When the ice cream craving hits, we don't even think twice--we head straight to Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream. This spot has been a go-to for us since 2022, and every visit feels like a treat. Tonight was all about the October fall flavors, and wow--Kelly's nailed it. My wife went with the Dark Chocolate Dulce Cookie, which was rich, indulgent, and exactly what she needed to power through to the weekend. I couldn't resist the Apple Cider Donut--a true fall-in-a-cone moment. The flavor had that cozy apple sweetness balanced with homemade warmth, like autumn itself decided to show up in ice cream form. One thing I really appreciate about Kelly's is the service. The staff is always so friendly and genuinely encourages you to try a few flavors before deciding--which makes the whole experience even more fun. Tonight I was also able to redeem my free single scoop reward (earned after 7 visits--worth every one). I was pleasantly surprised that my rewards never expired, which is such a thoughtful touch for regulars. Between the rotating seasonal flavors, the consistent quality, and the welcoming vibe, Kelly's is the kind of place you just keep coming back to. Local, homemade, and always delicious--it's everything you want in an ice cream shop. read more

The ice cream here is so delicious, not too sweet, always well-balanced in flavor, and smooth and creamy. The place is clean and well-kept. The customer service is great. I tried the cookie butter swirl and toasted coconut flavors and loved both, toasted coconut is my all time favorite though. read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Kelly's is fantastic homemade ice cream and love that they keep multiplying locations in Orlando area. Great monthly flavor options and always kind service! Nice clean locations every one I go to. read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Kelly's ice cream is always a won't for me. You can tell It's so well made with good ingredients. Lots of fun flavor options, always creamy and delicious. I've been to several of the locations and I've never had bad service. This locations if the smallest I've been to, but it's tucked into the neighborhood so it's probably a good size for the location. read more

See all

I love Kelly's ice cream and I'm so glad they've expanded to add more locations throughout Florida. The staff is always very friendly and I love trying the new monthly flavors. read more

I love all the dairy free ice cream and sorbet flavors here. It's nice to be able to walk into a local ice cream shop and get delicious vegan ice cream. read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Very tasty icecream! I got a vampire icecream which was red velvet with caramel drizzle....so delicious! Service was quick and ambiance was welcoming. read more

See all

Great ice cream flavors, waffle cones were fresh! Can get a bit busy but definitely worth the wait. read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Wall mural - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

I have been to various Kelly's locations and tried a number of different flavors and they have all been wonderful! The Horizon West location is definitely a great one! There is a small parking lot by the store and there is a collection of tables inside. I also love the mural they have inside. The staff has always been amazing and excited to let you try some flavors before you make your choice. The ice cream itself is delicious and each month they have new flavor options, as well as there signature flavors they offer all the time. If you are looking for some great local ice cream, definitely check out Kelly's! read more

See all

I really enjoy Kelly's! They always have fun flavors to choose from. My favorite is the banana cream pie! The staff is very kind and patient. This is my go to place for ice cream! Highly recommend! read more

Ice cream is always amazing great flavors the specials are nice to try new things. The staff is always super friendly and the service is always on point. read more

Greatest ice cream in horizons west! Love the flavors! The staff is amazing as well! Must try!!

You scream, I scream, we ALL scream for Kellys!!! This has very quickly become my go to dessert spot. There's something about the texture of this ice cream that just hits different. The Cake Batter is my go to but I recently tried the Dunkaroo flavor and it was also to die for. It's a cute little shop with plenty of seating to enjoy your treat and there's even a park right next to it where you can walk afterwards if you're into that sort of thing! The employees are always kind and don't get annoyed when you ask for samples. 10/10 would recommend this spot to satisfy your next sweet tooth. read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Two scoop cups - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Friendly service! Popular spot. Line out the door. Free samples! We ordered a banana pudding scoop and Cookie Monster and caramel cookie in a waffle bowl. Delicious! read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

Oh man I wish I had pics but I don't .... This spot is amazing wayyy better than cold stone especially the cake batter ice cream. They have little pops for pups as well and the service is excellent. Staff is very attentive and knowledgeable. This spot has ice cre For wall, dairy free and vegan included on the menu. Will definitely be returning. read more

Such a cute location and nice staff! Had the best Rocky road ice cream and the best thing is that had it Dairy free which is highly important for me. Loved that they were able to provide that without compromising flavor and quality. Which I had a location in my home town in South Fl! read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Rocky Road - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

I recently stopped in and ordered my favorite double scoop ...coconut and chocolate peanut butter. It was served on a waffle and tasted very fresh. It was exactly what I have grown accustomed to when purchasing Kelly's. They sell original and signature flavors along with a small selection of sorbet and non-dairy options. read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Coconut and PB & Chocolate - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Kelly's is my FAVORITE ice cream place in town. Her flavors are just the absolute best and I love how they have monthly flavors as well. The ice cream is so creamy and delicious. The staff is so friendly and always offering samples. The dog popsicles are great too- meeko approves! read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Dog popsicle! - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

I love this location! Even though parking can be rough during busy times staff is wonderful. We also had a baby shower at this location and it was great! Staff was friendly and accommodating. Flavors are great, what can I say and they rotate. My current favorite is POG and guava and cheese. Inside bathrooms are clean and a handful of tables. Murals on the wall are great for instagram pics. Will come back again and again! read more

My daughter said if I could give this place a review it would be 5 stars. I told her don't worry bunny let's do that right now. We did a ice cream flight and they loved it. It's also so cute inside. We went for a bike ride and played at the playground nearby, so to have some really yummy ice cream after to cool down was so needed. read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Cute Art - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

My mom and I stopped in for ice cream and we loved it! My mom is a root beer float junkie and she was excited that Boylan was offered. She had a root beer float somewhere else earlier in the week and she was super disappointed so this definitely made up for it! I had a Blondie ice cream milkshake! I'm hooked! I can't wait to return to try more flavors soon now that it's getting warmer out! read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Blondie milkshake - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

Awesome selection of ice creams, great service, friendly staff. We purchased several flavors and even some to go home. Great place for sweets after dinner read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Had another ice cream at Kelly's. Always such a treat to be there. Did I mention in my previous post their music is on point? Old classics are the best ! read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Chocolate ice cream - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Every time I go to the park I have to get Kelley's it's just that good! The ice cream is to die for, the flavors just hit your mouth with aw and the limited seasonal flavors are amazing! The workers are so nice and makes service nice and smooth just like their ice cream! And let me tell ya, the overall ambiance is amazing, the ice cream is so fresh that when you walk in it smells like ice cream, good ice too! You know the ice cream is gonna be good when the milk carton is just blue stained plastic, I mean how much more fresh can you get! I'm lactose intolerant and whenever I go to get ice cream from Publix or other places I never need to go to the bathroom but Kelly's sure does! That's how you know it's fresh! read more

You scream, I scream....We are all literally yelling about how delicious Kelly's is! My first trip to Kelly's was a few years ago when I was living in Audubon Park. My flavor of choice for that time was the Mexican Chocolate. Mmm mmmm! That little spicy treat brought me many a smile and satisfied sweet tooth on days when I was feeling down. I moved over to the hourglass district and well what do you know? There's a Kelly's location there too (well hourglass adjacent) and here is where I switched up my drug of choice and decided to start dedicating my ice cream life to their Banana Pudding. It is sweet and banana-y and my favorite part are the vanilla wafers! I started seeing someone who lives in the horizons west area and as luck would have it, there's another Kellys for me to visit! I'm still holding strong on banana pudding but last time I did venture out to pistachio. Here's what I love about Kelly's: amazing staff, delicious waffle cones and ice creams, rewards program (for my fellow frequent scoopers!), pints to go! My only complaint about the Audubon location and the Fern Creek spot is the parking situation. Both have tiny lots and are off of fairly busy roads. The Windermere location has a great parking lot with ample parking. Don't be shy, ask to try as many flavors as you like and then grab 2 scoops and enjoy! read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Banana Pudding regular waffle cone - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Great option for ice cream especially if you live in the Summerport or Orchard Hills neighborhoods. Walk, bike or a quick drive to grab some ice cream here locally. Located in the small plaza kiddie corner to Keene's Crossing Elementary. Quality ice cream and good service. read more

The ice cream is simply the best, it tastes fresh, it's creamy, and tasty. Overall I love the branding of Kelly's and the service is great. read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - The Cookie Monster 5/5 - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Kelly's Ice Cream has been a hometown favorite of mine for a while. Unfortunately the original location is a bit far for me. I'm glad they opened this location in Summerport. It's right by the playground my son loves so we are in the area often. This location has more parking and the same delicious ice cream. Best kept secret in the area! Will be returning a bit Mrs than the downtown location! read more

See all

Yum! For a local chain this ice cream is always delicious. If you go at the right time you can get served right away, however it is often fairly crowded no matter what location you go to. Every flavor I've tried has been outstanding and they give you all the samples you want! read more

Kelly's has some great ice cream. Ice cream is my favorite dessert, and I try ice cream a lot. Kelly's had a gelato-ish vibe to me. I had mint chocolate chip which was great. My family also enjoyed bomb pop ice, chocolate peanut butter, and Cookie Monster. We enjoyed all the flavors. I got a double scoop which was a great portion. The decor was cute, and the tables and chairs were clean. The staff members were friendly and efficient. I will definitely be back for more. read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Mint chocolate chip - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Everytime I eat ice cream now I have to think to myself "will it be as worth as Kelly's?" The flavors are always on point and even the simple every day flavors are done so so well. I like to grab a pint to go for home ($9) and every time the workers pack that container down with ZERO hope of leaving air in there. Definite high quality creamy ice cream - my lactose discomfort knows immediately and still loves it. Favorite seasonal flavor was by far the Peanut Butter flavor a couple of seasons back. read more

I love, love, love their seasonal flavors. The service is always quick and the employees will let you sample every flavor you'd like, which you will want to. read more

This place was amazing!! So many unique flavors to choose from. I decided to get the Blondie ice cream and it was absolutely wonderful. I also got the waffle cone and it was so tasty, probably the best waffle cone I have had!! read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Blondie ice cream with waffle cone - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Love love love Kelly's, but they just sent me expired ice cream. I thought it was odd that the ice cream tasted freezer burn like, but to see that the date on the bottom is expired, wasn't expecting that. read more

I have always been a fan of Kelly's ice cream and have been going to Winter Park at their Corrine location for the past 3 years. However I finally got to this new location in Windermere and it was the same great ice cream and service. The interior is pretty and I like that they provide water and cups for you to get a drink if needed. My favorite flavor is the ore-dough and cake batter. They also offer limited edition flavors that pop up every so often and they are usually pretty creative, and sometimes involve other local businesses (which I love the collaborations)! read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Small cup of icecream - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Great local ice cream spot! So many different flavors and options, love that some of the flora it's rotate based on the season. Got the Oreo dough as a milkshake it was amazing, a lot of ice cream so it lasted for a while. I can't wait to go back! read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

An outstanding couple experiences at Kellys.An outstanding couple experiences at Kellys. A very kind, attentive and engaging staff as well as a cool vibe and some excellent ice cream. A classic vibe meeting modern tastes and flavors with lots of offerings. A hop skip and a jump from Keene's Elementary School in Summerport in the small plaza that has Foxtail Coffee and Marcos Pizza. read more

See all

Such a great ice cream shop! Lots of yummy flavors to choose from including seasonal flavors that are constantly changing and a welcoming environment. Kids and pet friendly read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Pumpkin spice ice cream - Desserts Near Me - Windermere, Florida

So delicious! I got birthday cake flavor and it was amazing. The ice cream wasn't too sweet which is rare to find.

Cute little place! I had the cake batter ice cream which was delicious. They do not have a wide variety of flavors but their ice cream is very tasty! I'll be back for more cake batter ice cream read more