This is the best ice cream I've ever had. Please never stop making it. The peppermint ice cream and the White House, the Twinkie, the butter almond. Omg. Friendly staff and very cute inside too! read more

Sugar and spice is a classic ice cream shop. Homemade vanilla ice cream with MANY options to add in such of Kit Kat, Oreo, Nerds, etc. they also have soft serve. Why the 3 stars? They rarely have a dairy free option. My husband and son do like the vanilla flavor but I'm always miss out b/c they do not have a dairy free option. A good spot for folks who like traditional vanilla. read more

Great homemade ice cream shoppe! Staff is very friendly. They serve soft serve as well as hard ice cream. I love the decor! They also have a cute little candy store and sell ice cream cakes as well! Very affordable compared to the other ice cream places. read more

Sugar & Spice - Classic Banana Split - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

I can't believe I haven't stopped here before! Delicious, homemade hard serve ice cream is a must! They had so many unique combinations to choose from, it was hard to decide. We ended up ordering brownie sundaes, and wow wow wow... delicious! The service was great; and I appreciated the girls being so patient with us while we took 10 minutes to decide, and took our time with samples. The parlor was so cute, old school diner feel and very clean. Can't wait to come back! read more

See all

This place has some truly delicious ice cream! I am nearly never in the area. But, I'm sure this place is a classic for the Baldwin/Brentwood/Whitehall community. The vibe it gives is like one of those old school ice cream shops. Local, family owned, and amazing. I tried the peanut butter milkshake. Super simple, but very good. The number one greatest thing about this place is probably the value. You get a ginormous shake for under $5. And, it was far larger than I have tried in nearly any other place. This sort of value is just incredible. The flavor is also quite good. I thought it was a little vanilla-y for a peanut butter shake, but still great. You can taste it's homemade, not just Hershey's or some other brand. They also have numerous other standard flavor (chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, and more). They even have frozen yogurt, no sugar added flavors, sundaes, and more. I'll have to try out some of the more unique flavors sometime; my review would probably be 5 stars by the time I do that. They do close early though (but they are also open year round. Yes, even in the winter). Would love to come back. read more

Sugar & Spice - Peanut butter milkshake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Sugar & Spice has been a part of my life since it was located off of Brownsville Road. It's such a great little local ice cream place. We love the homemade ice cream. We wanted a treat after dinner today so decided to go to Sugar & Spice since it's so close to home. It's been awhile since we've been there, but it's just as delicious as I remember. They have such a great menu that can accommodate everyone's preferences and I appreciate the size options. Everyone is friendly & the prices are reasonable. read more

Sugar & Spice - Strawberry cheesecake sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Sweet little ice cream shop. Nice staff. Had a variety of flavors. Clean inside eating area but didn't realize the door is on the side. Cute little picnic area to sit and enjoy the day. Didn't try the candy but I'm sure they are good. On my list of things to get when I go the the burgh. read more

Service was great! We even got recommendations how to adjust when making Christmas chocolates:.

Fantastic place! Not super expensive but quality ingredients cost more. Variety of baked goods daily, all of them incredibly delicious! Don't miss this special, tasty place! read more

If you're looking for a delicious and affordable ice cream shop in the area, look no further than Sugar and Spice! The ice cream here is some of the best I've ever had, and the prices are very reasonable. I highly recommend the banana split, it's so good! The service is also great, the staff is always friendly and helpful. Overall, Sugar and Spice is a great ice cream shop that I would highly recommend to anyone in the area. read more

Awesome ice cream place! They have a bunch of different choices of cones, milkshakes, sundaes, cyclones, and traditional scoops. Their flavors are also unique, like orange whip and almond butter, mixed in with your favorites. I ordered the Kit Kat Cyclone and it was delicious! Not only did they pack in kit kat pieces into the vanilla ice cream itself, but they piled them on top of it too. The vanilla ice cream was the perfect amount of sweet and creamy, mixing well with the crunch and flavor of the candy pieces. The portion sizes are fantastic too for the price you pay. I almost wasn't able to finish mine with how much was in the regular size cyclone. Definitely stop by this place to treat yourself and the family, theyre open all year round! read more

Sugar & Spice - Kit Kat Cyclone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Wonderful little place, they have great ice cream and the staff is always great! The soda shop is so nostalgic! Take home a pint! read more

Anything we get there is always delicious from ice cream cones, ice cream sandwiches, slushies, floats, shakes, or sundaes.

They take credit and debit cards now! Ice cream is still good. Frozen yogurt is very good. Customer service has greatly improved! The classic ice cream parlor feel makes my daughter happy, so we keep coming. read more

Great place and delicious ice cream! One of the few places I've found that still does a walnut sundae! Friendly staff made our visit an all around great experience. read more

I believe this is the same company that I am referencing but my work recently had the Sugar and Spice food truck come and serve ice cream during the workday. I chose the hot fudge brownie sunday and it was amazing. One of those "meals" that reminds you of your childhood. I could've eaten the brownie alone!! I chose to swap out vanilla ice cream for cookies and cream to add some variety. Hoping we have the truck come back soon! The portion size was also huge. I could've easily spilt with one or two other people. read more

Sugar & Spice - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

This is a wonderful little ice cream spot in the South Hills. It doesn't get quite the publicity of some better known spots In the area, but it should! They offer probably 20+ flavors of hard ice cream a day, all homemade, in addition to homemade soft serve that is available with a long list of flavors. Their indoor setup is adorable, a classic ice cream parlor, but during this time of COVID-19 you will appreciate their outdoor windows even more, where they have the two windows separated by plexiglass and marked for social distancing. They have outside benches where you can sit and eat your ice cream, and they are very dog friendly, offering vanilla soft serve in between two natural dog biscuits for $1.50 for your best buddy as well as a bowl of water near the benches. One thing that prevented me from going too often for years was that they were cash only, but they now take credit and debit cards! They also just introduced almond milk vegan ice cream. In addition to the ice cream shop, there's a shop here where you can buy cake and candy making supplies. July is ice cream month and Pittsburgh has been sweltering so do yourself a favor and check this place out! read more

See all

Truly one of a kind. Absolutely adorable store with great workers. The shop has an outdoor ice cream window as well as an inside 'dining area' there are tables inside and outside. Great options for ice cream and specialities. They also sell 6 packs of delicious ice cream sandwiches. I ordered a brownie boat. You can choose your brownie- Blondie, chocolate chip or cheesecake. My husband ordered a coke float. The hard ice cream soaked up the coke halfway through the dessert. I asked for a little more coke and she gladly took care of me. I noticed thinks like an ice cream taco as well as ice cream sandwiches for dogs. They sell Mexican coke too. Excellent experience. Can't wait to go back. read more

See all

Came here after a baseball game with my team when we were out in Baldwin. We had a TON of people order ice cream and the workers were nice and accommodating. The ice cream was delicious and we were all able to hang outside of the establishment and eat it and have a good time. They have a huge selection of flavors and cone options. If I'm ever down in the South Hills again I wouldn't mind swinging by for a waffle cone. Great little place! read more

My son and I made an ice cream bucket list to check off this summer and this made the list. I really just wanted to go for the cute 50's ice cream parlor nostalgia. My son got chocolate soft serve and i got the whitehouse cherry on a sugar cone. The whitehouse was delish, im only giving it four stars because i just wish there was a little more cherry mixed with the vanilla. The ice cream is homemade daily here. Overall it was delish, clean, fast. FYI- they do accept credit & debit here despite a photo of a sign that says they do not. read more

Sugar & Spice - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

A good place for ice cream on your way home. I've bought baking supplies there a few times as well and they have a decent selection of basic items needed. read more

24 flavors of soft serve. They mix the flavors with the plain custard. So no samples. BUT very good, rich flavors. Service was good. And he helped with directions. Guy was super nice and made some jokes. Ambiance was cool. Quaint vibe. read more

Stopped for a cone when the S&S truck was in the parking lot. Had a Fresh homemade Strawberry cone. Very good ice cream without the pink coloring you get in most store bought and some other ice cream parlor ice cream. A nice way to end my lunch on this warm summer day. read more

Sugar & Spice - Truck - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

I took my boyfriends son here and we usually get the really sweet younger lady who mixes the soft serve flavors but there was this bitter and mean older female in there last time we went who refused to do it and said its not possible even after i explained it to her and gave us the meanest grossed out look. The ambiance is cool with the retro feel. The food was good but she skimped out on the portion bc i kept tryin to argue my case. She needs to learn how to do basic stuff or ask someone not just stand there stubborn and rude. read more

Super yummy, so many flavors and always friendly service. They also have a dole machine which is hard to come by. The parking is sometimes a little hard to get in and out of, but it's definitely due to being a popular spot. read more

Sugar & Spice - Orange Dole Whip! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Great place for home made ice-cream. Many different unique flavors. The only problem is the customer service sometimes is not friendly at all, unless you get younger/ teenagers serving you. The lady owner is very rude when it comes to customer service. In my opinion she needs to go to school on how to treat her customers. read more

Walking into this place is like walking right into the ice cream shoppes of the 50s! So much nostalgic here! They have both an outdoor serving area as well as an indoor one along with a bench if you wish to eat outside. The ice cream here is home made and consist of your traditional flavors. They serve both hard and soft ice cream here and yes you are permitted to sample them. There is a $.50 off checkin bonus for a brownie boat. This consists of your choice of either a traditional brownie, a chocolate and pecan brownie, or a chocolate cheesecake brownie topped with two scoops of ice cream and of course whipped cream. I also had a choice of hot fudge or caramel topping. I settled for hot fudge. After sampling the flavors I decided to opt for the peach and butter almond ice creams. When I received it I didn't realize the ice cream was so huge for small scoops! So I had to take it to the "fountain" so I could sit in front of the soda jerks and enjoy my treat. It was very good. Believe me I'm glad I opted not for the whipped cream because I was stuffed! The lady who waited on me was friendly and helpful. I inquired as to why this place is cash only. She explained that since most of the purchases are under $10.00 she is charged a small fee for using a credit card so it is easier for her to charge by cash. She also informed me that the cost of vanilla ice cream has increased so she is trying to keep the costs down. Although everything in here is nostalgic nothing really works. It would be a great touch to have a juke box playing inside but there is so much to look at you really get the feel for being back in the 50s. They also have another side where you can purchase cake and candy supplies. When I was finished the lady brought out some wet naps so I could get the chocolate off. if you eat indoors you are served your dessert in a glass dish which you can leave on the table for them to clean up. It has good ice cream with that nostalgic feel to it. Located on Clairton Blvd near the Cloverleaf to Curry Hollow Road there is a traffic light which will allow you to enter from either direction. read more

See all

After dining at 51 Wings, Kay and I decided that it was an appropriate time as any to revisit one of places we stopped at during our very first date in July of 2010. Due to the weather, we dined inside this time, finding ourselves transported backwards in time to a kitschy 1950's ice cream parlor complete with stools, a long counter, cheap candy, and...a mannequin??? This trip, I decided to go with something called the Chocolate Covered Banana Royale Sundae (???), and go with it I did, allowing it to take me to realms of dark desire. The housemade (!) vanilla ice cream was coated with a chocolate that hardens when it meets cold. Served in a traditional glass dish, banana medallions were strewn about, an amazing (also housemade?) hot fudge rocked my pleasure centers with subtle richness, and a mound of whipped topping helped keep things from getting out of hand. This weeknight delight was brought to you by Sugar & Spice, a den of sug'ry iniquity hidden in a seemingly innocuous suburb and building. read more

Sugar & Spice - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Love this place for so many reasons. Staff is always friendly. You literally can find all of your baking needs here and order cakes. Such a neat little place. read more

If you are in the need for ice cream or feeling nostalgia for the 50's you might want to check this place out. It is right on 51 and at a major intersection so it is easy to find. What is interesting is that they have soft serve and also hard ice cream. I ordered the Brownie Boat and had the option of either to go with it. I chose soft serve. The brownie was nice and soft. It had warm fudge sauce poured over it. There was soft vanilla ice cream on each side. They asked if I wanted whipped cream and a cherry. Yep! If you order inside they give you glass dishes but we ordered outside so we were given styrofoam. We decided to go in and check out the 50's theme parlor. It did not disappoint. It's a nice place to stop and get a treat or take your parents/grandparents for a stroll around memory lane. read more

See all

Half of the store sells candy and baking ingredients, and the other half sells ice creams. We bought lady lock cookies, which were perfectly made, kolachki cookies, an orange creamsicle soda, chocolate ice cream, and blueberry ice cream. The food tasted good. Employees were nice. We liked the appearance of the 1950s-style parlor. read more

This is not just a provider of excellent ice cream (and candy supplies) but offers a true experience. The interior is old fashioned and the service really creates a sense of a time when family businesses cared deeply about their products and customers. Ice cream flavors are all made on premise as well as ice cream cakes and novelties like chocotacos. Don't miss their sundaes--the brown with hot fudge and your choice of ice cream makes it worth being an adult. read more

Delicious! It was out first time there after drivin past many many times. Sadly, we got the last cookie dough cone, so one kid had to settle for a seconf flavor. The staff were very friendly and the cones and sundaes were very tasty. read more

Bring cash! They don't take cards! This is one of the places Darren took me on our first date almost 3 years ago, and i'm glad we went back so I could review it (I wasn't on Yelp then)! The inside of the place is so quaint and old-fashioned. I had a hot fudge sundae that was really good with homemade ice cream. I also walked out with with 5 lollipops for just $2! Neat little retro place. read more

The customer service was very good! The service was fast! The ice cream was good! It's worth stopping by if you are in town and have a sweet tooth! The prices are fair. read more

Sugar & Spice has ruined my ice cream palette. Meaning, it is so good that in all seriousness, no ice cream can compare anymore. After trying it for the first time in December, ever since I have not been able to find better ice cream. You can taste the fresh ingredients in the perfectly homemade ice cream. They have such a large selection of flavors it is always hard to decide which flavor. The setting inside the store is such a great atmosphere taking you back in time. Everyone working in the store is friendly and helpful answering every question about flavors, sundaes, etc. I highly recommend. It's worth the drive and especially with the holidays coming up, they have a great candy supply store right next door. Personal favorite: Chocolate Chip Doreo. Yes, I mean it is oreo ice cream AND cookie dough. Doesn't ever get better than that. read more

SUCH A TREAT! This shop looks like it is an actual 1950s soda shop & the decor is beautiful! The ice cream is incredible! We had a brownie boat & it was to die for. The brownie was perfect & the fudge and whipped cream were delicious. We will definitely be back to our new favorite dessert spot! read more

Sugar & Spice - Brownie Boat-- delicious! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

If you live in the South Hills and haven't been here, I will need an explanation. The Heenans (who are wonderful!) have been running the ice cream and cake/candy shop since it first opened in Brentwood over 30 years ago, and it has only gotten better. It doesn't matter what you get--but I recommend a chocolate covered banana cone--as everything is homemade and awesome. Make sure you peak inside at their old fashioned soda counter with tons of old Coca-Cola memorabilia and nostalgic candy. There is also a candy & cake supply shop with tons of molds, ingredients, other fun stuff for your feelin' crafty in the kitchen stash. read more

Not only do they have ice cream, they have a cute little store with all your baking needs, from piping bags, royal icing, and prepared cookie mixes. I'm super happy with this cute little ice cream shop read more

I was able to visit their brick and mortar location in Baldwin recently. As expected, the ice cream was top notch! The building has the 50's 'parlor' feel and plenty of seating inside and out. Only bad part of the visit was that they were cash only (which I heard changed in last few weeks). S&S spice is my go to local ice cream and will continue to be-just wish I lived closer to Baldwin. read more