This place is amazing! It's seriously the best pizza I've ever had. My grandma, who is 73, agrees that it's the best pizza she's ever tasted, and I couldn't agree more! The waitress is incredibly attentive and friendly, creating a cozy and warm atmosphere while dining here. My family and I love it! We really wish this restaurant was more widespread. The food is absolutely to die for! On a different note, I usually don't eat the crust on pizzas, but I got so full from the pizza that I ended up eating the crust because it was so good! It had a very crunchy, cracker-like texture. read more

Starlite Pizza - Really good pizza - Pizza Near Me - Granger, Indiana

Still awesome. Tonight's was their best pizza ever. Good job Starlite! Pepperoni, sausage & ham. Yummy read more

Starlite Pizza - Yum - Pizza Near Me - Granger, Indiana

Ordered a cheese pizza for takeout and once I was home, opened the box to see a dark hair. (I have blond hair.) I called the restaurant to ask for a new pizza and was rudely spoken to berated for even asking for another pizza. Stay far away from this location. It's not worth it. I should've stuck with the tried and true Bruno's across the street. #pissed read more

Even with the power out they still cooked a pizza for me. It was delicious. My thanks to them for being willing and able to fulfill my order. read more

where do I start .... not good. I ordered a cheese and pepperoni pizza and asked for well done definitely they didn't understand the assignment. The pizza crust was a cracker style but it was very dry didn't taste real. I also ordered the pierogi because I am polish and I was very excited, but when I took a bite and looked inside... it was just cottage cheese with some herbs with zero flavor. very disappointing! read more

All three of the above categories were at 100 percent! We had a group of 20, and the service and food were top notch! Very nice restaurant for cozy or for groups! Pizza, pasta and salads were all very good!!! read more

Just had it for the first....and last time. Some of the ratings talk about this being thin crust....total flop and no crisp. Dave Portnoy would give this place a 0.5/10. The cheapest ingredients. The "cheesy garlic" bread is just premade. If you enjoy high quality legit pizza, go elsewhere...I just don't know where else Bc the chains are way better than the local spots here read more

So much better than the ireland rd location. Its great. My only gripe is the lack of toppings. They are very light on the toppings. Its still amazing. read more

Starlite is our favorite go-to pizza place. Their thin crust pizza is tasty and the staff is so friendly. We refer all our friends to go there and they agree!! read more

Greasy pizza with sweet sauce and crisp outer crust. Doughy and minimally filled pierogi. We did have take out, so it may be better in person. read more

We like to support local one off places and don't like to be negative BUT. This place really needs a top to bottom Gordon Ramsey type update. The decor and the menu are very dated and while they may be happy with the amount of business they have, it could be so much more if they embraced some changes. I'll stick to the pizza here. The sauce is way too sweet and there was to much of it. We bought two cheese pizzas and actually threw out the entire second pizza and some of the first. Two adults and two children 12 and 13 agreed it was "TOO SWEET" and "NOT GOOD". The people seem nice and the prices are good. I want to support the place but have to say, we just can't see returning. read more

One of my family's favorite pizza place in the area. Has a nice family side. Place is a little run down but if you look past that, staff is very friendly and the food is great. It's generally very peaceful there. Most people get take out. read more

Starlite Pizza - Yum!! Meat lovers and the Starlite special!! - Pizza Near Me - Granger, Indiana

Dinner salads were huge and very good. Though the pierogies were not what we expected, they were quite tasty. The Sicilian pizza was well-topped but it lacked garlic, which we look for in a white sauce pizza. The crust was also pretty soggy, like it had been fully cooked but then had gotten wet. The biggest complaint was that we ordered delivery and the pizza arrived almost an hour after the expected delivery time that was initially quoted to us. read more

I live out of state and I get this pizza every time I am back in town! The sauce is homemade, very sweet. The pizza is thin crust, but not too crispy. A change in ownership in the past few years means all ingredients are fresher. The restaurant is clean and casual, but not too busy and a nice environment for a family gathering. Their perogis are my parents favorites. Slightly expensive but their website has coupons and deals. They will even premake your pizza so you can take it home and bake it yourself later! read more

If you have never had a Starlite pizza, you are in for a surprise. If you judge pizza on how thick they are, then you might as well just keep on going. This is thin crust at it's best. The sauce is a more sweet sauce than you are probably use to. But it works. Add a little grease on the top and it's perfect. The place has that old pizza restraurant feel that you will remember as a kid. Almost as good as the original Starlite on the west side. read more

Unbelievable. This was the first and last time here for me. Ordered the stromboli, comes with 3 toppings and cheese, or so they say. There were virtually no toppings on half of the sandwich, sausage was not present on any of it. Pretty much bread and sauce with a little bit of cheese. Now things happen, so you give them a chance to fix it. The waitress came back after I had mentioned the issues and merely said "are you ready for a box?" I said I would actually like some toppings for this sandwich, she went to the kitchen and an older lady came out to defend this creation saying she made it herself, and the toppings go to one side when she folds it over, then simply walked away. No solution was offered. This probably would've been good if fixed, the sauce was tasty, but the refusal and attitude we received was totally unjustified. Never will return. read more

My wife brought home a 1/2 cheese and 1/2 sausage and onion pizza. The cheese side was mediocre but the sausage side was horrible. Very little sausage and the onions tasted like they were spoiled. Very disappointed for a $19.00 pizza. read more

I tried Starlite's lasagna for the first time tonight. It is homemade and very rich, with fresh ingredients and a generous layer of mozzerella on top. It arrived at our table piping hot and smelled fantastic. Very filling! If you like lasagna, you are in for a treat.....best lasagna I have had. read more

Best pizza in the area! I love the thin crust and sweet sauce. Dave is a super nice guy. We always call in our order ahead of time to cut down on the wait in store. We have small kids and they get restless. This place does have toys for kids to play with. Honestly, I just can't wait for the pizza. I know that it's amazing and as soon as I walk through the doors I MUST HAVE PIZZA! They also have a large party space. I had my mom's 60th birthday there. read more

A neighbor told us about this place and I probably wouldnt have noticed it otherwise. A true hidden gem. Great pizza and service.

My fiancé and I are creatures of habit and decided tonight we would go beyond our normal Jimmy Johns and try something local. After a 20 minute drive across town we were not greeted as we walked in the door. Found our seats and waited about 5 minutes before we were acknowledged. Once acknowledged we waited a few more minutes until we were given menu's. We started to wonder if we had to order at the counter.. Once our waitress finally came to our table we ordered right away. Once she took our order it took several minutes, as she helped to go customers, to get our waters and my salad. We ordered a breadstick appetizer which was okay at best. The sticks were somewhat dry. They did however come out promptly. While waiting for our pizza several other tables came and ordered. One couple in particular came about 20 minutes after we ordered and received their pie before us. To add to the pain of waiting they accidentally delivered the couples pizza to us. When we saw it wasn't ours they took it and gave it to the rightful owner. This was very frustrating because our pizza was simple 1/2 cheese, 1/2 mushroom. What the heck was taking so long?! At this point the woman (not our waitress) who delivered the pizza was on a mission to find out what happened to ours. While she was looking we heard her tell our waitress she needed to tell us what was going on. To which our original waitress said okay i will and never came to tell us. After 5 more minutes of watching her wait on other people I got up to ask what was going on with our pizza. According to our waitress she put our order on the wrong side of the line. She said sorry but didn't seem very genuine in her apology. I'm somewhat confused on how we got our breadsticks and my salad okay but the pizza never came. I realize businesses make mistakes and that we're all human and waitresses make mistakes but the fact it took us getting up ourselves to ask about it was inexcusable. If a waitress makes a mistake she should at least extend the courtesy to her customers that they are working to correct it. We were there an HOUR before we got our pizza. She did end up giving us 1/2 off our pizza and my side salad for free which I feel was appropriate after our hour long wait. The pizza itself was sweet and didn't appear to have fresh ingredients. The mushrooms were canned. I personally prefer fresh ingredients on my pizza so this was definitely a turn off for me. Overall I would try Starlite one more time because I understand people and businesses have off nights. I don't anticipate we will return in the near future. Maybe one day. read more

Out of all the pizza I've had in my years, starlight pizza takes the pie!!! Great service, good portion, and tasty choices!! Me and my family go every month!! read more

We ate here for the first time tonight. We had a meatball and mushroom pizza and some cheesy garlic bread. The pizza crust was thin and crispy around the edges, and they did not skimp on the toppings. The food and the service were both great! We will be back. read more

BLT Pizza was awesome the new owners have really improved the restaurant from what it had become.If you have not been there in a while give them a try.Very clean and friendly environment I will definitely go back again soon read more

First time in awhile here. No greeting. Over 5 minutes for drinks. Husband ordered Budweiser and me a bud light. Server brought bud light for him. Seldom came back so he never said anything. I don't know what they did to the crust of there pizza but it ruined it. Almost taste like remade or frozen. The sweet sauce and toppings were the same but couldn't get past the crust. I always loved their thin crust, I don't know what happened. Not worth it for us. Then on top of that poor service. read more

A TRUE Granger gem! Family owned and operated. Unique pizza with its thin crust, slightly sweet sauce and always loaded up with toppings! I've never had a bad pizza from them! read more

First the initial phone call to order pizza, was greeted with a hello such as what you'd get when you dial the wrong number. My wife and I hadn't had their pizza in a few years so we figured why not. Ordered a large with pepperoni and sausage, was told be about 25 min for pickup. Upon arriving was told that my order would be a little bit longer still not a problem. Waited in their clean and nostalgic dining area. My name was called, order was ready opened the box to see that the pizza while hot and full of pepperoni didn't live up to what I would think was adequate for sausage toppings. I asked the girl behind the counter about it and was told that's how it's always been (not how I remembered it), so after paying almost $20 dollars for one large 1 and 1/16 topping pizza I left. Don't get me wrong flavor is good but price for what you get is why I give it 2 stars. read more

Starlite Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Granger, Indiana

The pizza was very limp (undercooked), the toppings skimpy, and the sause a bit like tomato paste.

3 1/2 stars for this place at the time of this review is pretty generous. I'm not in the habit of blindly trusting reviews on yelp, but rather using them as guidance for places I should eat and places I should be hesitant about. In the end I like to take the time to shake a place down for myself. I tried starlight and I will say it was underwhelming. For a hole in the wall Italian joint I was expecting more. I'm not in the habit of slandering anyone, so I'll end the review there. It's probably not worth your time to find out. read more

I grew up with Starlite and love the sauce on their pizza. It was a disappointment this last time when they cut back on the amount of sausage and cheese toppings. Please go back to your roots and provide that excellent pizza we crave so much! read more

Staff didnt seem interested in taking care of me when I walked in for pick up. It was pricey for a small pizza almost 20 bucks. The onions on the top were raw! The whole thing tasted bitter were the onions spoiled IDK never had pizza taste like that?? There are a lot of better pizza options within a few miles of this hole in the wall waste of space. read more

Great Pizza! We get take out occasionally but find it taste better fresh at the restaurant. If you dine in make sure you try some of the garlic pepper on your pizza. The negative is the atmosphere is a little dingy and has a bunch of arcade games that don't work. The positive is that there is plenty of seating for multiple large groups and area for kids to play. Very relaxed environment. read more

One of my favorites in the area. Excellent thin crust and sweet sauce. If you are looking for something unique then try their pierogi. Family ran with great atmosphere including old arcade games for kids and adults. If you want deep dish then this is not the place for you. read more

After a busy Friday afternoon, my wife and I decided to try out Starlite Pizza in Granger, IN at 7:30 p.m. Neither of us had ever been to this place, even though we live just a few miles away. We were greeted by a busy waitress who said she would be with us shortly, while we waited at the entrance to be seated. This restaurant was about 1/4 full of seated customers. There was a cashier about 35 feet away from us and yelled, "You can just grab a seat anywhere!". So we took a booth closer to the checkout counter. We waited another 10 minutes for a waitress to take our drink orders. About 5 minutes later she finally arrived with our drinks and took our food order. My wife ordered the "Philly" sandwich with a side of "Chippers". I ordered the "Italian Sausage" sandwich with a side of "Chippers". This restaurant was not busy with seated customers but there were quite a few carry-out order customers flowing in/out while we waited for our order to be filled. Almost 30 minutes passed before we finally got our food order. My wife said that her sandwich tasted okay but she did not like the "Chippers". They tasted like deep fried cardboard (no flavor). My sandwich was a disaster. It contained sliced up sausage links (not even close to Italian sausage) covered with sugar sweet tomato sauce and very bland cheese coating. I must admit that the only part of this sandwich that tasted okay was the toasted BUN!! I had to agree with my wife that the "Chippers" were just terrible also. We told the waitress how disappointed we were with the food. She notified (I guess, the store manager) who came over and immediately asked, "OK, What seems to be the problem?" I felt that was a rude way to introduce herself and show a concern about her customers. I explained that "my sandwich" was the worse Italian Sausage sandwich that I ever tasted and it certainly was not Italian Sausage. AND their deep fried "Chippers" were terrible. She asked me if I ever tried their Starlite pizza. I told her, "We have never been to this restaurant before and I certainly would not want to try their pizza, since I was completely unhappy with the meal that we were just served." She told us that they would not charge us anything for the meal and give us a free coupon to try their pizza the next time we stop in. I told her that we were not interested in coming back to Starlite Pizza for any reason. I only ate about 1/3 of the sandwich and just a few of their "Chippers". I do not recommend this Starlite Pizza restaurant. David and Charlotte read more