If I could give it less than 1-star I would. I organized a guys night out dinner based on the excellent menu. The menu was all that was good. Calling the food terrible would-be kind. The staff has no idea about the food. Before posting I contacted the restaurant directly for their reaction. It has been 3 weeks and still no response from the owner. Please do not waste your time or your money. There are many other kosher restaurants in the Teaneck area that are worthy of your time and money read more

TERRIBLY RUN- Service and Management are terrible! Placed an order 3 weeks ago and we were missing items. I called several times, each time was told that a manager would call me back. Supposedly, only a manager can issue a refund??!!?? C'mon guys- I have been more than patient here and am chasing you at this point to respond. You know exactly what my refund should be- you know my order number- you already verified what happened- I called minutes after we received the food. You are making excuses. That is NOT how you run a business! I shouldn't have to call over and over and I CERTAINLY SHOULDN'T HAVE TO CHASE YOU! You couldn't pay me to try them again. read more

I went one night. The service was terrible my house burger was gross! it smelled gross. the place was tiny and the tables were small. one of my dads sandwiches was cold. my brother throw up all over the place. read more

The ambiance was good but the restaurant itself was a bit dirty. The food came quick but the service was very slow. There was only one waiter but otherwise the food was really good. One of the chicken wings we got was raw but everything else was good. The fried Oreo's were great!! read more

The Humble Toast - Loaded fries - Sandwiches Near Me - Teaneck, New Jersey

I thought the food here was very very good as was the service. They accommodated for gluten free, they had just the right almond milk. Device was friendly and the food (breakfast) was excellent. I must add that we did have reservations which I HIGHLY recommend. read more

The ambience and customer service was good, but the food was a little lacking. Left me wanting more.

Humble Toast was highway robbery, literally. After having a mediocre dinner at this hole-in-the-wall restaurant, I was presented with the check. I gave my credit card. The manager of the restaurant, who also doubles as a waiter, ran the card and gave me the credit card back with no to leave a tip. I knew something was up. When I asked the manager to print out the receipt, he fumbled for 5 to 10 minutes. To make a long story a little short, he had padded my bill with a bogus 35% tip that I never authorized and did not know about. The manager was rude and did not even apologize for this larceny. Besides, literally stealing money by putting in a bogus tip, not informing me and trying to cover it up, this restaurant was horrible. -There were four diners at our table. Each main dish was served one at a time. By the time, all four plates were on the table, three of the entrees were stone cold. -I ordered the basic burger with onions. There were no onions. The bun was twice as big as the burger. The same thing with the pastrami sandwich: lots of bread, a little bit of pastrami. -The water glasses were dirty. -The staff were untrained and rude. One of the waiters spilled water all over the floor. Another one dropped a dish. I felt like I needed to take shelter under the table. I am going to report this shady, disreputable trash can to the Better Business Bureau. It is establishments like this that need to be weeded out so that kosher restaurants, many which are good and run by responsible people, do not continue to be be tainted by the rotten apple in the barrel. read more

Very sweet staff. I ordered the sweet potato fries and regular fries and they were one of the best fries I have EVER tasted. On the other hand, I also ordered the chicken Ceaser wrap and to my surprise it was lacking flavor. The chicken was way too dry. I will definitely be trying other foods and happy that this is an additional kosher restaurant to our neighborhood read more

Our food was good, not the best. They didn't separate the bun from the saucy chicken and my bun was soggy and fell apart. The pulled beef tacos were good. We sat outside the service was none. We asked a few times for a heater but it didn't work. I heard good reviews and wanted to try this place. Overall ok, we'll probably just do take out if we try again. read more

The Humble Toast - two tacos on a tray - Sandwiches Near Me - Teaneck, New Jersey

Did not honor first responder discount. Double charged gratuity and refused to take it off the bill. Had to dispute charge with credit card company. FOOD WAS GROSS, not sure how they stay in business. Meat was chewy. Nothing tasted fresh. read more

This evening I ordered food from Humble Toast for us & one of our grandsons. We received our order through Grub Hub & the order belonged to someone else. Grub Hub apparently took the wrong order from the restaurant--inconveniencing two customers. When I called the restaurant, the "gentleman" who answered the phone informed me, in a very curt manner, that the issue was with Grub Hub and not with Humble Toast--even though they gave the driver the incorrect order. When I told him that it was the restaurant's responsibility to insure that the correct order goes to the correct driver--he told me it was not their problem & hung up on me. A few minutes later, the mashgiach called me back. He was very polite--but very unhelpful. He also repeated that this was not the restaurant's responsibility. I disagreed and explained that the restaurant received the bulk of the money from the order ( that we never received) and not Grub Hub. I will never order from The Humble Toast again. Luckily, Grub Hub refunded us our money. My grandson got his chicken nuggets from Schnitzel Plus, but had to eat them in the car, because by the time his food finally came--it was time for him to go home! read more

Outside dining is ok, but no reason for cold food and a pace of service that's out of the realm of timely. Tasty but... no. Jerry's (sandwich), fries and soup of the day (not cold, just warm); normally would have sent back, but see pace of service. As far as social distancing. A big eh. read more

The Humble Toast - Fries or FRIES. - Sandwiches Near Me - Teaneck, New Jersey

Was a great atmostake,and the portion sizes are large, but the sandwich I ordered tasted stale.

Poorly run even when fairly empty. Waiters were nice despite manager having the energy of a con artist. Area looked fine, just poor spacing. Food wasn't bad, just not worth it at all. read more

After a horrible visit and a 1 star review (would have given no stars if an option) the general manager, Bryant, reached out to me via Yelp to chat about our terrible experience and said he would like to offer me a gift card so we would come back to give Humble Toast another chance. WOW! He requested I reach out to him in WhatsApp and give him my number because he was going to call me. That was 30 days ago. GUESS WHAT??? BRYANT NEVER CALLED. Now I can add HORRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE to my review. My original review still stands. Will NEVER go back! read more

Some of my favorite sandwiches on the planet are here, including Salino's Hoagie. The turkey bakon (kosher, of course) wrap sounds boring but it's the best wrap you'll ever have. Just don't order a gluten-free bun, they're hard as rocks. read more

Finally tried this local spot and was impressed with the space, staff and wide variety of offerings. My family tried the Jerry sandwich, Buffalo chicken sandwich & traditional burger. Based on our opinion the pastrami came out on top in terms of fresh and supreme quality. The Buffalo chicken was a little less than we expected and the burger was pretty good except it's listed as MW but in some spots felt a little less "done". The staff was very attentive, patient and friendly all throughout no matter who took care of what. The spot itself was clean and comfortable, perfect for a variety of gatherings. All in all though we had a great experience and all agreed we would definitely return. read more

Based on all the great reviews I decided to pop in for lunch. The owner seemed friendly as he said hello as I walked in and asked if I had been here before. Upon hearing I hadn't he informed me that they make all the items on the menu in house (except for the bread). This is the type of place I like to support. I quickly peruse the menu and decide on the Jerry (house cured and smoke pastrami, remoulade sauce, coleslaw, grilled marble rye). I place my order with the person behind the counter and am asked if I want fries or a side salad with the sandwich (I chose the salad). What I didn't realize in making this decision was that the fries and salad are both add ons and not included with the sandwich. The menu does state this (so I should have paid closer attention) but I feel like the way I asked made it seem like I had a choice of one or the other. What exasperates me more is the bill came to $21. I hadn't realized the sandwich was $16 (fries are $3 extra and the salad was $4 extra). Okay for the price this better be the best pastrami sandwich I've ever had.... so, was it? No, this is not the best pastrami sandwich. The saving grace was the pastrami. It has a nice smoky peppery flavor. However, the slaw was just okay, fairly standard and the remoulade was barely noticeable. The worst part was the Brooklyn Bred branded bread. It wasn't toasty enough, dispite the grilled claim (in the description), and honestly just wasn't very good. Marble Rye is usually delicious but this bread I actually removed after a few bites and just ate the pastrami. The $4 salad was standard lettuce, cucumber, tomato and onion (I saw the owner critiquing it to the chef and cook before it went in my to go bag and almost thought he was going to have them redo it; I wish I could have heard the exchange). I feel given the price the salad should be included with the sandwich as neither are worth their individual cost. So as I said in my opening "this is the type of place I like to support" and now that I've supported it I don't need to come back. Sounds harsh but, for me, the bad simply outweighed the good. read more

The Humble Toast - The $4 salad - Sandwiches Near Me - Teaneck, New Jersey

I thought the place was ok, but more of a 3.5. Some little things bothered me though. There was only one server and he seemed to be doing the work of more than one person. Even though the place was virtually empty. There was a delivery of various boxed items, food included and it was sitting there for at least an hour. Also, the dishes and tables weren't so so clean. The food was ok. We ordered the Queen Anne fries which were super tasty but the amount of pastrami ends could've been a little more. I ordered the turkey sandwich with the beef bacon. The menu states all meats (including the turkey) are smoked or cooked in house. This 1000% was not the case with the turkey. It was regular plain deli turkey. I really don't care, but don't make a point to say it's homemade. The other thing that bothered me was the beef bacon. It was ice cold and tasted old. Really disappointing because I love beef bacon, I paid extra for extra bacon and it was bad. My friends got different variety of chicken and they liked their food which I was happy about because I treated my friend and her kids since we were celebrating a special occasion. I was a little disappointed with the overall experience. read more

If I could give it zero stars I would. We walked in two minutes after they opened and the restaurant was filthy. Clearly the floors hasn't been swept, mopped or vacuumed in days. Ordered our food and went to use the bathroom. I've seen cleaner porta potties. One bathroom toilet was filled and completely unusable. Toilet paper all over the floor. Filthy sink. Second bathroom I tried was also filthy but the toilet wasn't clogged so I had to use it. Took 30 min to get 4 sandwiches to go. With prices like that I expected WAY more. Corned beef was skimpy and lacking flavor. You couldn't taste the horseradish at all on the French dip. Tasted like a regular Mayo. Just terrible all around. Now I understand why no one came in while we were there! Do yourself a favor and go to The Kosher Deli. Amazing food. read more

We went here after the Teaneck street fair today. The place is clean and has a well designed interior. The menu has just the right amount of options. The waiter was friendly but did not offer suggestions or elaborate when asked a food item question. I had the pastrami on rye with fries, my wife had the beef burrito. The pastrami sandwich was decent and my wife really liked hers. I thought they were both good but nothing memorable. The burrito was pretty small, especially for $16. The pastrami amount was proper but again $16 and it doesn't come w fries? This ain't Katz or 2nd Ave where's it known everything is a la carte. This is Teaneck, at that price you give fries. Lastly they don't have silverware. Everything is plastic disposables. Again if it was a dive serving $5 hoagies or burgers, ok, but you are charging normal dining prices, have the decency to serve your customers with silverware. I know this has come up before and must be an issue. In just the time I was there, I overheard another table dining complaining about it. Humble Toast, scrape off the burnt ends and step your game up. read more

Used to be my go to but has gone down hill with the new management. Food isn't as good and although the service was good the atmosphere seems tense. read more

My husband and I ate dinner there last night. I ordered a hamburger and asked for medium. It was served within minutes so obviously not made to order. In addition it was well done and dry in addition to being small. It came so fast I was halfway done before my husband even got his order. My water glass had a chip. My husband did like his food but I would not return. I did complain to our waiter but no one came to discuss our concerns. read more

Hands down best pastrami sandwich in NJ. I live in Edgewater and don't mind going out of my way to come here for the food. Always consistent and a great experience. Me writing this is making me salivate haha. Highly recommend! read more

The Humble Toast - a sandwich in a cardboard box - Sandwiches Near Me - Teaneck, New Jersey

Expensive and low-quality food. Bun was cold and burger was bad. Ambiance and staff were fine.

great food fun place. my friends and I were very happy

Ambience & Incredible Food! That's what The Humble Toast brings finally to Teaneck, I have been here about 3 times since opening and it seems like the food & service keeps getting better. Friendly staff that always keeps a smile on their face & very welcoming. Some of my favorite dishes are; The Jerry The Lonewolf Burger Queen Anne's Fries I highly recommend! Can't wait to come soon. read more

The Humble Toast - Sandwiches Near Me - Teaneck, New Jersey

Placed an order at 4:30 PM and was told it would be ready in 45 minutes. Went to pick it up at 5:15 and they said another half hour. Decided to leave and then go elsewhere. When I found another restaurant which had tables I called Humble Toast 5 times with no answer, only a machine saying leave a message. BTW, the machine had the name of the former owner. The new owner could not make an effort to re-record the recording?) I could not cancel the order. Went back at 5:45. The place was a zoo. Short staffed, and a complete mess. Order was not ready until 6:30. 2 hours for three sandwiches. Customers were annoyed, long lines to be seated, and obnoxious, unfreindly staff who could not care less. read more

Ordered on UberEats after looking at some reviews on here. I went with The Irving and the Knish. Even my driver said she dreams about the Knish! I have to say the whole grain mustard is exactly what these dishes deserve. The kraut on the sandwich is the best krait I have ever had. They seasoned it perfectly! The meat is tender and juicy and cooked perfectly. The knish really is life changing. I've never had one so soft and savory. I will 100% order from here again! Can't wait to go in person with my husband someday too. My UberEats driver was on point with her review! read more

The Humble Toast - The Irving - Sandwiches Near Me - Teaneck, New Jersey

See all

We ordered five things and loved them all! Started with the Queen Anne fries, and the pile of onions. Enjoyed the It's Lit, The Lone Ranger, and the Beef Barbacoa. read more

It's good, it's just waaaaaaay overpriced. I wouldn't bother having a hot dog on the menu and charging $12 for it. It's ridiculous. Perhaps have lighter items as well. read more

It was a really good burger. A burger that gets all over the place. You can't put it down for fear that you won't be able to pic it back up. The chips where OK. The fries where decent. I think I might visit this place again. read more

The Humble Toast - a tray of fries and a fried egg - Sandwiches Near Me - Teaneck, New Jersey

See all

Ordered chili and knish for delivery. Chili was fine. Knish - was legit burnt to a crisp. Not sure how the restaurant thought it ok to send out like this. read more

The Humble Toast - Knish - Sandwiches Near Me - Teaneck, New Jersey

Our local family favorite. Everything I've had here was delicious and we've been coming for a while. Staff is friendly and service is great. Some of our absolute musts from the menu are Queen Anne fries, the Jerry, Brussels sprouts, my kids love the burgers. Everything is just always delicious. Would highly recommend read more

Wow, was just here last night and very disappointed. This place is garbage. Food was gross. If you're lookjng for high quality food, Teaneck has a ton of other options. Stay Away. read more

Overpriced, under seasoned and sad fare. I wish i could give it better marks but at almost 20 per appetizer and mains that don't really satisfy, i just gotta give this a fat 1 star. I guess if you're a hipster that has a trust fund financially backing you, this place won't hurt (and the atmosphere they're obviously trying to pay back) but if you're a regular human being this is not the place to hunt for a good meal. This place won't last long charging most of their menu items at $15+ while portion sizes are more $5. Then again this is in a part of Teaneck that's been gentrified for the upscale Jewish community so they have a base to pander to, i guess. read more

Incredible food, amazing dining experience, and good prices! The staff and owner are very polite and welcoming, looking forward to dining there again. read more

Amazing sandwiches, I had the southern chicken sandwich and it was out of this world! read more

The Humble Toast - Southern chicken sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Teaneck, New Jersey

Finally a great new restaurant in Teaneck! Came 2 nights in a row because it was that good! Service was great, food was delicious! Has a trendy vibe, not like the other kosher restaurants in the area. read more

The Humble Toast - Sandwiches Near Me - Teaneck, New Jersey

See all

Apart from the joy of seeing young Jewish people out and about in the thriving Teaneck shtetl, there's the food! Steve has chili bowl and destroyed it. I stuck to fries and dr. Brown and humble sauce. Delish. read more

The Humble Toast - Couples and waiter taking photo together. - Sandwiches Near Me - Teaneck, New Jersey