This is a great little Italian restaurant in Old Town Tustin. Everything we had was great. My son and I shared the huge meat platter. The steak was cooked perfectly medium rare -- so many places overcook steak. This was done by a chef who knows what medium rare is. The pork and sausages were also excellent with a nice smoky flavor. The chicken was cooked fine, but I didn't love the whole idea of pounding out meat. I wish they didn't do that. The pasta dishes were also great. The pasta was cooked al dente -- be sure to tell them if you want it well done. The sauces were both very flavorful, and there was plenty of it -- I sometimes have to ask for more sauce at some places, but not here. The calamari was also very good. My wife ordered the bruschetta ... Very good, but so huge! We're definitely coming back. read more

See all

I really liked the gamberi pasta with the thick noodles; half size was plenty with the chopped salad as an appetizer. I wish the carbonara was creamier with more egg yolk or something. More variety of veggies in the chopped salad would have made it better. Overall: 3.5/5 read more

Storico Spaghetteria - Gamberi - Tuscan Near Me - Tustin, California

Amazing food made fresh and worth its price. Services, friendly and timely The ambience is small and quaint and can get a bit loud when the restaurant is full I highly recommend this place with their freshly made pastas read more

Very friendly service, shout out to Federica! Pasta Carbonara was really good with generous portion of crispy pancetta/bacon. Their pear Gorgonzola salad paired well with it too. Cute restaurant with a gelato section in the back for dessert or other treats after dinner. The area has several cute businesses around the restaurant, but most were closed on a weeknight by 6pm. read more

See all

From the service to the food... you can taste the authentic flavors!!! The focaccia bread was crispy and was a hit at the beginning. I got a latte meanwhile I waited for my food. The pesto and vodka pasta is delicious..you have two options for portions-small or big..both very good portions. I always get the large so I can take home leftovers. You can see how lovely and hardworking the staff is here. read more

See all

We stopped by Storico for a light dinner after dropping off donations at the nearby library. Having loved our previous visits, I was really looking forward to ordering my favorite dish, the Gamberi e Prosciutto pasta. Sadly, it didn't quite hit the spot like it used to. The flavors felt a bit muted compared to the incredible, authentic version they served when they first opened (I even cross-checked with my old food photos!). Fingers crossed they revert to their original recipe and prosciutto brand soon. That said, service remains a bright spot--Nicole was warm and friendly, and we were seated quickly. read more

See all

One of my new favorite pasta restaurants. There is something special about pasta dishes that know when to keep things simple. The Cacio e Pepe and Gamberi e Prosciutto were both beautifully balanced and a strong example of how important restraint is when it comes to saucing pasta. In both cases, the pasta itself was the highlight and was cooked exactly as it should be. Paired with high-quality ingredients imported from Italy, the result is a combination that produces truly memorable dishes. The sauces complemented the pasta rather than overwhelming it, making both plates especially well executed. I also had the Chopped Salad for a lighter option. It was fresh and well-prepared, though fairly straightforward in nature. The Hugo Cocktail was an excellent choice for a warm day--light, refreshing, and not overly sweet, which made it particularly enjoyable. Service throughout the meal was excellent: attentive, professional, and welcoming. With pasta of this quality, this restaurant is well on its way to becoming a regular destination. I look forward to returning and exploring more of the menu. read more

See all

Food: - Salsiccia: pasta was al dente, good ratio of pasta to sauce, tasty flavors - Ragu: pasta also al dente Ambiance: - easy parking in attached lot - plenty of seating and attentive staff read more

Storico Spaghetteria - Salsiccia - Tuscan Near Me - Tustin, California

This place is cute, vibey, and in old town tustin! Def hard to find parking but it is doable. Very busy on a friday evening but there was indoor and outdoor seating. Our waiter was very friendly, and all the pasta is supposedly made fresh in house daily. We got the bruschetta as an appetizer and each got our own pastas. Def do not get the half size, just get the full! Some pastas come with protein but mine didnt so i added chicken for $9!!! My pesto pasta was $22 for the full size so its very pricey, especially for not including any protein. The bruschetta was very good, and I dont even like tomatoes usually! I liked it a lot though! The pastas were a miss though imo. I liked the texture of my pasta noodles but the flavor was meh. I thought it was underseasoned. The chicken on it was very good though and I liked the charred flavor. I tasted the carbonara and between the 4 pastas the consistency was not there. The carbonara was sooooo raw LOL. Like very raw, i wouldnt call it al dente. Same with the farfalle - super raw. My pasta and the other red sauce pastas were fully cooked though. Its a cute spot but i just don't think the pastas are that impressive. Especially for the price. read more

See all

A great little local spot in the old town Tustin area. If you love Italian food you must drop in for dinner. My wife had been wanting to try this place for sometime and we finally went on a Friday night, it is small so make a reservation. Between us we ordered 3 plates of pasta. You can get a full size and half size. We got two full size and a half size so we could share a little bit of everything. My advice order the full size because who doesn't love left over pasta. In order by our favorite dish... Carbonara - rich and creamy, one of the best I have had (my wife didn't like it as much as me) Ragu fettuccine - my wife loved this plate Gambrei pappardelle - this was so so but the shrimp was good We also ordered the house bread which was worth it. There are so many different pasta dishes that we plan to comeback read more

See all

Not sure why it took me so long to try this cute restaurant in Old Town Tustin when I live just minutes away! We started with Prosecco served in chilled glasses (such a nice touch ), then shared the calamari, burrata salad, and Gamberi e Prosciutto pasta before finishing with gelato. Everything was delicious, but the pasta was the highlight of the meal. Made with fresh shrimp, shallots, white wine, prosciutto, tomato paste, and a light cream sauce, it was packed with flavor while still feeling light and balanced. Already looking forward to coming back and trying more of the menu. read more

See all

We love this place. Food and service is always amazing. I've celebrated my birthday here twice. I prefer coming for lunch or early dinner, only because the evenings can be loud. Do true dinner hours, I'd recommend smaller parties under 4 so you can hear everyone at the table. read more

Decided to try this place since the restaurant I planned on going to did not open for lunch. Got seated at the bar since most of the tables were reserved. Service was sick and efficient. Ordered their chopped salad and the meat ragu and rap and sausage pasta. Food was ok but nothing special. I am glad we finally tried this place that I had driven passed many times read more

Storico Spaghetteria - Ragu di carne - Tuscan Near Me - Tustin, California

See all

Came back to Storico to try other dishes and it did not disappoint. The Paccherri alllaPanna was fresh, savory and delicious plus the pasta was perfectly al dente. The calamari fritti were crispy and crunchy (love the vodka sauce that came with it). The tiramisu was the perfect dessert to end this wonderful Italian meal. Nicol was our server and she was super friendly and attentive. The ambiance was cozy, intimate and festive. read more

See all

I ordered a full bowl of the Salsiccia pasta. Plenty of free parking behind l. The pasta was really well done. Perfectly cooked and coated in a rich, flavorful sauce with the sausage bringing a nice savory depth to the whole dish. It felt hearty without being too heavy, and every bite was consistent. The place has a clean, modern feel but still feels comfortable enough to sit and enjoy your meal. Staff was friendly and service was quick and smooth from start to finish. Simple order, but everything was done right. Definitely a spot I'd come back to when I'm in the mood for a solid pasta. read more

Storico Spaghetteria - Tuscan Near Me - Tustin, California

I absolutely love this place! Although I wish you could order both the pasta from here and pizza from Centro next door, I always have to come here when I'm craving pasta. The Salsiccia Rigatoni is one of my favorite dishes, but everything I've tried has been delicious and the pasta is always cooked perfectly! This place can get packed so make sure to plan in advance. I will say the service has been a bit slow the last few times we went, but when the service is great, this place is a 5/5. read more

The vodka penne is amazing and truly always a win here! It's rich, flavorful, and one of those dishes I'd order again without even thinking twice! We also finally tried the fried calamari because every time we come to this chain I see people ordering it, and now I totally get why. It was super fresh, perfectly crispy, and really delicious. Everything we've had here has been consistently great, which is why I keep coming back! Definitely one of those places where you know you're going to eat well every time! read more

See all

Full marks for ambience and service. I love that you can enjoy a meal, have a coffee afterward, or even go wine-tasting--all on one property! However, I continue to be a little underwhelmed by American-Italian cuisine. While the food looked appetizing, the flavors were a bit too heavy for my taste. The two standouts I truly enjoyed were the loaded bruschetta and the delicious affogato! read more

See all

The incredible quality and authenticity of the Italian food here at Storico Spaghetteria, together with the relative affordability of such foods, makes this restaurant my top pick for everyday Italian fare outings. The pane della casa ( homemade focaccia with olive oil & balsamic vinegar ) was extremely delicious, perfectly salted, and the olive oil with balsamic vinegar tasted outstanding. There were four pieces of focaccia that came for just $3 and I had to take a piece home because it was a lot! The pesto pasta in the half size was $17, and even this was so much that I had to take some home. However, the quality of the pesto and the fusilli pasta noodles were second to none here in OC, and I am now so happy to have found a real Italian restaurant that serves real Italian food for reasonable prices - I worried about having to choose between unhealthy Alfredo and cheese wheel cheaper pastas versus expensive full-scale dining experiences, neither which made sense to me, until I found Storico Spaghetteria, the answer to my Italian food needs. The staff at the Spaghetteria are super dedicated, professional, attentive, and courteous, and I love the kind of upscale yet friendly Old Town Tustin atmosphere here. This actually differs sharply from my experience at the Storico Cafe next door, which is for my next review. I love Storico Spaghetteria and I know my mom will love this place too!! read more

See all

I came to Storico for an early Mother's day lunch. It was around 12:30 on Saturday. I called the day before to ask if I could get a reservation but the nice gentleman on the phone said they don't do reservations for that time but I should be good to get seated right away with 7 people. He assured me I shouldn't have any issues. I will assume he forgot it was Mother's day weekend lol. When we arrived the hostess told us all of the big tables were full and it would be a 30 minute wait. She also said the kitchen closes down at 1:45 so.... In other words my chances of dining in were slim to none? Or we would not be able to order any food once we are seated?? I really am not sure where she was going with that. My daughter stepped in and asked if there were tables available outside. She said there was but it was probably too small for us, we asked to go see and thought the table was actually perfect for us. So we asked to be seated there. We had plenty of elbow room and the table fit our food perfectly so I am not sure why she thought it was too small. Overall we did not feel like she was taking much initiative to be accomadating on a holiday weekend. The food was so authentic and amazing that I didn't even care. My pesto was so fresh and flavorful, the pasta was cooked perfectly. Everyone in my family ordered something different and everyone loved their dish! Service was friendly but not very attentive. They add a 20% gratuity for parties 6 and up. The restaurant inside and outside is super duper cute and charming. I would definitely come back again as the food was just so good, I would hope to have a better experience with service next time though. I am always very aware and forgiving when going out Mother's day weekend. read more

See all

Storico continues to impress! Great vibe, great staff, and great food. Our three pastas tonight were packed with flavor, high quality ingredients, and so delicious! The pesto was flavorful but not overwhelming, the ragú was so rich and the pappardelle were firm enough to scoop it up, and the risotto was creamy even without cream. The salad was also a great, light appetizer. I will definitely be back! read more

See all

Storico offers some of the best pasta dishes around, and I can confidently say every dish I've tried has been delicious. The freshly made pasta adds an extra level of flavor and texture that really elevates each dish. The service is excellent, and the atmosphere is relaxed, warm, and welcoming. Their drinks are also fantastic and pair perfectly with the meal. A great spot for a consistently enjoyable dining experience. read more

See all

Came here with my boyfriend on a lunch date and honestly, it was such a great experience. I have a dairy allergy, and the staff was incredibly accommodating and attentive when it came to modifying my order. I got the arrabiata with no cheese and added mushrooms because I love them, and it was absolutely impeccable. So much flavor, perfectly balanced heat, and honestly didn't need cheese at all. The quality of the pasta and sauce really stood on its own. The interior was really charming too, which made the whole experience even better. It's always a relief finding a place that takes allergies seriously and still delivers amazing food. I'll definitely be coming back. read more

Storico Spaghetteria - Tuscan Near Me - Tustin, California

The food here is made with love. Everything was so fresh and tasty. Food was hot and delicious. Been a long time since I had really good authentic Italian. read more

See all

Storico Spaghetteria is a quaint Italian cafe in Old Towne Tustin (which is unfortunately located adjacent to street construction along El Camino Real). The restaurant is cute and great for a more casual dining experience, perfect for a family gatherings. I found Arancini a bit dry and bland, which was disappointing as Arancini is typically one of my favorite Italian appetizers. The Cacio E Pepe was fine, the highlight of the meal was the Tiramisu. read more

See all

Storico Spaghetteria truly felt like a little slice of Italy. Every pasta we tried was delicious, authentic tasting, and the portions were HUGE. Their focaccia was also so good. The restaurant itself is super cute and cozy inside. The food and atmosphere definitely outshined the service. Will absolutely be back for another pasta night tho!! What we tried: PANE della CASA Daily special: GNOCCHI IN ARRABIATA RAGU di CARNE RAGU BIANCO PESTO CARBONARA GAMBERI E PROSCIUTTO read more

Storico was decent overall. We ordered quite a bit, and the pasta was very good definitely the highlight of the meal. The food itself was flavorful and well prepared. The service, however, was just okay. There was some miscommunication, as I wasn't informed that changing the pasta would come with an extra charge, and I also wasn't told that the bread they offered would be an additional cost. The servers were present to clear plates and remove food, but there wasn't much check-in beyond that. I completely understand that working in the food industry can be overwhelming, but attentive service really makes a big difference in the overall experience. The restaurant itself is very nice inside, but if you're dining as a party of two and plan on ordering multiple dishes, I'd recommend asking for a booth or a larger table. While the staff did help clear plates between courses, it sometimes felt rushed almost like we needed to finish one dish quickly just to make room for the next. We honestly ran out of table space with everything we ordered. Overall, excellent pasta and a beautiful space, with room for improvement in service and communication. read more

Storico Spaghetteria - Tuscan Near Me - Tustin, California

Service was on point tonight! Completed dishes never sat long and we were checked on constantly. The pasta was al dente and flavorful. The caprese salad was fresh and enjoyable. The restaurant has a decent amount of seating and is open and inviting. They have a few tables for larger groups. read more

See all

MUST TRYYY IF YOU LOVE PASTA. Cute spot in old town Tustin. They have a parking lot right next door in case you miss it. We sat outside for dinner on a weekday and were sat immediately. Staff is super nice and kept checking on us. A lot of their pasta is handmade and it was so good. I got the papardelle with shrimp and it was perfectly cooked pasta. I like more al dente and it was perfectly cooked! They have huge portions too and offer full or half portion. Picture is size of full! We also like that they offer the wine flight but they pick the flavors for you because we hate picking. They all were awesome snd tasted great with pasta. My fave was the Prosciutto with bread and a buttery cheesy sauce! I'm still thinking about it today. read more

See all

I have been here two times and pasta is fresh and authentic! Storico is a cute restaurant in downtown Tustin. It gets super packed during peak time so highly recommend coming early to avoid the rush. There is inside and outside seating. They have various selection of pasta, apps, drinks and mains. For apps we recommend the calamari! Very crispy and not overly greasy. For the pasta they do half portions which is good for me. My favorite is the gamberi proscuitto! The sauce is light, creamy, and wide ribbon pasta is bomb! I've tried the capperi e olive, great if you like olives. The cacio e Pepe is a little bit too creamy. My fiancés Ragu pasta was meaty and delicious. If you are going to get dessert definitely get the gelato, so creamy and refreshing, good portion as well. A bit pricy but worth the price, would highly recommend stopping by here for a pasta craving. read more

See all

First, I want to say that the service here is always wonderful. They really do hire some of the nicest people. The servers, hosts, and cafe workers were all incredibly kind, attentive, and helpful. The ambiance is PHENOMENAL. It's such a beautiful space, and you can really tell that the designer and owner put a lot of thought and care into making it both gorgeous and comfortable. Honestly, I could sit here for hours. As for the food, this was my second time trying Storico, and unfortunately, I had a similar experience to my first visit. The first time, I thought maybe I had just come on an off day because I had seen so many great reviews online. I was honestly surprised to have another disappointing experience. I'm not big on Yelp, but I felt the need to give recognition where it's deserved and let people know about my experience. The first time we came, we ordered some type of lemon spaghetti, and I found it extremely bland. It almost felt like the pasta had been placed in a room next to a lemon for five minutes rather than actually having much lemon flavor. Today, we ordered a caprese salad, cacio e pepe, and a pesto pasta. The caprese salad was easily the highlight, 10/10 and honestly the only thing I'd order again. It was delicious. Unfortunately, the cacio e pepe was incredibly flavorless. We ended up barely eating it because it was so bland. My friend felt similarly about the pesto pasta. I completely understand that traditional Italian food can be much more subtle than what I'm used to, so maybe this is simply a matter of personal taste, but I just didn't love it. The cafe was great, though, and our espresso was delicious. I really wish the food had been better because I genuinely wanted to love this place. I will say again that the staff absolutely rocks. If we'd had more time, I probably would have asked if something could be done about the flavor, but we had already waited about 45 minutes for our food and were running late to a show. Unfortunately, we had to leave feeling like we had spent quite a bit of money on a meal we ultimately didn't enjoy. Beautiful restaurant, phenomenal service, great cafe and espresso, just unfortunately not food that worked for me. read more

Been wanting to go here for a while, glad I finally went! Came here on a Sunday evening for a nice dinner. The weather was perfect so we decided to sit on the patio. Got to enjoy a surprise view of a Space X launch too! The dining room is nice, if not a bit loud but nothing out of the ordinary. The patio is very quaint, I highly recommend sitting here if the weather permits. Service was a tad bit slow but the place was packed so I won't fault them for this. Took a while for our server to first come out and to get our drinks once ordered. The food came out quickly though and at a good temperature. We weren't starving so we started with the antipasto plate, basically a nice charcuterie board. It had pepperoni, salami, and prosciutto for the meats; brie, pepper jack, and a delicious soft crumbly cheese. The board also included olives, artichoke hearts, and perfectly toasted ciabatta bread. For our entree we split the grilled meats plate which was a perfect way to try all their specialty meats. It included 2 Italian sausages, 2 lamb chops, a filet mignon, and a flattened grilled chicken breast. It was all cooked perfectly and tasted great. No dipping sauces or anything to take away from the flavor of the meats. We enjoyed it very much. A bit of arugula and a lemon wedge on the side made a great pairing. We both got the wine sampler which comes with four 2oz pours of their choosing, usually 2 whites and 2 reds. All were very tasty and went perfectly with the meal. We'll definitely be back, thanks Storico! read more

See all

We went on a weekday for lunch and it was nice and not too crowded. The three of us ordered a salad to share and each of our own pasta. All the dishes were so delicious and enjoyable. Nice vibe and interior decor. We'll definitely be back! read more

See all

Came here for a work outing and ordered the Ragu fettucine, which includes San Marzano Tomatoes, Pork, Beef, Veal, Garlic & Onion. The fettucine was authentic and tasted made in-house. The dish was creamy from the marzano sauce and meaty from the pork and beef. Overall, it was a good meal and service was good. Would've been great if they provided complimentary bread though. Parking is in a small lot, but there's street parking available also. read more

We always do take out and the pasta is freshly homemade. PERE e GORGONZOLA salad and the ZITI alla GENOVESE as an entree. Delicious food.

Really enjoyed the Cacio e pepe pasta here! The noodles were especially delicious -- loved how they're made fresh. Tried the Pane della Casa (Focaccia bread with olive oil) too and was pleased with it, plus it was only $3. We also got the Ragu di Carne, but wasn't really a big fan. The service here was great too. Our waitress always checked up on us and made sure we had everything we need. She was also very nice when giving us recommendations when we had questions/were indecisive on what to order. As for how busy it gets, we went here on a Saturday evening and waited about 15-20 minutes. It wasn't bad though since the area was nice to walk around and explore. The parking lot also looks small, but it was easy to get a spot. read more

See all

This Italian place is fantastic! The pasta is made from scratch. You can taste every single flavor. We also got the salmon dish, which was delicious. We tried the Barada and tomato appetizer. The wines provided. We're also delicious. This is a hidden gem. All of the food is outstanding and their wine pairings are also great. The servers were very attentive and were great with recommendations. The restaurant was very busy, but felt like you were in the back of a kitchen from Italy. read more

Located on the cute strip of old town Tustin. Wandered in at 9:15 on a Friday because I was waiting for a seat at Hondaya and I almost had a rethink of my dinner plans. This place is cute and hip yet casual. We got a bottle of decent pinot grigio for just $30 and enjoyed it at the bar. Menu looks good and I'll have to try it sometime, but the wine alone makes it a hangout place I'll return to soon enough. read more

Storico Spaghetteria - Tuscan Near Me - Tustin, California

Stopped by on a weekend around 11 AM and was seated almost right away with minimal wait. The vibe is casual and welcoming, and the servers were super friendly and helpful. They also offered some great recommendations for both food and drinks. 1. Vongole (Linguine) with White Sauce - Creamy yet light, and the clams were incredibly fresh. This is for the seafood lovers- you can definitely taste the quality. 2. Paccheri alla Panna - Rich and creamy white sauce loaded with ham, mushrooms, and onions. The paccheri pasta shape is unique so I recommend giving it a try! 3. Gamberi e Prosciutto - A lighter red sauce with fresh shrimp. The pasta shape was also unique and a great contrast and balance to the creamier dishes we ordered. Overall, a great experience. Parking can be a bit challenging during peak lunch hours, but there is a shared lot nearby. Prices felt fair for the quality and portion sizes, and the pasta definitely tastes authentic! read more

Storico Spaghetteria - Tuscan Near Me - Tustin, California

While looking for more unique eats in the area, this was recommended to us and we generally don't go out to eat Italian food that much and seeing that there's a good amount of pasta that sounds delicious and that we've never tried before, this was the play. It was also within walking distance from an event we were attending so everything worked out! Loved that there's some historical pieces outside and inside the restaurant too. The towing sign is with a historical vehicle and there's a tractor (?) inside and some farm vehicle outside too. The restaurant has table seating and bar seating, it's not super big, so there may be a wait depending on when you go and how big the parties are in front of you. We were lucky enough to wait long since our party was smaller. The restaurant is attached to their cafe as well. Non-alcoholic drinks and desserts that are available at the restaurant are also available at the cafe as well, so if you can't make up your mind during your dining session, you can just walk right next door and order there. They also have daily specials for entrees, appetizers, desserts, and spirits, just take a look at the chalkboard that they have up. Our group got the: 1) Peach Italian Soda: -Very bubbly and had a light peach taste. Not bad. -Wouldn't mind trying their other flavors. 2) Sweet cream Maple Nut Latte: -Strong coffee taste to it that ends with the sweet taste of maple nut. -It's a very "European" way of doing coffee if that makes sense. -You'll definitely stay up if you down the entire thing. 3) Mango Menta: This is a green tea with mango and mint. -Refreshing with real sprigs of mint in it. -The minty taste with the sweetness of mango went really well together. 4) Pane della Casa: -This is their house focaccia bread with olive oil and balsamic vinegar. -Really wish this was something offered on the house instead of for purchase but it was relatively cheap for $3. Only issue was that the bread was QUITE hard. Not sure if it's supposed to be this way or because we went right at the end of the day. -I'd skip this. 5) Paccheri alla Panna: -This is paccheri pasta in a light cream sauce with peas, Italian cotto ham, onions, parmigianno, and mushrooms. -We opted to try more of the unique pastas that we don't usually see at other restaurants and this was one of our choices. -Nice chewy texture to the pasta and the little burst of flavor from the peas added to the yummy creaminess of the sauce. The ham also added a nice saltiness that brought everything beautifully together. 6) Sacchetti ai Funghi Porcini: -This is fresh pasta stuffed with porcini mushrooms, garlic, Swiss, and Fontina cheese. -Favorite of the night. Can never go wrong with a stuffed pasta. -Loved the seasoning and flavoring of the sauce and the texture of the mushroom filling. At first I was a bit wary of splitting 2 pasta dishes with 4 adults, but was convinced to order the full serving and I'm glad I did because the full serving is about half of what you'd normally see at an American restaurant (lol at my fat ass), so ordering half would have definitely left us hungry. Overall pretty good place. read more