Clean spot, great pizza, great service! I stumbled upon these guys while out in the field at work. Lunch time came, and I looked over and saw a pizza place I didn't know existed. Now, I try to bring everyone who I know who enjoys pizza so we can support the local economy. Greeeeeat crust. read more

My husband and I had a respite evening but because the week had been busy we never made an actual plan. But thankfully he had remembered about Surefire and we love trying new (to us) places! We walked in and noticed the place was very clean and tidy, spacious with plenty of seating options (especially for us early birds as it was still before typical rush/dinner time.) We decided to get a small combo and try the garlic parm chicken wings. The pizza was stacked with toppings, the bread soft on the top, nice crunch to the edge and my favorite- the crispy bottom! I also noticed the flavor of the bread itself was very good- sometimes some places just have boring crust. The chicken wings, while for some reason I expected them to be a dry rub style, they were coated in a creamy garlic parm sauce and juicy and crispy as we bit into the. We really enjoyed the food and will be ordering from here again for sure! read more

Surefire pizza - chicken wings with garlic parm sauce - Pizza Near Me - Modesto, California

See all

I had a great experience at Surefire Pizza in Modesto! I ordered the pepperoni pizza, and it was delicious. The crust had a great texture, and the pizza was hot, fresh, and full of flavor. For dessert, I had the chocolate chip Pizookie with cookies and cream ice cream, and it was the perfect way to finish the meal--warm, gooey, and absolutely delicious! Definitely a spot I'd recommend if you're looking for some great pizza and an amazing dessert in Modesto. I'll definitely be coming back! Also, the staff we're very attentive great vibe read more

Surefire pizza - Cookies and cream, chocolate chip cookie Pazooki - Pizza Near Me - Modesto, California

I am still in search for good take out pizza in Modesto. This seems to be getting closer to what I want, wife did not seem convinced but I enjoyed it. They don't deliver so I picked up two smalls a pepperoni and an all meat. Their packs of Parmesan cheese were better quality than the green bottle we have at home so that was as good. I enjoyed the crust and the overall experience. Issue is, we just had the best pizza in Colorado so I think the wife was expecting that and as good as this was, it was not that..... Will come back and giving them 4.25 overall. When I was waiting for my order not too many people eating in all was pick up so they were busy. Will try in person next time but I think we got a winner here folks. read more

See all

We have gotten pizza from Surefire 3 times now. They have not disappointed! Everyone is friendly!! Food is made fast and the quality is great! Not a fan of sauce but they put the perfect amount and it tastes delicious! The XL pizza is way bigger than I thought! read more

Surefire pizza - Cheesy Garlic Bread 10/10 - Pizza Near Me - Modesto, California

See all

Beautiful pizzas. Beautiful customer service. Beautiful pitchers of beer. Can't believe I didn't know about this place. Please visit and tell em large marge sent ya read more

HOT HONEY SPECIALTY PIZZA?? SOOOO YUMMMMY!! No complaints. Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza - a little disappointing. The dough wasn't cooked all the way /: read more

Surefire pizza - Pizza Near Me - Modesto, California

Me and my son came here to try it out and it did not disappoint. The girl who greeted us was friendly and helpful telling us some of the popular items. We ordered a medium pepperoni pizza and the cheese garlic sticks. Everything was good the crust and sauce tasted fresh. I would definitely be back again. read more

Surefire pizza - Garlic bread sticks - Pizza Near Me - Modesto, California

See all

We drove past on our way to the tulip fields, we seen this place tucked away in a corner shopping center on the edge of town. It looked and sounded like a mom and pop place, and we knew that we would be hungry on our way home so we called in an order. We asked what they are known for and with some popular dishes are, the employee on the phone recommended we try the cheesy bread. He said that they make a homemade garlic Parmesan sauce that they put on it before the cheese, and that it really sets it apart from cheesy bread at other places. So we ordered an extra large pepperoni pizza with double pepperoni , and an order of the cheesy bread. To be honest, the cheesy bread was so delicious. We wished that we had more! It was savory, garlicy, salty and super delicious! Their crust seems to be much fresher and possibly made in house? It was much better quality than ordering a pizza at round table or any other pizza chain. Probably the best pizza I've had in a moment. We ordered to go, but the interior was nice new and clean. The bathrooms were well kept and clean as well. I think you would have a good experience ordering to go or eating in. 10 out of 10 recommend giving them a try. read more

See all

My wife wanted to try this place because of the gluten-free options. This was our first time here. I ordered a calzone and she got a gluten-free pizza in terms of the crust. Overall, both were pretty good. It wasn't too busy in here with only a few patrons. It looks like they're waiting on a few things for adult beverages. It looks like it's been piped in, but not in use also there's not much decoration on the walls. So aesthetically I wouldn't call this pleasing to the eye. But that's OK cause the food is good and the service was good as well. read more

See all

Customer service was friendly We got a combination and a veggie both were good the crust was a little doughy but tender I think next time I'll get the thin crust read more

Surefire pizza - Veggie and combination - Pizza Near Me - Modesto, California

This is my second visit and I was craving sweet and savory. The spicy honey is my favorite on the Hawaiian. Service with a smile each time and the servers are super friendly. Open seating area with a nice view of the tvs if you want to watch sports. Prices are reasonable read more

Surefire pizza - Hawaiian pizza with spicy honey - Pizza Near Me - Modesto, California

I've only tried the pepperoni pizza and it is very good. It's kind of fluffy with a crispy bottom. The pepperonis are crispy as well. The ranch is also very good. Inside feels kind of empty but it's spacious. read more

Surefire pizza - Small Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Modesto, California

YUMMMM!!! my husband and I were craving pizza after being burned on an out of town trip. We did a 1/2 chicken bacon BBQ, 1/2 supreme thin crust. It was SO good! read more

We have eaten at most of the pizza places within 30 minutes of home. That is to say, I know a good pizza place. Sure fire is hands down my favorite spot. They are so friendly when I call and when I pick up. The pizza is amazing. I've yet to dine in but I really like the clean and simple decor. They added beers on tap, so we will be dining in soon! read more

We have passed this location many times and decided this was the night to stop in. Walked in at around 5:15 on a Saturday. One group of eight were seated and their pizza arrived as we were ordering. I think their customer base is heavy in takeout. We ordered a pepperoni and sausage on original crust with red sauce for takeout. Our server said it would be about a 20-25 minute wait. My husband ordered a beer and I got an ice water bc they don't have wine. We seated ourselves and before long our pizza was brought to our table. The server asked if I wanted ranch, I said yes please and she brought me three. We headed home to Oakdale and dug in. We both agreed it tasted fresh, with a delicious crust, perfect chew, good topping to sauce ratio. Service was pleasant and on point, too! I am hoping they add wine to the menu. They do have a small but good looking salad bar and a small section with some ice cream offerings. We will definitely return! Give them a try. read more

Excellent pizza! Great customer service. Will definitely be coming back. Nice to have a good pizza place on this side of town

1st time trying this new pizza place. It was 10/10. Great Food. Quick! The garlic cheese sticks amazing. Wings were big and delicious. Pizza was great! Crunchy but soft inside. Great Flavor. Nice clean restaurant ! Will definitely be back! read more

Surefire pizza - Pizza Near Me - Modesto, California

The pizza here is incredible! Original crust is a little chewy, with the right amount of bite, slightly crispy and bready. A little bit of all the best things. We got a medium half just cheese and half pep pine jalapeño. The ranch is perfect pizza ranch, creamy and herbaceous. The service was friendly and when they brought out the pizza they suggested we have the hot honey with the pep and pine and it was fire! Clean space and good pizza joint vibes and music. 10/10 would recommend. read more

Surefire pizza - Medium original crust, red sauce, half pep pine jalapeño and half cheese only - Pizza Near Me - Modesto, California

5 stars for the pizza. The pizza is sure fireeee! But, message to the owner. Please tone the ranch down , its super salty. Not sure if you guys buy it made or make it there. Ranch is salty combined with the pizza is twice as salty lol if you guys make it there, can you guys remake the recipe pleaseeee lol and start a rewards/loyalty program. Lots of people would benefit from it and so would you guys. Bless! read more

Decided to give this new spot a try. Some of the best pizza we've had in a while. We got the combo pizza and some garlic bread, which was to die for. The combo pizza is LOADED with toppings. Definitely going to try their wings next time we go. The service was great. They gave us some ranch, marinara sauce (amazing), cheese and red pepper. We can't wait to come back and try some more! read more

Surefire pizza - Combo pizza - Pizza Near Me - Modesto, California

See all

The food was absolutely phenomenal. The garlic Parmesan wings were the best wings I've ever had! Service was fantastic, Sofia was welcoming and incredibly attentive! We will definitely be back! read more

Surefire pizza - Pizza Near Me - Modesto, California

It was ight, flavortown non existent Fresh, yes Crispy? Yes Just i dont know not flavorful read more

We came in on a Saturday - decided to dine in after driving past it and wanted to give it a try. We ordered a small vegetarian pizza, a calzone, and the BBQ wings. Everything was delicious! The portions were generous, and all of the food came out hot and fresh. One thing that really stood out was the service -- the employees checked in on us throughout our meal to make sure we were satisfied and well taken care of. Overall, a great experience and definitely a place we'd recommend! read more

Love their pizza and cheesy bread!! The dough is awesome, great crust. Service was great and didn't take long at all. It's ambiance could be better. Little bit bare bones. Maybe more decor or style will come later. Can't wait to eat here again. read more

Your pizza was soooo good!!, I can't tell how much tipes of your pizza's!! Combining more pizzas,you can make a pizza mix!! I want more drinks that are good for kids read more

Tried the spicy pepperoni with hot honey and the bacon ranch half-and-half absolutely incredible! The flavors were perfectly balanced, the ingredients were fresh, and the crust was just right. Surefire Pizza is a must-try for anyone who loves bold, delicious pies. read more

Surefire pizza - Half & half so fire - Pizza Near Me - Modesto, California

Decided to try Surefire Pizza the other night. To say I was impressed is an understatement. The BBQ Chicken pizza was amazing! Flavor was on point and they definitely do not skimp on the toppings! I think we've found our new go to for pizza! Try it, you won't be disappointed. I forgot to take a picture before the family devoured it We're going to try all the specialty pizzas, next time I'll add a photo! read more

Good food , great service and just an overall great experience. The place was very clean and the pizza and wings were a hit for us. read more

Surefire pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Modesto, California

Let me start by saying the service was excellent. From the time I gave my order until I left the restaurant, the employees were very attentive. So, this place gets four stars for service. Now for the food. I ordered a small pizza with mushroom and artichoke. I also ordered barbecued wings. The wings were good. They had a little too much sauce for me, and we're messy. The pizza however, was subpar. It was extremely doughy. The cheese and toppings were very sparse. I did not like it. A+ for Service, C for food. read more

Late night stop 25 mins before closing ordered a pie. It was good! Pizza B+ service A+ will try again. read more

Surefire pizza - Large pepperoni with olives - Pizza Near Me - Modesto, California

Great pizza with a lot of toppings! it was a hit and will be a new family favorite! So happy they are in my neighborhood!

I've tried Me&eds, gold dust, round table, bob's take N bake. Hands down Surefire has the best white sauce chicken pizza. It's the Chicken bacon ranch pizza. The crust along with all the flavors marry so well. The crust is not too thick, crispy edges, good flavor and overall good texture and flavor ...love read more

Came Wednesday night which seemed like a perfect time to come. Not a lot of people and service was really fast. We decided on hawaiian and meat lovers and let me say such a good pizza and at a good price. Would definitely be returning. Also not to mention the 2 gentle men that were there were very attentive and nice. read more

Love this place. It's like a breath of fresh air with all the older pizza places around Modesto. Service is always great. Pizza always hot and they have many options to choose from. Meat lovers, combo, Hawaiian, and sweet heat are our must haves. read more

Surefire pizza - Sweet heat - Pizza Near Me - Modesto, California

Really, really, good pizza and friendly service. We ordered take out. I was amazed at how clean the restaurant was. We learned about this place from the article in the newspaper article. Two thumbs up Surefire! read more

Surefire pizza - Pizza Near Me - Modesto, California

Excellent pizza, nice people, good service. Interior is functional. We did takeout and it was great - piping hot and full of toppings.

I am always looking for new spot for pizza. This is fairly close to my house l, so we have it a shot, and weren't disappointed. We only had pepperoni, but it was good. The crust was crispy, the cheese and pepperoni were generous, and the sauce was really good. It was really slow, like one other couple in there, so I hope it picks up business and lasts. The staff were super friendly too. I'll definitely go back and am looking forward to trying something more than just pep. Please, go try this place, I want it to stay open, and I think you'll like it too. read more

We got the chicken and bacon BBQ pizza! Loved it. The bread and cheese were phenomenal! The bacon was a little fatty but everything else was fabulous. We came on our anniversary and I wasn't disappointed. The ranch was bomb too! read more

Surefire Pizza is LEGIT From the moment I called in, the customer service was top-tier--super friendly, helpful, and just all-around great vibes. Walking in was the same energy, which honestly makes a huge difference. Now the pizza... WOW. You can taste how fresh everything is. The ingredients are on point, and that crust?? Absolutely perfect--crispy, flavorful, and not too heavy. Easily some of the best pizza I've had in a long time. This spot is definitely a new favorite. If you haven't tried Surefire yet, you're seriously missing out! read more