Went for lunch on a Saturday with a friend. We wanted to try this place because it just opened recently and my friend really likes Italian. We sat down and asked for water and I was delighted that our water was served with a little tray of several lemon wedges. I've never seen restaurants do that before. Some restaurants don't even give you lemon unless you ask. I love lots of lemon juice in my water.
For appetizers, we ordered the fried calamari. The waiter commented on it and made it seem it was going to be the best calamari ever, but although it was indeed very good, it was similar to calamari I've had at other restaurants. I really like the sauce they drizzled around the dish though. Every restaurant seems to have a different dipping sauce. The one they used at Taverna tasted like a tomato/red pepper/pineapple paste of some sort. I could be totally wrong and there might not be any pineapple in it, but it was fruity and sweet.
For main course, my friend ordered a brick oven baked pizza, and I ordered their in-house-made gnocchi. The meal came with a basket of bread and sun dried tomato oil. I was disappointed to find the bread was not warm out of the oven, but I think they do bake the bread on-site. My friend and I devoured our bread before our food came out and our waiter happily restocked us with a second helping, which was immediately followed by our entrees.
The gnocchi was the best gnocchi I've had (although I've only had it 3 other times so maybe it doesn't mean much). It's much softer and finer than gnocchi I've had before, not hard and chewy. The sauce tasted like a red vodka sauce of some kind, also very delicious. My friend had his pizza split half and half with two different toppings, margarita and chicken/spinach. The pizza was similar to those found at California pizza kitchen and Anthony's. It wasn't as "well-done" as the pizza at Anthony's and the toppings they had were much more innovative. I'd say the pizza at the three places are all very comparable, in that gourmet/brick-oven-baked category. One thing Taverna does differently is that the pizza is served with a sprig of dried oregano and their special chili oil in fancy little hexagonal jars. I really enjoyed plucking the leaves off of the oregano. It tasted wonderful on the pizza, way better than the oregano flakes that come out of a plastic shaker. I didn't use up the whole sprig but I hope they don't serve it to another table because I definitely put my fingers all over it. The chili oil sounded more fascinating than it tasted. It wasn't spicy at all so I loaded a bunch on my pizza in hopes to taste the chili, only to find that it made my pizza taste heavily like olive oil. Go figure.
Commenting on the service, my waiter was very prompt and was able to answer our questions about the menu. My only complaint was that I felt really pressured during the whole meal because our waiter would not leave us alone! We asked him to give us a minute on the menu and he literally came back 2 minutes later. Usually a minute means like 5 to 10 minutes. During our meal, he kept coming to back to check on us and asked how we were doing. I'm sure this was in his training but I found it some what distracting. Each time he came around and asked how we were doing, I had to swallow my food really fast so I didn't answer him with food in my mouth. One of the managers in the store came around, too, and introduced himself. I'm pretty sure our meal was interrupted every 5 minutes. The staff tried to be hospitable and friendly by being vocal but I think it did more harm than good. Customers like to savor their food in peace without having to answer questions every 5 minutes!
Over all, my dining experience at Taverna was positive. My friend and I left with happy filled stomachs. The price here were very fair. Topped with the generous servings of bread and the gourmet condiments they offer, I think it's very well worth it. I'd say this is the best Italian restaurant on Main street, better than Cucina Di Napoli and Caffe Gelato!
Oh and commenting on the alcohol. Although they have many different brands of beers on tap it's pretty standard flagship stuff. Don't expect to find 10 different types of IPAs, ciders, or chocolate stout, etc. Home Grown still has the more interesting concoctions on Main Street. I do want to come back and try their wine on tap though. read more