Cancel

Open app

Search

The Second City New York

3.8 (18 reviews)
Closed • 10:00 am - 1:00 AM (Next day)

The Second City New York Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - The Second City New York

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Hunter S.

I wanted to love this place. And in many ways, I did. And I'll probably give it another chance. The main thing about Second City and me is that I've been to the original Chicago location. In Chicago, my friends and I laughed until we cried. One of my best friends still has a nickname acquired at Second City Chicago. The comedy was witty and funny and politically relevant. The show was cohesive and progressed naturally. Second City New York is still trying to find out who they are and who they want to be. The bits are a little clunky and don't flow well together. Very choppy. Missing that sophistication Chicago has. One second they are doing a skit about school kids, the next NYPD in the subway, then Harry Potter. That being said, I really loved the cast. I could tell they were funny people in real life, even if some of the skits fell flat. I could see they are cool people that I would enjoy hanging out with. There was a lot more audience interaction work here than in Chicago. I was actually part of the skits several times, to the point that the cast gave me kudos at the end for being a good sport. While this wasn't the funniest night I've ever had, it was fun, and the audience really seemed to enjoy themselves. Oh, and it didn't hurt that my seat was front row and center! So great view! The bartenders were great. Very welcoming and helpful. The service staff is still working out the kinks. I got overlooked at first because (as happens to me so often), I was a single party sat next to a group of a few. I finally got service and had the charcuterie platter, which was actually pretty good for a comedy club, and the deviled eggs (they were fine, but lacked seasoning, but what do you expect from deviled eggs at a comedy club). They also have burgers, fries, and some other sandwiches. I just didn't want to mess with dishes that heavy in a comedy venue. There were a couple drinks I had ordered from the bar that were decent. The Back Line (tequila reposed, mastic tears, agave, lemon juice, transatlantic bitters). I also had the Rave Review (mezcal, cappelletti aperitivo, heirloom pineapple amaro, lemon juice, and agave). I had a couple of other drinks as well, both a little too sweet for me. We also had a couple of mishaps during the night. At the beginning of the show, the fire alarm went off. So we stood outside for quite sometime while the FDNY came to shut it off. We got a complimentary drink ticket for that. And I already had two complimentary drink tickets because they changed the show time twice beforehand. Unfortunately, I only got credit for one of my tickets, but that's ok. I understand working out the kinks. Anyway, this place has a way to go, but this is just their inaugural season. I'm willing to stick around and see what happens as they grow into who they really want to be (let's be honest, I'm always rooting for New York over Chicago any day).

Frank M.

The staff were helpful and very accommodating! Bar was reasonably ok, but not enough room for people to stand. Not all menu items are available in all locations. Drinks are a bit pricey. Fries were great! But, for the price should have been double the amount of fries. The reason for the rating: the comedy itself was not good. Saw the show at 7pm sat 4/27. While I pride the group on their quick setups when the lights are off, there is no buildup into any of the jokes, the jokes themselves weren't consistently funny, and sitting on the second floor there were two skits only visible and audible from the bottom floor. Also it was hard to hear the performers from the back of the second floor behind a group that was quite loud.

Sherry T.

Amazing cast! Laughed so much it hurt. The bar and food was typical bar food but the drinks were surprisingly better than expected. We took the subway from Manhattan to Brooklyn and it was a quick 7 mins walk to the theater. The staff were super friendly and the ambience was great! Clean bathrooms. But the show was phenomenal!! Hilarious and creative! When we go to NYC next time we'll be sure to come back. Def worth the trip.

Good menu
Cassandra M.

We had a great time at the show last night! We went to the Friday show at 7pm and it was a full house. Show was about 2 hours with an intermission. They performed prepared sketches mixed with improv scenes. The scenes were funny, the flow of the show was well done, and the actors were great. I couldn't find the food/drink menu online so I am including it here. You scan the QR code when you arrive. We got the two mocktails on the menu (pretty good), the fried chicken sandwich with fries (very good) and the chocolate parfait (very good). All the food came out fresh and fast. We got there a half hour before the show and we were able to eat at our seats before it started. They also continue serving during the show. All the staff at the venue were very friendly and welcoming.

See all

1 year ago

Helpful 6
Thanks 1
Love this 5
Oh no 0

11 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 17
Thanks 6
Love this 17
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 4
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Liz H.
8
93
31

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 2

2 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

3 years ago

Refunded my money after realizing I had Covid. Reached out via email. I am hoping to take a class in near future

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Shep S.
97
34
1

3 years ago

Laughably overpriced. Cool space. Good community involvement. Courteous, competent staff.

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - The Second City New York

Review Highlights - The Second City New York

“MC Jin honed his skills of free-style rapping and can think on his feet in that split moment- goes a long way in comedy as well.”

Mentioned in 2 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Comedy Clubs 3,931 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

House of Yes - Smoking Patio

House of Yes

3.9(376 reviews)
2.1 mi•Bushwick
•$$

Best venue for a bit of everything. Great DJs most nights. Can get slammed outside waiting to get…read morein, but worth the wait. Solid tunes.

House of Yes isn't just a venue--it's a state of mind, a glitter-drenched fever dream of queer joy,…read moreradical self-expression, and performance art that swings from the ceiling (literally). If you walk in expecting a traditional night out, prepare to be lovingly and fabulously corrected. From the moment I entered with a friend, it was clear this place plays by its own, very sparkly rules. The first room was more of a whimsical prelude than a line-up zone: drinks flowing, people mingling like old friends at a costume party, and a gloriously casual pile of pillows where you could recline like a disco-era Roman god. And yes--there was a tarot reader, naturally, because no true evening of hedonistic joy is complete without a stranger telling you your moon energy needs grounding. Once the main room opened, things escalated--in the best way possible. Performers appeared everywhere: on stage, above our heads, behind the crowd--acrobats, dancers, aerialists, all oozing talent, glitter, and just enough danger to keep you watching with your mouth open and your drink clutched tightly. It wasn't just a dance floor--it was a full-blown immersive experience. The music kept the energy up all night: infectious, thumping, and curated to make even the shyest feet consider their moment of main-character glory. The crowd? Pure magic. Full of respectful, expressive, and joyful people, the kind of fellow partygoers you dream about meeting in New York. Everyone was there to dance, to celebrate, to vibe--not to posture or preen. What makes House of Yes so special is that it's not just a nightclub--it's a celebration of freedom in all its forms. Of identity, of movement, of art, of joy. It's campy, chaotic, oddly intimate, and--somehow--profound. In short: if you're craving a space that feels like Studio 54 met a circus in a utopian queer commune, House of Yes is your new church. Bring an open mind, comfortable shoes, and a healthy appreciation for sequins.

Photos
House of Yes - View of the theater.  Main stage behind and extra box stage is separate.  Performers on both.

View of the theater. Main stage behind and extra box stage is separate. Performers on both.

House of Yes - Our view from premium seat (basically any front row seat).

Our view from premium seat (basically any front row seat).

House of Yes

See all

The Moth - Get here an hour early the line gets ridiculous!

The Moth

4.9(8 reviews)
1.9 mi•SoHo

Looking for a unique night out? Get tickets to The Moth instantly. No really, they run out in five…read moreminutes, get on that. The Moth is a storytellers event that occurs at different places, and the one I went to was at Housing Works Bookstore and Cafe, which was the perfect venue. It started at 7:30 and ended at 9:30, there's no drink minimum, you can bring your own food, and tickets are cheap, but hard to get. It's essentially a show where people who'd previously entered their names get picked to tell stories in under five minutes. Anyone can do it, and anything can be said. There were funny ones, sad ones, dramatic ones, silly ones, overall twelve performances along with a host who introduces each one. They also sell drinks and snacks there, which goes to a great cause. Whether you're looking for something New Yorky, cheap, chill, cute, or thought-provoking, The Moth will satisfy.

Going to a Story Slam hosted by The Moth is actually one of my favorite things to do in the city…read more The story slams happen 4-6 times a month at various locations around Manhattan and Brooklyn (see the website for schedule). Each slam has a different theme. If you feel that you have a worthy 5-min story, you can put your name in the bag, where they draw out names. Ten storytellers go up and these stories are judged by three teams of judges from the audience. The winner of the slam goes on to the Quarterly GrandSLAM Championship. It lasts about 2.5 hrs and costs $8. I've gone to a couple of these at the Housing Works and I'm always really impressed by the quality and talent of most of the storytellers. Many of them take this quite seriously and you can tell that they spent time crafting their story and delivery. The best stories aren't the ones that are merely funny, but they're poignant, send you on an emotional roller coaster of highs and lows, and leave you with a message and something to think about. There's a certain raw honesty and catharsis that comes through and the audience is always supportive, especially so for the new storytellers who stand up there alone and vulnerable. Indeed, if the audience feels the judges are too harsh, the audience lets the judges know. At the Story Slam at Housing Works, the doors open at 7 pm (stories start at 7:30). There are limited seats, so if you're dead set on sitting, stand in line by 5:30. There are plenty places to stand and get a good view as Housing Works' second floor is a mezzanine. Recently I got to the line by 6:30 and easily found a comfortable spot to stand and watch (wear comfortable shoes!). The ticket sales of the Story Slam goes directly to The Moth. Housing Works, which is a wonderful organization that helps people with HIV/AIDS, sells alcohol and snacks, so you're giving to a great cause by drinking.

Photos
The Moth
The Moth

See all

The Slipper Room

The Slipper Room

3.8(374 reviews)
1.5 mi•Lower East Side
•$$

THE BEST PLACE FOR LOCAL BURLESQUE IN NYC. HANDS DOWN. Forgive the all caps but I have strong…read moreopinions on this topic. No food. Good drinks. Great vibes. Waitress service with reserved tickets, which is the only way to guarantee a seat; though I have never had any trouble getting in for the $20 midnight show on weekends and for that price plus the quality of the performances I don't mind standing!! Some people Venmo but it's more fun when you bring cash to tip!! Every host has a different vibe. Weeknight shows are more local, weekends before midnight are very fun and lively. Also the decor here is awesome. Very classic old school downtown theater vibes but elegant. Dress is elevated but casual and keep your clothes on, you don't want to distract from the absolutely fabulous line up of talent they book on the regular!!

I can't love this place enough. I can't rave about it enough. Sexy burlesque girls (and this time…read morethere were a lot of fine looking men!). Something for everyone! There were also acrobats and aerialists this time. Bastard Keith (that's literally his stage name) brought the laughs again as emcee. And yes, he pulled out his testicle again. I even got called up on stage and had some very interesting moments with Bastard Keith, which was captured by an artist stage side (you know I bought that sketch too). This time I went on a Saturday night and again bought reserved seating. I got another seat right up front. I don't think it was 85 dollars this time though, maybe more in the 60s range. Still 100 percent worth it. Again, it was laughter til tears rolled down my face. It was joy. It was love and acceptance. If you're not a prude and you need some respite from today's hard times, the slipper room is for you. Can't wait to go back again. Ignore the hater reviews. They have multiple acts every night and you can tell the performers work hard on them. They are impressive. If you don't like it, please get up there and YOU do it.

Photos
The Slipper Room
The Slipper Room - Curtain & Slipper Room Overlay

Curtain & Slipper Room Overlay

The Slipper Room - Stage

See all

Stage

Accomplice The Show - Incredibly fun Accomplice The Village group.

Accomplice The Show

4.5(333 reviews)
2.0 mi•SoHo

Accomplice continues to be an absolute favorite attraction in the NYC area and having not been to a…read moreshow in over ten years my recent visit did not disappoint. I was paired with a small group of out of town visitors who brought their family to NYC and wanted them to experience the Accomplice. The parents of the family group were repeat guests like myself who like me absolutely enjoyed their experience several years prior and wanted to share it with their family. It's NYC so even when you participate in the live experience it may seem awkward that an actor is making a scene (literally) on the streets of NYC but nobody bats an eye cause weirdness can feel normal on the streets of Manhattan. Accomplice still has the typical tour around the small area of the city where you interact with amazing actors and make your way to the grand finally where you share a simple drink with your group to celebrate your accomplishment. The staff do offer a hotline to get clues if you are stuck but thankfully my group was witty enough to figure out our way through our adventure. Accomplice is also great for corporate team building activities. I've raved about this experience at my office for years and one of my teams decided to book with the show. Not only did my office team have an amazing time but buzz is going around the office about this show that another team was considering booking but business guests thought it would be too cold in November for such an event; such party poopers! LOL! Corporate events include a three course meal and tons of fun! Highly recommend for both tourists and corporate team building events.

A wonderful immersive theatre experience and great excuse to pop around some interesting places in…read moreThe Village. High recommend for 3 hours of fun.

Photos
Accomplice The Show - Just finished the show!  Success.

Just finished the show! Success.

Accomplice The Show - A fun afternoon in the village

A fun afternoon in the village

Accomplice The Show - Guys day out

See all

Guys day out

Women are Crazy Because Men are A**holes

Women are Crazy Because Men are A**holes

4.8(4 reviews)
2.5 mi•West Village

This play is about a universal theme of love, sex and relationships. If you are looking for love,…read moreand who isn't, this show will speak to you. For me, everything in this comedic play seemed all too familiar..during the show, I kept on thinking, OMG I think I found bits and pieces of myself in all the women characters...which makes me ask myself, am I crazy?!!!??? I'm okay with that....because MEN ARE A**HOLES. One of the actors when introducing the play in the beginning and after the intermission was making the audience chant..he would say Women are crazy because men are........and the audience, made up of mostly females said......A**HOLES!!!!!!! It felt therapeutic to shout it out loud! I was really getting into it...I looked at my boyfriend and he was making a frowny face. ahahha. I was trying to get him to chant A**HOLES too but he wouldn't bite. He said men are a**holes because they used to be hunters...okay. ahahhahah. That's why I love him! He's my hunter, now go hunt! This play reminds me of the book, Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus. The play is set at one of the character's home, Nicole is throwing a soiree to celebrate meeting her internet fling for the first time, at this soiree!! Nicole invited her whole entire family to meet this internet fling that she herself never met...WHO DOES THIS??!! Nicole's family consisted of her sister and her BF, her brother and his GF, and her best friend and her BF. There was another couple that were supposed to be at the soiree but never showed up. All these couples are all having dysfunctional relationships, which makes for a funny play. This play takes a look into human nature, human relationships and human behavior. Sometimes the play may seem over the top, overly dramatic and highly passionate to get some laughter from us, but I recognize the characters all to well!! I know people just like the characters on stage in this play. I definitely have seen some of the characteristics even in myself. I felt ashamed at times...but laughed at myself! The comic timing in this show is awesome. My favorite couple is Hillary and George who never even made it to the soiree! I was laughing through the whole show. Even coming back from the intermission was fun! Be forewarned, women are going to be portrayed as psychotic beings, men are going to be portrayed as insensitive liars and we all need each other in unhealthy ways. But at the end it's all for laughs and for fun which this play definitely accomplishes...I would highly recommend this entertaining show for any adult who has been through dating or relationship angsts. This show is definitely Rated R for RAUNCHY! See it if you want to laugh your A** off! Last day of show is June 21, HURRY!

LOVE***LOVE***LOVE***LOVE***LOVE***LOVE***LOVE***­LOVE***LOVE***LOVE***LOVE…read more "Women are Crazy because Men are A*****!" You got to see this ... ^^traumatic - ^^hilarious - ^^relationships of all kinds ! ! ! With now days insane serial dating... and always looking for something better ((instead of searching within yourself first)).... Relationships have become a beautiful nightmare...... simply: confused dot com AND This "so here right now" play with its gifted cast which was perfectly bouncing of each other cracked us up from start to finish. This intelligent play was one of my favorite ones I have seen, as it is so merciless honest !!! Even with a smart New Yorker audience, am convinced everyone could recognize themselves at some point. Yes this a pretty genius piece !!!!! You could go with your other half or a date... that will be fun !!! A MUST--IF YOU STILL CAN GET TICKETS-- !!!! The Cherry Lane theatre: "Oh my"... this is the cutest charming theatre which is located at a tree lined old fashion cobble street and fairytale houses, the inside is as wonderful: intimate, comfy, simple, it is just right. My friend said she saw many plays here and all of them were exceptional. OH YES I WILL BE BACK ---- this is a hidden diamond --- DO GO and you will see what am talking about.

Photos
Women are Crazy Because Men are A**holes
Women are Crazy Because Men are A**holes
Women are Crazy Because Men are A**holes

See all

The Second City New York - comedyclubs - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...