I always promised myself to review this place, and after some time --- here's the review! I saw Spinachio's on my FYP for a while, especially during Lent, and I knew I needed to try them - especially on those Lenten Fridays. I called-in my order for 1 Spinachio's Pizza - what their known for, which "features fresh spinach marinated in garlic and extra virgin olive oil, combined with our secret Spinachio mix, pecorino romano cheese, and mozzarella for a rich, flavorful bite. " The woman told me to pick it up in 20-min., and I arrived at the 20-minute-mark, I saw my pizza being taken out of the oven! What a sight! The inside of the restaurant is charming and unassuming, yet welcoming. The two ladies (owners?) were very kind in showing me the pie, and then with payment afterwards. Taste? Amazing. If you're a fan of hot spinach dips for appetizers, then this is not too far off --- in pizza-form, dare I saw, the superior form! I can see why they are recommended and highly rated. Try it out today! read more

Spinachio Pizza - Spinachio Pizza - Pizza Near Me - North Haledon, New Jersey

One of the best pizza places in NJ!!!! I love that it's woman owned and family run business. They are also BYOB which is always fun. The food is soooo good I loved the spinach cheesesteak- really good!!!! And of course you can't go wrong with any of their pizzas!!!! read more

See all

Been living in North Haledon close to 10 years and recently discovered this slice of pizza heaven. my granddaughters love the cheese pizza and garlic knots and i love the square slice. Congrats to the two sisters who created this welcoming place. read more

I've been dying to try this spinach pizza that's been on my mind the first time I ever laid eyes on it on instagram. It totally lives up to the hype! When that crunchy bite of spinach and cheese first hit my mouth, I think I saw heaven. This pizza is crispy, light, slightly garlicky and perfectly melted. If you're not into spinach, the rigatoni vodka pizza was another major winner in my book. It was carb loaded in the best way! The mosaic pizza is perfect for a group with all different taste buds. You can actually choose from seven of their specialty pizzas to create this beautiful masterpiece. Don't even think about sleeping on the meatballs! They were so tender and comforting! Of course, we ended with their fluffy golden Zeppoles! Major shout out to the lovely ladies that own and operate Spinachio. Proving that women can run great pizzerias too! The whole staff was just so friendly and welcoming. The pizzeria has a handful of booths with neat murals adorning the restaurant. Making it a fun casual spot to hangout and eat. If good pizza is important to you, Spinachio is completely worth the trip! read more

See all

3% Credit Card fee The Spinachio pizza is the best slice to get here! Or at least it was my favorite out of the 3 I tried. I also had the square vodka and a plain. It was about $10 for the spinachio and vodka slices and the plain was over $3. All slices have a very thin crust so the pizza is not too doughy. I didn't love the sauce on plain slice, a bit on the sweeter side for me, but still a solid slice. I was happy that all the slices were very hot when I went to eat them! I tend to find pizza places never get the slices warm enough. There are several tables inside and outside for dining in. Even though the tables outside were in the sun I'm not sure if it's cooler sitting outside or inside on a warm day. Overall I'm glad I took the time to travel to try this place! read more

See all

With ample outdoor seating, Spinachio is a welcome upgrade to this strip mall. The garlic knots are huge and perfectly seasoned. We opted for the pepperoni pizza and those curled cups filled with hot honey did not disappoint! read more

See all

Really really good pizza. Great toppings and at a fair price. Only bad news is they don't deliver. I used to get from Puzo's in North Haledon but this is definitely better. read more

I was visiting from west coast to see family. Grew up in NJ and was craving the pizza flavors I grew up eating. We got take out. One plain pie and one with 1/2 mushroom 1/2 onions and bell peppers. Both pizzas were delicious but the stand out was the Chicken Francese with lemon sauce and pasta. Outstanding! Very tender chicken cutlet and the sauce was a winner. Prices reasonable too! Will definitely be ordering from them again!!! read more

Spinachio Pizza - Pizza Near Me - North Haledon, New Jersey

We finally gave this a try for some takeout last night and we were definitely impressed with the quality of the food. Definitely not generic pizzeria food.. We started with the Mediterranean salad, which was very very good with a nice mix of green olives, cucumbers, and tomatoes with some feta cheese. It was crisp and refreshing. We then had the muscles marinara which were some of the best muscles that we've had recently we have to tend to get them everywhere we go and a lot of the times were disappointed, but these were absolutely delicious. The sauce was amazing. We got the thin pizza. It was a little bit doughy for my liking. I thought it was gonna be a little bit Thinner and a little more cooked but it was pretty good. I think next time we would just ask for it cooked a little bit more. We are definitely gonna be going here again. They were also very nice when we called and when we went to pick up the food. read more

The spinach pizza was spot‑on, also had the vodka pasta with grill chickens and the staff were really nice.

We've come here a few times for different pies and every pizza has been amazing but the Burrata pizza we got last night has been by far the best we've had. I haven't tried anything other than pizza so I cannot speak on other items but I'm sure it's all delicious. All the workers have also been very nice every time we've gone. Would absolutely recommend Inside is really nice and they also have nice outdoor seating read more

Spinachio Pizza - Burrata Pizza - Large 18'' (8 Slices) - Pizza Near Me - North Haledon, New Jersey

See all

Food: The pizza is great! But personally, I have to say the spicy rigatoni is the best. I stumbled upon this dish one night and now I cant stop coming back for it! They are kind enough to sell me the vodka sauce in the container which allows me to serve my addiction while still being affordable. You can tell they use fresh ingredients in all their food. I've had pizza, pasta, rice balls, salads.. all have been wonderful. This is definitely a popular spot in town and its typically quite busy. Atmosphere: The place is clean and updated with about 10 tables on the inside. They also have outdoor seating which is a nice alternative. Parking is no problem as there is a large lot. Just your typically pizza place really, nothing crazy going on. Service: The ladies that own this place or I always see working there are so nice! If they can, they will always accompany any requests (like my quart of spicy vodka sauce). I have never had any issues when calling in an order, and pick-up times are always under 30 min which is great. read more

I love this place. Every time I go to New Jersey, I go here. Always. Close to my cousin's house. And, it's not just their pizza, their wings and pasta is great. read more

Someone recommended Spinachio's to me so I gave it a shot. I ordered a chicken parm slice to eat there and a spinach slice to go. The slices are huge! One slice is enough for a meal. The chicken parm slice was ok. The spinach slice was fantastic and I will be back for that. I will say the spinach slices from Vinnie's in Wayne are very comparable in taste. The restaurant was very clean, the staff very nice, and the slices warmed perfectly. read more

Really 3 1/2 stars. Heard about how great the pizza was so ordered from them. Their red sauce is really tasty, but my grandma pizza was burnt on the edges and it wasn't as thin as expected. Spinach pizza was just okay. I'll probably try this place again and maybe try something else. read more

The Spinachio Pizza is amazingly great. Haven't tried the rest of the menu because we are hypnotized by the spinach pizza. The owners and employees are offer delightful and respectful hospitality. read more

Went for dinner last night with my son. Had the thin crust cheese pie and buffalo pie. One of the best pies I have had. Cheese pizza was very crispy and had great flavor. Buffalo pizza was loaded with chicken and nice and crispy. Grew up in North Haledon and this is the best pizza by far the town has had. Very friendly service as well. Will be hitting this place after every swim meet for my son. read more

I love Grande cheese mozzarella cheese on pizza. Only a few pizzerias in NJ use this cheese one is Deluca in Raritan. Dave portnoy gave Deluca 9+. This pizza at Spinachios is one of the best old style pies in the tri state area. The crust is crunchy on the outside chewy on the inside on the thin side but not a traditional thin pie. The sauce spicy with a great flavor. I am going back. I need more from this restaurant. read more

Everything I tried here was amazing! Cannot go wrong with the spinach and burroni pies. They also have fried Oreos that were to die for. The cheesy bread was also amazing. Staff were so friendly, as well. read more

Spinachio Pizza - Penne vodka - Pizza Near Me - North Haledon, New Jersey

See all

I ordered a pepperoni pie and a grandma pie. The pies tasted good, and the crust was crispy on both pies. The pepperoni was good because it wasn't dripping oil. The grandma pie also had good flavor. The only bad part was the cheese would come off the whole slice on the first bite. read more

Spinachio Pizza - Pizza Near Me - North Haledon, New Jersey

See all

Great pizza and great service! It was about a 20 minute wait for our pizza on a Friday night which isn't bad at all. I'll definitely go back and try a few different slices read more

Tried this place for the first time visiting my parents and theyre excellent! Their pizza is awesome, great flavor on the sauce and top notch cheese quality. Their dinners are great also! The penne vodka sauce is amazing! Cant wait to go back! Highly recommended! read more

Good portions, fast and friendly staff, woman led, and really good pizza. Came in and immediately felt welcomed. Had the white slice and meatball pizza. Flavors were distinct and ingredients felt fresh and not stale like most pizza places. Crust is nice lots of air pockets and not burnt, good amount of oil, melty stringy cheese, and the slice holds its shape for the bite without compromising the bite. Idk how they do it but toppings and sauce doesn't seep into the bottom, stays crunchy even after 10 mins. Only place where I eat the crust. Pizza similar to what you'd get at fancier side of Manhattan or Brooklyn read more

Ordered their regular pie and "grandma" style Sicilian pie. Crust was good, not too thin not to thick. Pretty good flavor for both. Biggest issue is their regular pie was way too oily and made the crust soggy. Their Sicilian sauce was way too watery and also made the crust soggy. read more

Get the skinny plain and nothing else. The chicken tenders are gross. The regular pizza is alright. Delivery takes way too long, so I recommend picking up. But yeah - the skinny pie is solid. read more

I found this place on IG and decided to give them a try bc their pizza looked absolutely delicious. I ordered the Burrata pizza, but Sicilian. It was delicious and if you like doughy pizza then you will not be disappointed at all. The fried calamari was crispy and not soggy at all! read more

See all

I stand behind my previous review. If I want a margarita pie or some wings, I'm not coming here. But, if I'm just getting pizza.... They have the best cheese pizza around! The crust, sauce and cheese are all perfect! Their pizza is consistent. The crust is just right! They're not stingy with the sauce and the cheese is nice and browned. They use a better pepperoni than everybody else and it shows. Check the picture, see how the pepperoni is little slices? I've been having my friends over for football Sunday's and we tried a few different places. Everybody overwhelmingly wants their plain and pepperoni pizzas every week. We haven't been disappointed yet. read more

See all

Pro: They have a great dinner special of a pie, garlic bread, and 2 liter soda. Con: The pizza was completely burnt when delivered. No one wanted to eat it. I would try again to see if the overcooked pizza was a one time issue. However, they should never send out pizza that is overcooked. read more

I will say the pizza is great. But i was disappointed both times we went with the men at the register. One of them asked me if i wanted my change back which i feel is inappropriate and puts the customer on the spot. It's also tacky. And then the other man the next time was wearing a glove at the register handling money, and then picked up the pizza with the same glove. Please do better read more

This place is a hidden gem. The pizza is delicious and the folks that work here are friendly and passionate. Crust was delicious and the sauce was flavorful but not too salty. Good firmness in the pizza as well. I came in for a couple of slices and I will definitely be coming back for more read more

Spinachio Pizza - Plain Pizza slice and Margherita Pizza slice - Pizza Near Me - North Haledon, New Jersey

Hands down 100% Brooklyn style pizza. As authentic as it gets. Here on a quick trip from NYC and i wasn't pleasantly surprised to say the least. Family owned and operated, staff is awesome as well. Will hit this spot up anytime I'm in the area. read more

Spinachio Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - North Haledon, New Jersey

Best pizza in the area. We love the 3 pointer-pizza, garlic bread and 2 liter soda. Pasta w vodka sauce is delicious. This is our new spot and we love it. read more

Really good pizza. I never even knew this place existed because it's hidden in the back of the shopping center. Pizza was nice and fresh. The owners were so polite and service was A+. Highly recommend Spinachio if you are local. read more

Ordered on Superbowl Sunday in the snow for delivery, and it only took about 45 min which was amazing in my opinion. The pizza was amazing, had cup pepperoni ( my favorite) the cheese was so flavorful, and it was thin crispy crust that I thought was cooked to perfection! I also ordered an order of mild wings, these definitely were not my favorite they seemed very seasoned and herby and then the sauce was put on top giving them a weird taste. I would go again/order again for their amazing pizza though! read more

Spinachio Pizza - Pizza Near Me - North Haledon, New Jersey

See all

Horrible experience. Food was old, overcooked and terrible. Will not be ordering from here again.

Dear Spinachio, firstly, i literally just got my order - had one bite and had to thank you. thank you for super high quality calamari (which has become really hard to find). thank you for listening to my request for a side of vodka sauce. thank you for listening to my request for dressing on the side, just thank you. My goodness - not only do you guys do like real pizzaria pizza, but your actual food is phenomenal, as a true jersey italian - i couldn't be more genuinely obsessed ... very sad i moved to montclair and am out of the area but very happy that i was babysitting my nephews tonight and remember why my sister was so smart to move back to our area ! dear everyone who sees this post don't even question it - if you're doing pizza night - order from here ** also really sad i didn't read reviews first and am missing out in this whole white pie thing (for sure my favorite kind of pizza) read more

Delicious pizza and great service. Can tell they use quality ingredients and cheeses. Pizza is baked perfectly, crispy crust. After trying all the local spots, we previously had one favorite pizza place for the last 6 years that became the only one we would ever order from. Decided to give this place a shot and we now have a new favorite. Have since ordered pizzas from here for work and the staff loved it as well. Also tried the mussels marinara and my 2 year old DEVOURED it. Looking forward to trying more menu items but definitely try their spinachio and drunken grandma. You won't be disappointed. read more

I've come here several times and this has become my new favorite pizza joint. Mussels Marinara (ask for extra sauce), calamari, pizza... everything i've had was excellent! Wings are basic, nothing special but crispy. Margherita Pizza was the best I can remember having. Crust is always cooked perfectly on all the pizza. The staff is very friendly and the times i've been there during the pandemic they have worn hand and face protection. Definitely worth a shot if you've never been! read more

Whenever I come back from Philly, this is the first place I want to go. Cannot find pizza that compares. Absolutely delicious and everyone there is super friendly. So happy I found this place! It's been a favorite for years. Super adorable location and lovely vibe inside as well. read more

Spinachio Pizza really did name their best pie after them, The Spinachio! It is absolutely drool worthy. White pies are hit or a miss in my family, and rest assured, this restaurant has unanimously won 'best overall white pie' in our household! It's our number one, go-to pizza spot for white pies. Don't get me wrong, I've tried their other pies and their pizza is overall delicious, but something about their Spinachio pie has you day dreaming and craving their white cheesy goodness. It has a medium thickness in dough, so don't expect a super thin crust and they don't hesitate on their toppings; I'd say they are even a bit heavy handed (YES PLEASE). No one likes a stingy topping pizza joint! Their fried calamari also impressed me. I hate when pizza places put this on the menu and then just buy junk they toss into their frier and serve up. With Spinachio, you can expect high quality. They even have a small outdoor seating section. For a small corner pizza shop, they aren't cutting any corners. Check em out! read more