place in the area but god is it worth it if you like really good thin crust, Italian, New York style pizza and tasty sandwiches, pastas, and salads. And who doesnt?! read more

Enjoyed our pizza. Ricotta and meatball and chicken broccoli the meatballs are delicious. Sliced thin on pizza. Broccoli was disappointing. It was the frozen stuff. Really needed fresh. We will be back read more

Great pizza and buffalo panini. Easy to get to as well. Definitely recommend the quick trip up rte 2

Of the three pizza places in Marlborough this is by far the most expensive. It is delicious pizza and has courteous delivery people.

I think pizza is the only thing to get here. We generally like the pizza (not the gluten free though- it came with uncooked dough)). Just had the worst take out meal in a long time. It just wasn't good, most of it ended up in the trash (all 5 of us barely ate 1/2). Anything fried was tossed bc of the taste of old grease. Burnt burger bun. Perhaps an off night. But...a lost customer none the less. A call to the restaurant to let them know didn't help either. They only offered a discount on next order. That sums it up for me. 10% discount off 0 orders = ? read more

This has probably just became myself and my families favorite pizza! Usually we're not that into thin pizza but this is exceptionally delicious. This town doesn't have much but the small local businesses have some of the best quality food you'll ever have like Three Fellas. Will totally remain a customer. Friendly staff. Fast service. 10/10 would recommend. read more

I have to lower my review by one star after having eaten here several times. The reason is the toppings are awful . Veggie pizza almost inedible. The cheese pizza is absolutely amazing, it's really a shame that's the only thing i can order and be satisfied with. When I compare this to pleasent pizza in Willimantic toppings, it really shows how poor they are. Hopefully they work on it. read more

Best pizza I've ever had. New York style, thin crust, great cheese and pretty good sauce. I recommend the buffalo chicken pizza if thats your thing. the wraps and calzones are good too. I would NOT recommend the margherita pizza, it was kinda a soupy mess. other than that, 5 stars. read more

Great job guys!!!! Food is great. Pizza is great! Delivery is great! You all are doing a great job making three fellas number one!!!!

Best pizza I've ever had, hands down. They also sell by the slice where the other pizza places in the area do not, the slices are always fresh and very large. Their delivery service is fast and the customer service is great. I personally would recommend the chicken parmigiana grinder or buffalo chicken pizza. read more

some of the best pizza outside the city (and made nyc style) if they upgraded to the expensive ingredients and high burn ovens they'd be an unstoppable franchise, but then 1000 degree ovens are not easy to come by... read more

Was passing through on travel. Got a slice of plain and a slice of white broccoli. Best pizza I have had in a long time. Exceptional crust!! And nice guys to boot. read more

This is the best pizza in the area by far! Highly recommend it. El Presidente would give this place an 9.1. Great tang in the sauce, super thin, great crunch, no flop, and just the right amount of grease. Perfect! read more

This place is a nice variation on a theme. It's a take out/deli place without any tables, so you can't really squabble about "customer service." It would fit in really well in NYC really. A bunch of guys throwing pizzas together and watching the loud football game on the television set while they work. The set up is a little awkward, but that's probably due to the fact that the space itself is a bit awkward. You enter through a door that's part of a corner for example. You order in the back and when the food is done they take it to the cash register at the front to ring you up... As a resident of the East Hampton/Marlborough area this is such a welcome addition. Everything else in the immediate area is overpriced and poorly prepared. So, while the prices are not really much different than the other spots, at least you are getting something decent to eat for the money. (Restaurants in East Hampton seem especially overpriced for what you get). As far as the menu: they do everything from cold sandwiches and panini's to pizza and pasta. We've tried a couple things and were happy, so this spot will likely become a staple. Oh, and as a wonderful bonus they deliver to East Hampton! Even East Hampton restaurants (excluding one Chinese place) won't deliver. read more

Authentic New York style brick oven pizza in small town Marlborough. Love the pizza and convenience. I think they deliver too!

This place has damn good pizza. I put these guys in third place all time behind a joint in Boston's north end and El Presidente in Naples. That's how good I think they are. read more

My parents moved to Hebron four years ago and this is by far the best pizza joint I have encountered in the area. Every time I am over and we want take out, I recommend this place. Their grinders are delicious too. The restaurant is clean with great chip and soda options as well. They deliver, make a great pie, and are reasonably priced making this place the best option in the area! read more

NY style pizza. Probably the best in central CT. Doesn't hurt that the fellas are nice guys.

Absolute best pizza I've ever had. Beats out any pizza in the area. Tons of creative slice options with an extensive menu for other goods. #1 choice for pizza. Also so easy to just stop in and grab slices. read more

Very good prices and for the money you can't beat the food. With that said, if you're looking for the best, you may want to go elsewhere. Their pizza is good and so are the buffalo tenders. Be sure to ask for extra hot sauce as it's delicious! read more

Very expensive pizza for very mediocre pizza. Their mushrooms are canned. I bought 2 large pizzas and a small specialty pizza. The bill was over $63.00!!!!! The small was a veggie; canned mushrooms, a few onions and peppers that were barely cooked, a few pieces of spinach that were barely visible, AND it cost over $18.00!!!!! read more

Best pizza in town hands down. New York style pizza. Plus they sell it by the slice. The staff is polite and greet you when you come up to the counter. read more

Perfect pizza, fresh ingredients, friendly staff, and they deliver! Decently priced, too. We are never disappointed with Three Fellas.

I really want to write something nice but I just placed an order and waited an hour and a half. I am writing this as the pizza sits in my oven because it arrived cold. Called to inform Three Fella's of the issue and they only offered 20% off my NEXT order if I ordered within 2 weeks. Very disappointing, for what is a better tasting pizza in the area. read more

Great location, delicious slices, just had a slice of chicken bacon ranch! Wow! Friendly service too!

Best pizza around! The girls are the front counter are so sweet and the food is excellent 10/10 recommend!

Good pizza and fast delivery! Crust was thin and pie was well done...just as I ordered

Great thin crust pizza. The first time I called, a Friday night, the wait was an hour (just for pickup, not delivery). I passed on that and tried again two weeks later on a Saturday. Twenty minute wait and very pleased with the Tony's Special and the Fiorentino we ordered. Will be going back for more. read more

My favorite pizza in town! Extremely tasty. Also the only place in town that delivers. Wonderful if your baby is sleeping or it's too cold to go out in the winter. read more

Can't go wrong with the fellas! For a take out style pizzeria you can't get much better. One of the few places that will deliver in the area. If we call in to pick up it usually takes no more than 15-20min and delivery has never taken more than 30-40. When the delivery arrives its always nice and hot. Defiantly would recommend to anyone in the area looking for a good slice, or two! read more

Went in to grab a quick slice of pizza, great service and great prices. BBQ chicken pizza was delicious, chicken bacon ranch to top it off... And gotta love me some Stewart's soda read more

I eat this pizza all the time and love it. However recently they upped their prices on everything and most of it, isn't worth it! If you are going for a slice it's not too bad- but anything else seems expensive. read more