Look, I know Jeremiah's model (mostly) is to not have any inside for guests but this corner location just feels dangerous. Cars were driving too fast for a parking lot, kids and families are walking around, heck I watched so many cars run right through the pedestrian crosswalk it was scary. I know that isn't the business' fault but I think location planning is important Now, this location was probably the slowest moving Jeremiah's I have ever visited. The customer service was lackluster and for having to wait so long it was frustrating that our items were melting down the sides of our cups making a mess everywhere! With so many other locations this one won't be one I visit again. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Scoop froggy frog - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Jeremiah's Italian Ice is the perfect treat especially on a hot summer day. They have a variety of treat and not only Italian Ice. They also have ice cream with a variety of toppings. They have shakes and malts. The service is great as always. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Stopped by for a quick dessert after dinner. We walked up while another family was placing their order so we waited our turn. A while later someone opened the second window to help us take our order. We placed an order for 4, two tadpole and two small jelatis. It took a while to finally get our order and while they were making ours the group behind us was waiting for someone to help them. All of this to say that service on our particular visit was slow compared to the service I'm used to getting at a Jeremiah's. Saving grace was that the flavors were still on point and people were kind when they were interacting with us. Plan to spend a leisurely amount of time and you shouldn't be disappointed. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Cookies and cream with vanilla ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Windermere, Florida

I love the different flavors and combinations. There's plenty of seating area on both sides of the building. There's a Halloween special where you get 4 different flavors for $15.99 I like that they have 4 sizes now. The tadpole mini is just enough for me. My favorite flavor is mango with vanilla ice cream. Recently I've tried the pumpkin pie in different locations. Although they're not consistent in flavor so I would recommend asking for tasters before ordering. The service is good overall. People are nice. read more

See all

Came to pick up an order, Girl at window looked at me and walked away for almost 5 mins. Finally came back and asked me to move so she could help someone else? Finally asked name for pick up and it wasn't even started yet. Total attitude. Def will not visit this place or pick up anything from here. Don't hire 15 year olds. They are busy flirting with their boyfriends standing in line. read more

They are so slow you want to rip your eyes out. Can never get ice cream because it's half hour wait.

Fun spot, quality soft serve ice cream. Jeremiah's is more than just "Italian ice" as thier name would indicate. The best items to get are the ones in which they mix both soft serve ice cream with the Italian ice to make what they call a "jelati" . Today I tried one of their specials which is the salted Carmel chocolate truffle which was fantastic. During the holidays pumpkin pie is soooo good. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Yum! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

I absolutely love Jeremiah's and think their soft serve and Italian ice combinations are delicious. Super light and delicious. Plus there are so many flavors to choose from. However, this location is awful. Every time I've been, the girls working behind the counter have been rude or standoffish and not helpful in the least. They look like they hate their jobs, and it doesn't make me want to come back. I will be choosing another location from now on. read more

I just went to Jeremiah's with some friends, and actually the experience was awesome! We had multiple orders that they accommodated pretty fast, didn't confused any of the ice cream, and even gave us little cups for the puppies! Super nice! It was busy when we got there (we stayed outside because Ashe we had the dogs), but it started to thin out pretty fast too. Everything was very clean and they had AWESOME 90's music playing! We loved that too! Definitely recommend if you want different style of ice cream! read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Small ice cream with the Italian ice! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Windermere, Florida

We come here so often and I have never written a review. This place is a huge hit with the whole family (all 3 generations). We always get gelati's because we love the ice cream with the Italian ice. The place is always run by young adults and they are fantastic. They are so patient with people trying to make a decision l. They also make suggestions. AmazIng service. I so wish that there was an indoor location to eat at (not my car or at home). Florida can get way to hit and it melts super fast. I do love the shady place to sit on the side of the building though when it's available. We always order smalls as they are the perfect size. The other sizes would be great for sharing. Sometimes the small is to big. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Strawberry shortcake gelati - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

Jeremiah's is great, as usual! My daughter had a coupon for a free small item that she received from school so of course we had to go! It's always a pleasant experience as their customer service is top notch. I was curious to try the sugar free tangerine flavor and was gladly given a sample. It wasn't for me so I ordered my usual strawberry and my daughter got mango gelati with chocolate and vanilla swirl. It was a great way to get the weekend started! Of course, we attended Yelp's Disco Jungle event at the Orlando Science center and they were there too! Love that they give back to the community and enjoying Jeremiah's twice in less than a week?! Yes, Please! read more

See all

Always a great experience at Jeremiah's Italian ice, they have many choices to choose from and I always try something new each time and never been disappointed. Great place, nice area, Friendly staff. Check them out read more

Always delicious! Met some friends for ice cream. They had a great key lime flavor, although I wish it was a little more tart vs sweet. But nonetheless, still delicious! You can't go wrong with the scoop froggy frog (chocolate mint) gelato mixed with chocolate soft serve. This location has some shaded seating around the side which helped on a super hot day, and it was great for our larger party of 7 with a few kids. If you want a yummy ice cream treat, this is a GREAT choice. Note: parking in this area can be kind of tricky so be prepared or build a few extra minutes into your arrival time. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Absolutely love Jeremiah's. Consistently delicious. Our cashier was so kind and patient with us as we were deciding what flavors to order. They have so many flavors and the menu changes through the seasons and you can sample as many flavors as you would like to. They come in 3 different sized cups but don't let them fool you because the small is enough. We opted for a mix between Italian ice and gelati. I ordered the orange slush with vanilla gelati and it tasted like an orange creamscicle. Absolutely delicious. We also ordered the black cherry with gelati & that had a great cherry flavor that balance well with the gelati. Great stop for a light dessert. Fun for all ages. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Orange Slush with Vanilla Gelati - Medium - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Service was very cheerful and helpful. I love that they are able to give samples so that you can figure out what you may like and the staff never seems upset about this at all. I tried what I wanted and quickly was able to get what I wanted. They have limited outdoor seating but it is a small location. Will be back! read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Lemon basil & vanilla soft serve gelati - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Windermere, Florida

This was our first visit to this location, and unfortunately, it was a disappointing experience. After waiting in line, the young clerk began cleaning the stations just as we reached the window, while the employee at the other window continued serving customers. We were ignored, and even those behind us were served and already eating. Frustrated, we decided to leave without ordering. This place seems to lack proper management and organization with too many kids "working" by themselves without any supervision, and we wouldn't recommend it based on our experience. read more

This place is amazing! I have had Italian Ice before but the texture here was the best. The staff were friendly, there was no wait, and the price was super worth it. I appreciate how they don't charge extra or give a hassle to combine flavors, even in a small size. You can't have just one- they're too good! Getting a gelati - a combo of ice and soft serve - is definitely the move. The combination of horchata and cookie butter ice flavors and vanilla ice cream was satisfying and so creamy. It's surprising how well the more hearty flavors translate to the ice. I would definitely come again. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Small gelati - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Windermere, Florida

It's pumpkin Season and Jeremiah's has created a new Gelati flavor to satisfy taste buds. Be sure to try this new flavor because it won't be here for long. I tried it and was happily surprised at how much it tasted like pumpkin pie. I love how the shop gives samples. Everyone wears masks and gloves, so everyone is protected. I definitely will be back. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Pumpkin Pie Season is here! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Love this spot! It was our visit to this specific location. They have two windows to place your order and some seating in front and beside the building. I do wish that they had some indoor seating like some locations but otherwise I'll definitely be back! They give unlimited samples and help you choose the best flavors for what you want! And what's better than soft serve or Italian ice on a super hot fl day. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Windermere, Florida

I am a huge fan of Jeremiah's Italian Ice. Over the. Years I have learned that you can visit any location during anytime of the day and you can count on them to provide the same quality product. They consistently put out an excellent product and their service is always friendly. The truth is that over the years I never varied my order. Not once have I strayed from purchasing the delicious Scoop Froggy Frog. Mint chocolate chip with vanilla or chocolate soft serv is my absolute go to. I've sampled just about every other flavor and thought that they were all very good but never felt compelled to change things up. They offer a rewards program that provides discounts or free treats. I've never joined but understand that it is beneficial to frequent visitors. read more

See all

Finally, a Jeremiah's has opened closer to me! Located in a new shopping center off of 535 in Windermere, you can find Jeremiah's in the left corner of this shopping center. Location is easy to find and parking is just as easy as they have parking to the side if the shop. Just like any other location, they offer many different refreshing flavors whether you're out in the sun or if it's 50 degrees out. You can get it regular Italian ice, a gelati which is a layer of Italian ice, a layer of soft serve and vice versa or you can get soft serve. All the employees were super nice and explained the different options. They advertise that they give free samples out and they really do. They ask if you want to try any flavors and do not hesitate to give it to you. We were enjoying our gelati on one of the picnic tables and one of the employees came up to us and asked how everything was. He also offered us wet naps. That was a nice touch. Can't wait to be back. It's dangerous that this location is close to me as I'll be seeing myself here often. Enjoy! read more

I wanted to take an item ToGo. The team told me to come back to the window to pickup. They were VERY inattentive and I had to get back I. Line and wait 20 minutes. I will never allow this again. A bunch of inattentive kids giving terrible service! read more

I am not a desert or sweet lover but sometimes when the family wants ice cream, I will get the peanut butter ice with soft serve. Very good and very consistent.... read more

When you're in the mood for something sweet, Jeremiah's does not disappoint! I have tried different flavors over the years at different locations. I have not found one I did not like yet. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Passionfruit vanilla swirl - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Jeremiah's Italian Ice is truly the best. The flavors are so delicious and refreshing, making it the perfect treat to enjoy on a sunny day. I love the quality and variety of their Italian ice, it always hits the spot! read more

I always love Jeremiah's. I wish there was one even closer to us in the Clermont area. The coconut is one of my top three, as is black cherry with vanilla soft-serve swirl. Rounding out that top three would be the root beer with vanilla swirl. So good. I could go into a top 20 if need be but there's so many flavors to try but, you should figure out your own favorites. They'll let you sample anything before you order. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Coconut Ice - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Windermere, Florida

I don't know who Jeremiah is but one thing I know is he knows how to make an exceptional frozen icee. I ordered a small pina colada flavor. The small size was more than enough to keep me satisfied. The icee was cold creamy and packed with little bits of pineapple. The young man behind the counter was more than helpful in suggesting which flavors to get and offered free samples of anything they make. I will definitely be back. read more

See all

It seems like we've been waiting for such a long time for this location to open. We were in the area recently and my youngest really wanted to stop. We had dinner next door at Portillo's and then walked over here for a special treat. This location like many of Jeremiah's locations only has outdoor seating. They also have a drive-thru. There are two windows on the front of the building where you can place your orders and receive them. The people working here are very friendly and efficient. We typically get the gelati which is a blend of Italian ice with ice cream and they taste fantastic. I had salted caramel Italian ice with a chocolate vanilla swirl on this occasion and was very impressed with the flavors of it. Adding the chocolate with the ice cream really enhanced the caramel. If you're out looking for a treat for the family I definitely recommend Jeremiah's. Download their app and sign up with them and get points towards free treats as you use them. read more

They have so many interesting flavors of Italian ice. They have some permanent flavors and some seasonal flavors - like pumpkin pie around thanksgiving time - and some limited time flavors. They also have gelatis which swirl Italian ice and soft serve ice cream together. I've been there many times - my favorites are the scoop froggy frog(mint chocolate chip Italian ice) and chocolate/vanilla gelati and the mango and vanilla gelati. read more

We never get within 50 miles of a Jeremiah's Italian Ice and not stop for a Sea Salt Caramel Gelati. No words are bold enough to describe how good it is, was! Visiting DisneyWorld from Hidaway, TX. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Sea Salt Caramel Gelati. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Our first time here and it definitely won't be the last-- although, the endless amount of middle school aged kids running reckless and crazy around this plaza is a big deterrent of coming back. That aside, the ice and soft serve was amazing, the service amazing and the price amazing!!! Thanks for a delicious treat!! read more

Wow. This place is just next level. Every single flavor is top notch and the consistency of the ice is amazing. Even their vanilla ice cream has a great flavor. I don't know how I lived without this place all my life read more

The weakest location in Central Florida - customer service is poor, portions/servings are smaller and it would appear it's a free-for-all with the teenagers running the show. Every other location I've been to has been consistently great, but this one needs help. Looking forward to a newer, better location in Winter Garden. read more

Don't forget to download the app so you can claim your free rewards. If you forget your phone, you can add your points later with your receipt. If you download the app, you can also take advantage of the birthday rewards. Make sure you use it within the month or it will expire. They sell three different types: gelati, soft serve, or Italian Ice. There are a ton of flavors and you can either do just the Italian Ice, just the soft serve -chocolate or vanilla, or you can go all out and have the heavenly Gelati. My favorite is cookie butter because it's awesome and delicious but the family prefers the cookies and cream. They had a special today for BOGO where you can get two quarts. So if you wanted to create a massive two quart gelati, you could! We decided to take home a quart of chocolate soft serve and a quart of cookies and cream Italian Ice. It came to about $7 for both (BOGO) and was certainly worth it. They do require you to wear masks and social distance on the adorable frog markers. They don't seem to take Apple Pay so don't forget your wallet! read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Cookie butter - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

Yum yum!! Originally from the northeast, this Italian ice is a slice of home after growing up on Rita's Water Ice. Dare I say it's even better? More flavors! And just so refreshing on a hot summer day. Small size is more than enough for me. I recommend the mango or Bahama breeze. Don't be shy asking for a free sample taste to make sure your happy with you flavor choice before ordering. Also! I recommend downloading the app. Accumulate points for rewards, even for just downloading you get a free Italian ice! read more

Love this place!! The counter girl was super sweet and friendly. She happily gave us a couple of samples before we ordered. They had a ton of flavor choices! The ice was delicious. The servings are large! We each got a small and it was plenty. We ordered a small cherry ice, a small Cookie Butter Gelati and a small Salted Caramel Gelati. They were each amazing! read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Cookie Butter Gelati was so good! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

As I've only recently discovered the deliciousness that is Jeremiah's I decided to stop at this location after lunch to help beat the heat a bit. Jeremiah's is an Italian ice stand with many flavors to choose from. You can also mix your Italian ice with vanilla or chocolate soft serve ice cream to create any combination your heart desires. At first, it sounded a bit weird to mix ice and ice cream, but after trying it out I am totally hooked. The flavors all come through and the ice cream adds a great creaminess to it all. Its also pretty fun mixing and matching flavors to come up with your own combinations. The only reason this location is not getting 5 stars is the limited seating available which was all outdoors. It made the experience a bit rough on this 95-degree day. read more

I LOVE Jeremiah's Italian ice!! Last summer I frequented this place probably every other day. My favorite is the Pina Colada ice. The servers are always nice and understanding even when I mess up my order and realize it after they made it. They get your order out to you quickly, and keep the line moving. Would 100% recommend this place, go here a soon as possible!! read more

Delicious and amazing service! I was a little worried to visit this location based on one review about the staff and the judgment of 'teenagers'. I'm glad we decided to visit this one anyway. Our family of 6 just moved here from out of state so this was our first time to Jeremiah's. The young lady at the register greeted us with a big smile (behind a mask), asked if this was our first time there and gave us the SCOOP on what Jeremiah's is all about. We also had multiple staff members greet us at the table and ask how we are doing. They even brought hand wipes and bracelets for the kids! This was next level customer service, plus delicious dessert, we plan on returning often!! read more

This location is the best addition to the Windemere/Horizons west area. It had a little bit of a line when we got there today but it went by fast. I tried the "scoop froggy frog" aka Mint Chip with the swirl ice cream. Amazing!! I didn't think that would have worked with an Italian ice/ice cream combo but it was delicious! I'm glad this location is open and so close. It looks like I will be coming back :) read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Windermere, Florida