Loved the revamp at Sycamore but not so much the prices but we've still stopped by for a quick lunch break and for dinner services in the same week. For lunch, we tried The 6th Streeter Sandwich, The Sycamore Burger, and 2x Chocolate Chip Cookie. Everything was so good, even as takeouts. For dinner, we tried the Burrata & Heirloom Tomato, the Mussels, the Hanger Steak, 2x Semester Abroad, a Miller Lite, and a Sycamore Old Fashioned. And we loved their Chocolate Chip Cookie so much, we put 2 on hold before even ordering any of our foods or drinks (good thing too because we apparently snagged the last 2 for the night!). Of everything we tried, the Hanger Steak was the crowd pleaser. The chocolate chip cookie is truly fire but it's also $5 but it's also the size of my face so 100/10 would come back ;b read more

See all

I just love the Sycamore. I think this place is one of the best kept little secrets in the German Village. I lived in the Village for 2 years and would come here frequently then; I've since moved to another part of the city, but I will still drive down to the Village to go here. It's just that good. Wanted to start out by saying - I would take any reviews that are more than a couple years old with a grain of salt, because the Sycamore was fully remodeled a couple years ago, and I believe it might(?) be under new management as well since the remodel. I've only been here since it was remodeled, so I never tried the "old" restaurant. Most recent reviews are all really positive. First of all, the ambiance, omg. I want to live here. Everything about it is just so cozy and perfect, with all the exposed brick and pretty wooden details. I just love the style. The menu is small but really well-rounded, so you'll definitely find something you like here. All of the cocktails are incredible, you really can't go wrong. I've had lots of different food here, including a few different salads and some entrees, and I've loved everything I've had. Definitely get the focaccia bread as an appetizer, it's insane. And now for the best part...there's a COFFEE WINDOW. It's so freaking adorable. Sometimes I would take a walk to Sycamore in the mornings before the actual restaurant opened, and their coffee window would be open. You can order a specialty coffee drink from the barista and have it handed to you through the little window. Can it get any cuter. Anyway, seriously love this place and I think it's such a hidden gem in Columbus. I feel such cozy vibes whenever I'm here. The waiters are all really nice too. I'll be back soon! read more

Sycamore - A Paper and a Poem (left), Goodbye Clearwater (right) - Bars Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Food excellent Service spot on Ambiance fairly quiet and friendly Good date night dinners read more

This is a review of the new sycamore restaurant which just opened to the public yesterday. We had such high hopes for the new restaurant and unfortunately was disappointed on many fronts. I think in a couple of months once they work out some of the inconsistencies it will be worth another visit. We arrived at 4:30 and was pleased to see that they are offering a happy hour menu for discounted drinks and appetizers from 4:00- 7:00. Ordered the sycamore old fashion which was the highlight of the entire evening. The head on shrimp and artichokes were average at best. Zero flavor from the artichoke. There were some grill marks on them but eating the artichokes one could not tell they were grilled. Also there was a total lack of seasoning let alone salt or pepper. The other disappointment was that the artichokes are served at room temp even though they were 'grilled'. I mean who wants a room temp artichoke? The head on shrimp were drenched in a liquified butter. I do mean drenched. Although the flavors were good, I could tell the shrimp were not fresh. I'm guessing frozen/thawed shrimp which unfortunately were mooshy. For entrees we had the vegetable tagine which had a slight Middle East flavor profile but heavy on potatoes and carrots. While the menu indicated cauliflower it was barely noticeable. I'm guessing potatoes and carrots are less expensive than cauliflower. We also had the chicken thighs over couscous. The couscous was the highlight of the dish. The chicken was totally bland and flavorless. We also ordered the lobster roll which the menu advertised as double buttered. One would think the roll would be toasted and buttered. It did have the "obligatory" grill marks but zero indication of buttered and toasted. Let alone double buttered as indicated on the menu. My biggest complaint is with the chef who did not taste her food before serving it. Zero salt, pepper or seasoning. Service was average and that is just because of the newness. Our check totaled $150 for three entrees, 4 mixed drinks and 2 appetizers. For that kind of money I expect better and so should you. read more

See all

This place was perfect for our dinner out in the German village. It was so cozy and the staff was very welcoming. Everything we ate and drank was delicious! Couldn't recommend more. We had the streak frites, burger, buckeye pie and vanilla lattes. read more

Sycamore - Buckeye pie and vanilla lattes - Bars Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Let me start by saying that I really wanted to give this place 5 stars, but I could not overlook some glaring issues both in service and the plates that needed to be addressed. After I came here in August for my birthday and had a GREAT experience, this feeling I was left with Saturday evening was less than desirable. We had reservations for 5 as that was the only time they had open, so I'm led to believe it's going to be busy, which it in fact was. That would also lead me to believe they had been appropriately staffed and prepped for such a busy weekend night, which they were not. There was one bartender for the entire restaurant, and while a second round of drinks wass comped for the delay it took to get them, 25-30 minutes, I felt badly that she was flying solo. The bigger issue I took from the bar was the fact they were out of the house made gin which is used for at least one 3 of their drinks, two of which I was set to order only to find it from our server they were "unable to prepare any" the previous night. If it is house made and a staple for a few of your cocktails, I feel someone should have made this either the night before, or the morning of. Again, it was 5pm on a Saturday with the whole evening ahead. The food was mostly fine, not as good as I've had from them previously, but different seasons, different menus, I get it. What I cannot condone is the fact that the mussels dish was in NO WAY indicated to be made with an arrabiatta sauce and was very spicy. For me the spice is no issue, but my friend who ordered it doesn't handle spice well and was flushed after one bite with the heat being nearly overwhelming. This is the kind of thing you need to let your patrons know. Our server was pretty good despite a mix up in the checks which was quickly rectified, and he was good to let us know of the wait from the bar and the comping of the second round. I'll give this place one more shot as they're one for two right now, but my expectations will be tempered after this. Also, is a fairly small restaurant and it gets pretty loud after 6 when it's at capacity, not uncomfortable, just happy sounds and libations flowing. read more

See all

Sycamore is the sort of place you take your family if you want to really impress them. Classy and chic on the inside, their menu is equally impressive; elevated New American fare. The beets and burrata and the black bass were excellent. The daily pie I had ages ago is one I still can't get off my mind. Chocolate peanutbutter that tasted like heaven in pie form. A must try for those with excellent taste and money to blow! read more

This place rocks. Located in charming German Village, their service and dedication to craft food and yumminess is outstanding. The Sycamore Village salad (with added chicken) was delicious and fresh. My husband had the Cuban, which was excellent and sizeable, and came with delectable fries. It's a little place, with high ceilings, so it can be a little loud, but that can be said for almost any restaurant these days, and we avoid chains as a rule. We will definitely go back, and you should give it a try, too. Breakfast? read more

The vibe of this place was awesome and we had an amazing server. The price point was slightly elevated for the vibe I felt but I would love to go back during the day for some coffee! read more

This place is OK. Nice ambience, bar was full where we wanted to sit. It's hard to judge how the food is since we only had one appetizer but it was delicious. The one thing that was exceptional was Derek our server he was a very young, very polite man. Derek's a rockstar. If you come here, you should ask for him. read more

See all

What a gem of a place in German Village! It was an easy walk from our AirBnB for a Friday evening dinner. They have a fun cocktail menu and an affordable yet interesting wine list, so we had drinks from both! The place is modern yet rustic with a great vibe. The food was delicious and I definitely ate way too much but I couldn't stop. We split the jamon (which was served ala bruschetta) and the broccolini, both of which were delicious. For dinner, we had the trout (delicious) and chicken thighs (also delicious but a bit rich). After all this food, you won't need dessert, but you may choose to indulge anyways. A great night! read more

I came here by myself for a night out treat and really enjoyed it! I sat at the bar and received full menu service. The bartender was amazing and made me feel at ease especially by myself. The atmosphere otherwise was quite loud and made it a but tough to really enjoy the experience, but honestly it was great otherwise. Regardless, the food was great. The short rib ragu was excellent. The noodles on top hid the short rib, which made it fun to mix it all together to get the full experience. And I finished off my meal with a slice of pecan pie, at the bartender's recommendation. I looked at the menu in advance to get an idea of price, and for a single night out it still ended up being a bit more than I had intended. I do still recommend the Sycamore but for more of a special night out and not so much a casual gathering. read more

came here for a bday dinner for my husband with our baby and everyone was so nice and accommodating. food and drinks and vibe all 10/10!

Hm. We went for a special occasion. I have to say I was disappointed. There must have been something devastating with the staff, kitchen and bar this night. We've been before and loved it. This time: Nope! We ordered 3 different wines, they were out of 2 of the 3. The lamb ragu x2 was cold. Sat for a long time. Don't know if it was staff or kitchen. We sent one back because it was a congealed mess. Horrible. replacement came out in 5 mins tho. We waited a LONG time for food. Hangar steaks were tasty as usual, the only thing they nailed. Salads had a whiff of dressing, needed a lot more, could not find waiter. More drinks? Couldn't find the waiter. Again with the waiting. Place was full, but the bar was almost empty and there were a couple tables open/ or changing out. So IMO, it was a bar/server issue for this. I'll give you one more chance, maybe. Lots of tasty places to try in this city. You missed it on our visit this time with out of town guests Sycamore. read more

I've been hearing about this place for quite some time and figured I finally needed to check it out for myself. It's cute and tucked into the neighborhood, but tastefully stands out! We got several appetizers and each got an entree. The drinks were also AMAZING! Featured: Chicken Thighs, Black Bass, Housemade Focaccia, Suppli al Telefono, Devils in Crowns, Italian 90 cocktail, The Sycamore Old Fashioned cocktail This place has great food and excellent service! While a little on the pricier side, you're getting an excellent experience and I will definitely be back! read more

See all

I've lived in this area for nearly 9yrs now. This place was a favorite. Every friend that visited from out of town, I would take them here. I loved the ambience. The food, the drinks, the staff. It was great. You couldn't go wrong. We haven't been since 2020 until recently. Boy was I surprised when we entered. Turns out they are under new ownership and a new interior! It feels like the Interior of a boat. Not that I have a yacht. I didn't like it. They put in new modern booths that felt like IKEA. Definitely not the comfy, cozy type they used to have. The place lost its aesthetic charm that it used to have. I'm a big disappointed here. It was the neighborhood bar. The servers now wear aprons? That's weird. We were only there for the drinks. They were known for good and different drinks... they were still really good. Looked like they kept some of the old ones and added more. Sorry I can't review the food, we didn't have any. Don't know if we'll go back anymore, we'll see. I can't rate it accurately high because we didn't eat here, just drinks. Not sure if this review helps anyone, just another new restaurant it felt like. Nothing special. I hate giving reviews like this. If we do go back to eat, I will update. read more

Loved this lovely German Village neighborhood gem. Started out with a table out on the patio and a couple of lavender margaritas. Grilled Artichoke starter then hanger steak, medium rare with fries. SO GOOD and we were fortunate we snagged a table on the same day we wanted dinner on a whim. We went a little early at 5 pm though so worth it. Came home and took at 2.5 mile brisk walk around the neighborhood! Staff was kind. Food was delish. Experience was awesome. Would totally go back! Such a lovely establishment!! read more

This place is such a gem. Let me start with what we loved. Usually when I see chicken thighs on a menu, I roll my eyes and think how good can it be? It's so Ohio. Well, I was wrong. My husband had the foresight to order this dish and it was so decadent with every perfect tender bite. Match this with creamy couscous, cream cheese, dates, and asparagus. Exceptional. I ordered the mussels and good lord, I don't know what's in that sauce that feels like there's eggplant with a tomato base and a kick. Dish out a mussel, throw on the crisp bread with this incredible sauce and you have bruschetta. Delightful. Now the clam chowder. I almost couldn't find the soup it was loaded with clams. Really tasty. It did need a touch of hot sauce but it was solid. I am just in awe of those fresh clams. Now to the missteps. The grilled artichokes were so undercooked that we had to fight to get these leaves off the choke. It was a battle. Delicious dipping sauce but if not cooked perfectly, I'd knock this off the menu. Cocktails decent not great. Wine selection a bit too Spanish-heavy and I'd like to see a better selection of Cabernet Sauvignons which I didn't see one option on the menu. We will definitely be back. The positives far outweigh the negatives but I thought I'd share my two cents. read more

See all

Yup, 3 stars. Nothing bad but nothing great either. In town to celebrate my daughters birthday and she picked it. It's a nice little restaurant typical of German village. There was outside seating but a little chilly in the fall. There was one large table, some booths, and tables for two. Large bar dominates the right side. The staff was very friendly and we were seated 30 minutes earlier than our reservation. Our waiter was good and our drinks, apps, and entrees were served without delay. We started out with some cocktails and a couple appetizers, the charcuterie and some fried stuffed cheese thing. The stuffed cheese thing was the highlight of the dinner. I'd look it up but Sycamores website only has their breakfast and lunch menu. Their small plates and entrees are seasonal and seem to change often, which can be good but in this case it's not. I can't categorize their menu, they are really all over the map. I ordered the branzino, very bland, some salt would have been nice, but it was strictly heart healthy. My daughter got the Cuban sandwich, her boyfriend got the brisket and my wife got the steak frites. All, save for the boyfriend, were disappointed in their selections. I tasted my wife's dish and it was the worse attempt at this popular Belgian dish. The steak was marinated, and that's never good. Please please, never marinate a steak. Sycamore, uninspired dining. read more

See all

The food was fantastic! High quality ingredients, lots of vegetables, so delicious. Also had a superb latte. The decor is super cute blend of clean modern and authentic vintage. And I like the service system of ordering at the bar. Means wait staff isn't bugging you, keeps things moving, and easy to split checks. read more

Sycamore - Sandwich with broccolini, other veggies, and vinaigrette. Falafel sandwich. Latte and beetroot latte. - Bars Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I finally tried this little gem in German Village~ Loved the decorations around the restaurant! The holiday cocktail menu was amazing~ I enjoyed 'three more sleeps' the most! I got a variety of appetizers and entrées to share with my friends. Overall the food was cooked nicely and flavorful! The service was great~ can't wait to go back to try other dishes! read more

See all

Went here for the first time the other night and sat at the bar. Loved this spot. This place is such a unique neighborhood spot in German Village that feels like a hidden gem. Great vibes and delicious food and drinks. Bartender was super kind and attentive! Definitely recommend this spot! read more

Sycamore - Bars Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Loved this place. Came here around lunch time. The inside is super cute, cool bar area. Everything we got was super good and really cool lattes on the menu. read more

See all

The Sycamore is another long time German Village bar. It was cleaned up several years ago. That means they made it look upscale. It also got some jacked up prices. The food is good though. It has a pretty big list of cocktails. Only one of these is on happy hour. They could put some more variety into the happy hour specials. All of the food had meat in it. The only vegetarian entrees were about $15 or more. It's certainly not the dive bar it used to be. The beer selection is greatly improved. It also has other beverages. A Crispin cider is $6 for a pint. There's a whole page of various wines. Back to the overpriced food. The food so far tastes good thankfully. I had the guacamole and chips. It's $8 for a bowl of in house made chips with a heaping pile of guacamole. The guacamole has real nice spice. It can get really crowded. An early in the week happy hour isn't bad. They also have a free valet sometimes, so yeah, it's not the dive bar it was. read more

Sycamore - Cider With Guacamole And Chips - Bars Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Excellent seasonal crab cakes, wonderful service from their team and a delightful location in the heart of German Village. Always a good idea to book a reservation if you can. Don't miss this charming spot in Columbus. read more

Great dining experience and loved the rustic decor. Food was great! The focaccia bread was soft and melted in my mouth. The broth in the curry mussels was extremely rich - almost wish there was more bread or some pasta to take more of it. The entrees were all each special as well. Service was amazing as well and prompt. read more

See all

Dinner here was the perfect lil spot to catch up with a friend and enjoy some great food and drinks. Gorgeous interior. The holiday decor is tasteful and beautiful. Whoever decorated this restaurant, will you please come over and decorate my house?! Drinks: -"Semester Abroad" with wahaka mezcal - margarita with a touch of lavender -Rioja Sierra Cantabria 2017 - medium bodied and juicy yet not sweet Food: - Charcuterie & cheese - all charcuterie boards should include olives and pickles and this one delivered - Brussels sprouts - the sweet and savory and zestiness of this app! Bacon + pomegranate is an unexpected but amazing pair - Mussels - did not expect the kick of this sauce. So GOOD. - Frites - rosemary and parm should always go together. Fries were the perfect texture - Hanger steak - simple and delicious. Balsamic marinade, Italian verde, blistered tomatos - Ravioli - beautiful dish. Another savory and sweet dish with housemade pasta and rich flavors - Clam chowder - tasty/comforting with whole middle neck clams Will definitely come back to this cozy spot! read more

See all

When i first moved to the area i noticed a lot of people always gathering around this restaurant but i wasn't sure what it really was. I've been here for coffee and for dinner. When i went for coffee i got a blueberry muffin and once more i got a blueberry scone. The muffin was amazing and my coffee was pretty good. My mom got the omelette which looked great! For dinner the atmosphere was really warm and intimate. I got a tequila lavender drink (i don't remember the name) and i was really impressed. I for sure will return for drinks. For dinner i got the lobster roll but everyone's plates looked so good. The lobster roll was good (especially for Ohio) but wasn't my all time fav. If i returned I'd be eager to try other dishes! read more

Sycamore - Bars Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

beautiful spot for a nice dinner! the ambiance is refined without being snobby; clean, comfy interior with low lighting is perfect for an intimate dinner. service is so nice and recommended great drinks and dishes based on our preferences. i can't remember all we got but the focaccia was a crowd pleaser and my chicken entree was perfect. i would love to visit again! read more

Sycamore - chicken - Bars Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Absolutely our new favorite restaurant for any cute date night. Everything we ordered was unbelievable, and may just be the best food we've had in a long time. The service was fantastic as well, our starter bread and appetizer came out ever so slightly slow, so the server gave us the app and desert on the house with no prompting. Can't wait to go back! read more

We had an early dinner this evening, very nice interior..My daughter couldnt eat her dinner, way too salty..My pork loin was overcooked & the mashed potatoes were too salty, Main issue was the service, our waiter was training someone, which was not a problem-but he could use some training himself-He did not remove our bread plates before our dinner was served. I asked him for a steak knife when he served my pork loin--he told me the meats so tender I dont need one....just use my existing silverware...well, my pork loin was not tender-it was over cooked. We won't go back--food was over salted & mediocre. Unimpressed. read more

Great neighborhood spot. Reliable, good food and service. Nice place for any occasion.

My experience at Sycamore was AWKWARD and DISAPPOINTING. First off one person in our party had diet restrictions and the waiter was not accommodating stating "food is pre made" (pre-made? - a simple no cooking required appetizer? )... Additionally we could tell and even commented with one another that the waiter was 100% rushing us with ordering (stopped by every few minutes asking if we were ready to order when he could clearly see we weren't and were enjoying our glasses of wine and conversing)... fine dining is different than eating at Wendy's I like to take my time and not be rush (Especially when I am spending a few hundred dollars at dinner) So here is the climax to my review. When I closed my tab and I left what I thought was a fair tip based on my above experience the waiter ran me down and started complaining to me. Any restaurant waiter/waitress who runs down a customer and brings this up is so out of line. For specifics I gave a decent tip based on my experience at this establishment (10% NOT 0%). There is a first for everything but I am really blown away and feel DISRESPECTED that I was ran down like I did not PAY MY FEW HUNDRED DOLLAR TAB. Not to mention the people in my party witnessing this. A Cameron Mitchell restaurant would never tolerate a waiter doing this and for the above reason I will not be back to Sycamore. read more

I loved this place pre-lockdown and I love it now! Their new menu is very suitable for winter warmnesss and there is something for everyone! Meat eater or not, You'll be able to eat well here! read more

Sycamore - Bars Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

May 2022 update: Was able to get into Sycamore again while in town. The chef and staff continue to impress. Brussels sprouts and the seasonal lamb chops were remarkable. Nick was at the bar - his old fashion is excellent and get his beekeeper cocktail. Overall the service is simply outstanding, particularly Gretchen. An absolute gem in German Village. read more

Sycamore - Bars Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

The food, ambiance, and cocktails are awesome. It is definitely a pricier spot but I'd say it's worth it if you can swing it! It seems they put a lot of love into their culinary craft. LOVE the lavender marg. Charcuterie and steak frites have always made my tums happy. Service is polite. Having a reservation is preferred. read more

My husband and I stopped by because we had a gift card from a few years ago, we didn't use it due to COVID putting a halt to many things then we actually forget we had it. When we realized we still had this gift card decided to use it, well we got there and could not use the card as they had been sold and that card was through the old company...so that was a huge bummer we had no idea, especially since they kept the name. However, we decided to stay and ordered beer and food. The beer menu was limited with beers we would prefer, however we were able to find something we liked. On to the food, the menu was VERY limited 3 choices, it was lunch time, and pretty pricey but that is ok if the food is good. We got the burger and I must say it was delicious! Had some unique toppings that made the flavor pop and the burger price was not over the top for the quality and taste. Bartender was very friendly and helpful. Nice restaurant overall and the food and service was good. If you are in the German Village area worth a stop in, I personally wouldn't make this a destination place and drive into German Village just for the Sycamore, but if in the area worth a try. read more

Wonderful spot, stopped in on a whim and it lived up to the reviews! Great welcoming service and after a perfect Sycamore Old fashion, the meal recommendations were perfect! Sticky Carrots and the short rib ragu were excellent! Great ambiance and food with friendly people, can't miss! read more

We love The Sycamore. Great atmosphere food and staph. Blaine, the general manager is amazing. He is so welcoming and accommodating. He is good at everything he does. He makes every visit feel like an event!! keep up the great work ! read more

The best food with the best vibes! The service was amazing. It was very cozy and the food came out quickly. We ordered the BLT sandwiches with the Sycamore salad. read more

See all