Nice place with standout desserts. Food: 4 Atmosphere: 4 Service: 4 Cost to worth it rating: 3 Opentableable: no but Toast Return worthiness: sure Highlights - Brownie: pecan with caramel. Large, rich, and fudgey and best thing we ate. 5 stars - Key lime pie: one of the best and I've tried 15+. - Fluffy light texture with right amount of lime tang and bit of meringue up top. 5 stars - Short rib: standout savory item of the night. - Tender on the bone and savory gravy like sauce. 4.75 stars - Sushi: my friends shared a roll and said it was outstanding. 4.5 stars - Creme brulee: can get combo chocolate and vanilla minis 4 stars - Pork chop: tender and hefty slices. Said chimmichuri which was the reason why my friend ordered it but didn't see any. 4 stars - Rib eye: quality steak and cook. 4 stars - Snow crab claw: can order single medium or large sized. Simple with lemon. 4 stars - Chicken: roasted was good but smaller portion than expected. 4 stars - Mac and cheese: Gouda w cavatsppi corkscrews. Good flavor and not too creamy cheesey flavor was more baked into the noodles themselves. 4 stars - Fries: thin crispy. 3.5 stars - Burrata: hidden under a layer of prosciutto and a crostini underneath. 3 stars - Cocktails: pretty good. I got a coffee old fashioned and hub clarified rum punch which were quality sips. Midlights - Shrimp: was excited for the area special pinks but weren't anything outstanding. Soft rolls with cheese baked in on the top were good. 3 stars Lowlights - Cocktail timing: got them 1 by 1 and took a while before all 4 of us had ours before our meal. read more

See all

Hidden gem just off the Overseas Hwy...my friend found this spot and recommended it very highly so made it a point to come here for vacation date night / my birth dinner. Parking is anywhere you can find a spot. The restaurant is located on the 2nd floor of the Grassy Flats Resort & Beach Club. They have both indoor and outdoor seating...we sat outside and there was plenty of fans and shade so it was actually quite comfortable. Service was very good...think laid back Florida Keys but classy. They don't rush you between courses, but don't take too long that it is uncomfortable. We started off with drinks. My husband had a Stella Arois and I had Pinot Grigio. We also just went with their tap water, which they were excellent at replenishing throughout dinner. For apps, my husband had the Fried Octopus - he said it was really good and he especially loved the celery, carrot and kalamata olive sofrito. I went with the Roasted Woods...what a unique dish! Crispy roasted Maitake mushrooms with miso cream and toasted hazelnuts. I would definitely this again! For entrees, my husband went with the seared Catch of the day, which was Black Grouper; it comes with pureed sweet potatoes and brussel sprouts. He said it was all delicious. I went with the Cauliflower Steak which was good but I'd like to try something else next time. Maybe a salad or a pasta dish sans meat. I also had the sweet corn and coconut soup....so good! Would definitely have again! I already came with dessert on my mind when I saw they had a Bread Pudding but alas, this is only sold at the Grassy Flats Market now. I did go for the Guava cheesecake which was phenomenal...you can truly taste the home baked feel to it. All in all - Definitely coming back again! Hopefully before they close for September! read more

See all

Very cute place with a nice terrace qith water view on a beautiful beach on second floor FYI i had a bit trouble finding :) its in the grassy flats resort. The staff was very friendly and attentive from the start. The menu was small but had land and sea options as well as vegetarian. The filet is amazing!!! The ahi tuna was good but has quite a bit going on as far as flavors. Overall nice choice. read more

See all

The service was terrible. There were 10 of us to celebrate a milestone birthday. It took almost 10 minutes before a waitress showed up to greet us and take our drink order. The first cocktail showed up 10 minute later and the last one 20 minutes later. The drinks were just ok. She took appetizer for half of the table and 15 minters later for the other half of the table. The entrees were spread over a 10 minute period. I would say that the appetizers and main courses were very good, but certainly not outstanding. The deserts were good but they ran out of bread pudding and limited other deserts. Oh, and for spending over $1,000, you would think they would at least have a cupcake with a candle for a birthday girl. The setting was nice out on the deck area. Although for our 7:30 reservation, we had to wait 10-15 minutes for them to set up a table. read more

We had the most incredible experience at the rhum house. Zach and Robbie were great with recommendations on drinks and food ! Fantastic conversation and vibes ! Tuna tartare, fish dip and the paw paw martini was great ! Service was perfect. 10/10 read more

The weather was much nicer on this trip than it was the last time we were here, so we were able to sit outside on the deck. What a beautiful view, even after the sun went down and the full moon came out. Derek was our server, and the food and service were impeccable. He said it is not the same chef as a year ago. How could it be even better than thelast time we were here? But it sure was! We started with grilled prawns, which were enormous, Rhum House Spritz, and I ordered the Jamaican mango escovitch black grouper while RJ ordered the broiled black grouper with lime butter. The food was phenomenal; the Rhum House is outstanding. We want to come back to stay on the property and work our way through the menu. Except I will just keep ordering the grouper. We finished with cheesecake on a ladyfinger crust. What?? Whoever heard of such a thing? I'll only be eating my cheesecake with ladyfinger crusts going forward, thanks. read more

See all

Great staff and amazing food. The wait staff friendly and knowledgeable. The 20 oz prime ribeye, ahi tuna, mushrooms, and truffle fries were fantastic. I asked for salt with my steak and they served Maldon salt it was amazing. I would highly recommend the Rhum House. Inside had a boathouse / speakeasy feel and the outdoor patio was great. read more

The Rhum House - This is our view from the patio looking over the water. - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Marathon, Florida

My bf and I came back here for date night and the service was unbelievably bad. I wanted to leave and go somewhere else but my bf insisted we see how long it took for the bartender to acknowledge us. It took about 15 minutes for him to come over and ask us what we wanted to drink and then another 20/30 for him to make and give the drinks to us. In the meantime, he was walking around, cleaning glasses, talking with the servers, etc. ... no sense of urgency to take care of us -- not to mention they weren't busy. We were the only people seated at the bar. By the time our drinks came we were starving and decided we would stay to eat because we didn't want to drive elsewhere and waste more time. We ordered the shishito peppers, the tapioca fried octopus, and the kale Caesar salad. The only dish that was good was the octopus, so much so that we ordered another one. The peppers were not even charred and had zero flavor. The salad had a weird taste from the dressing. This was such a let down from the last time we came. Will not be coming back for a while. read more

See all

This was by far the best meal we had in Marathon. Service was excellent. It's a little out of the way and signage isn't very good but once you get there it's a great experience. read more

Exceptional service, attention, ambience and food. We celebrated Valentines Day and had a wonderful time. The staff from COO to servers are outstanding. read more

Food was amazing. There is a desert between Islamorada and Marathon for good food. This changed that. Definitely need to stop in the restaurant or upstairs patio for a drink and some snacks. Make sure to checkout the market before you leave as well . read more

Five stars simply isn't enough. The food, ambience, and service were all on point. Definitely one of the top three steaks I've ever had in my life. I cannot recommend this restaurant enough. read more

We enjoyed our visit to Rhum House on Grassy Key. Ambiance: lots of attention to detail went into the decor. We felt like we were aboard a luxury cruise ship while sitting at the bar. It is a very inviting space, and upstairs, they have another bar with a fantastic view of the water. It was windy, so we opted for inside. Service: Erich was our bartender, and he was great! My husband loved his cocktails, especially the espresso martini. Food: We shared a Caesar salad and the bison tenderloin. I loved the fried plantains on the salad, and our tenderloin was cooked perfectly. I forgot to snap a pic. We saved room for some bread pudding, and it did not disappoint. We saw the chef passing by and thanked him for his beautiful creations. Our bill came in a tiki cocktail book-clever. If you're looking for a dinner "experience," Rhum House delivers and is excellent for a date night, cocktail, or friend gatherings. read more

See all

Great food. Great service. Strongly recommend this restaurant for fresh seafood and delicious appetizers.

Nice outdoor atmosphere with a reasonably priced menu. Roof top and ocean view. Live music. Good variety from a small menu. Everything tasted great! Service was good! read more

See all

We are Marathon residents and have dined here 3 times. Tonight, our third time will be our LAST. They bill themselves as "Matathons Premier Dining Experience " however they most certainly are not. I ordered the "premium ribeye special " at 85.00 should have been excellent, it was not! My steak was bland, tasted like it was previously frozen, and served bare on a plate with NO presentation whatsoever. My wife had the black grouper and in the 15 years we lived here it was the first time she had to use a knife to cut it! At almost 300.00 for two people one deserves an enjoyable, tasty and excellent dining experience. The inside dining room was extremely noisy, service was rushed and the food mediocre at best. There are many other great restaurants in Marathon, this used to be one of them but they have fallen way off that chart. read more

The Rhum House is one of my favorite restaurants in Marathon. The food is consistently terrific, the ocean views are absolutely beautiful, and the drinks are strong and well-made. The service is always friendly and attentive, which makes the experience even better. I definitely recommend stopping by if you're in Marathon, Florida! read more

The Rhum House ambience is great! They have a beautiful indoor dining and a covered patio with a great ocean view! We opted to sit outside as we went around 615, so the weather was perfect at this time (not too hot)! We were greeted right away when we arrived and our server was very nice and attentive. The menu isn't huge and is different than most keys restaurant options. My husband started with 6 raw oysters and I did the key west pink shrimp cocktail. The key west pinks are always a good choice and are nice and plump! For our entrees we shared the scallops and the snapper. Both were just okay, I really was not impressed and honestly didn't eat much of either. The food presentation was nice! Scallops entree came with 3 large scallops over a corn polenta ($40), I did enjoy the polenta but the scallops lacked flavor and were honestly under cooked in the middle. The snapper entree actually was a decent size fish and had sounded very good/flavorful on the menu but the flavor of the dish/fish was underwhelming. The brussels sprouts were good. We did get the chocolate croissant bread pudding with a scoop of vanilla ice cream which I did really enjoy. Highlights of the meal was the key west pinks, dessert, and dinner view from the patio! read more

The Rhum House - Scallops entree - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

We attended this fine restaurant twice during our stay at the Grssy Flats. By far this was the best restaurant in the area and we tried several others. The atmospher is great and the Chef really knows what he is doing. The service was great. We Highly recommend this restaurant. read more

Highly recommend! The service was super attentive but also chill! The roof top bar was an amazing start to a fantastic experience! We had a party of 12 and everyone loved their meals! The steaks, tuna, snapper, lamb, scallops - all very very good! The cocktails and desserts were also top notch!! read more

We are staying at Grassy Flats so we had to try out the breakfast. Beautiful outdoor seating area with great views! The server was excellent! Super friendly. It took awhile for the food to arrive but we are on island time so thanks alright :) Hubby got the fruit which was amazingly fresh! Everything was so good! I got the farm fresh eggs. Over medium. The eggs were cooked perfectly. Bacon was crisp and the potatoes were delicious as well. Prices are about what you'd expect for a hotel restaurant. read more

See all

I would like to start this review by saying that the food was exceptional. Unfortunately, it took over an hour to get to us and was spaced out in an incredibly bizarre fashion. They sent several items out randomly and gave our drinks to the wrong table. Supposedly they had a system error and presented us with a check that was significantly less than the amount that was run on our credit card. On top of that, the manager was incredibly dismissive to any feedback and rude towards the female guests at our table, speaking over them instead of listening to the feedback they were trying to give. The restaurant was beautiful but spending two and a half hours waiting for food and drinks. I would have been happy to explain our concerns if we were allowed to instead of being dismissed, but unfortunately that was not the case. I sincerely hope the restaurant can turn around their front of house staff, because the food was excellent. read more

Great ambiance, service, and surroundings. Great place to celebrate a birthday. Not too touristy which is nice. A little pricey but we needed a place like this in Marathon. read more

The Rhum House - Bar - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

Ate here 2 nights while staying at Grassy Flats Resort. Excellent food, every dish was either 4 or 5 stars. Highlights were a 20oz ribeye and all the salads. Very high quality of all ingredients. Would dock half a star for some slow service and missing items off the menu, but overall a great dining experience. read more

Food was awesome, drinks were insane, service was impressive, and vibe was on point. This is a must try joint in the middle keys! Rooftop bar upstairs with live music is the cherry on top. read more

Great modernized atmosphere and amazing fresh food. Ribeye and drinks were delicious and our server was amazing.

The food was very good and the service was excellent. Will definitely recommend. Ambiance was very noticeable nice.

We've been wanting to try Rhum House for some time and we will definitely be back. We are locals and always looking for a high quality dining experience. It is a beautiful spot with a well appointed dining room with tables and bar seats. We sat on the veranda and the breeze and fans were perfect even though it was a very hot evening. Our server Rachel was fantastic, more impressive as it was her first day at Rhim. I had an aperol spritz that was wonderful with slices of blood orange and my husband had a nice white wine. For appetizer we shared the crab cake and the burnt ends. First, both were HUGE. The crab cakes were served in 3 large "hush puppy" size portions, with almost pure crab lightly breaded and fried, served with a nice chipotle mayo. Delicious. And I'm a crab cake snob. . The burnt ends was a large portion as well and delicious with the bbq sauce and charred pineapple. It was too much for the two of us but we managed. For our entrees my husband had the NY strip and I had black grouper blackened with the beurre blanc sauce. Both were perfectly cooked and delicious. The strip came with charred brussel sprouts which were fantastic. The asparagus and goat cheese mash was wonderful with my fish. My fish was clearly fresh and wonderful. For dessert we shared the bread pudding with vanilla ice cream and it was to die for. Cinnamon bread pudding (think Cinnabon) with a cream sauce and vanilla ice cream. Way way good. We sadly didn't have time to try the rooftop bar but it is gorgeous and we can't wait to come back for one of their awesome craft cocktails. Just a couple of notes for context. We are from NYC/NJ and have extremely high expectations. We were highly anxious but very pleasantly surprised. We were told they have a new chef and the menu will be changing with more seafood diversity, which I think will be awesome. We will be back and we encourage you to as wel read more

See all

Visited the Rhum House last Friday for dinner with a couple of friends. It is pretty new, so it was all our first visit. First impression of Grassy Flats resort and Beach Club was clean and fresh nostalgic throwback to the updated slightly larger than boutique resort. To rooftop bar is comfortably spread out with plenty of warm breezy ocean views. Short bar menu offers a great (albeit small) grilled octopus. The Rhum House restaurant wasn't too busy at 7pm. The decor is nautical theme with tables 270 degrees around a center bar, and looks brand new. The service was very attentive and shared all their personal favorites for us to consider. Their homemade bacon bourbon smoked old fashion cocktail was a highlight. Everyone in our party enjoyed their meals and gave compliments to the chef: salad with grilled chicken, Caesar salad with blackened shrimp, beef filet mignon, and flank steak. All cooked to the correct temperature. Special mention about the amazing grilled cauliflower side. Didn't have the room to try any dessert ... this time. read more

Delicious. I'm from Hawaii and the ahi was as good or better. Highly recommended! I will dream of it and be back soon! I can't wait to try the bread pudding and I am now so sad I didn't get the salad with seared grapes...the staff is super attentive and friendly. I don't even love butternut squash and I would not share any bite because I want it all!!!! read more

The Rhum House - Wait staff - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

What a delightful and beautiful place. I'm staying in the hotel so I wanted to just have a light meal before bed to go and so glad I chose to walk down rather than drive somewhere to eat. Nikko is a pleasure to talk with and has a delicious menu! He speaks with passion about the food and that speaks volumes of the vibe. The entire staff was so friendly & accommodating. Although I only got a salad and a side of broccolini the salad was Delicious! The blackened shrimp were surprisingly filling, (I am a very light eater to be clear), and the combination of fruits and greens with warmed goat cheese was perfect. Simple dressing and a toasted side of bread, the perfect light meal for a beachside evening. The restaurant is open to the public and the view is spectacular. This is definitely a place to try if you're in the area. read more

Food was mid waited an hour and an half to get food they can't saying that they were short staffed wouldn't be surprised if they closed over night. Waitress was so nice plus the manager just the service was not good. I hope this place gets better but in the short time do not come here go to Frank's grill ! Other than that the food was great and the view is amazing. read more

The Rhum House - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Fair is fair. After the staff at the Rhum House reached out and invited us back we decided to give them another chance. Our appetizer and dinner were plated beautifully and delicious. The staff did a good job of ensuring our food and drinks met and exceeded our expectations. We are glad we gave them another opportunity and were not disappointed! read more

Best ambiance, best drinks in the Keys! We had sweetest waitress Tracy, she gave us the best experience of our lives here in the keys with expert drink recommendations and food recommendations! We recommend the rum flight, cevice, octopus, and blueberry pound cake. The views of the ocean are incredible also! We visited twice so far and plan a third visit this week, we will visit here everytime we return to the keys! A must when visiting the marathon! read more

We dined here for our 27 year anniversary based on the recommendation of our realtor. Our server Olivia and the staff were great, very friendly and it seemed they all worked well together. However, this is the first anniversary where we dined at a nice restaurant where nothing was offered, not even a card celebrating our special occasion. The food was ok but some of the menu items were very high priced. We recommend you honor these occasions and put a celebratory card and offer complimentary wine or dessert as people celebrate their special time with you. You should also get bug fans for outside so that guests are not constantly swatting flies while they're eating their fancy meals. Doing simple things like this will keep guests coming back to dine with you for years to come. read more

Beautiful spot. Food was outstanding staff was lovely as well. Great views in a cozy comfy spot. Definitely will return

Drinks were outstanding so was the food. The bartender was very king and knowledgeable about the keys, the drinks, the hotel. Definitely go back. read more

Stopped at this beautiful restaurant to hopefully see the sunset but it would be perfect the sunrise instead! Our waiter Caden was absolutely amazing! We decided to just have a quick appetizer and drink, so we decided on the Tropical Burnt Ends and can I tell you, mouthwatering! Never had BBQ sauce with Guava before but so glad that we tried! read more

See all

Had a really memorable dinner here for my partner's birthday a few months ago. Excellent food and great service. The team here clearly really cares about attention to detail and providing quality food that is a little different than what you can find elsewhere in the Keys. Can't wait until I can go back! read more

My girlfriend and I had dinner at the Rhum house during our vacation. Had a little trouble finding the place when the cab driver dropped us off. Thanks to his help we found the entrance. It is definitely a hidden gem! Absolutely worth a visit! read more