Quick friendly service. Bagels were fresh and NY style as advertised. Lot of NY memorabilia around AJ it's very inviting.

Was craving a bagel and Stuff A Bagel is my closest spot. I've been here once or twice before and there's always people waiting for their orders upon entering so that's always a good sign. The lady at the counter took my order and asked if I was a Cast Member cause they offer a discount. Ordered the Jersey Turnpike and added cream cheese (first time having pork roll/ Taylor ham EVER and it did not disappoint). The interior is rather narrow inside and with people waiting for their orders I opted to take my order home. The sandwich overall was really good but I feel like their bagels aren't as fresh as they market them to be. I've had fresher bagels elsewhere in Orlando but I would go back solely for the polite service and accessibility to home. read more

See all

Chill out with the cream cheese it's actually insane. Maybe buy the chef a knife instead of an ice cream scooper for the cream cheese

The location of this stuff a bagel is prime! It's a perfect stop for cast member or even residents of Windermere to come in and grab a slice of NYC before starting their busy days. Lots of parking and limited seating inside. The staff was beyond friendly - would bend over backwards to serve you, and everyone was so kind. They had really delicious bagels - they tasted fresh and the cream cheese was absolutely delicious (I mean - look how much they gave me!!!). I only knocked a star because they are a bit pricey for what they are. I just got a plain bagel with cream cheese and a strawberry milk and I paid just about $9. The theming was so cute!! Made me miss NYC! read more

See all

3.5 for a great breakfast spot and good bagels. Dropped in with my family and was welcomed with enthusiastic greetings. The place is very New York deli vibes with its cozy space, limited seating, and a fast moving line. Ordered the breakfast special that comes with a side of potatoes, two eggs and choice of meat with your bagel. I opted for the everything bagel and asked for a vegetable schmear. I did not expect the potatoes to be so good! It had that nice crisp and seasoned great. The veggie cream cheese was ok. I prefer ones that are bit more chunky with visible vegetables, and the everything bagel didn't seem to have as much of the seasoning on it. The chew on the bagel is nice though. Overall, still a delicious and satisfying meal. I'm ts a bagel shop, but to me it's the breakfast options that will have me coming back. Love a good diner! Will also have to try some of their black and whites and cinnamon rolls on the counter on the next visits. Protip: ask for your bagel to be toasted when you order if you prefer it like that. read more

Stuff A Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Windermere, Florida

After supporting this establishment since the first day they opened, I regretfully, have to leave this review. From what I understand, they are under new management and have charged me a fee for requesting EGG WHITES ONLY! I can't imagine why I would be charged additionally for OMITTING something. I am not adding anything. I calculated my expenses for this year alone and have spent over $700 at Stuff-a-bagel this year 2025 and they charged me $2.79 to request egg whites. When I called, I was told the store is under new management and this was the store's choice. We have met the previous owners many times and they are from the same town on Long Island that we were from. Just for the principle, I will need to find another breakfast spot. Sorry Stuff-a-Bagel. I am more hurt than you know. read more

I'm not sure where all these good reviews came from.... This place is the worst bagel shop I've ever been too! There bagels are sooooo dry and bland. I'm not even the type to write reviews, but this one was necessary. 0 - 10 for me. read more

Stuff A Bagel has been a go to since they opened. Whether it's a post morning event stop for breakfast, bagels for family in town or just because. The staff here is always great at the bagels and food overall is very good. Seating inside is fairly limited so keep that in mind. It's a nice place to pick up breakfast or if you like this kind of lunch. Typically I stop in for a "to go" and something to bring home. Located right behind the Magic Kingdom Cast Member parking, nice option if you're going/coming to/from work. read more

Amazing NY bagel place. Great service with fresh bagels, rolls, sandwiches and more!

Promise I'm not a hater. Bagels do taste good however not when they use the same knife they used to slice a sweet bagel on my savory bagel. Place felt like ny so there's that. I'll still come back cautions of when my next bagel will have that sweet taste. read more

Bagels are 10/10 for FL. Service is efficient Its a small place but they made the interior interesting with some native NYC memorabilia. read more

Wanted a decent breakfast not on Disney property on our last day here in Orlando. It was New Year's Day and options were limited so I popped into Stuff A Bagel. Service was quick and the staff was really friendly. It's a grab and go place so don't expect to eat in really. I wanted to love this place but the bagels seemed really dry to me, like abundantly so. Also my everything sandwich was pretty charred. I'd give it another chance if I were in the area again but would try other options first. read more

I love this place! The people are all great (love Michelle!) and bagels are always fresh. I moved last year and had to stop by to fill my craving. The owner Melissa still remembered my name and my regular order - I haven't been here in 7 months! read more

Stuff A Bagel - A bag of assorted bagels (14) - Bagels Near Me - Windermere, Florida

I truly debated between a 3 & 4 rating. I leaned towards a 4 because I'm just grateful for an option for bagels because I refuse to eat Dunkin/Panera/Einstein etc , but my experience lined up with those places. I ordered an egg everything toasted with bacon, egg & cheese, a crumb cake and an additional egg everything in a bag. They have a sign saying if you want your bagel toasted, you have to ask. I asked 3 times. You'll never guess what wasn't toasted? Yep, the bagel with my bacon, egg & cheese. I think she was quite distracted as she had just gotten done gossiping about a peer & answering the phone in the middle of me ordering. Let's just say customer service is lacking, but truly didn't expect it to be top notch if this is NY spot. The bacon was burnt. Sandwich was fine. Probably would make it at home instead next time with their bagel. The crumb cake broke my heart. They look great in the container and let me tell you, it's not. Someone else mentioned this in their review - take off the crumbs and that's fine. The cake is like a hard, sponge you could use to clean. I am going to go with it being stale vs they intentionally make it that way. But either way, won't be wasting my money for that again. The other egg everything bagel was great. Love the flavor & the freshness. I will probably be back for bagels, but hope they remain fresh unlike their pastries. read more

See all

Obsessed with this place! Their bagels are so good and the staff is so friendly. We always get the sausage, egg, and cheese on an everything bagel and add cream cheese. It's so tasty and keeps me full for hours. The bagels are always fresh and never taste like they've been sitting. 10/10! read more

Stuff A Bagel - Everything bagel - Bagels Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

I've been here a few times now. Every time I've gone, the bagels have been fresh and delicious! NY style bagels are some of my favorite breakfast foods, and I'm glad there's a spot near me where I can get them. If you come early in the morning, that's when they're the freshest and best. I especially love their bagel sandwiches and love to add their jalapeño cream cheese to them. My favorite thing to get there besides the sandwiches is just a plain bagel with their lox spread. So so good. The inside of the store is very charming as well. I love spots that have a bunch of memorabilia on the walls, especially if the owner is from out of town. It was so cool to look at how much they fit inside. They even have a horse from an old school carousel hung up on the ceiling! All the staff have been friendly to me every time as well. Definitely check them out for a guaranteed great start to your day! read more

See all

Food and service were amazing! We got some breakfast bagels and some other baked goods. Everything was so good and everyone was so nice and helpful. read more

Marissa knows her New York bagels :) Great spot to walk around. Amazing service 10/10 recommend!

My go to bagel stop since moving to Orlando from NJ! The bagels taste the closest to home I've found. Bagel sandwiches made fresh & they have pork roll! Friendly service from Michelle! read more

Stuff A Bagel - Pizza bagel - Bagels Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

You can take the boy out of New York but you can't take New York out the boy. When I travel I'm always on the lookout for the foods that I miss from New York. Imagine my surprise when I find myself in Wintergarden and saw that Stuff-a-bagel is offering NY style breakfast sandwiches. On hard rolls! So off I went. I ordered my favorite: ham, egg and cheese on a hard roll. It came out quickly and look fantastic. And it tasted great. My only negative comment: the roll should have had more crust to it. But it was pretty darn close. I got to talking with Anthony, boyfriend of the owner, Ava's he said that they make the rolls, and everything else, in house. They also sell bialys, which truly are rare outside of New York. In this case, I got it with butter. If it only had more onions and poppy seeds in the center, it works have been perfect. But it was really, really good. I could not resist trying their homemade coffee cake. It was sensational. You *must* try a piece when you are there. Now I'm only sorry I didn't have more room to try more things! It's easy to find: right across the street from the cast member entrance to Disney. With plenty of parking in their lot. Enjoy! read more

Stuff A Bagel - The coffee cake... after I cut away (and happily ate) a piece. - Bagels Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

With so many great reviews I did not expect to get a salt bagel that tasted like a garlic bagel with salt or purchase a coffee cake that was so over cooked that I could have cut the crumbs off and used the cake layer as a sponge to clean my kitchen with. The cake slices looked amazing in the package but was anything but when lifted out and exposed. The pumpernickel bagel taste outstanding!!!!...but it had a soft exterior that matched the soft center. Nothing like a New York bagel. read more

See all

I've been coming here for years. Sadly I think today was my last time. I feel they've gone downhill. Orders are wrong, loud music coming from the cooking area. Good service, quality food and professionalism is still a thing... read more

Offered gluten free bagels and had lots of cream cheese flavors to choose from! Fun decorations too.

So I know I posted a review all about the bagels and cream cheese but I have to add this morning we tried the smoke fish salad!!! OMG! Had flash backs to my childhood. I am not from NY I grew up in Chicago. Our family go to was a New York bagel place in Chicago and so I know that may make some people say I don't know since I am not from NY but It is so good..... read more

See all

Loved my experience here. Being originally from Jersey it's so hard to find decent bagels that actually taste good! Well here in orlando I finally found it! The bagels are delicious and I love the variety of flavors they have for cream cheese. The staff is kind and efficient and even though the restaurant is small I love the theming inside because it reminds me of home . They also have outside seating which is cool. Everything also is affordable which is hard to find! Def will be back to get my bagel fix! read more

I spied this place out of the corner of my eye as I was on my way to run an errand. I stopped in when errand was complete. This little spot was busy inside...Busy walls, lots to look at. It had like 6 tables, all were clean, and unoccupied. I ordered a bacon, egg and cheese on and everything bagel, toasted. They won't toast if you don't ask. By the time I turned around to find a seat to await my order, at least four other parties came in to order. When my order was ready, they brought it to me and the sandwich was piping hot. It traveled well as I took it home to eat it. Locals are keeping them busy. I want to go back to try lunch items. read more

Stuff A Bagel - Inside - Bagels Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

First of all, let me start off by saying this place has great bagels. Probably the best you will find on this side of Orlando. They also have a good selection of sandwiches and baked goods. They do have a few things standing in the way of being a 5 star location. The first one is outside of their control at this point - but it's WAY too small. To the point that I've never been there when there is a seat available and really no where to stand when you are waiting for to-go orders except for on top of someone trying to eat at a table. Also - service isn't good. The folks working the register don't seem to know the menu and there is always chaos in filling orders, etc. BUT assuming these are teething issues of a new location, I'll still come back! read more

See all

I am a sucker for a good breakfast sandwich and this place did not disappoint. It has a cool ambiance inside decked out with New York decor. The bagels are fresh and they are not stingy with the cream cheese. A lot of options! I got the jersey turnpike aka a pork roll aka Taylor ham on a keiser roll. My goodness, the salty savory deliciousness of this breakfast sandwich wanted me to get another. They are open at 5am! However, they do close at 2:30pm. They do run out later in the day but everything they have is delicious. read more

Stuff A Bagel - Jersey turnpike - Bagels Near Me - Windermere, Florida

We ordered a Plain Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese and a Breakfast bagel. They were delicious! read more

See all

Excellent & authentic chewy bagels. Recommend the bagels and cream cheese highly, the breakfast sandwiches are very good also. Nice job, keep up the great work! read more

Stuff A Bagel - Bagels & jalapeño cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Today was the 2nd day this place was open- still in soft opening and it was PACKED. There was a long line to get in and then a bit of a wait, so be prepared if you are wanting to try them right now. They make everything fresh and you could see them bring out the steaming hot bagels. I got an everything bagel, egg & cheese. The bagel was delish! They are definitely still working out their kinks though. We ordered a cinnamon bun and as our cashier called back for it the other cashier took over, I guess thinking it was for his customer?? And asked for that one to be not glazed and then they brought it out and gave it to his customer... so when our food came out I had to ask about ours and they said they didn't know about it They politely went to the back and made it, but it was just weird how it happened. Also my partner asked multiple times for extra sausage and paid for it. It is our fault we didn't check the order before getting home, but again, it was slammed. He did not get the sausage. Lastly, I did find some meat on my sandwich. Just little bits but I don't eat pork so this was a little unsettling as it looked like bacon. If I had been a vegetarian I would have been even more upset. I just think they didn't wipe the griddle down enough prior to making my eggs, but again, I know it's a new place and it was busy, and they are learning. We will definitely go back and give them another chance, especially since their bagels were the best we've had in the area- delicious! read more

See all

Every time I come to Stuff A Bagel, the food and service are always spot on! The staff is super welcoming, and the food never disappoints. Definitely a go-to spot! read more

Great food, Nice atmosphere, they all were very friendly and helpful. would highly recommend!! There are so many options for bagels fillings and deserts it is hard to choose. read more

I'm gonna start off by saying i download Yelp just to write this review. Now, I was born and raised in Long Island, New York with access to at least 7 bagel places within walking distance of my house. In my 12 years of living in Florida, never have I ever come across a bagel place that comes close to any of those places UNTIL NOW. I can not give enough praise to this place. I ordered an Egg Everything with plain cream cheese and it was incredible. The bagel was soft, tasted fresh, and the cream cheese was creamy and tasty. Cast members also get a nice discount if you show your blue ID. Let's frequent this place and keep it open!! read more

See all

If you are looking for an authentic New York bagel place, this is it. Since my time in New York, there's just not been anywhere that compares to walking into a neighborhood shop and getting fresh handmade bagels- you can absolutely taste the difference. Prices are fair, and the menu is excellent. I got a Lox deluxe without onions on an everything bagel and it was delicious- they didn't skimp on the lox, which is the entire point of that sandwich. I also got another Everything bagel and a plain to take home and have for the next few days. Cast members, be sure to show your ID, this neighborhood place gives us a discount! Had to come here after some friends told me about it- after three visits (within around 2 weeks) the workers recognized them ~by name~ which was just an additional thing similar to a real New York downtown bagel place that cannot be taught and just ~is~. They open at 5, I got here around 6:15 and have to share- early in the morning (prior to the 8 and 9am start time banker hour crowd) has been a great time to visit- short wait and a friendly staff with fresh products. Granted, no sweet bakery items were available when I went, probably because of the early time, but I can't wait to try some of their sweets if the bagels are this yummy! Definitely a place to visit! read more

As much as I hate the area of its location, this restaurant has saved me during MANY hangovers. Delicious SAVORY bagel Sammies!

Service was always friendly and attentive! The staff remembered us by name after going a few times! Bagels are always delicious, and with the different cream cheese and bagel flavors, there are so many combinations to choose from! My husband loves the boss breakfast burrito! We highly recommend this place! read more

Just ordered the Pastrami Bagel with mustard on a Garlic roll and it was absolutley delicious!

Once was the pride place to eat behind the Magic Kingdom. This place is quite and hidden away from tourists. That's what is disturbing because they are slowly going downhill and should consider listening to their local guests. The food tastes great but the portions seem to be getting smaller. The coffee has a bad taste of a burnt campfire container and should be rethought for a fresher tasting product. We skip coffee here now. Most of the items we purchase have gone up over the past year approximately 12-13%, that's pretty bad given the CPI index only went up about 8.7- 9 % for social security cola and military pensions (which is a huge part of this local community), and Disney workers definitely didn't get a 12% pay bump. So basically the local area is expecting pay 4% more the. They did last year to eat here.... But wait there is more .... They now have a hand written sign at the register saying guests must also pay 3.5% for both credit and DEBIT cards!!! What? Why not just put that in the menu price ? Oh ...it's because then the price increase would be too high and guests would notice. Price gouging your local supporters is always bad and we will be sure to pass the word along to others. We recommend if you want to eat here, bring CASH. They claim cash users get a discount but they didn't give me one. Food is good but so is food at other options. read more

Stuff A Bagel - Signage at the register - Bagels Near Me - Windermere, Florida

As a New Yorker, we generally balk when someone suggests there's a spot "just as good as home". When my best friend told me Stuff A Bagel was the real deal, not going to lie, I didn't fully believe him - thought maybe the few years of being away from New York finally got to him. Boy was I wrong! Stuff A Bagel is not only authentically as good as what I get on Long Island, but their prices are also incredibly fair. My BEC was tasty and side of potatoes was great. Definitely recommend for anyone in the area! read more