Stoney's is definitely a hidden gem in Schenectady. It doesn't look like much from the outside but the food is always really good. If you're a seafood lover, they do a great job with their seafood dishes. The table next to us ordered shepherds pie and it looked and smelled amazing, I could hear them raving about it. We started with the seafood stuffed mushrooms, and we're starving so forget to take a picture. The portion was generous and plenty for 2-3 people to share. I ordered the seafood boil which was a special and it was so flavorful, loaded with garlic and a side of drawn butter. My husband ordered the seafood fra diavolo, it was loaded with seafood and had a very good sauce. read more

Stoney's Irish Grill - Seafood Boil special - Pubs Near Me - Schenectady, New York

See all

To paint the full picture I've lived in Schenectady my entire life and I'm mid 40's. I'm had been to Stoney's but not for at least 15-20 years. Back in the day they would have pizza brought over from their pizza shop across the street bud the pie was good. Fast forward to our trip this year. It was our 19th year wedding anniversary and the wife and I were looking to try something new. The pictures from the food looked great so I figured this was worth a shot. Upon arrival we were greeted very warmly and the bartender and waitress were both warm, friendly, and it was all very natural like we just walked into there home. The place is decked out in craft Irish stuff but it was just at patty's the week before we had gone but I imagine that is a typical look there. We both had a dirty martini which was made very well and the waitress served them table side with the remainder left in the glass fir us to pour ourselves. Very nice touch! We had scallops wrapped in bacon and a French onion soup as an app. Both were good but the soup was a bit cold so we asked to have it warmed up. The staff handled it well they didn't make a huge deal and just got us a nice hot soup with no excuses or rambling on about this "this never happens" or "staffing issues". On to dinner. I had the steak Au Poivre with mashed and veg. All of it was done well and the portion was perfect. The wife had chicken piccata which had a great egg batter on it and a nice white wine butter sauce. We also ordered some Togo meals for the kids and they enjoyed them as well. They had boneless wings, a burger, and a chicken parm sub. I would definitely recommend this place for a medium priced dinner and drinks. Very friendly staff and the place was super clean and well put together. We will be going back! read more

Stoney's Irish Grill - French onion soup - Pubs Near Me - Schenectady, New York

See all

Excellent neighborhood restaurant with a great menu. Don't let the name fool you. Got some excellent Italian dishes on the menu. I had the seafood Diablo dinner. Asked waiter how hot it was and said they could tone it down for me. Meal was prepared just the way I wanted it and a pleasure to eat. Bartender came over and took our drink order and waitress both were at the top of their game. The neighborhood feel of this place was awesome. If in town, try this place read more

Our go to place for dinner. They do everything well. Drinks are good, and they seem to appreciate their customers

1st time there. Nice ambiance and the food was great. Defintely planning many return visits.

Maybe we ordered the wrong meals, but neither myself, nor my husband were very impressed. I ordered the fried seafood platter, which was pretty overcooked. My husband ordered the shepherds pie, and it was borderline tasteless. I don't think we would return for food. The pub atmosphere was nice though! read more

Nice cozy dinner spot on a cold April night. We had dinner reservations for 8 and were seated right away towards the back next to their display cases with fancy decanters of liquor- a whole wall of them- impressive! Despite being an "Irish" Grill I got the feeling that it had an Italian side too. Nothing wrong with that! Nice beer selection- I had an IPA followed by a Blueberry Blonde draft. Of course they had Guinness! I had the Jersey Joe sandwich- plenty of roast beef and melted Swiss on a roll with a side of au jus. Their take on a French dip- it was filling and excellent. Others in our party ordered the Chicken Parm- a massive dish with a side of pasta and garlic bread. My bro had the Piled high Shepherds Pie- it looked good. Other bro had the Ciappino (sp.?). Everything looked great. Good place to hit for a variety of Irish, Italian and other comfort foods. read more

Stoney's Irish Grill - Pubs Near Me - Schenectady, New York

My wife and I went there spur of the moment for our anniversary. As we walked in the bartender greeted us and asked if we had reservations, which we did not. He checked to see if there were any available tables, there weren't, but he had 2 seats at the end of the bar. We took those seats and our night was perfect. The atmosphere was so welcoming, a woman entertainer was singing in such a beautiful voice, the other patrons were friendly to us, the food and drinks were fabulous and the service seated at the bar was the best. read more

Delicious food is offered by this unassuming-looking establishment. Friendly owner and staff.

Big portions, but nothing phenomenal. Very slow service on a Friday night. The highlight was the Reuben balls, which were crispy with a fantastic thousand island dipping sauce. I had the marinara haddock which was watery and undercooked. The portion was huge; enough for two or three people and came with overcooked and over-oiled vegetables. Reasonable prices, but I was quite underwhelmed. read more

See all

This place is a total POS. I had several good experiences there but had a bad experience with one of their drunken regulars. Stopped by to say goodbye and they were total. A holes. Do not go there unless you are into drunk regulars that run the place. read more

Hands down the worst meal we've had in a long time. We had the Fish & Chips dinner. How could that be bad in an Irish pub? Frozen, burnt, dry and tasteless fish and overcooked Frozen fries. Beer tasted as if the lines hadn't been cleaned in months! AVOID this "little gem" as others called it. This was an expensive negative experience. We won't be back. read more

Don't let the looks of the neighborhood deter you. There are some real gems in this area and Stoney's is one of them. We've been here a couple of times now and so far, so good!! I was a little surprised when we first walked in. Because it looks like it's going to be a bar (and there is a long bar running almost the depth of the restaurant), it was fully carpeted. That told me that I was in for something different. And it was. We have always enjoyed what we ordered, sometimes it hasn't been Irish food. read more

This place gets an extra star for atmosphere, if I am being totally honest. But the food and drinks are also good, although a bit pricey (and the prices on the menu were not up to date by a dollar for each item we ordered). They also charge for soda refills (but I stuck with water anyway). However, I wasn't really mad because the service was so friendly and homey, and the food was still good. My husband and I shared a Jersey Joe. It was good, but I didn't really taste the horseradish. My husband enjoyed it a lot, though, and the fries were very good. We also shared Irish Cannonballs. Those were really good; my husband was a huge fan. All in all, the food is not the best I have ever had, but it's good and the atmosphere is special. read more

Stoney's Irish Grill - Irish Cannonballs - I liked these, especially after they sat for a bit - Pubs Near Me - Schenectady, New York

See all

Came here with the boys on a Saturday night, as saturdays are typically for the boys. The lovely atmosphere was only made better by the somewhat talented group of singers who sang hits from "Ticket to Ride" to the lion king theme song. The food, while had massive proportions and tasted good, was not reflective of the prices online at all, some by $3! What perhaps let the night down was the service... the place was not crowded at all, but we waited a whopping 1 hour and 16 minutes and 63 seconds for the food. I was "shooketh" as you could say. We only ordered 4 dishes! Hunker down and perhaps bring some light reading as you'll be waiting awhile. read more

See all

I gotta say, I've pasted this place so many times and never realized it served food. I thought it was just a local bar. Well, they serve food and it was good! They have great specials during the week and for Sunday football serving 50 cent hot wings! They also have a great Tuesday special too which includes Martinis and oysters. I will go back to try ! Tonight, of all things I got the bacon, liver and onion special. I have no idea why I ordered it but I'm glad I did! It was moist and flavorful! My husband got the haddock in lemon butter. Huge plate. My daughter had the Buffalo chicken wrap. Full of chicken. Very surprised at the portion size, and the service. Just to note, surprised at the older crowd. Definitely a "older" crowd attraction for some reason. Surprisingly? Anyway, great feel, great service, really good food , and affordable!!! 1/10/17 been back twice since my last review! I gotta say, each time I go back I like it even more! Tuesday Oyster special was fantastic! Served perfectly! Chilled perfectly! Enjoyed the calamari! And I enjoy how friendly the staff is. Good job! read more

Great place! Food was excellent, large portions, very reasonably priced, service was great. Nice little gem tucked into a corner.

Decided to check out this Irish pub after so long and was pleasantly surprised. The place was decorated for Halloween and the walls were adorned with the 37 years of history behind the pub. The menu was a diverse and actually very impressive for such an unassuming place. There are a number of beers on tap and the staff was professional and friendly. I'll definitely be frequenting this local delight in the future. read more

See all

This is a regular for us... They have Lambrusco, my wine of choice and a large menu to choose from. Some days better then others on food. read more

See all

Very unassuming...nice place, fantastic bartenders. Food is soooo good. I had the zuppe de pesce. Though it's an Irish place surrounded by Schenectady Italian places.. this was the best I had since moving from long island. read more

Stoney's Irish Grill - Pubs Near Me - Schenectady, New York

Delicious Food, Great Portions, Great Ambiance, Reviews weren't kidding - hidden gem!

We love Stoney's. Food is awesome. Not much of a wing fan but tonight we had garlic Parmesan wings. They were excellent. Crispy and flavorful!! My favorite place. Staff and customers are so friendly read more

Totally love this place..friendly and clean.the food is fantastic..burgers n onion rings,.cornbeef never disappoints even off season ..large group or 1,2 or 3...variety of entertainment from trivia nights to our own personal favorite Mia. read more

Great local spot with great pub fare. I had mozzarella stix which were very tasty. Also had a couple Sam Adams Summer Ales. Good stuff. Funny story, I was going up to the bar for round two, and ordered a miller for Dad and a Summer Ale for me. The bartender brought them back and declared $7 dollars. $7 for each, I asked, quizzically? Um... no $7 together. Me dumbfounded look. Utter shock. Okay. great! Of course in New York $7 for one beer is on the cheap side, it can often be $8 or more. SO to get two for that price was utterly earth shattering. =) read more

Dined there tonite....nice pub atmosphere..... decent staff ... Scampi was good.... My lady , who hates to complain, said her chicken francaise was undercooked to the point of being inedible....and over lemoned as well..... much as I liked the bar ,...we will not likely return....... Sad, a little care in the kitchen might have made us regulars ... Go for a drink.... don't eat there read more

Food was excellent! There were HUGE portions, enough for three meals! The seafood Diavolo away really delicious. Prices were very reasonable for the portion sizes. I will definitely be back :) read more

Stoney's Irish Grill - Shepard's Pie - Pubs Near Me - Schenectady, New York

See all

Visited on a busy Thurs night. The had live music old classics, blues. some Irish dishes on menu. Decent bar. Service we had to ask a few times. Seems like a place for regulars, no special welcome for this group of newbies. Irish nachos interesting. I'd try again if I was in Schenectady. read more

Their specials are a good value but the food is sometimes not great. For example, the Reubens my friends and I ordered for lunch were not prepared well--soggy bread, so they fell apart. At dinner time, the turkey dinner was too salty, but the Haddock Francais was excellent! read more

Our favorite place! Drinks are great, staff is so wonderful, and the food!!! Delish!!! Mike and Ned do a great job keeping the menu (specials!) new and exciting, and there's a great variety! From bar food, to Irish classics, and even to die for Italian food! My go-to spot for sure!!! read more

Really tasty food and friendly people. The scallop appetizer was a meal in itself. It was bacon wrapped scallops on 2 cups of sauteed spinach with garlic, several yummy toast points and a vegetable mousse. The lamb stew was good according to my husband and the European platter was a huge mountain of food that I could in no way finish. Everyone there was very nice. read more

Stoney's is the best restaurant in Schenectady! Food is delicious, atmosphere is lively and happy and the owner Mike is helpful and friendly! Portions are large so come hungry and grab some popcorn at the bar :) read more

Food was great, atmosphere friendly and fun. Staff was friendly and efficient. Will cone here again when in the area.

Great setting, Mike has this place putting out great dishes from Shepards Pie to Prime rib Wednesday. The drinks are top notch as well. From appetizers to the main course, you won't be disappointed. read more

Consistently good, consistently busy! Lively little local pub with great food. Irish themed, but the Italian dish or two will rival your favorite trattoria. Good portions--you'll always bring home lunch for the next day. It's not cheap but I think prices are very reasonable. Owner will always greet you. One drawback--when you spot the table that is just finishing up--don't count on it! They're going to stay for drinks! read more

Stoney's Irish Grill is the greatest! Their food is awesome and they have great drink selections. I have continued to buy one of the wines they have on the drink menu which is a new favorite. The Shrimp Alexander appetizer is just one delicious item I have had off of the menu and they have great weekly specials like $5 steamers on Wednesday nights. The boyfriend likes everything he has ordered - chicken parm, burgers, eggplant, prime rib, calamari... it's all great! On St. Patty's day my Aunt had the best Corned Beef and Cabbage she had EVER had! We go so often they started stocking my Dad's favorite Rum at the bar! They are great people and we go to Stoney's once every couple weeks. Nice cozy atmosphere and really great service. The place is always hoppin'! read more

I finally had a meal at Stoney's Irish Grill, and it certainly met my expectations. In fact, it exceeded my expectations. I had the Shrimp Alexander appetizer and the shrimps that they served were huge. I also had a sandwich and it was very filling. I certainly enjoy the atmosphere and look forward to coming back. read more

So I have lived around the corner from this place for over 10 years and never have been inside - my dentist asked me one day why I never went there and I really had no answer - Until now. The menu was the basic tavern fare with sandwiches fried foods and a few simple entrees - yet oddly enough an abundance of Italian food??? Umm... Not to state the obvious - But the sign outside says IRISH Grill! I did not see any Irish menu items. How Odd. Not as odd as the new Irish/Mexican Restaurant but still odd. I mean I know Schenectady has a large Italian heritage but for God's sake can we stop with the Italian food at every friggin place you go already? It's not even made with love - it's generic! And no offense to Stoney's... but you are next to the Appian Way, around the block from Riccitello's and a stones throw from Cornell's - Do you really think this neighborhood is suffering from a shortage of veal and chicken smothered in sauce and cheese?? We already have amazing Italian restaurants like Ferrari's, and Canali's that are unparalleled, So come on!... stick with your niche and work it! Serve us up some shepards pie or corned beef n cabbage or even just some potato soup, hell even potato skins would be a worthy attempt! I will say there was entertainment (no one I knew or would have gone out of my way for) but its nice to know there is something going on in the neighborhood to go enjoy if we wanted. Everyone was very pleasant and we were not left to our own devices for long as 3 different people were waiting on us. The establishment is clean and inviting - until someone opens the door behind you and BLAST! chills go right up your spine and into your plate of food (eat fast!). My husband had the fish and chips - unusual for him since we r not seafooders but he was dying to find something unique (perhaps irish) on the menu. His plate was nicely presented - two big planks of fried fish with fries and coleslaw. He enjoyed it very much and his plate was empty in little time (before someone else opened the door! lol). I had been stumped at the menu - hoping for something enticing (heard raves about the food!) but was finding it to be lacking for originality. Even the nights specials were other menu items prepared a little differently. I considered the pork chops but since he was going simple I went with the burger instead - med rare-cheese-grilled onions (my way). It was big, juicy, attractive, handmade and properly (perfectly) cooked! However very very bland - again not even salt. If you are going thru the trouble of making these beautiful patties by hand - why not go the extra step and throw some seasoning salt or whatever in the mix? Apprentice was a 9.5 - taste was a 3. This makes no sense to me whatsoever. They didn't even put any salt on the fries! I am waiting for the one time to dine out and say - man this place has really got it's collective Sh*t together! Still holding out hope... Drink specials and consistency I am sure bring this place the majority of it's business and the good reputation it has. The hospitality is certainly great too - its great for them to know your name... but do we really need it running ticker tape style on a lighted sign behind the bar? I really think it's time to step up here folks - when people today have a much greater choice as to where to go to spend their dollar - wouldn't you rather they never even consider it? My recommendations: Taste what you are serving - season it accordingly! Dump the 80's goldfish tank behind the bar - it's tacky as hell. If you want a nice modern aquarium people can stare at for hours then call a service who will not only give you a discount for the exposure to your customers but they will come service it for you! Secondly; Call a good contractor to figure out how to modify or move the front entrance so as to not to blast everyone+their food every time the door opens (NOTE: All tables by the front door were empty - which was why we sat down unaware.) Lastly the running lighted ticker tape style sign behind the bar would be best served OFF - at least put some interesting trivia or quotes on it so after you commit to reading all of what it says you are amused, not left to wonder who the hell is Lori and Steve? and why do we care when their birthday is? And why would they want the world to know they spend THAT much time in a bar? It's a total distraction and really serves no useful purpose other than force me to try and position myself in such a way it so that it is out of my peripheral view. AKA your top liquor $helf - get the draft? I mean drift? I thought so... read more

No place like Stoney's - very inviting, meals are absolutely phenomenal - mixed drinks are not made by "mixers" - they are made the old fashioned way - staff always pleasant!!! read more

Wow! This place was recommended by a pal. Neighborhood pub with fantastic food. Eggplant rollatini and seafood stuffed mushrooms were fantastic appetizers. Mom raved about the Rueben. I had shepherds pie which was incredible. Six beers on tap including fat tire. Daughter raved about the pasta in vodka sauce. Big portions. We all took leftovers home. Best pub food I've had in a long time. Nice casual place. Great service. Cute patio too for eating outside. read more

Come Hungry! The portions are HUGE! I'm a big guy & I wan't able to finish my meal. That says something. Staff was friendly & service was well paced. This is Sch'dy, so being home for a family visit, I wash't looking for a fine dining experience. Mom likes this place so that's good enough for me. Live music, cold beer, good food, & family. It was a pretty good night. Can't ask for much more! read more