I made a reservation (or priority seating, as it's called, more on that later) for my fiancé's birthday on a Saturday night since I liked the look of the menu, and it was the closest steak restaurant we had to us other than going down town. We shared the blue cheese chips, each ordered a steak (mine the fillet with horseradish crust), shared a bottle of wine and sampled the chocolate cake (which they gave us for his birthday, nice touch).
Pros:
When you go to a steak place, you expect good steak. Stoney River delivered on that promise. My fillet was cooked perfectly medium rare, fork tender, and didn't ooze a ton of juice when I cut into it...which means they let it rest before bringing it out. Bless them! Great flavor, great steak, yum. The portion size for the blue cheese chips was also a plus, there was more than enough for the two of us.
I found the service to be friendly, if not super prompt, but they made an effort to be cordial. The ambiance was also nice for a date night; low lighting, wood tables, etc. Overall, what I would expect for a slightly upscale steak restaurant.
Cons:
Reservations are basically a no-go. Instead they have priority seating, so you call to put your name on that list and they guarantee that you will be seated within 20 minutes of that time. Mind you, it saves you the 1.5 hour wait you'd have if you just walked in the door, but no reservations? Even Red Robin has reservations figured out, come on. If I'm going to spend over $100 on dinner, please help me out and seat me when I walk in on time.
Other than that, my gripes are minimal. The potato side that comes with your steak wasn't as big as I thought it should be (coming for Chicago, you get spoiled with big portions). That said, I was pretty full by the end of it so it would have gone to waste. Ultimately, if they had picked a better plate (the plate was HUGE compared to my fillet and potatoes), I would never have noticed. The blue cheese chips came with a warning (for blue cheese lovers only!), but didn't really deliver on that warning (tasty, but not as much cheese as they warned about). Service was a bit awkward at times, we went without water for awhile, etc. Nothing that killed the experience.
Bottom line:
The fiancé enjoyed his dinner, so they score points for that. Both steaks were cooked to perfection, and everything tasted wonderful. If you're looking for a nice, steak dinner date spot out in the 'burbs, then this will work just fine. They get points for food, but fall short of the 4 star mark for me due to all of the little dings that just add up (reservations, service, portion sizes, etc.). I would go back again, but will probably try another steak place first.
Food and Presentation (1-5): 3.5
Ambiance and Decor (1-5): 4
Quality of Service (1-5): 3
Favorite Menu Item: The Lodge Fillet, yum!
Best Suited For: Couples for date night, or friends for appies and drinks at the bar.
Kid Friendly? There were families present, but it's not like they have a children's menu.
Vegetarian Friendly? There were vegetarian friendly items on the menu, but it's a steak restaurant. So really, not ideal.
Recommend to a friend? Yes read more