Well first off soft serve isn't ice cream unless it has 10% butterfat. The service is a little slow…read moreand the atmosphere isn't very cozy as it right on the main road. I will give it another try but the tip jar by the window is a turn off.

Servings are huge, prices are reasonable, food is delicious, and service is quick. The building is…read moreold-school, and evokes fond memories of neighborhood ice cream stands from my childhood. Can't want to return!

Homemade ice cream Large variety of unique flavors…read moreHomemade waffle cones Friendly and pleasant staff What more can you ask for!! One of our favorite places that we put on repeat!

Stopped here today after coming off Brookville Lake. Was able to talk to the owner. They have been…read moreopen 2 days! He said the response from the Brookville community was fantastic. He also prints the Rushville Recorder next door and plans to connect the two businesses through the archway next to the counter so everyone can see the old printing equipment. I enjoyed a dip of cappuccino and fudge brownie with caramel sauce and whipped cream. Homemade ice cream shops are tough to find these days. I will be back to support this business again.

The gentleman at the window took our order and passed it on to someone in the back that got all…read morewrong except one item out of 6. We had to ask for the milk shake as it was not prepared with the test of the order. We told them of the error that we ordered a pulled pork sandwich not plain nachos. It was corrected and they gave us a free cone card. We ordered two inside out drumstick sundaes, amazing idea, with vanilla and chocolate swirl, there was only vanilla. We did not make them change those. The nachos and pulled pork sandwich were like something like you would get at a high school concession stand, nothing special. The sundaes were delicious in spite of the errors. I may come back for a frozen treat but not for food. Great variety and interesting options of frozen treats. The serve soft serve bot ice cream, great for lactose intolerant costumers.

Cute ice cream shop in Oxford. It's reminiscent of old time creamy whip ice cream shops. They…read moreoffer a few outdoor activities also. Such as tetherball and a small playground. It's a great atmosphere to enjoy a cone or sundae outside and stick around for a game of cornhole or watch the kids play. I, unfortunately did not have the time to stick around to enjoy any activities, so it was a quick stop and go. I ordered a turtle sundae to go. It was a large portion size - I mean really large! Plenty of caramel and chocolate covered with its and whipped cream. It was yummy. The ice cream (a soft serve) reminded me a little bit of ice milk. It seemed a little lighter version of the typical soft serve. The to-go sundae was served with a re-sealable lid which was a good idea- as this treat lasted more than one serving!

I love going to the Dairy Cottage to get ice cream. Their milkshakes are so Yummy. They do serve…read moreother kinds of foods that are good.

I called in an order and was told 20 minutes. Arrived on time and was asked to pay. Then proceeded…read moreto wait 35 minutes and asking where the order was 3 times before I received it. It should have been free at that point. Meanwhile, the same food i ordered was served before me the entire time. Very poor and no manager intervention. When I did get it one item was cold and fries were actually not completely cooked. I gave 1 star because I can't give 0.

Grateful to have an ice cream shop in town! I enjoy the rotating, seasonal flavors--I think lemon…read morecookie is my favorite I've tried

Amazing ice cream and amazing service! The ice cream is handmade and the flavors change every now…read moreand then. Came here with an uncle to visit, I live in LA and work in an ice cream shop myself so I appreciate how hard it is to make good handmade ice cream and they definitely are a must! The service here is also top notch!

Stopped in after dinner last night. I got the fat Elvis and my boyfriend got the chocolate fudge…read more Both were amazing and a very large scoop. We will be back

HAVE AGAIN: The chocolate blitz and rocky road ice creams were delicious - really good ice cream…read more And, I could have two different flavors in a small cup!

Stopped on Wednesday for after 1st day of school treat. Approx 5pm…read more This year we have only had the Lil Goodie Shoppee one other time but last summer we visited approx 6 times. Learned our lesson when eating at an ice cream shop to order only ice cream. The ice cream is always perfect tasting & at a good price. This time we ordered 3 hotdogs & a pretzel. We received 1 hot dog / 1 foot long/ 1 pretzel. The pretzel was a little hard and dry. The footlong was gray outside/pink inside & the hot dog was ate by my husband before I could even ask although he said his stomach was bubbling after. I spoke with the girl at the counter about the footlong and she said she could give us a new one although I didn't want another one that could be bad as well. I just was skeptical after looking at it & tasting it. The taste was off & the color was off. I trashed it. Ice cream we ordered was great. 3 dirt sundaes for the kids & 2 twists ( chocolate & vanilla) for the adults.

Amazing family owned ice cream shop + salty snacks!…read more It felt so nostalgic with the creamy yogurt ice cream. The parfait was absolutely stunning! It's very peanut buttery, if that's your thing. Meanwhile, the strawberry shortcake felt like I was eating a summer treat with my nonna. Really great selection and you get your desserts fast! They have a walk up window and drive-thru! Very friendly.

I wanted to try a new ice cream place for my birthday weekend and this place didn't disappoint I…read moreliked there creativity and all the mixes you could make .I got a waffle cone dipper with chocolate ice cream Oreos and cheese cake bites so I could have my cone with out the mess such a good idea I couldn't tell ya what my boyfriend got I just know it took him 2 days to eat it but in a good way. Service was great very friendly. I would say the only downfall would be that parking is close but backing out while the parking lot is full is kind of scary because you really can not see the Rd to safely back out in that case otherwise ambiance was good.

Sprinkles in your small town ice cream spot. Walk up window with many different flavors and…read morechoices. Just a block off Rt 50, easy stop in and roll out. They are also dog friendly and offer a fee doggie dish.

Great place to stop in this small town. There weren't a ton of flavor choices, but enough to have…read morevariety. They have scoops of ice cream, soft serve, shakes, malts and fancy sundaes. Plus, the prices were very affordable!

The young women that run this shop are fast, personable, and fun. The ice cream is wicked good!…read moreEven a small sundae will fill you up. Generous portions. We go as often as possible. Jeff Pix to follow! Also, Parking is plentiful and a great park with a lake is there for the kids and adults as well. If out of town. it's a beautiful and friendly establishment and community. ENJOY!

Midweek on a hot July day, this was the only place in town that was open, and boy were we lucky. We…read morewere driving out of town after a fun educational visit to the state museum grist mill, saw this place was open, and we had to stop. And boy was it worth it. Cold waters, cold sodas, and perfect one scoop waffle cones. I had pumpkin ice cream and the wife enjoyed cookies & cream. Friendly service. Incredibly inexpensive. And the cookie jars are as advertised, floor to ceiling, with an entire back room filled too. If you're touristing around in Metamora, this unique place needs to be one of your stops.

Grannies Cookie Jar & Ice Cream Parlor is a Metamora, Indiana icon, though it may be weird to call…read moreanything in this historic Franklin County town an actual "icon." There's quite a bit you know about me if you've followed my reviews for any length of time. This likely includes my long friendship with fellow Yelp Elites Rick G. and Holly G. - in fact, I performed their wedding ceremony! The three of us have actually collaborated on quite a few projects over the years, either due to Rick's music and comedy or because of my long history of activism and charity work. Frequently, our collaborations combine Rick and Holly's creativity with my activist spirit. For a couple years, Rick and Holly owned a shop in Metamora called Mosaic Learn & Play - I, in turn, owned a small charity bookstore within the walls of Mosaic. While I never spent nearly as much time in Metamora as did Rick and Holly, I spent my fair share of time there and grew to appreciate the picturesque, friendly town. Rick and Holly's wedding was even in Metamora! As is true of most historic towns, accessibility can definitely be an issue in Metamora. Truthfully, I'd say there's more that's not accessible than there actually is accessible in the town. Grannies is most certainly not perfect, a step greeting you at the front door and a crowded shop making even the most experienced wheelchair user more than a little paranoid. It's possible, I've been to Grannies more than once, but it's definitely a shop where I take my time wheeling and I am super careful everywhere I turn. Grannies, first of all, is an official world record holder. Granny owns over 2600 cookie jars - and I believe they're all actually here in this shop. She's held the record since 2012, as I recall. Grannies is, of course, an ice cream shop. Granny even makes all of her waffle cones by hand. Each one has a Hershey kiss at the bottom. She puts a whole lot of love in her waffle cones. The ice cream is pretty incredible, too. She has quite a few flavors and they're at reasonable prices for pretty darn amazing servings. Grannies is open 7 days a week throughout the year. While I can't say I'd drive all the way to Metamora for her ice cream, if I am in the Metamora there's no way I'm leaving without stopping at Grannies. Metamora is a beautiful little canal town. It has definitely been impacted by the pandemic, but the people are also hanging in there. I'm not quite going to say that time stands still here, but it's sure not a place you go to speed up. Metamora is a surprisingly easy drive from Indy and the entire Franklin County area could easily be a relaxing, fairly isolated day trip with Brookville also nearby as the seat of the county. There are even a couple places you can stay in Metamora, though they aren't particularly strong with access and you'd probably want to go to Brookville if that's needed. If you get a chance, head south to Metamora and be sure to stop in at Grannies for some ice cream and definitely check out those cookie jars!