Square Pie Photos
Business Info
Square Pie Popular Dishes
SQUARE PIE ATMOSPHERE
You might also consider
More like Square Pie
Recommended Reviews - Square Pie
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
This was one of the tastiest square pies I've had! I think this might've been called the Brooklyn? Can't remember... especially once it was in my mouth. It's probably one of the best 20 dollar purchases I've ever had! However, it was one of the worst dining experiences we've had... and what keeps us from going back... after being seated we had to wait almost an hour for pizza. The girl employee tried to encourage us to order appetizers or drinks (likely cause she knew there would be a wait...) but walking in all we saw was one party of 8 and just us. We remained patient as we saw they also took phone orders and only saw one guy making pizzas and another young man carrying flour... but two parties that arrived later complained about the wait and said they were going to leave and got served pizzas before us... it also sucked because we saw people order pizzas to go 20 mins after we ordered our pizza get frustrated with their standing waits get their pizza before us. It was especially frustrating cause when they opened their box to check their pizza it was literally the pizza we ordered. Payment process was also not organized Maybe it was an atypical day... Pizza was great, but hope they improve their service!
omg omg omfggggggg this place must be known . if i had to wait an hour and a half for this pizza which i didnt twas 20 min , i still would rave about how good my MVP pizza was . holy cabooses this place got it right !!!! try it . i know im going back for more . til next time !!! Its byob fyi
This pizza is so bad I stopped and ate a salad instead. It's easily the 3-5 worst pizza of my life...I am truly shocked and taken aback by how bad it is versus the ratings.
I love square pie! Their sauce is unreal and is in perfect proportion with the cheese. And I don't know who needs to hear this, but it's a favorite of my 90 year old grandmother and queen. She has a hard time chewing but their Sicilian is nice and fluffy. (Close seconds for her are Angelo's Sicilian and la Rosa...Emmy squared can be hit or miss on how well done it is.)
My, My, My the pizza was sooo good!! I got every bit of my 20.00 worth at square pie! So I was in the area for work and was looking for something quick to pick up for lunch and I saw square pie. I ordered online and went in the store about 15 minutes later and it was ready when I arrived. I ordered the white pizza and decided to add pepperoni for some razzle dazzle! The first bite was yum at first bite! The dough was light crispy and soft at the same time...yea I don't know how they did it either....and the cheese was flavorful and garlicky, it didn't need nothing added to this pizza it was perfect just the way it was, oh and the pepperoni cups was chef's kiss! What more can I say this pizza was delightful by far one of the best pizza I had. Customer service was also great. I definetly look forward to returning!
Great neighborhood gem! The staff was very helpful and accommodating of my friend and I requesting to get the speciality pizzas without various meats. We got the MVP and white sausage (both without meat) and they were awesome! The MVP is some of the best pizza I've had, the vodka sauce and flavors are amazing. The atmosphere is very cozy. It is also a byob.
My little baby and I had been working our asses off, so wanted a day to just watch movies and demolish a pizza. The soul just needs a full pig out day every now and then. We had our heart set on Angelo's Pizzeria, but after waiting in a line stretching the block we were told "we aren't making any more pizzas." A crushing blow to the heart, mind, and soul. I was pouting like an 8 year old on the walk back, when my baby said "We could try Square Pie, it's new and supposed to be really good!" I was still crushed from the Angelo's defeat and responded with a "yeah, whatever." She ordered a Large Red pie with Pepperoni on top, and when I opened the box I was in disbelief. It looked SO good. Like an angel spreading its wings. It's a thick square pizza doused in red sauce, mozzarella, topped with perfectly crisped pepperonis and has an elite crunch on the crust. It tasted even better than it looked. We sat there watching White Chicks, ripping through this pizza slice by slice, brick by brick. It was sensational and everything I could have asked for on a pig out day. Sometimes, God closes the Angelos door and opens the Square Pie window. You gotta keep the faith. IG @jnov_ Tiktok @jnov_reviews
Came here after drinking coffee in the area and we were starving for lunch. The place is quite cold, despite the double doors. Service is super friendly and prompt. I can imagine it would be really cute at night with the intimate seating and lighting. During the day it's just okay, haha. We ordered a small red pie and a small white. It took a little longer than expected to come out, despite how empty it was, but it was worth the wait. The crust is super crispy and had a great flavor. We liked the red over the white spinach pie, the white was a tad bland for us.
Amongst three, we shared the Caesar Salad and two small pizzas - one red sauce and one white sauce pie. The Caesar Salad was a bit salty in my opinion but the garlic and pepper helped offset the creaminess/heaviness one might feel. The dough was out of this world - having tastes of an everything bagel seasoning with the texture of a ciabatta, so you'll end up finishing every bite (no crusts left behind)! I'd love to come again and try their other specialty pies.
Sometimes 5 stars just isn't enough! So is the case for the experience I had this weekend at Square Pie. A quiet Sunday lunch with a bottle of cabernet, two "small" pizzas, and a perfect house salad. I'll get into the food, of course, but more important to me is the fact that I came here and felt immediately initiated into the Square Pie family: literally. Owner/chef Giuliano was tucked away in the kitchen while his dad served my boyfriend and I with the kind of immediate care and welcoming nature you can only find in an Italian joint run by native South Philadelphians. We had made plans to come here as an extra special post-half marathon meal and got so much more than we bargained for at every level. As for the food, the pepperoni pizza is the best pizza I've had in Philadelphia and it's not close. Pardon my french, but I am Philly pizza's number one shit talker. I love Pizzata and I love Paulie Gee's and a few of the other spots that specialize in specific styles, but I overwhelmingly find Philly's pizza scene to be...unfortunate. Cue the Shrek credits because I am now a believer. The cup and char pepperoni holds honey and oily perfection in every bite, with a crust that melts in your mouth. Sauce matches sweetness to acidity and isn't heavy handed. Or maybe it's that everything is a little heavy handed and that's what makes it magical? Who cares. I tried to savor every bite but I am already daydreaming about the next time I can drink wine and eat this pizza. The romaine salad was a recommendation and shouldn't be skipped! Roasted tomatoes bring it all together but the red wine vinaigrette and jelly yolk boiled egg make it pack extra punch. The pizza on special was amazing as well - covered in brussels and fontina and caramelized onions. They post their special pies on Instagram and I think they change weeklyish. Delivery is available on Slice and Uber Eats, something I know I'll be taking advantage of in the near future. That being said, it's hard to replicate the fun of dining in. Square Pie has updated their hours so if it's been a minute, grab a bottle of wine and settle in. Pizza cheers!
Ordered on Uber eats. They partner with a third party to actually deliver. Arrived quickly. Very thick pizza with soft crust and was honestly some of best pizza I have had.
I'm a person that loves pizza! I've tried pizza from a lot of places. This is the BEST pizza I've EVER HAD IN MY ENTIRE LIFE! Thank you. I will be back.
3 months ago
Definitely my favorite pizza in Philadelphia and probably one of the best pizzas I've ever had. Thick square pizzas with lots of sauce and flavor - we got the MVP (vodka sauce and hot honey, and add ricotta) without meat and Squash Pizza (roasted squash, potato, leek, mozzarella). Both were delicious, but the MVP was so divine we got it twice in one week. Saucy on top, creamy from the ricotta, and a hint of sweetness from the honey - chewy crust and the sauce went all the way to edge on the crust which made it even more tasty. Can't wait to come back! read more
7 months ago
Love this place! I come here very often. The ambiance is very warm and welcoming. The staff are very friendly and incredibly kind. I will never forget on one of my visits, I ordered the meatballs along with the delicious pizza and on my way home, spilled the meatballs. I called them to place another order and to my surprise they remembered me and gave me the meatballs on the house! Great customer service! Their pizza is top tier! Highly recommend! read more
Honestly, one of the best square/Sicilian style pies in the city. The dough is flaky and airy. The toppings are fresh and the sauce is a nice consistency that's not overbearing. A fantastic option, that's been consistent over the years if you're looking for this kinda style. read more
This was one of the tastiest square pies I've had! I think this might've been called the Brooklyn? Can't remember... especially once it was in my mouth. It's probably one of the best 20 dollar purchases I've ever had! However, it was one of the worst dining experiences we've had... and what keeps us from going back... after being seated we had to wait almost an hour for pizza. The girl employee tried to encourage us to order appetizers or drinks (likely cause she knew there would be a wait...) but walking in all we saw was one party of 8 and just us. We remained patient as we saw they also took phone orders and only saw one guy making pizzas and another young man carrying flour... but two parties that arrived later complained about the wait and said they were going to leave and got served pizzas before us... it also sucked because we saw people order pizzas to go 20 mins after we ordered our pizza get frustrated with their standing waits get their pizza before us. It was especially frustrating cause when they opened their box to check their pizza it was literally the pizza we ordered. Payment process was also not organized Maybe it was an atypical day... Pizza was great, but hope they improve their service! read more
2 months ago
5 months ago
omg omg omfggggggg this place must be known . if i had to wait an hour and a half for this pizza which i didnt twas 20 min , i still would rave about how good my MVP pizza was . holy cabooses this place got it right !!!! try it . i know im going back for more . til next time !!! Its byob fyi read more
1 year ago
This pizza is so bad I stopped and ate a salad instead. It's easily the 3-5 worst pizza of my life...I am truly shocked and taken aback by how bad it is versus the ratings. read more
7 months ago
I love square pie! Their sauce is unreal and is in perfect proportion with the cheese. And I don't know who needs to hear this, but it's a favorite of my 90 year old grandmother and queen. She has a hard time chewing but their Sicilian is nice and fluffy. (Close seconds for her are Angelo's Sicilian and la Rosa...Emmy squared can be hit or miss on how well done it is.) read more
9 months ago
My, My, My the pizza was sooo good!! I got every bit of my 20.00 worth at square pie! So I was in the area for work and was looking for something quick to pick up for lunch and I saw square pie. I ordered online and went in the store about 15 minutes later and it was ready when I arrived. I ordered the white pizza and decided to add pepperoni for some razzle dazzle! The first bite was yum at first bite! The dough was light crispy and soft at the same time...yea I don't know how they did it either....and the cheese was flavorful and garlicky, it didn't need nothing added to this pizza it was perfect just the way it was, oh and the pepperoni cups was chef's kiss! What more can I say this pizza was delightful by far one of the best pizza I had. Customer service was also great. I definetly look forward to returning! read more
8 months ago
Great neighborhood gem! The staff was very helpful and accommodating of my friend and I requesting to get the speciality pizzas without various meats. We got the MVP and white sausage (both without meat) and they were awesome! The MVP is some of the best pizza I've had, the vodka sauce and flavors are amazing. The atmosphere is very cozy. It is also a byob. read more
My little baby and I had been working our asses off, so wanted a day to just watch movies and demolish a pizza. The soul just needs a full pig out day every now and then. We had our heart set on Angelo's Pizzeria, but after waiting in a line stretching the block we were told "we aren't making any more pizzas." A crushing blow to the heart, mind, and soul. I was pouting like an 8 year old on the walk back, when my baby said "We could try Square Pie, it's new and supposed to be really good!" I was still crushed from the Angelo's defeat and responded with a "yeah, whatever." She ordered a Large Red pie with Pepperoni on top, and when I opened the box I was in disbelief. It looked SO good. Like an angel spreading its wings. It's a thick square pizza doused in red sauce, mozzarella, topped with perfectly crisped pepperonis and has an elite crunch on the crust. It tasted even better than it looked. We sat there watching White Chicks, ripping through this pizza slice by slice, brick by brick. It was sensational and everything I could have asked for on a pig out day. Sometimes, God closes the Angelos door and opens the Square Pie window. You gotta keep the faith. IG @jnov_ Tiktok @jnov_reviews read more
2 years ago
Came here after drinking coffee in the area and we were starving for lunch. The place is quite cold, despite the double doors. Service is super friendly and prompt. I can imagine it would be really cute at night with the intimate seating and lighting. During the day it's just okay, haha. We ordered a small red pie and a small white. It took a little longer than expected to come out, despite how empty it was, but it was worth the wait. The crust is super crispy and had a great flavor. We liked the red over the white spinach pie, the white was a tad bland for us. read more
Amongst three, we shared the Caesar Salad and two small pizzas - one red sauce and one white sauce pie. The Caesar Salad was a bit salty in my opinion but the garlic and pepper helped offset the creaminess/heaviness one might feel. The dough was out of this world - having tastes of an everything bagel seasoning with the texture of a ciabatta, so you'll end up finishing every bite (no crusts left behind)! I'd love to come again and try their other specialty pies. read more
Sometimes 5 stars just isn't enough! So is the case for the experience I had this weekend at Square Pie. A quiet Sunday lunch with a bottle of cabernet, two "small" pizzas, and a perfect house salad. I'll get into the food, of course, but more important to me is the fact that I came here and felt immediately initiated into the Square Pie family: literally. Owner/chef Giuliano was tucked away in the kitchen while his dad served my boyfriend and I with the kind of immediate care and welcoming nature you can only find in an Italian joint run by native South Philadelphians. We had made plans to come here as an extra special post-half marathon meal and got so much more than we bargained for at every level. As for the food, the pepperoni pizza is the best pizza I've had in Philadelphia and it's not close. Pardon my french, but I am Philly pizza's number one shit talker. I love Pizzata and I love Paulie Gee's and a few of the other spots that specialize in specific styles, but I overwhelmingly find Philly's pizza scene to be...unfortunate. Cue the Shrek credits because I am now a believer. The cup and char pepperoni holds honey and oily perfection in every bite, with a crust that melts in your mouth. Sauce matches sweetness to acidity and isn't heavy handed. Or maybe it's that everything is a little heavy handed and that's what makes it magical? Who cares. I tried to savor every bite but I am already daydreaming about the next time I can drink wine and eat this pizza. The romaine salad was a recommendation and shouldn't be skipped! Roasted tomatoes bring it all together but the red wine vinaigrette and jelly yolk boiled egg make it pack extra punch. The pizza on special was amazing as well - covered in brussels and fontina and caramelized onions. They post their special pies on Instagram and I think they change weeklyish. Delivery is available on Slice and Uber Eats, something I know I'll be taking advantage of in the near future. That being said, it's hard to replicate the fun of dining in. Square Pie has updated their hours so if it's been a minute, grab a bottle of wine and settle in. Pizza cheers! read more
11 months ago
I'm a person that loves pizza! I've tried pizza from a lot of places. This is the BEST pizza I've EVER HAD IN MY ENTIRE LIFE! Thank you. I will be back. read more
2 years ago
Simply incredible. Honestly we came here because Angelos was closed and what a find this place was. I'm a huge fan of square pies and this place more than delivers. The crust was so light and airy with great flavor and seasoning. We got half pepperoni and half sausage but I don't think it matters what toppings you get! Can't wait to go back! It takes around 25-30 minutes to make but well worth the wait. read more
9 months ago
7 months ago
2 years ago
I came here on a Saturday evening with friends and was lucky it wasn't packed yet for dine in. This place gets filled up fast as it is small, but well lit. I had a large 12x12 sausage pie which is around $23. The pizza is a thick Sicilian style that is very filling. I needed a box and should have got the smaller 8x8 which goes for $14 if you want it plain. Service was very good and we got our pizza pretty fast. There's a small bathroom for one person. Overall great experience and I would suggest this place to anyone. read more
1 year ago
3 years ago
I didn't think I would like it but I loved it. It was $20-ish and when o saw the small box I was about to be sad because I was hungry but This is some fluffy pizza and filling. so if you like this square pie style- you'll love this! I think they call it Brooklyn style? Is it Sicilian? Is it deep dish or something like that or cast iron? I have no idea but it was some puff pizza and flavorful. I dunno but the dough is good. Just got the basic cheese flavor because I have an anti-pork partner and I didn't see any beef choices. I'm not a chicken fan person. But I saw a mushroom special on the board and I totally would have gotten that one. I love mushrooms. I only got to eat 3 slices out of the 9 before my partner vacuumed it up the next day leftovers too. Ha. All good. read more
Back again for another stellar experience. This is some of the best pizza in Philly. Period. Came here on a Saturday night and got seated right away (3 people around 6pm). Our waitress was so friendly and bubbly that we just felt right at home. As an update to my last review, they added many more tables (probably for the dinnertime rush). There is plenty of seating here -- good for parties of 4 or less, but you may be able to squeeze in 6. In this update, I ate a Red Pie with Pepperoni and Olives and Arancini. Red Pie with Pepperoni and Olives - This one was the personal pie size, which leaves the average person pretty satisfied, but I wished these were just slightly bigger. Finished mine and reached for slices from others. Crust is perfectly crisp while maintaining good fluffiness internally. Plenty of pepperoni and olives on here. The olives were nice and tangy. Really can't go wrong with any of their red pies. Sauce is bold and delicious. Arancini - Like fried risotto balls, these are wonderfully light appetizers. Rich in flavor, very savory, crisp exterior -- paired nicely with marinara sauce. Tbh I wasn't very excited about these when we ordered them, but I was pleasantly surprised by nearly every aspect. Definitely would order again. Value: 4/5 Quality: 4/5 Quantity: 5/5 Service: 5/5 Atmosphere: 5/5 read more
3 years ago
We've walked past this place so many times and finally went! When we took our first bite of pizza, we knew we had been missing out. Square Pie is the kind of pizza shop that any neighborhood would be happy to have - it's homey and cozy, the staff is friendly, and the pizza is really well made. (It's also a BYOB - which is getting increasingly harder to find in Philly.) The dough is flavorful, with beautiful bubbles of aeration that somehow still have structure under the generous toppings. We tried the soppressetta red and pancetta white pizzas ($17 for 8 inch squares) and they were the perfect size for the two of us to split and feel comfortably full. The pancetta one was creamy, rich, and decadent, and the sopprassetta was zingy and a little spicy - we'd definitely order both again. There were some big groups (including a group of octogenarians who came in with literal gallon jugs of wine) and based on the good times being had, I'd say that if you can score a table, this is a great place to split some pies and salads with friends and family! read more
1 year ago
1 year ago
8 months ago
Square Pie has been on my radar since it opened. I don't know why it took me so long to finally place an order for delivery. I ordered a large pizza, half pepperoni and half sausage. The pizza arrived warm, looked tasty, and I was eager to dig in. The pizza was so delicious. The sausages were large and juicy on one side. The pepperoni was good and plentiful on the other side. This is a thick crust pan pizza on par with the best pan pizza in Chicago. You can't get pizza like this anywhere else in Philly. One large pizza ended up being three meals, as each slice is so filling. I'm already looking forward to my next order. read more
2 years ago
2 years ago
1 year ago
2 years ago
Looks are deceiving, great things come in small packages. Started with Arancini which was delicious with a slight kick at the end, but not too spicy at all. Pizza was amazing and I have my share of pizza being from Brooklyn, NY. Sauce was delicious and pizza was not doughy and cooked just right, it was not soggy and light. Service was attentive, respectful and extremely friendly. Dining room was a little one but quaint and homey and feels like a Godfather restaurant feel, in a food way. Definitely place to go for pizza when back in Philly. read more
2 years ago
Page 1 of 6
More info about Square Pie
801 E Passyunk Ave
Philadelphia, PA 19147
Queen Village
Directions
(215) 238-0615
Call Now
Visit Website
http://www.squarepiephilly.com/
Full menu
Hours
Payment methods
Food & Alcohol
Indoor Amenities
Outdoor Amenities
Other Amenities
More Info
Health Score
Ask the Community - Square Pie
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
8 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
1 year ago
9 years ago
7 years ago
6 years ago
9 years ago
8 years ago
11 years ago
