Very mediocre experience.
I was incredibly hesitant because there previously was a Stella D'oro restaurant in Middletown years ago. We went once for brunch, the food looked awful, and we walked out. It closed soon after. So I wasn't optimistic, but everyone has been saying how good it is, so we decided to give it a try. Especially since Tuscany Grill was one of our favorites so we love the space it's in.
We walked in on a Friday night and there were only two parties in the dining room, and only one or two people at the bar. Bad sign!! We had drinks at Esca immediately before and it was packed to capacity. People are out again - they just aren't going to Stella D'Oro.
We walked to the hostess stand and got seated quickly, however we didn't get menus. It was at least 5 minutes until we finally got them, it was sort of an awkward time. And it's not like they have a QR code to look at it on your phone, and the menu on their website doesn't have prices or drinks. And the place isn't busy. Why not just give us menus when you seat us? Then it seemed the hostess was also our server, we don't really know, she never introduced herself to us or anything.
We thought their wine prices were fair and ordered a bottle of wine. Can't really mess that up, it is what it is. Mark West Pinot Noir for $30. She also brought bread and dipping oil. The bread was fresh, hot and crispy and the dipping oil was my favorite part of the meal. It was really good, but it's sort of bad that was the highlight.
Then we ordered entrees, which came with salads. They only have 3 salad dressing options, and they're all odd. Balsamic with Gorgonzola, creamy garlic, and house which was a creamy Italian. There were just two of us, we ordered entrees and she asked our salad dressing choices, then repeated them back to us. When she brought the salads, she got mine right (balsamic with Gorgonzola) but got my husband's wrong. And she knew it, you could tell by what she said. She puts it down and says "creamy garlic.....that's what you ordered, right?" Not right, he ordered the house. He agreed to keep it, but really? There were two of us, you repeated it twice, and still got it wrong? Salad was good, basic greens, two tomatoes, a cucumber slice and two kalamata olives.
For entrees, I ordered the rigatoni Stella D'Doro, based on the photo on the website and the description. Basically a rigatoni alla vodka with shrimp and shiitake mushrooms. Good in concept but not in execution. The sauce was extremely liquidy and bland. There were just 3 shrimp, all were horrifically over cooked, and one still had a vein in it. The pasta was undercooked. Overall it was so mediocre. Not inedible, but not anything I want to eat again. And not worth $22.95 in any way.
My husband ordered chicken parm and was equally underwhelmed. The chicken was mushy, not crispy. It also didn't have a ton of flavor and neither did the sauce. The portion was a decent size but if it doesn't taste good, then it's not like you're happy to have leftovers.
Then it was time to pay. Our server brought the check, it had a QR code for contactless payment, my husband did that and we told our server. She got confused and walked away. We knew we paid so we started to get up, then a man came over and says, you had a question? I said no question, we told our server we paid our bill and she seemed confused and wandered off. He said we were all set and we left.
Bottom line:
Gorgeous space and one of the best patios in Middletown.
Mediocre food and service.
Let the lack of customers tell you what you need to know.
Food can look pretty, but if it doesn't taste good...then why go here over the other 10 Italian restaurants in Middletown?
We won't be back.