I ordered encrusted pork dinner with whipped potatoes. First dinner came out raw and had to send it back. Second one came out perfect. The manager apologized for it coming out that way. I have to say it was very delicious and moist. read more

Stage House Tavern - Pork chop, fried onion rings, whip potato. I added the pepper to the potato. - Salad Near Me - Scotch Plains, New Jersey

The place is huge with plenty of seating, and the place was pretty much packed when we visited, and most of them seemed to be regulars. I really wanted to like this place but it was just average for me. Drinks were pretty good but the food was just okay. Staff were friendly and the service pretty quick, considering how packed they were. Ambience is more of a family restaurant vibe. Overall, there isn't wrong with the place, but just didn't work for me. There was one issue we had was when paying our check though. Since it was near Closing Time, the person who was waiting on switched, which was fine. Our total was barely $40 (Drinks & App) and we gave a $100 bill, and the Server asked if we wanted the change back. Seriously? You expect us to leave $60 Tip on a $40 check? She was genuinely surprised when we told "Yes" We did tip 20% read more

Stage House Tavern - Salad Near Me - Scotch Plains, New Jersey

Really disappointing customer service at Stage House. I called to ask if my jacket had been found, and the hostess basically shrugged me off and told me I could come in and check myself. When I explained that I live 40 minutes away, she literally asked, "Is there anything else I can do for you?" completely disregarding my concern. The lack of effort and basic courtesy was frustrating. I wasn't asking for much, just a little help and consideration. Definitely not the kind of customer service I expected. read more

Stopped in after a dress appointment near by and SO glad we did. We were able to be seated right away and was greeted by the kindest server. Love the feel of a bunch of different rooms really adds an old timey touch. The food was delicious- I did have to send my burger back to cook a little longer as it came rare and I requested medium well. But that was fixed and everything truly hit the spot after a long day. read more

See all

Got the cheesesteak sandwich and it was just ok. Fun atmosphere but food wasn't that good.

Food and service are fine, but have they EVER washed this patio floor? It's INCREDIBLY FILTHY and should be power washed regularly. Makes me wonder about the cleanliness of the parts of the restaurant we can't see. Such a popular place making so much $$$ should do better. read more

The wings were a hit. Meaty & fried well. They weren't too saucy though so if you like it saucy ask for a side of sauce. The short rib pizza fell a little short, was a bit dry and no tomato sauce, it had a garlic sauce instead. I'll probably skip it next time. read more

See all

Along the main street in Scotch Plains, the place is very large having two sides, one more of a bar and the other more dining in small rooms. The building is very old with old beams, which are beautiful and low ceilings. But doodle low ceilings it did feel a little more cramped on the dining side . It was a little confusing as they have formal tablecloths on the dining side, making it feel like more fine dining get our playing rock music from the bar. Seems a little like they don't know what they wanna be. The food is average nothing to write home about the drunken chicken Parm entrée had a vodka kind of sauce on it yet did not have much flavor. The chicken was tender, but smothered in it rubbery type of mozzarella did not taste fresh. I was surprised that an entrée does not come with or bread as usually this accompanies an entrée for the price. The chili was delicious layered in flavors and had just a small amount of cheese as not to hide the rich taste. I would've preferred two bowls of that rather than ordering the entrée. My husband got the tacos, which again were nothing to write home about not filled very full and just average. The sangria did not have too much flavor. The staff was very pleasant, I just wish the atmosphere was a little better and the prices were a little lower for what you got. Would've loved a small salad to go with the entrées seems more like an eclectic bar food restaurant than a fancy restaurant yet has more fancy prices. read more

See all

Rolls were stale tonight on both our dinners - really ashame with those prices. Same old waiter outside never asks how our dinner is & trying all night to flag him down for more water ( never got it) More drinks. read more

Sewer. Scraps. Shriveled. Great waiter. Placed smelled like a sewer the second you walk in the door. If they aren't willing/able to fix plumbing, what's the kitchen look like? The bacon on my Cobb Salad looked like scraps left on the flattop that usually get thrown away. Like bacon bits soaked in grease. All of the kids food was downright sorry. Macaroni and cheese was tasteless and dry. Hot dog was shriveled and cold with FF looking like last pieces from the bottom of the bag. Waiter was attentive and friendly but Would not recommend. read more

It was a night where it was finally nice to sit out, but I don't like outdoors haha. We sat at the bar. It was packed outside, only a few people inside. The bartender was really nice. Unfortunately, I didn't care too much for the cocktails. The first cocktail was not the right mixture. Not sure if he tried to play it off that he didn't know it wasn't the right fruit puree but he was nice enough to make me a different drink. New England Clam Chowder - we love New England clam chowder so we had to try. When it came out, I'm not gonna lie, it didn't look very appetizing. Darker than how I usually see it BUT it was very flavorful. I was actually impressed how good it was. Tavern Shrimp - these were also very delicious! Sweet Chili Chicken Wings - These were really good. I'd go back :-) read more

See all

I LOVE historic bars, & this place def fits the bill - they've been in operation since 1737!!!!! For that alone, five stars, & I wld not care if the food & drinks were awful, it was dirty, & the staff were rude! Thankfully, none of those things are true. They are upscale, & everything here is extra, & above & beyond (including the prices - they are not cheap). Def worth it tho - very clean, super friendly staff, & incredible homemade chowder & bread on a long cold winter day. If I lived closer, I wld be here all them time. read more

Ordered the Special of the day Paella. Asked the server his thoughts said he wasn't sure he just started. 6 Oz bass dry and burned. Server no help never returned after telling him not edible. Shellfish had bad odor and taste. Guess I should have ordered a burger and fries. Pub food only at this establishment. No management! Disappointing to say the least. read more

Made reservations! We got there early decided to go the bar in patio. Happy hour! We were a party of 3. Ordered 2 margaritas and 1 cosmo! Got 2 cosmos and 1 margaritas! Hubby ordered another margarita Cosmo was ok Made reservation for the second floor because website stated recently renovated. Dining area plainly decorated. Our Server was Antonio! Attentive and friendly. Appreciated his recommendations. He shared Monday night ravioli specials. Got the ravioli- appetizer portion. Requested extra pesto sauce- didn't get the extra sauce :( Cream brûlée was yummy! Parking on site. Small park across the street and near shopping area. read more

See all

I've been to this location now a few times. The vibes here are always good. They have great outdoor spaces and frequently have live music. The service is also always great. They have private dining rooms, and if you make a reservation with a large enough group, they'll automatically put you in one. Like the other locations, they have a lot of deals and specials (e.g. kids eat free days, tini tuesdays, endless ravioli days). However, you really have to know what to order and what to steer clear of. With a menu as massive as Stage House's, it's no surprise that they are spreading themselves too thin. A good rule of thumb here is to stick to basic pub food like their burgers, sandwiches, and tacos. Their appetizers are also pretty good, so if you come with a group and share things like wings, tacos, spinach and artichoke dip, pretzel, etc you won't be disappointed. I've found most of their pastas (including their raviolis) and some pricier entrees to be pretty disappointing and borderline unappetizing. Their desserts also should be skipped; they are dry and definitely not worth the calories. Overall, Stage House is a true 3 star experience (the Yelp averages don't ever lie). In spite of its flaws, we continue to come back to all 3 locations because they're great places to take our kids, and we're now armed with the facts about what to order and what to avoid. read more

Came in on a Saturday night to see the Suburban Stereo Band and get some dinner, This was our first time seeing this band and they were excellent! Really enjoyed them... They had a great selection of songs. For dinner my hubby had the Cobb Salad and a Burger and Fries and I ordered the Hot Honey Pizza. His salad looked really appetizing and he enjoyed his burger and fries as well. This was my first time ordering a hot honey pizza and it was really good. He tried a slice and liked it as well. I'm only docking a star because I asked for a table In view of the band since that's why we came but we had to wait to be relocated because there weren't any open tables when we arrived so we missed a majority of their performance unfortunately because we couldn't see them. But since the food was tasty hopefully we will return again. read more

See all

Really neat layout to this place. Especially for warmer weather. There is something for anyone. Large indoor bar, large outdoor bar, bar seating both inside and out separate dining room area if that's the preference and the menu has a very nice variety. Bartenders, servers and host all very nice. It was a pleasure and a relaxing atmosphere. I understand that the "stage" house also has entertainment but I was only there for a weekday lunch. I am sure it is also good. I will be sure to try and get back to check on that. read more

Irish bartender is extremely rude, mad about everything he does. Talks shit about his own place he works at. The girl behind the bar also rolled her eyes when I ordered food 10 minutes before the kitchen closed, then went on to explain the kitchen wasn't actually closed until 12. Waste of space human beings behind this bar. Go to Darby road, you know what fuck it go to Fabio's pizza and have a couple. TO ADD TO IT ALL: This ATROCIOUS smell was REEKING the entire bar area. We asked and wondered what it was but were never directed to the source of the smell. Are the bartenders musty or is there a gas leak? read more

Waited 20 mins on a Saturday afternoon for a table. Interior is an old bar style restaurant with 3 floors of seating. The outdoor bar and seating area was very cute however it was not open when I went. I tried the spinach artichoke dip, the hot honey pizza and the mango elderflower margherita. Food and drinks were good, but pricy. read more

Stage House Tavern - Mango elderflower margherita - Salad Near Me - Scotch Plains, New Jersey

As I walked in with my spouse the energy was low, but it was cute. The server was kind and was super honest about her recommendations. I'd go back if I'm in the area, but wouldn't go out of my way if that makes any sense. Glows: -Interesting/fun/cozy decor (feels like you're in someone's home) -Great outdoor space for the fall/winter/spring -Food is tasty -Service is decent -Huge parking lot I a +++ read more

See all

Big Mistake. Food was awful. My granddaughters hot dog was a shriveled, burnt, skinny as a pencil,dis grace. Mac and Cheese was tasteless so my other two granddaughters would not eat it. My California burger was tasteless, burnt, and they mashed the avocado on top. Just awful. The place smells bad, old and dirty. We should have waited the 45 minutes to eat at Darby Pub. My bill was $240 (tip included automatically) for the worst dining experience ever. I tried to send an email before writing this review but their website does not include an email address. Don't waste your money. This place needs to be closed down. read more

Stagehouse blends the nostalgic build of a pre-civil war transportation hub with the warm feel of a local watering hole. I came for dinner on a Saturday night and was happy to only wait about five minutes for a table for two. It is worth noting that the location is quite large - multiple floors, multiple buildings, and an outdoor section during the summer months. One warning if you get seated on the second floor of the original inn - it's not for the faint of heart. It shakes when anyone moves, and if you're over 6 foot you'll hit your head on the beam when you reach the top of the steps. Definitely a wild ride if you're also a few drinks in! I've had a few things here that are solid, but not worth writing much about (burgers, hot sandwiches). However, the French onion soup is on a different level. Crunchy onion straws on top, gooey cheese baked on a big bowl, and a tasty broth. Really a masterclass in taking a basic soup and punching it up a bit. Get the soup. read more

Stage House Tavern - French onion soup - loved the onion straws! - Salad Near Me - Scotch Plains, New Jersey

See all

We had a great dinner here at The Stage House Tavern for Valentine's Day. We had a reservation for 7 and arrived about 6:45. We were seated right away in one of the small rooms which was really quaint. I ordered from the special menu and my date ordered from the regular menu. I had the Brie appetizer, Filet Oscar, and the Crème Brûlée. Everything of mine was soooo good. My date ordered the Tavern burger and usually doesn't have cheese in his burgers but he really enjoyed it. The only complaint I have is that we waited forever for anything from our order to be taken to getting refills on beverages. We were never asked how our meal was and being that my date's fork was taken away with his appetizer he didn't have one to eat his meal. We kind of shared one because our server want around to ask for a replacement. Hence the 4 stars instead of 5. All in all it was a very good meal though. read more

See all

Went for a family get together and had a semi private room in the back. Waiter forgot about us a few times so seemed they were understaffed a little. Ordered an old fashioned, which was good not great. Had the chicken parm where the chicken was delicious but he noodles and sauce left a little to be desired. Two big pieces of chicken offset the underwhelming amount of noodles. I'll be back again to try something different. read more

Stage House Tavern - One of two big pieces of chicken parm (ate the other before I remembered to take a picture!) - Salad Near Me - Scotch Plains, New Jersey

See all

Went to Stage House for fixed price Thanksgiving Dinner. It was very nicely done. The dinner included an appetizer course, dinner course and desert course. The appetizer course included your choice of soup, shrimp cocktail or salads. My Son and I both had a Fall Salad with goat cheese, walnuts, apples and lettuce. It was out of this world. My Son chose Fillet Mignon as his entree; I had a Turkey dinner with the trimmings. For desert, David had cheesecake and I had apple pie ala mode. The restaurant has a great bar and service was excellent. A 20% tip was include, but I gave our waiter 22%. read more

Stage House Tavern - Front dinning room - Salad Near Me - Scotch Plains, New Jersey

This place is pathetic, I asked for a chicken parm with no pasta for my son, and I got 2 chicken tenders with a side of sauce Asked for a cheeseburger for my daughter and I got a over cooked shitty burger patty with no cheese, the owner should be embarrassed, anyone that would eat any of the three shit holes that these people own are wasting their money. Fuck this place. read more

had a rough day at work... decided to stop in.... and Matt the bartender delivered excellence attentive.... and outstanding service suggestions, this place delivers... as a matter of fact.... everyone is perfect read more

Food was great. I got the Ruben which was amazing. if you come here at the right time you won't have to wait. It feels like you are in a cozy house, def recommend. read more

Went for a late lunch. I had the poached pear salad which was delicious. Brother had the fish and chips which he enjoyed. Service was very good, checking on us but letting us chat. read more

Service was ok, but food was not great at all. Beef stroganoff had no taste (for $28) and my Pork cutlet milanese sandwich was sparse and the bread it was on was not fresh at all. (for $21) As the waitress took away the mound of the roll I pulled away from the sandwich, I told her what was wrong and she said "sorry"- but didn't offer to rectify or take off any $ from the bill. read more

Back to the SH post kitchen update and I have to say prices are even worse and food quality is falling. The fajitas used to be a great "go to" meal here. Now they aren't really as good as Chipotle which is sad. Not sure why they changed them. I don't mind ponying up the bucks if the meal is top notch. Used to be. Not so much anymore. The bar is still decent although I understand they no longer have bands here once again sad read more

I have been to one of the other locations, so I mostly knew what to expect. The setup was odd with so many places to sit. There were 3 separate spots to sit outside alone. We sat on the side patio, which was away from most of the other attendees. The service was appreciated, and the food came out in a timely matter. I shared the PEI mussels ($15.95) and house smoked pulled pork sandwich ($16.95). The mussels came with bacon, corn, tomatoes, white wine, and grilled bread. The mussels were extremely large and there were about 17 of them present. They were alright. Due to the mussels being so large, I do not think they obtained all the flavor. The bread was also too hard where the inside was not soft enough to absorb the broth. The pulled pork sandwich consisted of cheddar and coleslaw. It also came with a side of fries that were good. The sandwich was again, decent. The pork could have been more tender and flavorful, and a different roll could have been used as it did not hold up well because of all the filling. Will I go back? Possibly. read more

Stage House Tavern - PEI Mussels - Salad Near Me - Scotch Plains, New Jersey

See all

If you are looking for a Brunch Spot in Central NJ, your search ends here. Hands down the best Brunch Spot around with so many options. You can choose to dine at the patio or the bar side or even have a cosy family dinner. The possibilities are limitless with seating and dining. As soon as we reached the hostess offered us a short trip of the tavern, the original fireplace, walls, and beams that are beautifully restored to honor the history of the beloved Tavern. We were just blown away with the history and tradition this place has carried over years. It was a beautiful spring evening and we chose to sit at the patio. Here is what we ordered- Appetizers- burrata salad, spinach and artichoke dip, signature wings, Drinks- Old fashioned, hot summer girl, lemonade Entrees- Parm crusted chicken, house salad, thin crust plain pie Dessert- chocolate lava, apple crumb pie The burrata salad with arugula, prosciutto, tomatoes and bread is one of the best burrata salad we have had across NJ! Burrata was so creamy and delicious! The balsamic sauce added the right flavor to make this our pick at stage house tavern! We would HIGHLY recommend this! The spinach and artichoke dip with homemade nachos was as good as it gets. Dip goals for those who enjoy a creamy dip with crisp nachos. The wings were perfect for our kiddos and they loved it! However, once they got the plain pie, they ended up eating slice after slice! They say if you do the pasta right, you have a winner. The chefs at stage house have mastered the parm crusted chicken that comes with green pasta and this is another master chef creation here! The chicken was perfectly crusted and juicy and the pasta was flavored to go well with chicken! The craftsmanship at the bar was just phenomenal we tried old fashioned and hot summer girl cocktails and both hit the right spot! The house salad had egg, beans, bacon, peppers, avocado and cheese! It can't get any better! All in all this is one of the finest spots in Scotch Plains and central jersey to get brunch, lunch and dinner. We will definitely be a regular patron here along with all friend and family. Ps- always make a reservation and parking is available right behind the tavern. The manager Matt and Jeff are always readily available and very helpful! read more

See all

I really enjoy this place. The food is good and drinks are reasonably priced. Place fills up fast every Sunday during football season so if you go then get there early to get a seat. read more

We stumbled onto this cozy place. Food was good & outside atmosphere under pergola was perfect. I enjoyed the watermelon cosmo. The penthouse martini had a little too much Prosecco for me. The chili was delicious!! And the onion rings were really good with a great crunch. I would definitely like to go back soon & recommend. read more

See all

Solid spot! Huge dining area and bar. I met friends here on a Saturday evening and we started with calamari to share- it was good! We each then ordered different entrees from hot honey chicken sand, quesadilla, fish tacos and fish and chips. Everyone liked their meal! It wasn't the best chicken sandwich I ever had but service was great at the bar and we overall enjoyed!! Apparently they also host private events and I've heard great things!! read more

Stage House Tavern - Outside - Salad Near Me - Scotch Plains, New Jersey

Saturday night and they were clearly understaffed; 2 waitstaff vs. a half-full room in our area and a 10 person group next to us. The table for 2 got their food before our table of 3, ours were not complicated dishes. Two bites into my food confirmed the first thoughts - my crab stuffed sole was not fresh (the potatoes and asparagus were fine). Sent it back, (to his credit) manager appeared quickly and wanted to make it right, but my appetite was shot (I would be sick that night, able to hold off not having that happen there). The others enjoyed their food (Meatloaf and pasta dishes). My dish (of course) and desserts (for them) were comped. It was...not a good rest of evening. Have been there before and loved it (see my previous review), my skepticism for eating out has dialed up in the past few months; this did not help. Ironically that one of the other dishes was meatloaf - two out of three ain't bad?! read more

Love stage house tavern! My favorite is the Parmesan crusted chicken also SOOO good and a nice portion size. The drinks are really good too and they have the best wings that are cooked to perfection. 10/10 always read more

Stage House Tavern - Parmesan crusted chicken - Salad Near Me - Scotch Plains, New Jersey

See all

Food was ok Service - ABSOLUTELY HORRIBLE. Came here for lunch and the waiter was rude Didn't check back in to see if the table needed anything I sat with an empty cup of water for 23 minutes to be exact. Cleared the table and still didn't ask if anyone wanted a new drink. I asked for water and she still didn't come back with it. But when asked for the check she came right back with it. I will not be coming here again. Ambiance was mediocre. read more

I usually go for ethnic or exotic food so a tavern isn't my usual place, but we were pleasantly surprised by the quality of the food. We both went for the specials-- wife had lobster risotto and I had homemade rigatoni with sweet Italian sausage. Both dishes were of the quality usually found at a fancy Italian restaurant, at about 80% of the price. Beet salad was also tasty and the pumkin pie dessert was easily enough to share and melted in your mouth. I can see why the restaurant and parking lot were full at 5:30. We'll be coming back. read more