Honestly, the sushi rolls are always fresh and delicious. The size of the rolls are solid and the presentation is beautiful every time. I've eaten lunch here twice this week and dine-in regularly. The service is efficient, friendly, and consistent. The clear broth soup and salad with ginger dressing always starts me off as an appetizer. And the main event (usually 2-3 specialty rolls) never disappoints. Fried Oreo cookies and whip are given as a complimentary dessert which is nice. Overall, Sushiya is on my top regular rotation for value meals and consistency. read more

See all

Mediocre soup, less than mediocre roll, server never spoke to me until I got up to pay. Glass was sticky. Sushi chef was working hard. I cannot imagine eating here again. No idea why they seem busy. read more

See all

There is a reason this place has stayed open and busy for so long. The sushi is fresh and great quality, as well as portions. The service is always top notch. They treat you like family. I had the best birthday dinner here today with my family! read more

Sushiya - 54. U.S.A. Roll 63. Tuna & Avocado Roll 36. Salmon Katsu Roll 46. Rainbow Roll - Sushi Bars Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

Been going here for years but no more. The owner is an unpleasant lady who doesn't look like she cares if you're there or not. The son just doesn't want to be bothered. Only bright spot is mama. Food is adequate but not worth the hassle. read more

Don't be fooled by it seeming like a whole in the strip mall wall! This place is great. Their holiday roll is such a treat. Fast too.

I went here for lunch and it was so good!! The service was excellent - my food came out so fast and it was all delicious! A great value for the price, too! The interior is small and quiet. I'll be back for sure! read more

Sushiya - Sushi Roll Lunch Special - Shrimp Tempura Roll, Tokyo Roll, Soup, and Salad - Sushi Bars Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

See all

Nom nom.. I have been here countless times, and it never disappoints! The sushi is what draws me here! Fresh & well-prepared! Not outrageously expensive either! The Tokyo Roll is delish! read more

Sushiya - a plate of sushi rolls and a plate of chips - Sushi Bars Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

I have always had good service, eating in and taking out. It has always been fresh sushi at reasonable prices. Do not be fooled by the small restaurant in a strip mall. I lived in Japan and I think this is the best local Fleming Island sushi. Hasn't disappointed yet read more

Service was bad. Ordered things multiple times that never arrived. Charged for items that never arrived. Order wait 10 minutes. Ask again repeat. Very poor quality fish and preparation of sushi. Awful experience all together. read more

Not my cup of tea. The tuna salad looked good but was not. The restaurant is packed with old furniture.. you are literally sitting on top of one another. There is a sushi bar and it's sushi was... just okay. I would not recommend unless your belly is touching your back hungry and there is no place else to go... read more

Little hole in the wall shop. Really enjoyed the sushi rolls here. Great variety and good prices. We came here around 11 for lunch and it got full pretty fast. Lunch specials were under $14 Would recommend it! read more

Sushiya - a restaurant with tables and chairs - Sushi Bars Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

Sushiya can also be pronounced SUSHI "YAY" in our family! This is a hidden gem in a strip mall of Fleming Island ... it's fairly quiet and the staff has always been friendly the couple of times we've been here. I had the dragon roll and the TNT roll. My son had the kids teriyaki with steamed white rice and vegetables and he devoured it without talking throughout the entire meal so we know it was great! I can't remember the names of the rolls my boyfriend ordered but he said they were fantastic as well. The sweet ending is when our server brought us fried Oreo cookies with whipped cream! YUM!!! read more

See all

We started with our family favorite, edamame. Crisp and just the right amount of salt. Followed by some clear soup. Soup was average. Service was prompt. For supper we ordered a variety of sushi rolls. I would definitely recommend the Dragon Roll. Overall it was a nice dining experience for a week night outing. No need to get all dressed up at this place. Casual attire is fine. read more

I ordered my food at 6:18 p.m. I finally asked at 7:00 p.m if my order was done. I was told that my food had been given away because someone had the same order. I've never experienced service like this. No apology or anything. Everyone else was being assisted immediately but they basically ignored me until asked I about my order. read more

Honestly very upset. I got to the restaurant 18 minutes after ordering through the phone and my food was ready but when I got home I was shocked. Mainly upset that the Godzilla roll was 11.95$ and it was covered in extra bread crumbs and tasted like it sat out for hours. Was happy about the absurd amount of wasabi and ginger though. read more

See all

Went with friends who wanted sushi. I don't eat sushi but was told other items on the menu, like steak hibachi. My husband and I both agreed this was one of the worse meals we have ever had. The service was "hurried" in a way that questions were frowned upon. The rice and noodles were flavorless. The "salad" consisted of iceberg lettuce with a cup of dressing thrown on top. The restaurant itself was dark and dingy, old furniture which is fine if clean and cared for. We will politely decline if our friends ever invite us out again to this restaurant. If you don't eat sushi, don't waste your time or money. read more

Growing up on Fleming Island, this has been the most consistent Japanese restaurant near here. For the price that you pay the portions are larger than you would have expected, and the service is always on point. The sushi is always fresh it seems as though they take great pride in making sure things are up to a above average standard The only quarrel I have is with the interior/seating options that are at this location compared to others. It can get busy at some points in the week, and finding a table is near impossible, unless you'd like to be on-top of another table indirectly allowing them to hear everything you're saying and vice versa. Consistency is worth returning though, and I would recommend this restaurant. read more

Sushiya - Crunchy roll & Chicken Hibachi - Sushi Bars Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

Hibachi was really good seasoned well very attentive was asked several times that I need anything loving it will definitely be back!!!

This time coming here was a major disappointment. Our sushi was warm when we got it. Also my boyfriend got food poisoning from eating the cold maki roll. It looked like our order was with a big pile of other orders that have been sitting there as well. This used to be our favorite place for sushi but now it's become our last. Will not come again. read more

If I'm going to get sushi, it's going to be from Sushiya. I've been coming here for years. I usually get vegetable fried rice + a highway 17 roll. Depending on how hungry I am, I order 2 to 3 more rolls. I can never get enough of Sushiya! My only complaint is the customer service is usually very sub par. But the food is so good, I'll always come back for more! read more

Sushiya - Vegetable fried rice Highway 17 roll Crunchy roll - Sushi Bars Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

This is the worst sashimi I've ever had. First of all it was so cut into a sloppy mess of chopped cuts that were all over the place. Then I noticed that the slices of salmon (my personal favorite) were really super small. When I put the salmon in My mouth I realized it had began to turn bad!! Plus I didn't even receive the sushi nigiri in my order. If you care about your health, PASS on this place! read more

Eat there all the time with the family, the food is good and staff is friendly. We will continue to order from them.

Best sushi in Fleming Island!!! Looks like a hole in the wall but aren't those typically the best? Very nice staff, family run business so you know quality is important to them. read more

Visited for first time in a long time for a birthday celebration. Sushi rolls were good. Service was horrible. Server never came back to take dinner order until we were completely finished with rolls. I had asked her for something, and I truly felt like I was bothering her. Unfortunately I will not be going back. read more

Been coming here for years and definitely the best sushi place around. Not only is the food and service, excellent, but the owners good will towards their customers is second to none. Can't say enough good things about them! read more

My boyfriends family frequents sushiya a lot! It's always been their favorite sushi restaurant and I can see why. They have great prices and the food is always great! read more

We have lived only a few miles from this little Asian spot for years but only just ventured in. So not a date night, and no need to put on your heels or comb the beard, but this hits the spot if you want to munch. The portions were large, the special sauce waiting on the table and the wait staff quite pleasant. The only down sides were fried rice is bland and check out is literally in the dining area, so cheers for the tight China Town feel of a New York eatery. read more

See all

Excellent service and always fantastic food. Highly recommend this for any sushi cravings.

We just ordered Uber Eats from this place. Perfect 5.0 service! We got 2 steak hibachi dinners and 1 TNT roll We called because my wife needed her steak well done and it wasn't an option on the app. They said "no problem" and when the food arrived, her steak was well done and even notated on the receipt. There was TONS of food for a very reasonable amount of money (ginger salad, miso soup, sushi, large portions of steak, veggies, rice, noodles). $45 total with delivery fees and taxes. They didn't even skimp on the sauces (tons of yumyum sauce, soy, and tempura) Last but not least, the food arrived steaming hot and exactly like we ordered. Overall great experience! Will order again for sure. read more

The floors were so greasy, it was difficult to walk. Our server didn't smile once and seemed like she didn't want to be there. She brought out clear soup for everyone without asking if anyone wanted Miso. I don't eat mushrooms so I asked for Miso. She advised of the wrong vegetables that came with the Tempura. They added broccoli, that I did not order or eat. The food was excellent, but service was horrible. I guess it was a cost savings as we did not leave a tip. read more

Sushiya has the best sushi in Fleming island for lunch hands down! The lunch special for sushi is not as extensive but the price is worth it! read more

See all

Worst costumer service--- sushi has nothing in special really simple no flavor definitely will never be back to this place

Once upon a time it Was a nice place to order from and quick however this time of ordering for delivery they put my RAW fish right next to FRIED sushi roll. So my raw fish that is supposed to be kept under a certain temperature to prevent food poisoning is HOT. On top of that my $3 side of rice is less than a cup of rice, everywhere else charges $2.50-$4 and gives you anywhere between 3-5 cups of rice. read more

Sushiya - the inside of a styrofoam container - Sushi Bars Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

See all

Quarantine Review: This place is crushing it! Pick up only, blocked off by plexiglass-glass. Every person in that joint was masked and gloved. And they sanitized the "hand-off space" after every customer. This was already my favorite sushi place in town. The peace of mind their service gave me today was worth 6 stars. read more

They have seriously gone downhill since they reopened. Sushi was subpar at best. I won't be back. Too many good restaurants to eat that.

Sushi was fresh and delicious. When picking up our takeout, young person at register did not greet and he didn't say thank you. read more

This is my favorite to go to Sushi place. Sometimes I am there once a week. It is cheeper then most sushi restaurants and has great food. My favorite rolls here are Highway 17, and the Crunchy roll. If you are looking for a salad the Kani salad (cucumber and crab) is awesome. Some kind of spicy sauce on the top of the salad. My favorite for the hibachi is steak and shrimp it always amazing here. Dinner is too large a portion for me. I always have to get a to go container with Hibachi and I'm eating it for two meals after. At the end they bring you a tempura fried Oreo with whipped cream. Yum! read more

best place to eat for lunch if you're craving hibachi! i love this place, their lunch prices definitely match the quality of food. if you order during lunch you can get chicken and steak hibachi (my usual order) that also comes with rice, noodles, veggies, soup, and salad (ginger or ranch) for only about 12-15$. they definitely don't jip you out of food, that's for sure, it'll fill you up and it tastes so good. the people are so incredibly nice! and if you decide to eat inside, when they bring you your check they come out with fried oreos, it's like the cherry on top. definitely a place to try if you want some cheap, but good quality and tasty hibachi food! read more

Sushiya - Sushi Bars Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

Look like a little luck in the tranny but when you walk inside and has a great atmosphere the atmosphere was very Japanese like very fresh and then when you go and sit down the tables are pretty decently spread apart from each other so you have enough space and it was fairly set down fairly quickly I knew exactly what I wanted which was the spicy tuna roll but I like the crunchy spicy tuna roll and with that I also had a thing of miso soup which was just the right size it wasn't too big to small hose just right and I was expecting it to take a little bit of a while but it was not it was actually came out really quick and nice and fresh and then also on top of that when I was expecting the bill to be around $15 for those two things I was floored because it was only $5.30 that filled me up I am full satisfied and ready to rock and roll and I was in and out within 20 minutes can't beat that I found my next secret my diamond in the rough little sushi spot I will go again read more

Sushiya - For a roll and miso soup which was delish btw can't beat that - Sushi Bars Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

See all

The whole business is a JOKE!!!! I watched them cuss a DoorDash driver out like they were nothing because the 10 year old child they have running the register rang the order up wrong and they got confused on what he did and the DoorDash card declined they then proceeded to throw the food at the driver and cussed her out and told her to leave!!! Yes..... I said throw the food..... if you can imagine then yes.... that kind of throw.... If you don't want to get possibly cussed out and embarrassed in front of the whole restaurant, I wouldn't come here! Poor girl...... I'm sure the child they have working the register isn't getting paid either..... their has to be some type of child labor law! read more