I have to start with the "not so obvious" things about this place, which contributed to my less than stellar score for Strange Donuts.
From all the hype, I was expecting a normal donut shop with some flair, some pizazz..didn't happen. Matter of fact, this guy thought the first trip to Strange Donuts would be a great stop to take his wife and mother for breakfast. I was wrong. This location, by definition, is a hole in the wall. No wonder the lines are half way down the block. There is barely room for 3 people to stand and consider their options. There are no seats to sit and have a coffee and a donut, there is no ambiance, it is literally a door, a counter, and a guy (well two guys) dishing out donuts. Yipes!
Once we realized this wasn't going to be the breakfast stop we were expecting, we flipped to option B which basically meant grabbing one of each donut we were interested in trying, and then heading off to a nearby pancake house to have a proper breakfast. Good thing we are versatile, because we were disappointed in the lack of even a bench to sit and scarf down one donut!
As far as the selection and flavor goes, this was a mixed bag. From memory, there were about a dozen and a half different donuts to select from, ranging from a gluten free "puppy chow" donut, to more traditional looking choices. Our selections varied in taste and quality:
Barts Revenge-Better than expected in terms of taste. The butterfinger topping didn't overpower the donut at all, and was almost lacking in all honesty. It tasted like a chocolate donut with chocolate icing, and not much else.
Gooey Butter Cake-It was okay. The icing was buttery, but it didn't really capture the essence of a good gooey butter cake for me. The donut itself was also a bit dry.
French Toast-again, tasted like a cake donut with powdered sugar on it, but not the "powdered sugar" style you buy at the grocery store, but a sprinkling of powdered sugar, more for effect than anything else.
Banana Pudding-not a huge fan of pudding filled donuts, in all honesty, but this one wasn't bad. Definitely better than the previous donuts, but not something I would get again.
Captain Chocolate (not sure that's the right name)-it was a chocolate donut, with chocolate icing, and chocolate sprinkles. Nothing strange about it, but it was a good donut.
Puppy Chow-Gluten free and very dry. I'm not a fan of puppy chow, this was my mothers selection, but even she wasn't impressed with it.
Pumpkin Spice-NOW we are talking. This was a damned tasty donut. I loved it. I want another.
Strawberry Cheesecake-another wonderful tasting donut. I love jelly filled so this was a no brainer. Maybe I loved this one most because it was jelly filled, maybe, but still, damned good choice if you are going to go to Strange Donuts.
In all there is a lot of potential with Strange Donuts, but there isn't enough appeal for me to make this a regular stop. This is, however, a great place to take an out of towner to show them something different! Just plan on making these treats a dessert selection unless you like eating sticky donuts in your car! read more