This spot sucks. I ordered a vegetarian meal through door dash for delivery and they messed up my order by making it in chicken. I almost ate it before I noticed. On calling the restaurant they said there is nothing they can do about this order and they did not help in any manner. This is not acceptable. I almost broke my religion. read more

I had the paneer masala for $11 and it was super delicious. Basically it's masala tomato butter sauce withchunks of paneer cheese. Great vegetarian option, even if you're not vegetarian! My friends got two different types of biryani. It was pretty expensive biryani for $17 but the portion was GINORMOUS like a mountain of rice which they said was tasty as well. I have to take a star off for the fact their service is slower than waiting for paint on a wall to dry. ..kidding, but it really felt like that since it took definitely over 40 minutes to get our food out... and there were NO OTHER CUSTOMERS EXCEPT ANOTHER TABLE OF TWO. Oh my gosh I was dying but luckily their food was good or else it would have been a terrible experience. .. Overall food is a little pricy but at least it's good. They also serve hakka Chinese and southeast Asian cuisines but being that in already Chinese, I come to a predominantly Indian to eat Indian food. read more

It was my first time coming here, for a friend's wedding. I've never had this type of cuisine before and didn't know what to expect. It changed my mind after the appetizer portion, they have some bomb food and sure knows how to party. I plan on coming back for that mango salad and samosas. Everything was good throughout the night. read more

Another one of these Indian run down restaurants. Food is mediocre if u like gas and bloat feeling after eating. The place is run down and tiles falling off the walls going down the basement and all. It's not bad but just typical rundown and money not put into repairs but in the owners pockets. I think the simple days of cooking home has taken a back seat and people have been accustomed to eating outside not knowing what and who made it and what the aftermath is. I knew the previous north indians who owned it and now it's someone new again. Paint on top of paint and more paint does not make it look good, it's actually repairing this falling or crumbling place before someone gets hurt read more

Very very very good indian food. Everything is made fresh to order. Try the dry chili paneer... You'll thank me. Wish they had a better drink selection. read more

great food, especially the indochinese dishes. what i like about this place is that they will cook the food the way you like it even if it's not on the menu. staff is very nice also. i would have given this place 5/5 but the price for some of these dishes are priced ridiculously high when compared to places in the city. i wish they would offer a discount or some coupons. b/c of the outrageously high prices, i either cook these dishes at home or just don't frequent the place as often. but if you live in LI and want to cater for the family, the food is pretty good for what's in the area. read more

They are serving stale food in the lockdown. Ordered tandoori and chicken chettinad instead they gave me microwave overcooked soggy chicken tandoori and chicken tikka read more

Looks so UNapproachable from the road. Is it a catering hall? A private club? I wonder if they wonder why business is slow. Weird. read more

Great food, amazing service. Staff is very accommodating. we have done few parties so far and not once we had to worry about quality of service or staff. Thank you Cotillion. read more

This review is for take-out (only) from their restaurant. 2.5 - 3 Stars. We order from their restaurant at least 4x/month. Food is good, not too oily, which we appreciate, but they have some stiff competition in Hicksville. Unfortunately, their take-out service is unreliable for timing. I always call well in advance to place my order. Half the time we go to pick up (Usually before my work shift, so I'm rushing in/out), I'm waiting an additional 10 minutes just to pay/receive my order (with only 1-2 tables with customers). Today, called for a standard order, quoted 20 minutes. Arrived 1 hour later --No food packed, was told twice that the food 'was ready' but it never came, waited for 15min in an empty restaurant before letting one of the staff know I was canceling the order. Even more than the time issue, at this point, didn't really feel comfortable that they had made my order vs. giving me something else. Really disappointed in this service because this is not the first time. Would not recommend for take out. read more

Horrible food! The tandoori chicken was bland and the butter chicken had a weird taste (in a bad way). Would not go there again... read more

The food is absolutely amazing! Went for a quiet sit down dinner with family and was not disappointed! Highly recommend

The food was just alright- nothing spectacular. I had to remind the staff the dishes were dirty a couple of times. Not a fan of dirty dishes! read more

Great catering service. Everyone loves the fresh Naan and the main course has the proper texture, and isn't too liquidy or bland. The appetizers could be a little improved. read more

Ordered some food last night through Seamless. Didn't arrive even after two+ hours of waiting. Restaurant didn't even cared about calling and letting us know that they can't deliver. Had to go out in frigid weather at 11pm to get some food. read more

The food is incredible and the owners are very nice. I tried the lamb tikka masala, lamb peshwari, garlic naan, and the chicken 65 this trip and it was very very good. New favorite place. read more

Went to this place a couple of weeks ago (forgot to leave a review) and it was fantastic! My boyfriend and I ordered the chicken tikka, mango chicken vegetable rice, spring rolls and garlic naan.There was so much flavor in everything we ate that we couldn't get enough, we definitely over ate but it was so worth it.The portions are bIg and we had leftovers for two days afterwards. We will definitely be returning to this restaurant when we are back in the area since we live in Suffolk county. We might just end up making a trip just to go there that's how good it was! read more

The Cotillion - Indian Near Me - Jericho, New York

Simply put, do not make a reservation here for any large event. My mother reserved the lower space for my wife's baby blessing, expecting about 100 guests. Unfortunately my beloved mother passed away a few weeks ago. We obviously could not go through with the event and gave the Cotillion notice a month in advance. When calling to cancel, we received a very shrewd sympathy followed by a quick unprompted reminder that our deposit could not be refunded (but could be used as credit within 9 months). We could care less about the money nor ever having an event there. But to dismiss our loss and cancellation as a simple matter of business is not a healthy way to operate. It's blood money at this point. Shame on you Cotillion. I hope anyone planning a special event at the Cotillion reads this review prior to booking. You deserve a catering hall that is equally invested in making sure you and your guests are provided for versus being treated like a line item on their balance sheet. Disgusting. read more

Don't be turned off by the negative reviews. I was about to be, but I'm so glad that I took a chance on The Cotillion. I ordered the lamb biryani, lamb vindaloo, and a curry. All were delicious. The food isn't cheap but the portions are huge and the quality is there. read more

Chose them because they deliver. Service was fast and friendly. Food was delicious. Chose from the recommended section and the goat was delicious. Generous portions, and just the right amount of spice. You can choose your level of spicy and Spicy was just right. Only made my nose run a little bit. Will definitely become a go to when stuck at hotel. read more

I am a regular at this place to pick up lunch or dinner, because it is so close from my work. Out of the many dishes I have tried, I can never get enough of their chicken biryani! Good portion size, spicy and just good! They have recently started lunch buffet too, which has variety of good dishes and decently priced as well! read more

I was here for a party .their party hall is spacious .service was good .food was delicious .lamb pepper fry and the shrimp curry were excellent. read more

A lot of vegetarian options; had the bhindi masala, was very good, good amount of food, got to take home half as leftovers, great chandelier, server was very friendly read more

This Place is amazing...newly rennovated modern cozy little restaurant with a new fusion menu. The new Fusion chef is off the hook be sure to try his chilly lamb dry, honey chicken, thai lamb curry, and singapore noodles! oh yeah and the fried ice cream! read more

See all

I love coming here. I have been ordering out of here for a few years and they've never disappointed me. The food is delicious, and makes you want to try new things. The staff is courteous, and the space is beautiful. It's adjacent to a banquet hall that is constantly buzzing. Definitely a good spot to stop by every now and then. read more

My family and I had an absolutely wonderful experience at this restaurant. Besides the fantastic service we received, the food was incredible. We couldn't stop eating the Chicken Tikki Masala dish. By far, it was the best we have ever had. We truly can't wait to go back to this restaurant again. Thank you everyone! read more

Food was good and the staff very friendly. Was a bit disappointed that the chef that cooks the Chinese and Thai food wasn't there as we were looking forward to the fusion cuisine. That aside, we would come back or the Indian food alone. The curry goat and chicken were delicious. read more

We LOVE this restaurant. The food is excellent and the service is terrific. Three members of our family are vegan and one eats chicken. There are plenty of vegan selections and the staff are happy to make any adjustments to the dishes to make them vegan. We highly recommend it! Andrea G. read more

Overall service was great, food was good. Not many customers but Too many guys wondering around at that place buying nothing.

If you are looking for Indian/international food catering for your wedding/reception, look no further than the Cotillion. The food is fantastic, and the service is excellent. We had a great tasting experience a few months before the event, and were impressed with both the presentation and the taste of the dishes. Cotillion provides not just Indian food, but also make delicious Italian and Asian cuisines. On the day of the event, no one went hungry and everyone raved about how good the food was. I would definitely be hiring them again for future events! read more

Went there for the first time last week. My Boyfriend forced me to stop, or else would have emptied their Kitchen. Oh my god the Butter Chicken (My Boyfriend had ordered) was the best "THE BEST" . The food was so savory. I just could not stop. Cotillion was nothing like the any other Indian restaurant I had been to. The entrance is just beautiful! The lobby was tastefully done. Nothing like red, or orange or yellow drapes falling out of wall or fake plants hanging, picture of God and goddess or tacky lighting sticking out. This place is different. The ambiance matched the food they serve . As soon as we were seated our server bought us long beautiful spice plate and Papadam, We kicked off our meal journey with an appetizer and while I was ordering dinner I realized that this place was no Joke, and they don't like to mess around with the food. I was very tempted by the Chicken Vindaloo, looking at my blonde hair my server asked me if I was good with spices and I am NOT, so she kindly suggested that it might not be a perfect choice for me, and she refused to make it mild, as she told it would not be Vindaloo if I take away a spices from it.(Loved her answer) . Instead she suggested Chicken Tikka Masala which I always eat but it was the best I ever had. The quality of food is invincible. The food is freaking amazing and everything on the menu sounds so delicious. It makes you want to come back over and over and over to try all the dishes. Then after you're done trying all the dishes, you'll come back over and over for your favorite dishes. My mouth waters as I write about it. Definitely somewhere I would reconmend. read more

The food is really good and I will sure come back if I am in the area. We take advantage of the $15 for $30 coupon. Great deal!

Chili Chicken Dry is my fav. Very friendly family style place. Extensive menu. Still exploring new dishes.

This is a small restaurant inside the catering hall. A hidden gem. Now I don't have to go to Hicksville for authentic Indian food. Very good, Had the Lamb Saag and my partner had the Aloo Gobi. We also had Naan and Paneer Paratha. Loved it all . Lamb Saag had just the right kick to it . Will definitely be back read more

We had a very large house party and choose Cotillion to cater and serve. The food was perfect -- everyone loved it. The servers were knowledgeable about the fare and excellent. Cotillion truly made our party great -- 10/10. Everything we ordered stood out -- the lamb (lamb chops and roganjosh), the chicken (achari, the Kababs, chili, butter chicken and bhoona), the fish tikka and veg (aloo tikki & channa, chili paneer, potli mutter**, palak paneer, malai kofta, Hakka noodle, tadka dal) and much much more... Kulchas, Deserts, kulfi etc. read more

I've been passing this place for years and have always been confused and admittedly a bit scared to enter (assumed it was attached to the motel next door; spoiler: it's not). My family loves Indian, and I love Asian Fusion, so last time I was back home I suggested we give it a try. We pulled in and after years of wondering, I finally realized that the restaurant is completely separate from the "motor lodge" (immediately scored some points for that in my head). However, the parking lot was completely empty... we only knew the place was actually open because there was a delivery man getting into a car with bags of food. In their defense, it was 8pm on a Wednesday... The service was good. The waiter answered our questions well and not in a condescending manner, which I really appreciated. The food was good, too. I'm not the biggest fan of Indian cuisine, so I really enjoyed their chicken & broccoli dish (however, the broccoli was sparse), which tasted to be more on the Thai side. The Naan was better than average. Overall, I'd say all the Indian dishes I sampled were good- Loved the chicken tikka masala. Channa masala was good too. The chilli chicken with gravy had a great flavor but was a bit spicy for my taste. I'm not rushing to go back, but I'm sure I will soon and I look forward to trying more of the fusion dishes. The Cotillion gets an A-OK in my book. read more

We ordered paneer tikka , yellow dal, malai kofta and onion kulcha . Everything was out of world , super delicious . I will go again soon.Best place . read more

This is my first time ordering food from this establishment. I enjoy asian fusion food, so I decided to give this restaurant a try. My mistake . . . The good: Food was delivered in a timely manner . . . Driver was cordial . . . The not so good: Ordered the shrimp basil ginger, chicken basil ginger, and chilly shrimp dishes. Food tasted "old"; as if it was prepared last week and reheated. Also, the entrees were drenched in oil. With so much competition in Nassau County, one would think that they would do a better job ensuring fresh, high quality products. Much better asian fusion options in Nassau County include New Chili Curry, Masala Wok, and Mint. First impression was a terrible one. I do NOT recommend The Cotillion. I ordered: Basil Ginger Chicken Basil Ginger Shrimp Chili Shrimp read more

We stopped by for lunch time while going to LIU campus. It's a OK place nothing interesting but the hall for parties looks nice for small functions. read more

Small, unassuming little restaurant inside the catering hall but boy do they have amazing food! So glad we found this place!