We stopped by for a post-dinner libation, so we didn't get to try the food and sat at the bar. What a cool bar vibe. I loved the neon sign, the bar lighting and how cool and friendly the bartenders were. I ordered a dirty martini, but was immediately jealous of my husband's frozen pina colada. I usually don't order frozen, blended drinks but this was more like a real cocktail... it was super smooth and not icy, very rum-forward, flavorful and refreshing and not too cloyingly sweet. I might have helped him finish it. Get one, you won't regret it! I'd love to go back and try the food but this was a great nightcap. read more

Casual, diner-like feel. Attentive and quick service. In short - good bar food , great cocktails. The deviled eggs have pronounced acidity, which is great given how rich they are. The curds were light, gooey, but a bit salty. The trout dip was great. The cheeseburger was outstanding, cheesy, juicy, and the pickle added good crunch and contrast. All of the cocktails we tried were excellent. read more

See all

Dangerously close to where I live, the Long Island Bar has become a beloved entry into my list of local joints to grab a good bite and sip. For those who appreciate old-school New York, you'll love the vintage diner interior as well as the amazing neon signage out front. It truly is a blast from the past. On to the food! Having tried a few things on the menu I can say without a doubt that my favorites are the deviled crab toast, the smoked trout spread (it comes with Triscuits!), and of course the L.I. BURGER. So good and hits that burger spot especially with the fries. For drinks I stick with the White Negroni Sbagliato or the cognac French 75. I love a good classic cocktail. Fun trivia: Over the summer (2025), they filmed a scene here in the new Devil Wears Prada 2 movie. I'm hoping when it comes out next year, the scene is kept in the movie, but I also don't want this place to be swarmed by dumb tourists looking to reenact Andy's dance moves outside. read more

See all

I've been trying to try out the "Long Island Bar" for a while now. It's always insanely packed and rightfully so. What's not too love about an Americana style modern diner! My boyfriend and I were celebrating our 3 year anniversary and wanted to go somewhere special. I had the day and wanted to be literally the first person in and we were. It filled up while we enjoyed the course. I started with a pricey gin martini and lemme tell ya...it was worth it! Damn! Probably one of the best martinis I've partaken in. Ingredients: "Hepple Gin, Dassai 50 Junmai Daiginjo Sake, Lustau Blanco Vermut, house bergamot/pomelo tincture." Delectable! My boyfriend ordered a beer, Kolsch. We started with deviled eggs. So classic and fantastic. I was drawn to the smoked trout dip! Love fishy dips! As a girl, I'm into the salty snacks and little bites. So I ordered that and roasted beets that had some hazelnuts and delicious brandied cherries. I was in heaven with both dishes. My boyfriend ordered the burger and fries. The burger came with an American flag toothpick jammed into the top of the bun. So American! I managed to snag some of the fries. I really could not be happier with all the decisions we made. Thank you LIB for being a great anniversary spot. read more

See all

The food is very good. Loved the cheese curds and burger. Love the classic old diner like feel. Kind of annoying the way they take names for reservations and that they won't call your phone when it's your turn, and they seem kind of overwhelmed at the front with how busy they are but they're always like that so you would think they'd be more prepared. read more

The Long Island Bar - The L. I. Burger - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Another institution with a well earned reputation. Rustic vibes with classic cocktails in a bustling space. I mean what mire could you need. Dates, business meetings, pregames. The possibilities are endless here. Bartenders making classics the classic way... if you like watching bartenders craft drinks, come here. It is art. Of course, it was frozen cocktail season so i got a mix of the frozen cosmo and frozen pina colada. I may never sip something tastier ever again. Just an overall fun place to be. Full of love, booze, and bad decisions! read more

See all

The Long Island Bar is located in Brooklyn Heights, not that fish shaped chunk of land as the name would suggest. I have seen this place many times but each time I was having brunch across the street at Colonie. Its Art Deco inspired exterior and neon signage and classic looking interior were all aesthetics that spoke to me and I have wished they were open for brunch many times. Recently, circumstances brought me to Brooklyn Heights one night (around 8pm) and my partner and I were hungry! We were going to go to Colonie at first but when I saw the neon signage all lit up and the exterior bustling with activity, I knew this was my chance to finally check out The Long Island Bar. The Long Island Bar was opened in 1951 by Ramon Montero. His daughter and her husband would take it over and run the establishment for 50 years! In 2013 Joel Tompkins and Toby Cecchini restored and reopened the restaurant and continue to run it to this day. The interior of the restaurant is beautiful. Wood booths line the restaurant on the left while the right side has a long bar. The wood is beautiful and each booth has a small light installed off to the side. At our booth there was a bowling ball next to the window, a whimsical decoration. Adding some nice color to the restaurant were Christmas lights strung along the walls and the bar. The bar is also gorgeous featuring wonderful shelves behind the bartenders. I was instantly comfortable and awed at the same time. The hostess was very nice and seated us immediately. Our waitress appeared within seconds. The menu is not huge so it's not hard to figure out what you want. We ordered and in no time at all food was coming at us. Here's what we had: FROZEN EGG NOG This is a seasonal drink with spices, cognac, bourbon and rum. It has the consistency of a slushie and it is, without a doubt of the best cocktails I have ever had. The consistency was perfect, it was refreshing, creamy and spicy with the perfect liquor flavor. I split this with my partner but I'll tell you, if I wasn't driving I would have wanted one all for myself! SMOKED TROUT SPREAD (with cream cheese, trout roe, and triscuits) This is a fun dish. The Triscuits help balance out the decadence of the trout roe and the cream cheese is a nice vehicle to spread onto the Triscuits. This was nice and tasty without being over-salty. We wound up asking for a few more Triscuits so we could finish off the roe and cream cheese! PANISSE (crispy chickpea fritters with almond pesto rosso, pine nut, garrotxa goat cheese, and lemon) This was a really interesting dish. The crispy chickpea fritters are rectangular in shape and the rest of the ingredients are layered on top. I highly recommend you make sure to get a bit of every ingredient in your bite, using a piece of the fritter as a foundation. It's a wonderful savory and sweet combination that also has fun textures. The chew of the fritters contrast nicely with the pine nut crunch with the goat cheese kind of being an in between texture to smooth everything out. A really nice appetizer! THE L. I. BURGER (Two dry-aged beef patties, pickles, cheese, fancy sauce, & fries) The L.I. Burger was definitely the centerpiece of our meal. It's not the biggest burger ever but that's okay because it was delicious! The patties were perfectly cooked and juicy. The cheese and "fancy sauce" (think a better version of McDonalds' "secret sauce") were fantastic too. The fries were excellent, with a crisp outside and nice and chewy center. Thanks to the double patties, I had to use a fork to keep my half of the burger together, so be warned! I *loved* my experience at The Long Island Bar. I was super happy to see that the place not only *looks* cool but it also has awesome service and food. Check it out! read more

We had the burger here, and it was alright. Not bad per se, but the meat was not as juicy and a tad dry. I think I prefer 7th st burger over this. Their fries were good though. We had a gimlet mocktail ($12 vs $18) and a scotch/soda. The gimlet was good and the latter was a little too bland for my taste but that's probably on me. We came in at 5:30 on a Saturday and we were able to get a table right away as it seems that the tables are reserved for patrons who are ordering food and there were a few empty tables even though the standing room/bar area was crowded and turning people away. read more

The Long Island Bar - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Everytime I walk by this bar, it is always poppin' with people filling up the bar inside and the outdoor tables. We decided to come check it out on a Thursday evening and were able to grab a table in the back. The space has an old school retro, diner vibe to give it a charm. They were quick to provide water for us and were consistent with the refills as well. For drinks, we had the Dolores Del Rio ($16) and Kings County Distillery LIB Single Cask ($18). The Dolores had a nice refreshing taste with a jalapeño kick, which I enjoyed. To pair with our drinks, we nibbled on the Cheese Curds ($14) as well. I have always been indifferent about cheese curds, but the ones here were probably the best I've had! They came out piping hot, so the cheese just melted in your mouth with the crunch from the batter. I also really enjoyed the sour cream dip to pair with this as well. Overall, I really enjoyed the items were did order, although the menu is quite limited. The rest of the menu didn't appeal to us too much, but the cheese curds and dolores martini was delicious. read more

See all

authentically timeless, long island bar is refreshingly frozen in simpler times -- terrazzo floors, neon lights, spinning bar stools -- the same design since opening in the 1950's (which includes no reservations). just timeless charm and damn good food LI burger is the move: two dry-aged patties, gooey house-blend american, a tangy fancy sauce, and a bacon wheel lookin like a red onion. Sneaky how good it is -- only gets better with each bite. alongside fries with a golden crisp buzzing and full of energy, long island bar is the foundation for any perfect night in cobble hill (ultimately ending down the street with karaoke at montero's until late night). cobble hill doesn't have many institutions left. this one's the real deal fun fact: ramon montero, original owner of *both* LI bar + montero's, kept these businesses in the family for 50+ years (his son joseph ran montero's + daughter emma ran LI bar) read more

See all

Stylish spot - really enjoyed the cheese curds! Rice lager was great. Dont think i need the spaghettini again - wld love if they offered a veg burger option read more

What a great place in Brooklyn Heights! The drinks are off the charts creative and delicious as is the food! We tried the trout dip appetizer and of course had to have the cheese curds, wow! Classic burger with seasoned fries was outstanding! It's a fun atmosphere, great staff, great drinks and great food! Great place! read more

We waited awhile to get a seat, but I really wanted to go cause I heard such great things. I ordered the burger and I was really happy with it. I'd go back for the vibes. One thing to note, they don't take numbers for the waiting list so you'll have to be around and constantly check in with them. I ended up going to bars around the area to kill time, but we had to keep sending someone to check our spot. Oh when we went there was a private event happening so maybe the wait times are t typically as long as we experienced. read more

The wait: Came on a Saturday night and put our name in for 2 people at 6:29 PM. We were seated at 7:46 in the dining room. Believe the bar is first come first served, so that may be a shorter wait. The drinks: I tried the long island gimlet, the martini, and the improved pendennis club. The martini was absolutely perfect, and the improved pendennis was my second favorite. The food: My boyfriend and I shared the little gem salad, fried cheese curds and LI burger. The cheese curds were by far the best thing we ate, but the burger was also amazing. Overall would return - if only to sit at the bar and drink martinis!! read more

See all

Cocktails and tuna dip were superb. Highly recommend getting multiple things and sharing

Cozy and festive inside with the tastiest cocktails - the Dolores del rio was spicy and fruity without being overwhelmingly sweet. The French fries seemed to be battered and the gem salad was a refreshing balance. read more

Burger took 40 mins to come out, older blonde waitress gave attitude when asked to check on the food. Burger itself was small for the price and not seasoned well. Oh and also charged me more than what I wrote down on the check read more

We love the food, the Martini and the ambiance. Top notch. We love the vintage bar and sitting in a booth.

Great option nearby for drinks. This place has been in the neighborhood for decades. I was confused by its name since it's in Brooklyn. So it was surprising to learn that Brooklyn is technically part of the Long Island mainland! The service was attentive. The interior gave off classic old historic diner vibes. We were the first people there at around 6pm so I was sad to learn that there was no happy hour! The cocktails were really well done priced at 16-18 dollars. I would def come back for a cocktail. I liked the Dolores Del Rio - perfect sour and perfect spice. The Improved Pedennis Club was great too. I liked that the cocktails weren't overly sweet. We shared some fries and cheese curds. Can't really comment on the other food options. read more

Some of the best cheese curds I've had in QUITE some time + an irresistibly delectable burger + great beer + amazing service = highly recommend this place!!! My friend had the trout and loved it as well. Absolutely fantastic spot to stop by for a drink or a bite during your night out in Brooklyn Heights. Was there early Friday evening and the place was extremely lively already! Wonderful ambiance to accompany the great food and drinks. read more

See all

We've passed by this restaurant so many times, but never thought to pop in until our friends suggested it for dinner. They prepared us for a great meal of burgers, cheesecurds, and strong martinis, and they were 100% correct We each ordered our own burgers + fries, cheesecurds for the table, and a gem salad to be healthy. But it was deliciously covered in grated cheese To top it off, we got the strongest martini I've ever had. It was crisp and cold and huge! I dont think they take reservations, but they have another room in the back with more tables so we didn't wait very long Would definitely recommend if you're in the mood for any of the above read more

We were so excited to show our Wisconsin family this Wisconsin bar - we walked a half an hour in the summer heat! When our elderly father went to pull up a chair to a 4 person table outside, the hostess burst outside and announced to the block: "do not rearrange my furniture!" Ok, no problem. Inside, she offered us a few bar seats, while the outdoor seating was readily available. Unfortunately, will not be coming back to what used to be my favorite neighborhood bar. read more

My boyfriend had wanted to come to The Long Island Bar for brunch, however, they did not open until 2:00 p.m. on Sunday so we decided to go to another place to eat. We returned to The Long Island Bar later in the day for a drink and boy were we disappointed in the visit. The staff behind the bar was so rude and unfriendly. The guy said not two words to us and when we put in our drink orders it seemed as though we were putting him out for doing his job. I ordered a dirty martini which was not great and my boyfriend had a glass of Cabernet which was decent. The food did look good and I considered ordering some fries, but decided I would not spend a penny more due to the cold treatment. Not sure what we did to deserve the bad service but I will definitely not be back. Cute little place, hopefully The Long Island Bar can get its act together. read more

This establishment had been suggested to me after I returned from a jaunt to Wisconsin that led me to discover a newfound love for cheese curds. Not the squeaky kind, but the deep fried variety. Naturally, a large plate of those to share was called for, but ironically I ended up preferring our other shared plates more, including the tangy deviled eggs and mild Spanish tortilla. You can only consume so many cheese curds before they instill a strong desire for slumber. My cognac French 75 was good too. read more

The Long Island Bar - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Probably one of my favorite bars in the city. Cocktails are outstanding, service is efficient and friendly. They don't rush you in spite of how busy it gets. Old school diner vibe is cool as hell. read more

Although named The Long Island Bar, this bar is located on a corner in Brooklyn and gives vibes of an old school diner. It was ranked one of the top 500 bars in the world so I wanted to check it out. My first drink was the erin ($16) which was sweet and slightly bitter from the bigallet china amer. My second drink was the dolores del rio ($16) which is one of their more popular drinks. It was spicy from the jalapeño-infused tequila but not too spicy. It was tart from the passionfruit and the lime juice and balanced by the aperol. It was really good and I can see why it's a favorite among locals. For food I ordered the fried cheese curds ($13) which were really good. It's fried and cheesy; how can they not be good? If you want to be transported back in time, this is the watering hole for you. This was a cool place to stop for a couple drinks. read more

See all

Cool retro vibe, packed with people, busy bar and restaurant. We went for the burgers after seeing them featured on some burger show. They're really good! We were lucky to get a table fairly quickly (2ppl), as most of the others waiting were larger parties. We got a drink at the bar during the brief wait. They also transferred our bar tab to the table which is a nice service that most places won't do. (They will make you close out your bar tab before being seated). Burgers were on buttered toasted buns, are doubles (unless you specify that you only want one patty), and have little American flag toothpicks in them which was fun and cute read more

The Long Island Bar - LI burger - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

i just left this place where I was eating with my partner and our two children because the wait at our favorite, Henry Public, was too long. We sat next to a family who had sent a burger back for being undercooked. I guess the next burger came back undercooked as well so they tolt he waitress. Instead of just cooking it fully, they sent the manager out to tell the family that that was just how they cooked their burgers and basically if they didn't like it they could leave. The woman was visibly upset and crying, so she left the table. The manager later came back to tell the family never to come back. I felt really bad for them because actually our burgers were almost raw so we also did not eat them. I won't come back after seeing how the manager treated this lady. read more

The Long Island Bar is the place to be. A limited menu with great drinks, perfect food selection, and reasonable prices. Everyone comes for the martinis, cheese curds, and burgers - and trust me, they do not disappoint. The inside of the bar is no frills, old school booth seating and tables. They also have a good amount of outdoor seating. The inside is cozy and warm, and you can tell people love this place. The whole martinis and burgers idea is very much my vibe and you really can't go wrong. They have traditional martinis along with a special martini on their cocktail menu. Their fried cheese curds are amazing - it's like tempura fried with French onion dipping sauce. The burgers come with thin patties cooked medium with super crispy fries. It's a perfect burger to enjoy with a martini. I've been hear twice and loved it both times. This is an ideal neighborhood spot and you can't go wrong with strong drinks and expertly crafted greasy food. read more

See all

The Long Island bar definitely focuses more on their cocktails than food. I actually came here on a whim on my way back from Brooklyn Bridge Park. There were lots of folks dining out and it looked like a good time, so what the heck! The service was exceptional! Really accommodating and friendly. Things fell short with the food. For one, there's not really a huge food selection, and the items are slightly overpriced in my opinion. I ordered the burger and requested it to be cooked medium rare, I received a well done burger that didn't leave much to be desired.I ended up not eating the whole thing. However, the seasoned fries are very tasty! The puttanesca was also just okay. When we asked for more parmesan on the side, it seemed like a burden. Overall, if you're looking for a nice cocktail this is the place to be! If not, I'd recommend finding another option for food. read more

See all

Last night we went to attend a relative's birthday party. A table of 12 was reserved. Once the table was full and a few other guests started to arrive, the hostess confronted our cousin at the table and demanded to know how many more people were expected. As it was unclear, we asked if any of the other tables were reserved in the back room and if they were available or if we could split off and have some of the party sit at the bar. The hostess responded that if there were more than 12 people, we were required to rent the whole back room at an additional cost. She added that we weren't allowed to stand around in the back room and to stay out of the way of her wait staff. She came back 15 minutes later, making the same speech in front of the whole room. I understand the limitations of running a business in such a small place and the importance of organization and scheduling reservations to maintain some sense of order and flow for the kitchen and staff, but to repeatedly embarrass and humiliate your guests with such arrogance, hostility, and condescension is unforgiveable. If our cousin misunderstood the rules or even if she was blatantly ignoring them, the hostess should have pulled her aside in private for that conversation. Appalling, unprofessional, and disgusting behavior. I'll never go back. read more

We've had The Long Island Bar on our radar for quite some time and finally made it happen. We sat outside, which was nice because it's a nice day. Very much looking forward to dining indoors at a later time. We started with some drinks - The Erin - tasty, like an old fashioned - and Delores Del Rio. VERY spicy! Then we had the cheese curds and salad, very tasty and probably our favorite parts of the meal! Then we had the panisse - which was surprisingly good and unexpected, and a double patty burger with bacon. Now, I would describe the burger as "weird." It tasted good, but very unlike most burgers. Felt a little like it was made of steak-umms pressed together. I don't think I would get it again. My wife suggested perhaps one patty was the way to go, so I guess I would be up for giving that a shot. Overall, very nice experience. Service was very friendly and quick. If I loved the burger, then 5 stars...so I'll hold out for that in the future. Enjoy! read more

See all

Always the best. Great cocktails, love their Manhattans. Burgers and curds every time we go.

I've never met ruder restaurant staff. The hostess is unforgivably unwelcoming. Also there was not one but two hairs in my sandwich. Avoid.

Excellent place for drinks and food. Had the deviled eggs, LI Burger, and Delores Del Rio. All were AMAZING!!! So much so, we got a second order of deviled eggs. I've walked by this place for years and there's always a wait to get in. Happy finally decided to wait and give it a try. Staff was also very welcoming. Will definitely be back and HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!!! read more

Came here after a beach volleyball game, had a good time and the food was solid. The burger was noteworthy and the service was OK. The ambiance is what you would find at a diner. Overall had a good time. read more

This place is legendary. Very nice, old room with lovely booths and an area in the back. Unfortunately it can be very new Brooklyn at times. If you can go on an off night, better. Great drinks. Cheeseburger and white fish. The servers are very friendly. read more

I loved the standard cheeseburger. The quality of the meat is what stood out. The beef was certainly juicy and high end. The waitress was friendly and attentive. Ambiance - I preferred the back area. A little tight but doable. TV with sports was on but could still have conversation. Lest I forget - the drink I had was outstanding - La Japonaise. read more

Their burger has to be one of the best in NYC. It should be on every top 25, and most top 10s. You really tasted the aged meat. Get the double. And actually the rest of the menu is terrific read more

The gem salad is no joke. I know everyone talks about the burger, which is also worth writing home about, but man, that salad. I don't know if it's because I was on a caesar salad kick or what, but I was honestly blown away. It's not a caesar salad nor does it have any of the same ingredients, but for some reason it tasted like caesar salad's cousin. It's made with gem lettuce, tossed with pea shoots, radishes, pepitas, and a generous helping of manchego cheese, all enveloped in a shallot vinaigrette. And croutons! The portion is large so you can easily eat this as your main. Or you can do what I do and order both the salad and the burger and split both with your meal companion. read more

The Long Island Bar - The L. I. Burger - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all