It doesn't look like much when you walk by but I wanted sushi so I popped in. The staff were very friendly. Place was clean. Ordered a few different sushi rolls. Came out quickly and were fantastic. The bonus of the place- they keep the shrimp sauce in the table. I will definitely return again! read more

Amazing sushi Ok to modify Amazing hibachi Cucumber salad addictive Lunch great prices Clear soup delish Shrimp sauce the best Round Try the rice less sushi if going low carb-it's delish read more

Sushiya is my favorite sushi spot in Fleming Island. Its lovingly cradled away in a moderate-to-high traffic mini-mall (blink and you could miss it, but don't). You walk in and are immediately presented with a 1980s vending machine selling temporary tattoos. I got a butterfly one (well worth it). You'd be surprised how busy this little spot can get, but the food comes out rather quickly so if you're waiting, you won't wait long. Could Sushiya be worthy of a 5 star review? Definitely. But it's not quite there yet. I have a few nitpicks but nothing too serious. Let's discuss. Dont take this the wrong way, but everything is sticky. The tables, the sushi bar counter, the various sauces on the tables. While it's an easy fix and an obvious issue, it remains nonetheless. The spicy tuna roll (my favorite roll) could be spicier. Lastly, the service could be a little better, but it's not anything terrible. Some positive notes- the prices are reasonable, the menu is pretty great, the food service is fast, the parking is convenient, and the lunch deals are fantastic! read more

Best Sushi restaurant ever!! We used to go to manakai on Kingsley before they closed it, at the time they served the best sushi. We found Sushiya and have never had a bad meal! read more

We've only gotten take out hibachi from this place, but every time we do it is great. Awesome fried rice, I appreciate the amount of food they give. Great value, repeat customer. read more

This place doesn't look like much from outside..... it's in a strip mall but the food is always soooo good, prices are fair and staff friendly! We love this place and go often! read more

Sushiya is the best sushi on Fleming island and has been since it's opened. The sushi is always fresh and the people are nice and the service is excellent. It's not the nicest on the inside and could use some updates to renovate the inside but the food is far superior to sushi cafe across the street. Sushiya is closed Mondays so I was forced to go to sushi cafe last week and it was awful. The tuna was bad and fake looking with a light pink color instead of the dark red it should look like. I won't eat their again but will always come back to sushiya. The fried Oreos if you dine in for free are always an amazing touch. Love sushiya. read more

my best friend and I have been going for years but I'm vegetarian now and they will not substitute a soup for a salad when I pay for a soup it's ridiculous and rude and I'm getting fed up with it I will no longer return. read more

Fleming Island is seriously lacking in both local food businesses and cuisine diversity. I'm thankful that I know about this little gem for when I need my sushi fix (which is often, I was probably Japanese in another life). Seemingly a hole-in-the-wall, this place looks like it's a part of the neighboring Chinese restaurant so don't be fooled when you arrive. The staff has always been friendly both in person and on the phone. I've only ever gotten takeout, but the atmosphere for those who dine-in is pretty charming. Granted I've never been to Asia, let alone Japan, to try sushi there but the sushi here is pretty darn good and reasonably priced. My favorite roll is the spicy tuna, and if you're making a meal the side of fried rice and clear soup is a great (and cheap) option. I've also tried the lunch steak and shrimp hibachi, and I would give it 3/5 stars because both the steak and the shrimp were overcooked. The rest of it was excellent though. This is my favorite establishment "I'm hungry", "I don't want to cook", and/or "I really want sushi" on Fleming Island. read more

Great food. Very fresh and real friendly service. I will be back soon. My first time here.

I've been coming here off and on since it opened. At first I thought it was alright, cheap and average. Now, I walk in after coming back home to visit and the fish looks old and unnatural, the Chinese guys here working aren't the friendliest and seem like they're just going through the motions, the place is a mess, the furniture is falling apart, the paint on the wall is chipping off... It just seems shady and disgusting for a place serving raw, uncooked food. I've eaten in some very sketchy places in 3rd world countries, but I expect a little more here in America and in Fleming Island, a supposedly upper-middle class to upper class community. This is not to mention the massive health code violations I found while waiting for my food online. Even the avocado on my roll was black and rotten. If you absolutely have to have sushi in Fleming Island, consider Saigon-Tokyo across the street, but I would venture further out to the Southside or Riverside. If you have to eat at Sushiya, make sure it's cooked. All-in-all, this place is shit and probably should be shut down by the health department. read more

Sushiya - Rotten Avocado - Sushi Bars Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

See all

Oh, sushiya! This by far my favorite sushi place, ever. It's so small and cozy. It's always quiet, so it makes a good place to have conversation while you dine. Everyone that works there is so polite. The dynamite roll is so delicious and if you don't like sushi, they have hibachi stuff. Make sure you're really hungry because they give you SO MUCH food, you'll definitely be bringing some home. The staff makes sure that your drink is never empty! It's a really affordable place to go. I have never been disappointed going here! read more

Great local sushi place. The Kelmon and JAX roll was very good. The service was great and the rolls were made quickly. Definitely recommend this place to any sushi lover. read more

As for the food it was OK the service is horrible if I asked for a plate, straw or anything it was an attitude and slammed onto the table every time. I said thank you there was no you're welcome it was completely utterly the worst experience I've ever had sitting down eating anywhere !!! I was in disbelief of how I was getting treated. I will never take my family there or recommend anybody sitting there and dining in. It's sad when you just want to go and eat with your family and end up being treated so rude and badly that you just want to finish and get out of there. read more

This place is my go-to sushi place when I'm in Jacksonville. It's a small business off the street in Fleming Island, but don't let the exterior fool you Inside, it is very clearly Asian inspired. Despite the small space, we were able to be seated during lunch time. Here, you can find all the typical Japanese fare from sushi to hibachi. Make sure to come for the lunch special when there are a variety of sushi combos and hibachi specials to choose from! I always get the spicy salmon roll when I come here. At just over 4 dollars, it is probably one of the cheapest full-priced spicy salmon rolls that I have had. The other specialty rolls don't get too much more expensive thankfully. This roll comes with plenty of pieces (8 pieces per order) which leaves me satisfied every time. Make sure you dip it in their white sauce too! That sauce here is to die for. Overall, it is a VERY solid sushi restaurant for anyone looking to get affordable sushi that doesn't want to go to the Chinese buffet across the street. read more

THESE PEOPLE ARE RUDE. They act bothered that you're there. None of them speak any English. They just kind of nod their heads at you. They got my order wrong all three times Ive been there. Today when I called up there to inform them that they're Beef tataki was extremely over cooked. The lady argued with me and told me it was fine then hung up on me. And the lady up front who seats you is rude. While I was placing my order - she ignored most of what I said and sat on her phone. I will not be returning to this establishment. read more

We enjoy Sushiya Sushi. We're regulars and go atleast once a week and have been for years. Sushi is always fresh and the service has always been great. Nice family run business. I can't say that we've ever tried anything other than the sushi. It's so great we never try anything else. We will continue to eat at Sushiya! read more

Amazing food! The lunch special is incredible. It's a small little hole in the wall place, but you never leave with an empty stomach! (Bottles of yum yum sauce on each table are a plus too) read more

Freshest sushi on the island. This place is amazing! When we are craving sushi, this is our go to place! Friendly service, clean surroundings, excellent food! It's small so I wouldn't recommend large parties coming without calling ahead of time. I love the atmosphere cuz it's quiet, quaint and laid back. The chef is all biz which is a good thing because it is reflected in the amazing food! If you are in the area, stop in, you won't be disappointed. read more

Sushiya - Alaskan roll, eel roll, cucumber roll, Philly roll, yellow tail sashimi, salmon sashimi - freshest sushi anywhere!! - Sushi Bars Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

See all

Foods great! Until you try to get a lil extra meat/shrimp in your hibachi. They charge $1.50 for ONE shrimp. That's ridiculous. If I'm paying per shrimp, Jackie Chan himself better roundhouse kick the order to my house. I'd give at least 3 stars, but that'll work $1.50 a star. read more

Love their sushi and habachi grill lunches and dinners. Great service and the food is always excellent. The deep fried vanilla Oreo with whipped cream free dessert is always a treat! read more

Best sushi I have had in Jacksonville and great prices also. Will come back again possible tomorrow.

If there was a 2.5 star option, I would be tempted to go with that. I feel 3 is too generous and 2 is too harsh....so I'm stuck. *But after too many Health Department issues, 1 star works I hadn't been here since 2006, maybe 2007(?), but a friend loves their sushi and a night after dance and it being too late to drive to Bento, my daughter and I came here. This visit has solidified my loyalty to Bento for sushi and my belief that there is no good hibachi place on Fleming Island....or really anywhere in Jacksonville. Not anymore anyway! Phillip's Sushi was always a favorite for hibachi but lately they've been more of the miss factor than the hit factor. (insert long exasperated sigh) My daughter and I ordered 3 sushi rolls; Spicy Tuna, Godzilla, and Tataki. We also each got a Hibachi Dinner Plate with fried rice. (gluttonous, I know) The sushi was room temperature and that always makes me nervous for some type of food borne illness...room temp raw fish...but we didn't get sick. So that's a positive! The Godzilla was my daughter's favorite; the Shrimp Tempura in it had almost a sweet taste. My daughter and I did enjoy the sushi but we both agreed Bento is the best! Salad: Ginger dressing, but very orange in color and it had a distinct orange (like the citrus fruit) flavor to it. Soup: Okay, but lukewarm and the bowl was maybe half-full. Or half-empty depending on how you want to look at it! The fried rice didn't appear fried at all. And like my fried rice with a bit of veggies (e.g. peas, carrots, and chopped onion) in it. This had none of that but did have a little fried egg. And based on the white spots throughout, they must have squirted some soy sauce on white rice before sending it out and proclaiming it as "fried". Blah. The steak was of poor quality - I realized later she never asked how we wanted it cooked. Fairly certain it came out well done. But the flavor was akin to hamburger meat and it tasted the lowest grade of sirloin possible...if it was sirloin, I've no idea. And the shrimp tasted like it came from a BBQ restaurant (!?). Odd, I know....but it did. And it was absolutely frozen not fresh. The vegetables were the best part of the meal; the ones that were seasoned anyway. Their Shrimp Sauce looked like run of the mill Shrimp sauce, the right color and consistency, but had minimal flavor. IF we go back, we'll probably stick to sushi as their hot entrees were nothing to excite my palate. read more

Sushi is so fresh and delicious. Lots of fresh fish inside and just the right amount of rice. A win every time!

Hands down my favorite sushi joint! Greeted once we got in the door. They immediately took our drink order and were intuitive to when we were ready to order. It didn't take too long for the order come out. It was so delectable. Once we were done they came and took the plates and to our surprise we were treated to deep fried oreos. Never had an empty drink. All of this for a decent and fair price. read more

This place used to be one our favorites. Sadly, the place has suffered. Order Gyoza for an appetizer, which was soggy. Yes, we ordered steamed, but did not expect the dough to fall apart. The soup...luke warm. The sushi was good...Florida roll still a favorite, but that was the only plus of the day. read more

This is my favorite sushi place around. Once or twice a week I stop in to get sushi to go. The service, on the times I've actually eaten there, is great and my drink seems to always be magically full every time I look away from it. The fish is always flavorful and fresh (which is, frankly, important when dealing with raw fish). Drive past all those teppan places in Fleming Island and stop in here if you want some good sushi. read more

the food is good. but the women owner has the worst customer service. she need to stay in the back because she had an attitude with me and the gentleman in front of me. read more

This was my go to spot for Sushi. Then the quality started to disappear like Lebron James hairline. Getting hit with health violations only solidified that point. Man, if they only just cared. When businesses start making a lot of money the care and quality go out the window read more

Sushiya is a nice restaurant. The first time I came was with my daughter. We agreed to try it out and was very pleased! Sushiya is one of my few favorite sushi restaurants. read more

Unfortunately I didn't have the best experience here. I ordered the spicy tuna, California, crazy tuna, and the hungry roll. The spicy tuna still had a lot of chunks of tuna in it. It wasn't blended real well. The California was an Alaska roll I don't eat salmon so they took that off but gave me attitude like that was what I ordered they checked the order and it had California. The hungry roll was so so bland no flavor. The crazy tunas avacodo was not ripe. Super hard to the point it was crunchy and almost inedible only ate one piece so they didn't charge me for that one either. The soup and salad were good. Probably won't come back. read more

Sushiya - Sushi Bars Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

The staff and service was fine, cute little area. The sushi was decent, but the rice and chicken katsu was not good and overcooked

I really enjoy having a solid sushi place close to home. They have reasonable prices and provide a high quality product. Tucked in a strip behind Home Depot, Sushiya provides dine in or take out for Fleming Island residents/visitors. Enjoy any of their variety of rolls, freshly made by the sushi chefs. Their soups are a great start to your experience. I've also had their udon noodles with chicken - very good. Not the best I've ever had, but very good and close to home! read more

Delicious, Fresh, Friendly & Great Quality! Clean Too* Very Good Cuisine. Reasonably Good Prices & Yes, they swe've Alcohol! Saakii! read more

The service was quick. We had four rolls and sushimi. The Florida roll was delicious and very pretty with the knife skills for the avocado on top. The Rock in Roll was also really good. read more

Taking a star away. Strange atmosphere. We were seated quickly but when our server(who we came to find out is one of the owners) came over to our table she did not greet us at all. Her first words were, "you pay together or separate?" "What?" "You pay together or separate?" Ok. Together. Food was good and reasonable. The place is very basic. Kinda junky looking and cluttered looking around the sushi bar itself. Will we go back? Probably, but not for the ambience. read more

Went for lunch today. Got Lunch special of two rolls and soup salad. Salmon was ok but tuna had fishy smell and very dark color. Taste was off so I didn't eat it. They offered to replace but I needed to go. Sushi was also smaller than usual. read more

The best sushi restaurant around! I have been here more times than I can count and have never had a bad experience. Also they give a free appetizer and a free dessert when you go. I suggest to everyone to eat here! read more

Have been going to this place for years. It's a hidden gem in Fleming Island... Always good food and great service!

Very good sushi at reasonable prices. Unfortunately the word is out and the place is packed most nights. Try the Kelmon roll and ask them to add thinly sliced lemon on the top. Very good! read more