If you're looking for real, authentic New York-style pizza in the Gilroy area, you absolutely need to check out JR'S New York Pizza. This is not your typical pizza place. They operate out of a mobile trailer and cook their pizzas in a real brick oven, which gives the crust that perfect New York-style texture and flavor.
Oh my goodness, this honestly has to be one of the best New York-style pizzas I've ever had in my life. I do not say that lightly because I am a huge pizza critic. I love pizza, especially New York-style pizza, and I have tried it in many different cities while traveling throughout the country and around the world. I am always looking for that perfect slice with a crispy crust, great flavor, quality cheese, and no unnecessary grease. JR'S New York Pizza checks every single box.
The pizza has absolutely no flop. You can pick up a slice, fold it the way a real New York slice should be folded, and it holds together perfectly. The undercarriage is beautifully cooked, nice and dry, crispy without being burnt, and not greasy at all. The crust has the perfect crunch on the outside while still being soft and flavorful on the inside.
The sauce, cheese, crust, and toppings all work perfectly together. Nothing overpowers anything else. Every bite has an amazing balance of flavor. You can tell they take pride in what they make and that they use quality ingredients. This is the type of pizza where you take your first bite, stop talking for a second, and immediately realize you found something special.
I am not exaggerating when I say I could easily eat an entire large pizza by myself. It is seriously that good. The pizza comes out hot, fresh, crispy, and full of flavor. It is not heavy, overly oily, or soggy like a lot of other pizzas. You can enjoy several slices without feeling like the pizza is sitting heavily in your stomach.
I am so glad JR'S New York Pizza is now serving the Gilroy area. Their schedule may change, so I recommend checking their Facebook or Instagram page to confirm what days and hours they will be open. I believe they are usually available sometime between Wednesday or Thursday through Sunday, but definitely check their social media before making the drive.
They may not have a lot of reviews on Yelp yet, but do not let that stop you from trying them. Sometimes the best places are the hidden gems that people have not discovered yet, and JR'S New York Pizza is definitely one of those places. This business deserves a lot more attention and support because they are making some seriously incredible pizza.
Even if you live in San Jose, Morgan Hill, Hollister, or anywhere outside Gilroy, I truly believe this pizza is worth the drive. Gather your family, bring your friends, order a large pizza, and give them a chance. You will not be disappointed.
Trust me, once you try JR'S New York Pizza, you are going to understand exactly why I am so excited about it. This is real New York-style pizza done right: crispy crust, no flop, a perfectly cooked undercarriage, great flavor, and no excessive grease.
JR'S New York Pizza is officially one of my new favorite pizza spots. I will definitely be coming back again and again. Give them a try, and you can thank me later. Five stars all the way! read more