Sully's was a BLAST!!! I was in from out of town to visit my bestie and we stumbled upon this sweet place! The atmosphere is great. Not too stiff, kinda chill, but still upscale.We had some AMAZING Irish Nachos!! Yum!!! Drinks were cold and delicious! All the staff was friendly and helpful and FUN! :) There was live music which was AWESOME! Oh and my fav thing was the outdoor seating! Nothing better than hanging out on a patio on a nice night, at a cool joint, with a cold drink and your best friend! Do yourself a favor and check this place out. Def a hometown gem. Next time I come to visit her... we are FOR SURE coming back to Sully's!! :) read more

Chuck and staff rock this place. You should visit- you won't be disappointed- hope to see you there!

Came here with a bunch of friends for dinner before hitting the movies. Our waitress was very friendly and master DJ (free credits on the jukebox that night). The food was absolutely delicious. I can't remember the appetizers my friends bought, but the ones I tried were delicious. I ordered an appetizer with crab and French fries, and a Rueben sandwich. The fries were very good, and the Rueben was delicious. I'm giving them four stars because it was very hot that night and there was no AC. Other than that, great ambiance, food, and service. Just wished I didn't sweat while I ate. read more

Great place to be from the life music to the seafood you can't go wrong by choosing sullies.

Girls Night Out choice and the Food was very good! Clams Casino was so good! Just need 6 instead of 4!! Lol. I took the suggestion of the meatloaf and it was SO good. I've never had snow peas that I liked and these were done to perfection! Bartender was great and made me an awesome Sangria since I'm not a beer fan. Overall they were very nice, food was great. Only criticism is the music should not be so loud that you can't talk across the table. read more

8pm on Tuesday and the kids wanted to check out a Pokemon stop in the middle of town so while they're playing I say hey let me stop over here and grab a beer. Big mistake, the place is run down, dirty and has an odd smell. No wonder everyone was sitting outside. The guy tending the bar tells me they won't serve me because it summer and I've got on a tank top. This dives actually got a dress code go figure! read more

Love the shrimp and half and half soup. Cold beer and friendly staff make this a great stop on middletown.

Excellent seafood even though the eating area is in the bar area which is very noisy with the normal Irish bar patrons and loud music but we would eat there often if we were residents of the area. and we ate there during Friday happy hour. read more

Recently discovered...have visited more than a half dozen times and have not been disappointed. Food has consistently been delicious . Ahi tuna to burgers to the fresh corned beef reuben:....awesome Staff has been friendly and attentive. Special shout out to Stephanie. Thank you for always making us feel welcome On last visit watched the owner delingently work the room asking customers if they needed anything Worth a stop... enjoy read more

We had a few friends talk about how awesome Sully's is, so the husband and I decided to check it out for the first time today. Food was amazing! The service cannot be beat, they really make you feel like family. The prices are amazing for the food that you get. I definitely recommend it. I will be back soon. read more

A dump where the 20 somethings go for cheap beer. The best thing is the outdoor porch and live music during the summer.

I love Sully. The staff will always go the extra mile for you.

Great atmosphere! Reminds me of a corner bar in B-more!

We recently stopped at Sully's after attending the wake of a dear friend and family member. We were immediately welcomed, and made to feel at home by the kind and caring staff!!! The food was outstanding, and the atmosphere, comfortable. Mr. Sullivan himself even was gracious enough to play some favorite Irish Tunes on the Juke Box in honor of our loss!! Great history, great food, and some fantastic Craic!!!!! read more

I thought corned beef was ALWAYS tough. I'd never had a reuben that wasn't tough. But I tried Sully's "Holy Reuben Batman" and was amazed that corned beef is not tough and that a reuben could be so good! I am not a big eater but I ate the whole delicious thing! And I would again. And I look forward to eating it again! Great atmosphere and location and the food is incredible Deborah read more

Owner can't take criticism. Had a band named "3 day weekend" playing. All we said was that we could not hear the lyrics. The band said they were only doing what the owner Sully said they should do. The owner told us we could drink somewhere else. Very business like, wouldn't you say. Needless to say we left, figuring we were cut off. Table next to us thought the same thing, that they could not hear the vocals. Hey what do I know. Staff was great and was surprised at what the owner said. Oh well.\, lots of other places in the area. Funny thing is, he doesn't know who I am and the people i know. read more

Sunday, March 1st-- We ordered drinks, a chicken cheese steak, fried shrimp, onion rings. 20 minutes passed. We ordered more drinks. 20 minutes passed. I asked for a package of potato chips. We ordered more drinks. 20 minutes passed. To be honest, the bar was NOT that busy. The problem was: it was understaffed. Both at the bar and in the kitchen. After ONE HOUR, the bartender apologized for the wait. We said, no thanks, let us pay for the drinks. We left. It was OUR FIRST TIME there. We were so looking forward to the delicious food which we were told by other patrons, while we were there, was so good. HIRE MORE STAFF!!!! read more

I almost walked out as soon as I opened the door. Smacked in the face by overwhelming odor of chemical masking mildew and mold. Cluttered decor with surge protectors hanging with cords plugged in from multiple angles. Bathrooms are a disgusting mess of neglect. Barstools are falling apart floor around the walls are breaking down. Tvs and sound setup is the worst I have ever seen in an establishment. Looking at the menu I was asking myself it I read the sign right... Irish pubs should at least offer some irish foods... I ended up getting a burger. Bacon came out looking weeks old. Burger was without frozen. Came out well done when I asked for medium rare. But that might have been a good thing. Thankfully it did not make me sick... Staff was friendly and and fast. But then again I was only one there most of the time with 3 bartenders. Owner is loud and obnoxious belittling staff and close to yelling across the bar.... Only good thing about this broken down dirt pile was the selection of beer, and liquor. I hate to discount any place after one visit however I am more than concerned enough about health and safety issues to keep me out of here. read more

I found this place randomly on yelp on my way to Middletown from Newark . I am so glad I came across it. It was absolutely great one . The servers are always friendly and quick. read more

Love this place! I always get greeted when I enter and the bartenders makes you feel so welcomed! Cheryl is the best and makes great suggestions food or drink wise - make sure to ask for her! They have totally stepped up their food game and their weekend specials have been delicious! Definitely a place to check out! read more

Crappy service, dirty bathrooms, no food to offer, except bags of chips. Some live entertainment and that sucked too.... Poor beer selection

Pours a pretty good pint! I have been in several times and the food is always killer. Irish Nachos, the mussels, and probably THE best corned beef Reuben for 100 miles. read more

I enjoy this place during off hours. I'm not sure I'd like it so much when it's crowded. The food is good and reasonably priced. I wasn't a fan of the ahi tuna, but burgers and fish & chips are highly recommended. I cannot say enough about the fries. They are great! No ketchup required! The staff is pleasant enough and have always offered samples of anything on tap. Looking forward to working my way through all the menu options. read more

Newly renovated and did a great job. Place looks great and the staff is always friendly. Had a great cheese steak and the beef stew was also really good. Always a good stop. read more

Really liked the atmosphere, the place was packed inside & out. As it happened, we were there for the running of the Kentucky Derby, and who isn't a horse racing fan 3 days a year? I had the fish & chips, wife had the crab cake sandwich, and son had the Irish nachos. Everyone enjoyed their meal and the service was quite good (the owner stopped by our table several times). read more

Me and a couple of my friends went here for some drinks in food the other day (this was my first time at the bar since middle of the summer) the food sucked last time i went there but I decided to give em another chance and let me tell you what, they must have gotten a new chef or something because I got the crab cake sandwich and IT WAS WORTH EVERY PENNY! Best cake I've ever had. My friend got the Reuben, he said he's never getting a Reuben from another place because there's is so good. Now when it comes to service it took a while to get our order placed but there was a lot of people there but we got our food so quick i believe after we got our order placed it took the more than 7 minutes. This place has the best bar food in middletown. GIVE THEM ANOTHER CHANCE read more

Best crab cake I've ever had. Dog-friendly outside seating. Superior wait staff. A Middletown favorite!

Sully's is a wonderful local place in Middletown Delaware. The staff is incredible. The food is supper good and there is a great selection of unique items. The prices are are fair. Try the half and half seafood soup! Too good to even talk about. Love, love, love this place! read more

Great seafood , ordered crab cakes for Mother's Day . Friendly staff along with great drinks , definitely a place we will eat at again !

My husband and I stopped into Sully's for lunch one weekend. We both ordered a half and half, the crab cakes, which came with french fries. The half and half was the worst pour I'd ever had (not a layer of Guinness floating on top of the Harp, but all mixed together). Really, in an 'Irish Pub'? Then our lunch came. The fries were left over from the day before and dunked into the deep fryer to reheat. The crab cakes were barely browned and were cold in the middle. We both sent our orders back to the kitchen for reheating. They were back out to us within a minute or so. Not a good sign. Yup, that's right, the yahoo working in the kitchen put them in the MICROWAVE. Who microwaves seafood, for heaven's sake?! It was burning hot in some spots, room temperature in others, and rubbery and tasteless from the microwave. The waitress came back and asked how things were. I pushed my plate away and said "The crab cakes were microwaved." She looked stricken and apologized, and asked if I wanted a box to take it home. No, I certainly did not. We hardly touched our meals, and my husband complained again to her about the food. No offer to reduce the price or anything. Horrible, horrible food. Oh, I'd originally ordered the grilled reuben sandwich (which, incidentally, is spelled incorrectly on their menu). The waitress came back and said that the cook told her the ingredients for the reuben looked a little dodgy and I should order something else. Should've left then and there. Ugh. Will NEVER go back. read more

My friend and I went to Sullys; by the end of the night we had 2 bud lights and 2 house vodka waters. Tab was $20. Told the bartender (who was also the manager) to put it on my credit card I had used to start my tab earlier in the night. My credit card slip came back $29. I asked that they void the transaction. Instead I was given $3 cash. Not sure how that equates to $20. Asked again for the credit card payment to be voided and for an original itemized receipt. The manager said "it's in the trash". I then asked her 20 more times for the itemized receipt and the transaction voided, to which she replied "for my security the system doesn't let me cancel transactions so I can't do anything". So, what happens when your employee charges something to the wrong tab? What happens when a bill is split incorrectly on the wrong card? You honestly expect me to believe you can't do anything to fix those mistakes? That's nonsense. The manager then came back to my table again, threw $4 cash on the table, informed my friend that she should "really hang out with less bitchy people" and proceeded to call me "fucking immature". Sorry for being immature by not letting you over-charge my credit card? Sorry that you screaming over the bar and to every customer at the bar about what an "oblivious bitch" I was, was ME displaying immaturity? So, I immaturely tore up the credit card receipt she demanded I provide her (which is weird since she couldn't provide me with mine) and dropped it into my beer and walked out as she yelled at me about what an rude bitch I was. Moral of the story- Sullys SUCKS and they rip people off- check your credit card receipts! read more