Cancel

Open app

Search

Straw Hat Pizza

4.0 (168 reviews)
ModeratePizza, Italian, American
Closed • 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

Order Straw Hat Pizza Takeout or Delivery

Straw Hat Pizza Photos

Business Info

STRAW HAT PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Moderate noise
Casual
Good for groups
Good for kids

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Straw Hat Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Brittany C.

Oh an arcade. My kids will never eat dinner or want to leave. There are games in the front and a bit bigger arcade in the back. Would be a nice spot to have a bday party if we were from around here. Pizza was good but my kids fries were a bit overcooked. Service was quick as it was a Friday evening. We got 3 large cheese and pepperoni and we had lots of extra between 7 adults and 8 kids.

J H.

Called my order in on Halloween for the online special. They are a participating restaurant as I had ordered it earlier in the month and it is good through the 31st as the coupon states. Girl put me on hold, came back and said we stopped doing that yesterday and we can't make a profit selling large 2 topping pizza at $19.99. Instead of 40 bucks your order will be 70. At this point I had people that would be waiting for me with the pizza so I took the hit and went there. Went there at 5:45 as requested for my pizza and there was literally 20 people in line waiting to order/pay with only one young girl at the counter taking money, orders, getting pitchers etc for everyone. People had to wait out the back door there was not enough room for them. Needless to say it took an extra 45 minutes to get my food and by the time I got home to all the kids the pizza was Luke warm and sucked. If you don't want to participate in corporate promotions you don't have to, but if you do, you don't get to pick and choose when you start and stop your promotion without written warning. Your pizza is typically good but I refuse to patronize a store with ownership/ management that would do this. Also, it's Halloween for Gods sake. Employee up to take care of the orders. You aren't new. You know this. And don't feed me a typical standard response that someone called in sick and blah blah blah. Don't care.

Small (half and half) Aloha Chicken Pizza BBQ Chicken Pizza

Food was great. We ordered half and half on a small size for two and it was perfect. Service was quick (we were the only at the restaurant) and the ambiance was nice. If you have kids, it would awesome for them

Pizza menu

Straw hat became our pizza of choice during Covid. Pizza has always come out good, not burnt and with generous toppings. I used to enjoy the salad bar prior to Covid but since all salad is packaged so no more creating your own. Please bring salad bar back!

Linda V.

It is probably the best pizza in Gilroy. A friend who's lived in Gilroy for years swears by Round Table, but that place pales in comparison to Straw Hat, which doesn't say much but there it is. Regardless, their pizzas are pretty solid if you want pizza. And they serve Coke, not Pepsi at their newer model fountain machine, with is a plus for me. We ordered a medium combo pizza that had everything on it: pepperoni, sausage, olives, bell pepper, onion, mushroom and whatever else I can't recall, and it was good. Their fountain drinks are well carbonated and the seating there has big screen TVs all over the place, and games for the kids. Didn't see what the condition of their restrooms was like, but the tables ere in fair condition along the front entrance by the soda machines. Seating on a Saturday evening wasn't a problem and in the distance along the booths I saw they had kiddy chairs for small children. Medium sized pizza was good for 2, with some to spare. Staff was friendly. If I was in the mood for pizza and didn't want to go all the way to Morgan Hill for Mod, I'd def recommend coming here again.

Evan A.

Decent pizza but my dad asked for thick crust they said they had it and they gave him regular. My dad asked him again and the guy lied to his face

See all

Photo of Ladi M.
1
47
28

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of D B.
0
29
0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

15 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of R. R.
0
16
0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Tom C.
104
2
0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 5 of 5

Ask the Community - Straw Hat Pizza

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 3,881 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

High & Mighty Pizza Joint - Meat Combo Pizza

High & Mighty Pizza Joint

4.7(138 reviews)
1.2 mi
•$$
Family-owned & operated
Locally owned & operated

Stopped here on our way to Monterey. Super great! Staff was friendly and efficient, beer was cold…read moreand pizza was deeeeeelicious! Ordered the Tri tip jalapeño pizza (added roasted garlic because we are in Gilroy) Definitely would recommend!

My partner and I came to this pizza joint because we LOVE PIZZA. As soon as we walked in we were…read moregreeted right away by a very nice worker! He let us know where we could find the menu up close, as opposed to the giant one listed above us. My partner and I decided to go with the Cowboy Pizza and the Pesto Pasta. BOTH OF THESE FOOD ITEMS WERE SPLENDED!! Compliments to the chef, seriously. We really wanted to pair our food with lemonade, but they did have any like they listed on the menu. We ended up going with two ciders from "2 TOWNS CIDERHOUSE." My cider was POG Cosmic Crisp but unfortunately it was a little flat and not as enjoyable. My partner got the Mango Cosmic Crisp and he enjoyed his better. I wish they had lemonade, or I wish I would've just stuck to a water cup or a different type of beverage. They have a lot of options for 21+ but they also have a Stubborn Soda Machine with 8 different flavors. There is plenty of seating indoors as well as outdoors! The inside is decorated with lights, plants, and a majority of the seats are a nice brown leather. Overall, it was wonderful. "Better than Round Table." - Isaac Cain Alvarez (his fav place lol) I told him we have a new spot to celebrate his birthday!

Photos
High & Mighty Pizza Joint
High & Mighty Pizza Joint
High & Mighty Pizza Joint - Outside

See all

Outside

Pizza Factory

Pizza Factory

3.3(69 reviews)
1.9 mi
Casual dining
Healthy dining

I was in the mood for pizza this past weekend, and there weren't many optIons open on a Sunday…read moreevening and selling small sized pies or by the slice. Ended up at Pizza Factory, and was pleasantly surprised by my experience. The place was clean and bright, with a spacious dining room and a little arcade on the side. Staff provided immediate service, and my order took about ten minutes to be ready. I ordered a mini-size awesome combo on thin crust with a side of ranch for takeout. It was the perfect size to fill my hunger without leftovers, about 8 inches in diameter. The sauce, cheese, and toppings stretched all the way to the edges. It was yummy, though the ingredients weren't really balanced. It was loaded with italian sausage and black olives, piled on high, but lacking in onions and green peppers. It did affect the taste of the pizza, but the ranch helped (not hidden valley brand). I enjoyed the cheesy savory pie, and was happy with my meal altogether.

Worst lunch pizza buffet ever. No, worst buffet ever. I paid 16.00 for this crap-not including the…read moretip I left. This is the first time I left hungry at an all you can eat buffet . I would rather be hungry than waste calories on the slop that they offered today. The pizza is terrible. Too much sauce, it's greasy ,and the dough is really chewy. I would rather spend 50.00 on a cheese pizza at Lil Caesar's. I never thought I would experience a pizza buffet more disgusting than John's Incredible Pizza or CiCI's. Never again . Save your 16.00 !

Photos
Pizza Factory
Pizza Factory
Pizza Factory

See all

Gilroy Bowl - Grilled Salmon Salad

Gilroy Bowl

4.1(98 reviews)
1.3 mi
•$

We had a great experience with Gilroy Bowl! We originally made a reservation to take our boys…read morebowling for the first time, but unfortunately there was a festival happening in downtown Gilroy and, because of all the road closures, we couldn't get anywhere close to the bowling alley. I called and spoke with the manager, Saulo, who was incredibly understanding and worked with us to move our reservation to the following day. When we came back, Saulo and the entire staff were welcoming, hospitable, and accommodating. Our boys have special needs, and since this was their first time bowling, it was definitely a new experience for them. The staff was patient, kind, and made us feel completely comfortable. That meant a lot to us as parents and made what could have been a stressful outing into a really enjoyable family experience. Huge thank you to Saulo and the entire Gilroy Bowl staff for taking such great care of our family. We'll definitely be back. Additionally, the food and drinks were top tier!! 10/10 -- highly recommend!

A gem in the heart of Gilroy Loved my experience here and…read morewill definitely be returning. First off, the environment and atmosphere is perfect, it's a hangout/lounge, with a bar, a dining area, and of course the lanes. The couches are extremely comfortable, to where you can hangout and drink for hours. All the staff was extremely and accommodating for a Saturday in all sections, bar, bowling and food staff. Lanes felt well waxed without any big grooves or dents which is always a plus. My only complaint would be that the cheese literally falls off the pizza when you take a bite. But other than that, had a great time with the family and will definitely return and recommend this alley to others!

Photos
Gilroy Bowl - Restaurant

Restaurant

Gilroy Bowl
Gilroy Bowl

See all

Straw Hat Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...