I really wanted to like this restaurant because on the way to Sacramento from the coast I used GPT to find a restaurant with a menu that matched our desired dining experience.
First, there were issues with parking and accessibility. I am in a wheelchair, and The Waterboy has no designated handicap parking, only street parking with their small lot reserved for employees. We had to pull up to the curb at an intersection, with traffic going around the car, just so I could get out into my wheelchair. They do have an automatic handicap-accessible door, which I appreciated, but by the time I made it from the car, down the sidewalk, and into the restaurant, I was shaking from the effort. It took at least 15 minutes just to find a way to exit the vehicle and make it inside.
When I made the reservation I stated that I was in a wheelchair, yet Sophia did not give me a heads up on the lack of handicap parking. After finally getting inside, it was about 8:50 p.m., and the very first words out of the server's mouth were that the kitchen would be closing at 9:00. I described the ordeal I had just endured to get into the restaurant. The staff said they would call the city about the parking issue, but that didn't help in the moment.
Once seated, the server, Neill, was polite and generally accommodating, but I did not receive a copy of the specials menu, and wasn't even aware of them because he made no effort to describe them. When I asked about wines only being by the glass, it was only then that he brought the wine list, which I would describe as just okay. There was also an awkward moment that didn't leave a great impression. After I explained the parking issue and he stepped away to speak with the manager, he returned and immediately took the order from a table that had arrived after us--even though we were ready to order.
For my meal, I started with the Veal Sweetbreads with mushrooms, bacon, lemon, capers, Marsala, and demi-glace. ($23) It WAY over-salted. When the server asked how it was, I told him, and to his credit, he offered to replace it. I requested a half order instead. The second plate was better, but the heavy flavors overpowered the naturally delicate thymus glands, and they were also overcooked. I prefer a quick sear that leaves the inside creamy and melt-in-your-mouth, but this version leaned toward firm and lost its subtlety. When I mentioned the excessive salt, the chef actually defended the dish rather than acknowledging it might have been overseasoned. I am a very experienced home chef with my own recipe site and feel confident in my assessment of the food. I have since read other reviews where other diners have commented on the over salted dishes.
My second dish was the Sonoma Liberty Duck Breast with panzanella of bitter greens, focaccia, Twin Peaks peaches, bacon, roasted onions, peppers agrodolce, and balsamico. ($46) I asked if they cooked it rare, and the server said medium-rare. I said that was fine--as long as it wasn't overcooked. Unfortunately, it arrived closer to blue, which is even less cooked than rare. The duck was also completely unseasoned, and the plating--simply scattered over otherwise nice greens--felt uninspired and not particularly appealing.
For dessert, I chose the kumquat sorbet ($8), expecting a light, refreshing finish to the meal. Instead, it was far too sweet, masking the natural tartness of the kumquat and lacking the clean palate-cleansing quality a sorbet should have. I didn't finish a single one of my three dishes.
My dinner companion had a different experience. She enjoyed her Ravioli of Roast Chicken, Mortadella, Caramelized Onions and Greens with herb butter, pork belly, Parmigiano Reggiano, and roasted garlic jus. ($36) She especially liked the pork belly, noting it was rich and flavorful, though she did mention there were only five ravioli on the plate. Because of that, I gave her a few pieces of my duck--but she agreed that eating nearly raw duck was not enjoyable.
She also ordered an Old Fashioned Manhattan ($15!!), which she found well-balanced and enjoyable. For dessert, she had the Butterscotch Budino with whipped cream, caramel, and biscotti ($12), and she found it to be delicious--easily the highlight of her meal.
The one bright spot for me was the two margaritas on the rocks ($30!!!!), which were well-made and balanced.
In the end, while the cocktails were good and my companion liked her ravioli and dessert, my own meal was deeply disappointing. The ingredients definitely did not "shine," flavors were inconsistent, the seasoning erratic, the plating uninspired, and the experience was marred by accessibility challenges that could have been communicated upfront. For the cost ($207, including tip) and effort of dining here, I expected far more consistency and thoughtfulness--both in the kitchen and in the overall experience.
Anna S. - Wild Woman Kitchen read more