Cancel

Open app

Search

The Old York Tavern

4.4 (10 reviews)

The Old York Tavern Photos

Business Info

THE OLD YORK TAVERN ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

More like The Old York Tavern

Recommended Reviews - The Old York Tavern

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Gnudi
Troy P.

This is a high energy restaurant with a cool upscale casual diner vibe. The staff is super friendly and attentive, and the chef is uber talented. Everything was delicious, but my favorite dishes were the boquerones and the gnudi.

Interior - Sunday night
Jen A.

Our first time here, and I'm happy to report that I have a new favourite squash dish in Toronto! To be fair, I didn't already have one, but still-- this one came with the most wonderfully rich sauce, and it was terrific. I ate it with some of my fellow diner's fries, and together, this was a great pairing; I wish this dish came with fries on its own! Meanwhile, I'm sad to say that the burger was a miss; it was a bit burned on the outside, and very pink on the inside. Perhaps it was an off-night, since we came during a sudden rush. We would've ordered another entree, but the menu is quite limited. We were able to walk in without waiting, but the place soon filled up with groups, couples, and families. By the end of our meal, it was too hard to speak to each other, because the music and the fellow diners were so loud. I would try this place again; perhaps for brunch-- though the server said that sometimes, there's a 2-hour wait! Luckily, this place takes brunch reservations; a rarity in Toronto.

Tavern Burger & Frites
Jeslyn X.

Their Chicken Liver Mousse was amazing! There was a liver taste, but it wasn't heavy. The overall flavour profile had a sweet and sour tone and was super smooth. If you can handle liver, I promise you'll fall in love with it after the first bite. The burger was also fantastic. Fresh beef patty with charred onion, melted cheddar, and flavorful aioli sauce - the best burger I've had recently (although I haven't had many burgers lately, lol). The lemonade tasted great, just a bit pricey. Service was nice too, attentive and crisp. It's a nice spot with a patio and cute lights, perfect for a summer hangout. Food (quality, creativity, consistency) - 4.5/5 Drinks (quality, variety) - 4/5 Ambience (interior design, cleanliness) - 4/5 Service (courtesy, knowledge, timeliness) - 4/5 Value (quality vs. price) - 3.5/5 OVERALL - 4

Interior
Reston S.

Stopped by Old York Restaurant Tavern on a rainy day to catch up with some friends. It's a cozy spot with a classic diner vibe that's perfect for smaller groups (tables mostly suit parties of four or fewer). It does get busy, so arriving early is your best bet if you want a seat. The service was great, friendly and attentive without being overbearing. We ordered the salmon breakfast and the classic breakfast plate with scrambled eggs, bacon, salad, and bread. The salmon was fresh and flavourful, while the classic plate was solid too. Personally, I prefer my scrambled eggs less runny, but that's just personal taste--it was still a satisfying meal overall. If you're after a laid-back brunch in a casual setting, Old York is a solid choice.

French toast and classic breaky with fresh squeeze orange juice
Alanna R.

Such a good homey non pretentious vibe. Really good ingredients, everything is well cooked but doesn't break the bank. Menu has some unique stuff that makes you want to keep going back. Staff is also super nice and friendly. New fave spot and will be going back soon!

See all

8 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Beer Bar 120 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

CRAFT Beer Market Toronto - Seared Tuna Sandwich

CRAFT Beer Market Toronto

3.5(235 reviews)
2.5 km•Church-Yonge Corridor, Downtown Core
•$$

We are visiting for the first time and were out walking looking for a lunch spot. Randomly found…read morethis place and decided to give it a try. We couldn't believe how welcoming the staff was and how great the drinks and food were. The French Dip was the best I've ever had. Could not recommend Craft Beer Market more, we will be going every time we come back to Toronto!

Craft Beer Market is a restaurant located at Yonge and Adelaide & walking distance from the TTC…read more Craft has one of the largest selection in beers both local and international. I recommend making a reservation especially on weekends as they can get busy. From 2-5pm and 9pm-Close they offer Happy Hour specials daily except on Sunday's which is offered all day. Walked in and requested table for 2 but hostess provided no timeframe as to how long it would take as there were other reservations. Bar was mostly full and we waited about 30 minutes. No table still but some seats became available at the bar. Strange how on OpenTable it showed availability when they said no tables available. Service at the bar was great! Very attentive despite it being a very large bar with many seats filled at capacity. Ordered a couple of drinks and food from the menu shortly after. Got their Fried Pickles and Prosciutto & Arugula Pizza to share. Overall, food was fresh and wait time to receive the food was reasonable. Except, pizza was a bit salty I think this was due to the cheese on top. Fried pickles were A-OK, lightly battered and paired well with the house made beer ranch dipping sauce. I'd recommend checking out Craft during happy hour to get the best value for both food and drinks but expect there to be a bit of a crowd! Cheers!

Photos
CRAFT Beer Market Toronto - Ambiance

Ambiance

CRAFT Beer Market Toronto - Rocket Katsu Chicken Salad

Rocket Katsu Chicken Salad

CRAFT Beer Market Toronto - Seared Tuna Sandwich & Yam Fries

See all

Seared Tuna Sandwich & Yam Fries

Za Cafe Pizzeria + Bar - Truffle Mac n' Cheese

Za Cafe Pizzeria + Bar

4.2(43 reviews)
2.2 km•Financial District, Bay Street Corridor, Downtown Core

We decided to check out this rather innocuous looking pizza spot near my husband's office one…read morenight, and we were happy with our experience. The room is small, and the service was friendly. We shared a Caesar salad to start, which was simple but good. We had the duck confit white pizza and the Iberian red pizza. They were both quite tasty, and I reheated them the next morning on the frying pan for breakfast! They had some decent wines to choose from as well. Overall, we were both impressed with the good simple pizza. I think we've both kind of reached a saturation point with pretentious pizza spots, so this was a nice find in the middle of the financial district.

We were staying at a hotel nearby and picked this Italian restaurant within walking distance…read more It's a cozy small restaurant with a small bar area. The food overall was fantastic: Caesar Salad - 4/5 very good, with crispy prosciutto and shaved Parmesan. The dressing had a tangy kick but was on the lighter side. Spaghetti Seafood - 5/5 YUMMY! There were large tiger shrimp, clams, mussels, calamari, and salmon in a white wine tomato sauce. So good, loved the variety of seafood. One of better seafood pasta dishes I've had. Mushroom Mafalda - 5/5 HEAVEN! Mafalda pasta with four different mushrooms: cremini, oyster, portobello, and porcini. It's cooked in a truffle cream sauce and is a mushroom lover's dream! Absolutely delicious. The server was friendly but not attentive. She forgot a beer we ordered. Aside from that the food was overall so good I would most definitely come back again.

Photos
Za Cafe Pizzeria + Bar
Za Cafe Pizzeria + Bar - Fig Pizza

Fig Pizza

Za Cafe Pizzeria + Bar

See all

17 Tiles - 17 Tiles -  Chicken Wings plus $8pp Unlimited Board Game Play

17 Tiles

4.7(3 reviews)
3.1 km•Bay Street Corridor, Downtown Core

17 Tiles Board Games & Mahjong Cafe is a board games and cafe (drinks, mocktails, and finger food,…read morecandies). It opened at the end of Mar 2023. The second floor has the board games and cafe. The third floor is the Mahjong. We played many different board games. There are 2 big cabinets of board games. There should be more. We ordered the following food: 1. Hanamikoji Mocktail ($9.99). 2. Treasure of Sumatra Mocktail ($8.99). 3. Teddy Bear Milk Tea ($6.99). 4. Flat White (small $4.99). 5. Potato Wedges ($6.99). 6. Chicken Tenders ($9.99). 7. 17 Tiles Dusted Wings ($14.99) with Chipotle Mango sauce. The mocktails were pretty and tasty. The Teedy Bear is made of ice. All the food was good, except the batter on the Chicken Tenders was too thick; the chicken was tender. The service was good. For 3 people, our games and food totaled $86.93. I toured the Mahjong rooms on the third floor out of curiosity. The setup was good. To play unlimited board games, it costs $3/p. To play in private Mahjong rooms, it costs $20/h/p. For VIP Mahjong rooms (including drinks), it costs $30/h/p. For wheelchair accessibility, you must enter an elevator at the back of the building. There is free WiFi. The place is wheelchair accessible. On each floor, there are separate male/female washrooms and one gender-neutral washroom that is wheelchair accessible. There is paid neighbourhood street parking. Review 2023-404

Really good selection of new board games! And also a large selection of snacks. Also plenty of…read morelarge tables.

Photos
17 Tiles - Board games

Board games

17 Tiles - 17 Tiles - K2 Peak, Hawaiian Wave, Noman's Land Rose mocktails

17 Tiles - K2 Peak, Hawaiian Wave, Noman's Land Rose mocktails

17 Tiles - 17 Tiles -  Unlimited Board Game Play

See all

17 Tiles - Unlimited Board Game Play

Bar Maaya - Inside

Bar Maaya

4.5(4 reviews)
1.6 km•Entertainment District, Downtown Core, Waterfront Communities-The Island

We had a bit of a wait before dinner so we hopped in here for a drink. It was relatively quiet with…read moreonly a couple tables filled and no one at the bar. We ordered the Lychee Bliss and Smokey Sapphire. It took almost 20 mins before we received our drinks and by the time we got it, our dinner table was ready. My lychee drink was quite good and tasted like a mild flavored lychee. My only complaint is they added a large ice cube in the coupe martini glass which I have never had before in all the martini style glasses of cocktails I've had (very odd to us). It left very little room for the actual liquid which only gave me a few sips. My partner did enjoy his at least.. Besides the long wait and downside of the added ice in my drink, the bartenders were great and the space inside was quite nice.

Overall: A // 5 stars…read more Upscale, spacious, and comfortable bar that was surprisingly empty on a Saturday night. Their drinks are high class with expertly crafted flavor profiles incorporating flavors from around the world covering a wide range of palettes, and matching aesthetic. Highly recommend checking their menu out! (Saffron Spice: A+) - This is THE cocktail of Bar Maaya, highlighted by the mesmerizing fire show wrapped around the cocktail. I was pleasantly surprised by the forward saffron flavor given the subtleness of the spice; this is a spotlight cocktail well done. (Smokey Trails: A) - Another experience-based cocktail filled with smoke and served on the rocks using their custom engraved temple eye ice cube. The flavor profile is just a classic mezcal with a dash of smoke, but this is also done well to be easy on the palette. Food: +1 Presentation: +2 Price: E Atmosphere: E Service: E Menu: +1 Overall: 5 stars Insta/Beli/Yelp/TikTok: @amei_eats

Photos
Bar Maaya - Insta/Beli/Yelp/TikTok: @amei_eats

Insta/Beli/Yelp/TikTok: @amei_eats

Bar Maaya - Lychee Bliss and Smokey Sapphire

Lychee Bliss and Smokey Sapphire

Bar Maaya

See all

The Old York Tavern - beerbar - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...