Summary: delightful and romantic atmosphere, lovely service, delicious food, but wayyyyyyy too expensive for what it is, and I will be sticking to my beloved Tasca from now on.
Details:
The boy had a $75 gift cert here and we decided to use it last night for his birthday dinner. Upon entering the cozy, dim, tiny dining room, the sommelier/hostess(/owner?) gave us our choice of seat, brought out the huuuuge wine list, and let us know we could tell her what we liked and she'd be able to recommend a bottle for us.
Wine: As mentioned, the wine list is a giant overwhelming book, but many bottles were really nicely priced. With help from our waitress, we chose a $32 bottle of Cristanza Rioja, and it was delicious. Very pleased with the price and selection (and help from the staff).
Potato Salad, a complimentary start to our meal: this was a yummy version, nicely garlicy, a nice beginning. [tapas-sized]
Jamon Serrano: you can't go wrong with Spanish Jamon, tasty and delicious. Sadly, the plate itself literally just came with the ham, no toast points or accompaniments that often come with, and of course it's much more expensive than anywhere else. To be fair, we did get a basket of standard bread, although I couldn't tell if this was actually part of the jamon plate or if everyone gets it. [$15; tapas-sized]
Esparragos verdes a la parrilla (Grilled green asparagus): my favorite dish of the night. So simple, but soooo good. Tender, perfectly grilled asparagus drizzled with EVOO and sprinkled with salt, with an optional lemon squeeze. I think there were about 9ish spears on the plate, definitely pretty pricey. [$9; tapas-sized]
Gallina en Pepitoria (Hen w/sherry, saffron, almonds & jamon): A small bowl with pieces of bone-in hen swimming in sauce that was a little bland and disappointing, especially given the promise of the ingredients. Hen was cooked nicely though. [$16; tapas-sized]
Codorniz al Xocolat (Braised quail with almond, hazelnut and cocoa sauce over garlicky white beans): I love me some quail, and this was a tasty version. The sauce was very mole-esque and delicious, and the (whole) quail was tender and tasty. The beans were a little too al dente for my taste, but I still really liked the strong garlic flavor, plus you got a tooooon. [$15; small entree-sized]
Plato combinado (Grilled marinated pork loin, fried eggs, and French fries): probably the best bang for your buck of the night, this plate came with 2 plain pork chops, 2 runny eggs, and a ton of fries. Nothing special about any of it, just standard fare executed decently. A bit on the salty side, but I liked it because I'm a sucker for a good runny egg. We took half of this plate home in order to save room for dessert. [$16; main entree-sized]
Trufas Porreras (Home made dark chocolate truffles garnished with EVOO, cocoa and Spanish sea salt): the staff lit a candle and sang happy b-day to the boy, a nice touch. This dish had wonderful presentation- the waitress brought out the 3 small (a bit larger than a half dollar) truffles along with crusty bread, and proceeded to cover the plate with cocoa powder, EVOO, and sea salt table-side. I really liked the flavor combination (salt just adds something special to sweets, don't you think?), and the chocolate was rich and flavorful (although very hard to cut through). Worth $9 though, based on amount and quality? Highly doubtful. [$9; tapas-sized]
Sherry: the boy ended his meal with a glass of Amontilado, which was probably the best value of the night ($5).
Service: friendly, helpful, and attentive. The dining room was at about 90% capacity (this was a Wed night) but we felt nicely cared for.
Value/Price: it's so hard to figure out on the menu the size of the plates and whether it's worth it value-wise or not. I wish they would add some kind of qualifier so you know how small or large the dish is. Price-wise, everything is about 3X what I'd pay at a similarly-lovely tapas place (aka Tasca), and I just don't have the bank to be able to afford it here. I wish I could say it's worth the extra cost, either due to quality/flavor or amount, but I can't. Our meal with tip was $150, which was absolutely shocking to us given that we're the type of people who generally spend less than $50 for the both of us, alcohol included. $150 constitutes a major splurge (we did have the $75 gift cert to soften the blow, but still, even $75 is pretty expensive for us). The one bright spot is the wine list which had many reasonable and excellent options... so maybe just come here for a small snack and a bottle of wine with a loved one.
Overall, I had a lovely time at Taberna... but I just can't justify coming back, when there are places like Tasca which has just as wonderful an atmosphere and just as tasty food, for a third of the price (not to mention Tasca's constant deals and promotions). read more